Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Being mistaken for the PA

515 replies

BingBoings · 10/02/2023 21:11

Twice this week I have been in email chains, where I have been asked to supply dates for a meeting.

The reason for this has in both cases, I assume, is that I am the only female name in the thread.

Both situations have seen large numbers of clients and colleagues copied in on emails where… I am asked if I can help give times when my male colleagues are free. I am usually senior to them.

Am I the only person this happens to? I find it half hilarious, and half embarrassing… A few months ago I was asked in a meeting if I could do coffees when I walked in…

i have no issue with managing my own diary nor is there any issue with being a PA… it’s more that I don’t see men having this issue…!

OP posts:
WedonttalkaboutMaureen · 11/02/2023 22:37

@Basecampzero brilliant reply to Roses. I read her post and it pissed me off and you've articulated exactly why. Pulling up the ladder behind her is such a brilliant way of putting it. Thank you

MrsMikeDrop · 11/02/2023 22:37

larchforest · 11/02/2023 22:09

Senior people at work are perfectly entitled to ask a subordinate to carry out tasks on their behalf. That is what staff are for.

The problem lies when some of them assume that the only woman present is the most junior person there, and therefore the person whose job it is to fetch and carry.

I agree, if that is part of their job. A highly paid person shouldn't be expected to be ordering morning tea or booking travel (obviously it depends on the situation). If I'm in charge I don't want my technical experts to be 'wasting' their time on this. Eg I want people to be participating in a meeting not busy taking notes, and the person taking the minutes should be good at it which not all people are, that's a skill in itself

WedonttalkaboutMaureen · 11/02/2023 22:16

@Mark19735 god you love the sound of your own exceptionally dull and irrelevant voice don't you? Why use one sentence to mansplain when you can use 12 saying the same thing. Off you trot ...

larchforest · 11/02/2023 22:09

Walkaround · 11/02/2023 21:59

The real problem is thinking a subordinate should make your drinks and take your notes.

Senior people at work are perfectly entitled to ask a subordinate to carry out tasks on their behalf. That is what staff are for.

The problem lies when some of them assume that the only woman present is the most junior person there, and therefore the person whose job it is to fetch and carry.

LittleRedYoshi · 11/02/2023 22:08

RosesAndHellebores · 11/02/2023 20:09

I've had to be more assertive with women who resent another woman's success or position, than I ever have with a man or men to be entirely honest. Men tend not to bitch. They get it wrong, get corrected and move on once they have the message.

They do? My DF is a prime example to the contrary - I was just starting out in my career and was telling him about my new job, he said it was a shame that my manager was female because "nobody likes female bosses". A bitchier statement than I've ever heard from any professional woman and a downright awful thing to say to your female child with management aspirations.

Walkaround · 11/02/2023 21:59

The real problem is thinking a subordinate should make your drinks and take your notes.

blacksax · 11/02/2023 21:40

Fullrecoveryispossible · 10/02/2023 23:21

This is down to our biology. Instinctively, we look to men as leaders. Don’t hate on people when this happens, just smile and laugh!

Nope.

The real problem is that many men instinctively assume that women are subordinates.

dodobookends · 11/02/2023 21:32

Walkaround · 11/02/2023 19:54

Surely if there were only men in the meeting, it would happen to a man? Or do all male meetings not require minutes or refreshments?

Well, it is obvious. One of them sticks his head out of the meeting room door, locates the nearest female, and asks them to fetch the refreshments.

larchforest · 11/02/2023 21:10

Mark19735 · 11/02/2023 11:40

Morning. Wow this thread has been busy.

Lots of interesting perspectives on this thread so far, but none that really change the fundamentals. Little-minded people seem obsessed with job titles, email signatures, and who makes who a coffee. They are easily outraged by every anecdotal instance where assumptions have been incorrectly made, and see everything as a systemic problem. The real rainmakers know that a person's value isn't defined by such trivialities. They are relaxed about it when it happens to them because they know their worth, and it doesn't change based on a job title or who makes the coffee.

Best illustration of this? The story about the Queen and her protection officer meeting American tourists out in Balmoral. They asked her if she'd ever met the Queen and she replied no, but Dick (her protection officer that day) saw her all the time. They then asked her to take a photograph of them with him. Do you think she spent that evening on MN furiously posting about misogyny? Of course not ... because she was an actual Queen! She found it hilarious, and that's exactly what that story is - a funny anecdote about mistaken identity. Real Queens don't care. Nor do Kings. Little people seethe and fume - but really it's a sign of their frustration about their own precarious insignificance - and everyone else in room knows it.

Yes, I've heard that story before. It is funny because she was one of the most recognisable people on the planet, they were walking on her land, asking questions about her, and they still didn't twig who she was.

I suspect that the Queen would have been much less amused if those tourists had assumed he was a senior royal, that she was the housekeeper, and they had asked her to pop off and fetch them a cup of tea, love.

SerendipityJane · 11/02/2023 20:50

Maybe not quite the same area, but there have been a flurry of social media "stories" of late about an interview that went terribly wrong for the candidate (usually male*) who because of a sudden absence mistakes the CEO for the receptionist and treats them like dirt, only to face them 5 minutes later in an interview.

*Which tells you there are a few variations on a theme.

Pretty certain there's an old joke about someone saying to person of Indian descent who appears to jump the queue in a Doctors "in this country we wait our turn" or somesuch similar.

As I said, doesn't seem much has changed since Benny Hill and On The Buses.

larchforest · 11/02/2023 20:30

GiltEdges · 11/02/2023 03:34

Frankly this just makes you look stupid. Why didn’t you say “No, I’m chairing the meeting, he can get his own Sudafed”? Instead, to make a point, you apparently went along with it and delayed the start of your own meeting. How utterly unprofessional.

I couldn't disagree more. What the pp did was priceless, and did far more to cause total embarassment among the men in the meeting than merely stating her position ever could. They learned their lesson thoroughly that day, and I bet they wished the floor would open and swallow them up. And I bet they've never made that sort of mistake again.

RosesAndHellebores · 11/02/2023 20:09

I've had to be more assertive with women who resent another woman's success or position, than I ever have with a man or men to be entirely honest. Men tend not to bitch. They get it wrong, get corrected and move on once they have the message.

Crumpledstilstkin · 11/02/2023 20:03

And another one saying it's a poor thread title, it's not being treated like a PA but rather a personal servant. There's just a strong correlation between people who treat a PA like that and people who assume a woman must be a PA because, in their head, they both exist to serve.

Crumpledstilstkin · 11/02/2023 20:01

RosesAndHellebores · 11/02/2023 19:27

@Basecampzero or perhaps it's the way I dealt with it, assertively rather than taking offence, that kept getting me promoted. Despite starting my career in 1981 I have never ever felt discriminated against at work. Not for being a woman. Not for not having a degree. Neither have I felt subordinated or inferior. Because I am not and my bearing demonstrates it. I stand straight, look hard, and keep smiling.

It wouldn't happen to other women if they had presence and confidence. Nobody claps a whinger.

Call it what you want but you've still had to deal with it assertively so clearly you've experienced it.

I know I've got much better at the Paddington Hard Stare when I get these requests but I spent years developing that and I still get talked over in meetings and expected to make the coffee by people who don't know me yet. Plenty of the most respected and experienced women in my industry get the same, especially from people from cultures where women are subservient and from men who aren't very good at their job. And that's just the stuff that shows - there's plenty more that's more subtle and even more damaging because you can't fight what you can't see.

It's so wearing fighting this again and again and again.

WeCome1 · 11/02/2023 19:57

Basecampzero · 11/02/2023 18:56

Peak pulling up the ladder. I don't see the point of these posts that say that it didn't happen to me. What are you implying? That other women are making it up? They shouldn't be making a fuss? If only they handled better it wouldn't happen to them?

The point is that if they were a man it wouldn't happen to them at all. They wouldn't have to appear more confident or have strategies to deal with it. It's not that they shouldn't be making a fuss, it's that they shouldn't have to make a fuss.

Women like you are part of the problem.

The OP did ask if it happens to other women, so those posters are just answering that.

G5000 · 11/02/2023 19:57

Surely if there were only men in the meeting, it would happen to a man? Or do all male meetings not require minutes or refreshments?

Sure they do, but then the men would figure out whose job it is, or discuss and agree how it should be handled. If there is one woman in the room, they just assume it's her job.

Walkaround · 11/02/2023 19:54

Basecampzero · 11/02/2023 18:56

Peak pulling up the ladder. I don't see the point of these posts that say that it didn't happen to me. What are you implying? That other women are making it up? They shouldn't be making a fuss? If only they handled better it wouldn't happen to them?

The point is that if they were a man it wouldn't happen to them at all. They wouldn't have to appear more confident or have strategies to deal with it. It's not that they shouldn't be making a fuss, it's that they shouldn't have to make a fuss.

Women like you are part of the problem.

Surely if there were only men in the meeting, it would happen to a man? Or do all male meetings not require minutes or refreshments?

MabelMoo23 · 11/02/2023 19:54

Tribollite · 11/02/2023 13:44

I think my issue with this thread is not that men make assumptions about a woman's role based on her sex. That of course happens, is wrong and needs remedying.

It's the stories that go "X came in and thought I was the PA/ shop assistant and was horrendously rude. The last laugh was on him though when I turned out not to be!'. So no thought about the wider implications that women in these female-dominated roles get treated like shit on a regular basis. Just as long as it's not you, eh?

Absolutely this. I get treated like shit because I’m the admin!!!

TheOrigRights · 11/02/2023 19:47

*Peak pulling up the ladder. I don't see the point of these posts that say that it didn't happen to me. What are you implying? That other women are making it up? They shouldn't be making a fuss? If only they handled better it wouldn't happen to them?

The point is that if they were a man it wouldn't happen to them at all. They wouldn't have to appear more confident or have strategies to deal with it. It's not that they shouldn't be making a fuss, it's that they shouldn't have to make a fuss.

Women like you are part of the problem.*

For me, I have noticed the behaviour seems less prevalent in the tech industries (both in my own experience and from what I read).
So sharing this might be useful to some - what is it about that industry or the people it attracts?

RosesAndHellebores · 11/02/2023 19:27

@Basecampzero or perhaps it's the way I dealt with it, assertively rather than taking offence, that kept getting me promoted. Despite starting my career in 1981 I have never ever felt discriminated against at work. Not for being a woman. Not for not having a degree. Neither have I felt subordinated or inferior. Because I am not and my bearing demonstrates it. I stand straight, look hard, and keep smiling.

It wouldn't happen to other women if they had presence and confidence. Nobody claps a whinger.

SamanthaCaine · 11/02/2023 19:19

Basecampzero · 11/02/2023 18:56

Peak pulling up the ladder. I don't see the point of these posts that say that it didn't happen to me. What are you implying? That other women are making it up? They shouldn't be making a fuss? If only they handled better it wouldn't happen to them?

The point is that if they were a man it wouldn't happen to them at all. They wouldn't have to appear more confident or have strategies to deal with it. It's not that they shouldn't be making a fuss, it's that they shouldn't have to make a fuss.

Women like you are part of the problem.

Are forums not for sharing experiences now?

Sodullincomparison · 11/02/2023 19:12

@piedbeauty sorry- I was the Head he was waiting for.

if he’d had basic manners walking then I would have been able to introduce myself.

Basecampzero · 11/02/2023 18:56

RosesAndHellebores · 11/02/2023 07:00

No, I don't suffer from this. Perhaps because I'm in my 60s and still working in a very senior role. To be fair it didn't happen much in my 20s except when I was no longer the most junior member of the team in a male dominated environment and was asked to take a note I said "yes, of course, we can take turns, we need a little system". Final note: it was agreed the team would rotate as notetaker, at the next meeting John Smith will be note-taker.

Nowadays if it's a formal meeting, tea and coffee will be pre-ordered. If it's small and/or informal, I have no problem making tea for people with me, gives me a minute to have a wee usually ☺️

I've always felt so privileged and lucky to have been successful in the work place, I've either not noticed, not shown offence or provided a neutral solution. Being a woman didn't stop me being successful. Nobody ever assumed I was a secretary or admin.

Peak pulling up the ladder. I don't see the point of these posts that say that it didn't happen to me. What are you implying? That other women are making it up? They shouldn't be making a fuss? If only they handled better it wouldn't happen to them?

The point is that if they were a man it wouldn't happen to them at all. They wouldn't have to appear more confident or have strategies to deal with it. It's not that they shouldn't be making a fuss, it's that they shouldn't have to make a fuss.

Women like you are part of the problem.

Walkaround · 11/02/2023 17:28

There is a difference between being asked to order in refreshments in advance as part of your role and someone randomly turning to you in a meeting and telling you to go and make everyone coffee. The former is part of the proper organisation of the meeting and the fulfilment of a useful function, and the latter is childish power play. If you are the one who suddenly came up with the idea that everyone should have coffee, then you should make the coffee yourself, or if you are the visitor, ask the person responsible for chairing the meeting where you can obtain refreshments. You are, after all, the one who appears to be in need of it.

UserNameSameGame · 11/02/2023 16:13

FawnFrenchieMum · 11/02/2023 15:38

As an EA no where in my job description does ur say make tea & coffee! So I’m not sure it would expecting to do my job.

I think that is also a very good point.

And possibly it depends on people’s experiences and the type of industry they work in as to what’s common and what people expect from different times..

In my industry the Admin staff are graduates who are expected to perform administrative tasks like collating and editing content, organising people to come together for a bigger task, organising meetings including sending out invites, booking a room and yes, ordering the refreshments. They come in to the organisation at the bottom of the ladder, learn by doing these tasks for a period of time, and then move up the ladder.

My EA however has a very specialist skill set with years of experience and I wouldn’t dream of asking her to perform the same types of tasks. Completely different role.