Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Being mistaken for the PA

515 replies

BingBoings · 10/02/2023 21:11

Twice this week I have been in email chains, where I have been asked to supply dates for a meeting.

The reason for this has in both cases, I assume, is that I am the only female name in the thread.

Both situations have seen large numbers of clients and colleagues copied in on emails where… I am asked if I can help give times when my male colleagues are free. I am usually senior to them.

Am I the only person this happens to? I find it half hilarious, and half embarrassing… A few months ago I was asked in a meeting if I could do coffees when I walked in…

i have no issue with managing my own diary nor is there any issue with being a PA… it’s more that I don’t see men having this issue…!

OP posts:
Orangello · 14/02/2023 12:14

Women always say "oh but I don't want the job via a quota,

Like there haven't been plenty of studies demonstrating that a male candidate will be regarded more competent and deserving a higher salary than a female with exactly the same CV. Or when orchestra auditions are blind, suddenly women become sinificantly more capable. Odd, isn't it.

Cosyblankets · 14/02/2023 11:57

Walkaround · 14/02/2023 09:07

The problem here is the attitude towards “subordinates.” It is inappropriate to look around a meeting room for someone you think is subordinate to you and then try to order them around. An administrator is not a “subordinate” to someone in a completely different role. It is not offensive to be thought to be an administrator, it is offensive to be thought to be a subordinate incapable of doing a more lofty-sounding job. Both men and women need to change their attitudes.

Can't bear that word subordinate. It's just an awful word.
I also don't like 'my staff' it sounds awful. What's wrong with 'my team'?

IrritableCowSyndrome · 14/02/2023 11:56

BingBoings · 10/02/2023 21:11

Twice this week I have been in email chains, where I have been asked to supply dates for a meeting.

The reason for this has in both cases, I assume, is that I am the only female name in the thread.

Both situations have seen large numbers of clients and colleagues copied in on emails where… I am asked if I can help give times when my male colleagues are free. I am usually senior to them.

Am I the only person this happens to? I find it half hilarious, and half embarrassing… A few months ago I was asked in a meeting if I could do coffees when I walked in…

i have no issue with managing my own diary nor is there any issue with being a PA… it’s more that I don’t see men having this issue…!

If I was the OP and received an email like that I'd email back saying the dates I could do but that I don't know about the others.

ethelredonagoodday · 14/02/2023 11:26

Not RTFT, but has happened to me. I work in the public sector in a traditionally male dominated discipline.
Now I'm a bit older it happens less, but in my 20s and 30s it was a definite thing for me!

lieselotte · 14/02/2023 11:24

Oh and it forces people to widen their networks as well. Which might then benefit them as well.

lieselotte · 14/02/2023 11:23

Mark's viewpoint is why I support quotas. Women always say "oh but I don't want the job via a quota, people will just assume I was rubbish and only got the job because of the quota".

No. A quota forces the recruiter to try a bit harder. Not recruit in their own image. Look around a bit more for possible candidates. And where you get a man and a woman (or a white person and a black person) who are equally good, you'll pick the woman or the black person. I actually find it offensive to say women can only get these jobs because of quotas. No, it simply concentrates the minds of the recruiters. Same goes for things like speaking panels. People will say "but I don't know a woman who can speak in this area". Well go and look. "I only know white people who can speak in this area". Well go and look harder.

SeulementUneFois · 14/02/2023 11:18

@Stewball01
I meant in terms of people looking down on others - if they look down on women, they may well look down on foreigners too..so I've a double whammy! But if they're like that they're likely to look down further on non white people again, ... I was just being precise about where I'd fall in such people's hierarchy

Orangello · 14/02/2023 11:14

Considerably more women than men attend university. The tipping point occurred in the UK in about 2001/2, depending on what you count. So it simply cannot be claimed that women are an under-represented minority in most managerial or professional work environments.

Eh, one thing has nothing to do with the other and number of female university students really does not mean women are also suddenly the majority in managerial positions. As before, just take law.
Female applicants for undergraduate law courses: 69%
Female solicitors: 61%
Female law firm partners: 35%. In largest UK law firms, only 22% of equity partners are female.
So yes it is quite likely that in top management meetings, there will still be very few women.
But yes I'm sure it's all because women are simply not capable. Odd though that women seem to become more and more capable, as yes the number of women in top positions is - ever so slowly, but still - increasing. Now, what's the explanation there? Women getting smarter, while men are not?

NoPrivateSpy · 14/02/2023 10:56

Mark19735 · 13/02/2023 00:09

Exactly. There's some real cake and eat it thinking on this thread. Either, there are sex-based differences between men and women that are immutable, or the gendering of roles and responsibilities in the workplace is a social construct designed by, and to the benefit of, the patriarchy. Which is it? Because if it's the latter - then it's all an illusion. It can be willed into oblivion through enough people simply refusing to acknowledge it. Considerably more women than men attend university. The tipping point occurred in the UK in about 2001/2, depending on what you count. So it simply cannot be claimed that women are an under-represented minority in most managerial or professional work environments. Some blue-collar industries perhaps ... but anything indoors or office-based and women are not just no longer a minority, but increasingly they occupy key positions as gatekeepers and decision-makers. The days of routinely being the only woman in a meeting surrounded by men are long gone.
So, for everyone sharing all these anecdotes of "this one time, I was asked to make the coffee by a man! How rude!" - if you are genuinely aggrieved about the status quo in your workplace, do something positive about it - change your pronouns on your email signature block, if that's what you think makes a difference; demand that pay rise, close that gender pay gap and start acting like the authoritative, influential, important and senior bad-asses you claim to be, instead of whimpering on MN about how your lack of status or self esteem is all down to sexism and the fault of all the men out there.

This post is just so depressing.

If only we all tried a little harder to 'obliterate' those pesky social constructs and prejudices.

For what it's worth (though I doubt you'll listen), I spend every day in meetings as the only woman. Financial services. Middle management. It's tiring and frankly a bit boring. But actually there is so little diversity of thought, I know it's harmful to the business. And some of the men I work with are a bit like you - think they are in their role based purely on merit and their ability to assert themselves, ask for pay rise or lead a meeting. Absolutely 0 ability to show empathy for any other group who questions whether it is a level playing field. It still isn't by the way - despite what you might think.

cassandre · 14/02/2023 10:06

If nothing else, the contributions of the male participant on this thread demonstrate that sexism continues to be alive and well.

He himself hasn't experienced sexual discrimination in the workplace, so he can't imagine it happening to women.

Imagine being on the receiving end of sexual discrimination in the workplace and taking your complaint to a boss like that. 😢

I'm comforted however by the knowledge that things are changing, albeit slowly. I'm an academic and have seen awareness of gender inequality rise gradually in my workplace over the decades, although there is still a long way to go.

xJoy · 14/02/2023 09:09

It is interesting reading this, what posters have allowed colleagues away with, I don't mean a big fight, but going to GET the coffees, just because it was assumed that was their role.

It shows me that although some people can be assertive in their intimate relationships they aren't assertive as a go-to at work. I seem to be the other way around. I can say 'no' or ignore an inappropriate request a t work easily but until I was 45, every boyfriend just plundered me like a subordinate resource. So I'm not judging anybody who went to get the coffee!! It's kind of interesting that the two are not connected, necessarily

Walkaround · 14/02/2023 09:07

The problem here is the attitude towards “subordinates.” It is inappropriate to look around a meeting room for someone you think is subordinate to you and then try to order them around. An administrator is not a “subordinate” to someone in a completely different role. It is not offensive to be thought to be an administrator, it is offensive to be thought to be a subordinate incapable of doing a more lofty-sounding job. Both men and women need to change their attitudes.

Amy1992Brighton · 14/02/2023 08:56

Cosyblankets · 13/02/2023 16:14

With all due respect it does sound like you need to be more assertive.
Before i would clear cups away I would say X Y Z you've left your cups on the table there.
Job done. It's not hard.

That told me! I do know what you mean, but at the end of meetings people all file out and I feel bad that the minimum wage cleaning / catering staff are left with a mess to clear up. It's common decency to at least put empty cups back on the trolley.

StarlightLady · 14/02/2023 08:38

This happens to me fairly regularly. It only goes to show how far we have to go.

SunshineOceanAndOranges · 14/02/2023 08:38

This is down to our biology. Instinctively, we look to men as leaders. Don’t hate on people when this happens, just smile and laugh!

Biology is bandied about a lot by reactionaries to justify sexism. (I've also heard 'biology' being used to justify worse by the way). Smiling and laughing like a good little girl is never going to command respect.

Orangello · 14/02/2023 08:27

The poster absolutely means it. I mean in the UK, only 35% of judges are female, clearly women are just not good enough. But the number was 24% a decade ago, and 0 in 1965, so the only explanation is that women are now somehow better and more capable, right?

HowDoYouOwnDisorder · 14/02/2023 07:45

they are simply not good enough. Which, on the balance of probabilities, is also the most likely explanation for why women get overlooked too.

I honestly thought this was satire

but read the whole mansplaining post and now thing the poster might mean it?

Teateaandmoretea · 14/02/2023 07:37

The man has spoken 🤣🤦🏻‍♀️

Lucyccfc68 · 14/02/2023 07:07

A male primary school teacher isn’t mistaken for the caretaker (janitor), they are mistaken for the head teacher (when it’s usually a woman). A male nurse isn’t mistaken for a porter, people assume they are a Doctor.

ConfusedNT · 14/02/2023 01:20

I don't know why posters are pretending that women are systemically prevented from reaching the top after all 92% of FTSE 100 CEOs are male only because women are simply not good enough

Right-o, thanks for clearing that up, I feel much better now a man had explained I'm just bad at my job

Mark19735 · 14/02/2023 00:42

I don't know why posters are pretending that women are systemically prevented from reaching the top - they aren't. There are about 27 million people in employment in the UK. That's about 14 million men (52%), and 13 million women (48%). Of the 893 directors of FTSE 100 boards in 2021, 393 were women (44%). There's still some room for improvement, but it's really not that far from equal ...

Adjust the ONS labour force survey figures for all those industries where men still predominate (energy, mining, agriculture, construction, manufacturing, oil and gas, waste), and women will actually outnumber men in a great many of the environments in which they work - traditionally health, education, adult social care, but also in managerial and technical professions too. The graphic below is from Mar 2022 parliamentary report on women in the UK economy. Women are employed in professional occupations in almost identical numbers to men.

The only really skewed distributions are skilled trades, care work, and admin/secretarial, which in the context of this thread is highly ironic. If you were looking for an admin person to fetch coffee, then that person is 2.5 times more likely to be female than male. Yes, assuming that the only female in the room is that admin person might constitute bias, but if that assumption is 2.5 times more likely to be correct than incorrect, then the number of occurrences need to exceed that factor of 2.5 to amount to evidence of systemic bias, and based on this thread, they don't.

In much the same way, a male primary school teacher may be mistaken for the janitor by the parents at the school gate. Or a male nurse may get mistaken for the porter or orderly by patients and family members. I'm sure it happens frequently - and it's no big deal, because it's just a mistake. A common one, perhaps, but it is still a mistake. To respond with passive-aggressiveness is utterly unprofessional and is a much clearer pointer why some people don't promote than their sex. And to be quite clear - if someone knows the truth and still behaves in a way that disrespects someone's expertise, that is clearly unacceptable and should be called out. But filter out all the instances on this thread where the behaviour described was a one off, or happened on a first encounter, or it was a long time ago, or those where the aggrieved person quite inexplicably went along with it and said nothing ... and this thread gets quite short indeed. And the voices of the women stating that this has never happened to them become a more significant contribution to the overall testimony, and less easily dismissed by those pedalling their tired old agenda.

And also, stop pretending that men are fast-tracked to the top. There are 13,999,908 men who aren't FTSE 100 CEOs either, as well as the 12,999,992 women this thread concentrates on (based on 92 male and 8 female FTSE CEOs in 2021). Is that the fault of the patriarchy too? All these posters claiming men never experience prejudices in the workplace should take a good look at how most men are actually employed. Clue - they aren't all partners in law firms or IT directors ordering coffee be brought to them. Many men are overlooked for promotions for a whole range of factors, some fair, some not - wrong school, wrong social background, too short, no presence, but most commonly of all ... they are simply not good enough. Which, on the balance of probabilities, is also the most likely explanation for why women get overlooked too.

Being mistaken for the PA
Stewball01 · 14/02/2023 00:31

@SeulementUneFois
You are foreign (white)!!!!
What does the colour of your skin matter? I doubt anybody would have wondered what colour you are.

Basecampzero · 13/02/2023 21:14

RosesAndHellebores · 13/02/2023 00:29

@Basecampzero I think you will find that the majority of successful people/leaders male or female, have presence.

Never once have I felt disadvantaged by my sex. The only pronouns that have a whisper of a chance of finding themselves on my email signature are "I" and "me".

I have met many successful people without the kind of presence you're talking about.

You may never have been disadvantaged by your sex, but you certainly seem to struggle in following the point of an argument.

Blossomtoes · 13/02/2023 20:24

Oh dear @AdelaideRo, you’ve given someone the opportunity to climb on their regular soapbox yet again.

RosesAndHellebores · 13/02/2023 19:52

Oh dear @AdelaideRo. The only place I have experienced a reductive attitude to women is when dealing with the NHS. At outpatients all the men are called Mr John Smith or Mr Fred White. The Women: Jane Doe of Brenda Jones. The courtesy of a title isn't afforded to mere women

The number of NHS doctors who have introduced themselves as Dr Jones, Mr Graham, Dr Dunne whilst assuming they may use my first name is mind-blowing.

If they assume they may use my first name they may introduce themselves with and invite me to use theirs. Anything else is reductive. I always extend my hand and say "Oh, I'm awfully sorry, I didn't catch your first name". Sometimes they blush and say "oh, er Paul". Sometimes they tell me they don't share their first name with patients.

It really is the last bastion of the hierarchy.

For what it's worth, it's either first name/first name or title/title. Recently a partner of my GP practice told me he meant nothing by it but forgot my surname on the way from his consulting room to reception. I asked if he had also forgotten his first name. He got quite arsy. I'm not sure who he thought he was. At least five years younger than me so shoukd know better in the context of equality.

Swipe left for the next trending thread