Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Being mistaken for the PA

515 replies

BingBoings · 10/02/2023 21:11

Twice this week I have been in email chains, where I have been asked to supply dates for a meeting.

The reason for this has in both cases, I assume, is that I am the only female name in the thread.

Both situations have seen large numbers of clients and colleagues copied in on emails where… I am asked if I can help give times when my male colleagues are free. I am usually senior to them.

Am I the only person this happens to? I find it half hilarious, and half embarrassing… A few months ago I was asked in a meeting if I could do coffees when I walked in…

i have no issue with managing my own diary nor is there any issue with being a PA… it’s more that I don’t see men having this issue…!

OP posts:
sashh · 11/02/2023 03:04

I had a boiler breakdown a few weeks ago, I'd got an appointment anywhere between 8.00 and 12.00.

At about 8.30 I got a call saying, "well be with you next, about 10 mins".

I thought it was the same person I made the appointment with, nope it was the female plumber.

And yes she does get that all the time.

Strangely I wasn't suprised at the Sky engineer being female.

@Mark1973 you need to change the number to 1950sdinosaur

yellowtwo · 11/02/2023 02:52

Cordeliathecat

You haven't systematically experienced sexism but you are more than happy to play the useless female role and let DH have the headache!
That you think women have a "useless female role" is stereotyping and a result of sexism.

Everyonehasavoice · 11/02/2023 02:08

As an architect I had this in the early days with clients
Never with contractors who would bend over backwards to treat me with respect, actually far more than my male colleagues.

If you’re assertive and don’t take any crap they’ll get the picture.
In terms of them asking you to give dates for your male colleagues you just need to tell them your role.

Aria999 · 11/02/2023 01:43

I have never had a problem in a career context. I did have a tw*t kitchen contractor who would only listen to my husband about figures (they were wrong, I am an accountant).

Cordeliathecat · 11/02/2023 01:36

Twatalert · 11/02/2023 01:21

Sounds like you are doing OK!

Honest question: throughout your career did you never really observe that you are being treated differently because you are a woman?

I thought these things didn't happen to me until well into my 30s. Turns out it was all so ingrained in me that even I didn't notice. Looking back there were tons of incidents, starting with my first boss calling me a 'good girl' for agreeing to something. No man would ever be called a good boy in a workplace. I was just blind, had no awareness and considered all this normal.

Now I get these things on a different level. Mainly by my male colleagues who think they know my job better than i do. But yes they are dicks too. The more successful my part of the business is the worse they behave.

Of course I have had the odd experience of sexism both inside and outside the work place but not systemically so. Not enough to feel that it's common or regular for me. But yes, I have come into contact with a few dicks in my time! I have just given them a swift dressing down and sometimes I've not even needed to as others have jumped in on my behalf before I could even open my mouth.
All that said, I do carry myself well and am more than capable of holding my own in a professional environment. My father was a feminist and I had great male and female mentors in the early days of my career that set me up well. It never occurred to me that I would face any obstacles due to my sex and I can honestly say that I don't feel I ever have.
The only time I regularly experience sexism is when the plumber/builder/electrician/mechanic tells me he needs to talk to DH about the issues. And then I am more than happy to play the useless female role and let DH have the headache!

SueG60 · 11/02/2023 01:29

Delphigirl · 11/02/2023 00:52

Manspaining misogyny to Mumsnet.

I’ve seen it all now.

He's articulating his points very well, everything he's saying is logical and explains why these things happen. And I found it semi-interesting to read.

However, he doesn't seem to be grasping that its a problem for us. So what if you're a woman in the middle and jockeying for position. The issue isn't that it shows insecurity its that in comparison to a male in exactly the same position in the hierarchy you're having to deal with preconceptions that they don't.

Twatalert · 11/02/2023 01:21

Cordeliathecat · 11/02/2023 01:07

I am very senior and work in a male dominated industry. I have never found this. Quite the opposite in fact, I am often the only woman in the boardroom and I feel as though the men go out of their way to ensure I'm never the one pouring the coffee, taking notes etc. In fact, it was the same when I was more junior. And the industry I work in would never be described as politically correct. Maybe you just work with dicks?

Sounds like you are doing OK!

Honest question: throughout your career did you never really observe that you are being treated differently because you are a woman?

I thought these things didn't happen to me until well into my 30s. Turns out it was all so ingrained in me that even I didn't notice. Looking back there were tons of incidents, starting with my first boss calling me a 'good girl' for agreeing to something. No man would ever be called a good boy in a workplace. I was just blind, had no awareness and considered all this normal.

Now I get these things on a different level. Mainly by my male colleagues who think they know my job better than i do. But yes they are dicks too. The more successful my part of the business is the worse they behave.

Cordeliathecat · 11/02/2023 01:07

I am very senior and work in a male dominated industry. I have never found this. Quite the opposite in fact, I am often the only woman in the boardroom and I feel as though the men go out of their way to ensure I'm never the one pouring the coffee, taking notes etc. In fact, it was the same when I was more junior. And the industry I work in would never be described as politically correct. Maybe you just work with dicks?

Hawkins003 · 11/02/2023 01:02

Didn't the op say it was usually other women that made the error ?

CrackingCrackling · 11/02/2023 01:01

Yup. Whenever i was standing next to one of my male junior managers (retail) the customer would always direct their queries to them. They always seemed shocked when they found out it was actually little old me who was the one who could make the decisions as I was 'The' manager 🙄

DysmalRadius · 11/02/2023 00:56

Mansplaining misogyny - check
Denying the experiences of women - check
Claiming that overt sexism is just women being oversensitive - check
Telling women 'what they actually meant to say' - check
Blaming women for being victims of misogyny - check

I do believe that we are in the presence of a subject matter expert!

Delphigirl · 11/02/2023 00:52

Mark19735 · 11/02/2023 00:31

Are you sure about that? It feels like the OP was saying "I think I'm quite senior. I was treated like my role is more junior." That's about status.

Misogyny is dislike of, contempt for, or ingrained prejudice against women. But the OP didn't describe a scenario where anyone exhibited loathing and hatred at the very idea that a women could be quite senior. She just gave an example of mistaken identity - one where it was assumed that she was junior. There are other threads about age-based mistaken identity, race-based mistaken identity, class-based mistaken identity - all sorts. It happens all the time.

Making it all about the sex of the person is a distraction. Many men are status-obsessed and insecure. So are many women. Anecdotal examples of mistaken identity are not evidence of systematic misogyny. Unconscious bias, perhaps. But it's not always pernicious. Sometimes mistakes really are just that - mistakes. All the posts in which people are celebrating those who have responded to these situations with prickliness or rudeness are just exhibiting the attitudes I described - an unhealthy obsession with perceived status and a gleeful desire to brandish some weird identity-based victimhood. That isn't fighting misogyny - it's being a dick. People with real gravitas don't mind, seem to notice or even care when it happens to them.

Manspaining misogyny to Mumsnet.

I’ve seen it all now.

monsteramunch · 11/02/2023 00:48

@Mark19735

Keen to check if you were a troll, I did a quick search of your name. A recent post:

Men are just like babies. He wants sex and attention. You need to divide your time and attention between the two babies in your life. Clearly there are good reasons to prioritise the actual baby, but if you are allocating your attention 100% to the new one and 0% to the old one, you are getting it wrong.

Men are also quite useful. They can fix things, and provide for you. So consider any time you spend giving him the sex and attention he wants an investment.

Good grief.

I hope you are a troll tbh.

There we have it, a raging sexist... shock horror.

Women - stop womaning 'wrong' and have sex you don't really want to have, so men will 'provide for you'!

Bleurgh.

nocoolnamesleft · 11/02/2023 00:46

Oh, look, we have a man mansplaining misogyny to us. Deep joy.

One of our chief execs was such a rude bullying misogynist that even some of my male colleagues told him he needed to wind his neck in.

Mark19735 · 11/02/2023 00:46

monsteramunch · 11/02/2023 00:43

Being a woman is a 'visible characteristic', funnily enough. What an odd thing to apparently not realise.

Err ... that's my point.

PocketBattleship · 11/02/2023 00:44

Are you sure about that? It feels like the OP was saying "I think I'm quite senior. I was treated like my role is more junior."

@Mark19735 did you forget to add "because I'm a woman"?

monsteramunch · 11/02/2023 00:43

Mark19735 · 11/02/2023 00:41

Funny you should say that. I don't need to hypothesise that situation. And I know exactly how I behave - as graciously and forgivingly as I would any other mistake.

There is a world of difference between someone mistakenly assuming you have a different role to the one you actually have because of some visible characteristic and some conscious or unconscious biases, and someone behaving as if you don't merit the role you actually have once they know the truth. The latter is prejudice. The former, is a mistake.

Being a woman is a 'visible characteristic', funnily enough. What an odd thing to apparently not realise.

Hawkins003 · 11/02/2023 00:43

With my uniform I often get mistaken for a different role, which can be useful at times, but I can I understand your perspectives op

Mark19735 · 11/02/2023 00:41

Funny you should say that. I don't need to hypothesise that situation. And I know exactly how I behave - as graciously and forgivingly as I would any other mistake.

There is a world of difference between someone mistakenly assuming you have a different role to the one you actually have because of some visible characteristic and some conscious or unconscious biases, and someone behaving as if you don't merit the role you actually have once they know the truth. The latter is prejudice. The former, is a mistake.

theresastormcoming · 11/02/2023 00:39

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

monsteramunch · 11/02/2023 00:38

All the posts in which people are celebrating those who have responded to these situations with prickliness or rudeness are just exhibiting the attitudes I described - an unhealthy obsession with perceived status and a gleeful desire to brandish some weird identity-based victimhood. That isn't fighting misogyny - it's being a dick.

You heard it, women. Be kind to men. Always.

Even at your own expense and that of your female colleagues. Don't make a fuss. Don't be 'rude' or 'prickly'. Don't challenge men.

Smile and be kind to men, even when they are being rude / dismissive / sexist.

monsteramunch · 11/02/2023 00:35

Mark19735 · 10/02/2023 23:45

@ItchyBillco - I've seen both men and women get tetchy about their perceived status. In every case, the truth was they actually commanded very little respect. I've also seen very high-powered men and women in action. In every case, they didn't appear to care one jot about what others thought of their position in the hierarchy. Genuine authority doesn't feel diminished by mistaken identity or perceived slights. Only middle-ranking people insecure about their true worth seem to care. Their sex has nothing to do with it.

Would you say this to people of colour in senior positions who share that they have been treated differently to their peers in the workplace due to their race? Would you say to them that they were status obsessed, rather than simply acknowledging they want to challenge racism (conscious or otherwise) in the workplace?

Or is it just women's experiences you dismiss so readily?

Mark19735 · 11/02/2023 00:31

Twatalert · 10/02/2023 23:57

But we aren't discussing people getting tetchy about their status. We are discussing systematic misogyny, which is different.

Are you sure about that? It feels like the OP was saying "I think I'm quite senior. I was treated like my role is more junior." That's about status.

Misogyny is dislike of, contempt for, or ingrained prejudice against women. But the OP didn't describe a scenario where anyone exhibited loathing and hatred at the very idea that a women could be quite senior. She just gave an example of mistaken identity - one where it was assumed that she was junior. There are other threads about age-based mistaken identity, race-based mistaken identity, class-based mistaken identity - all sorts. It happens all the time.

Making it all about the sex of the person is a distraction. Many men are status-obsessed and insecure. So are many women. Anecdotal examples of mistaken identity are not evidence of systematic misogyny. Unconscious bias, perhaps. But it's not always pernicious. Sometimes mistakes really are just that - mistakes. All the posts in which people are celebrating those who have responded to these situations with prickliness or rudeness are just exhibiting the attitudes I described - an unhealthy obsession with perceived status and a gleeful desire to brandish some weird identity-based victimhood. That isn't fighting misogyny - it's being a dick. People with real gravitas don't mind, seem to notice or even care when it happens to them.

SueG60 · 11/02/2023 00:25

Twatalert · 11/02/2023 00:00

This misogyny in the workplace has really fucked me off for the past couple of years. I wish my male colleagues stopped mansplaining to me.

Sadly I don't think it will ever fully stop, we're the product of millions of years of evolution and its only been for the last 40 years women have been seen as an equal part of the workforce. 40 years is nothing in that context, our brain wiring won't have changed.

I reckon its pretty much engrained within us to assess groups at face value and build a picture of what the social hierarchy is within them. Women probably score lower than men in that subconscious hierarchy so we always have to work to show we're actually more senior or competent.

NatashaDancing · 11/02/2023 00:17

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

The going out to get Sudafed is just bizarre. The response should have been to see if a junior member of staff, of either sex was available and then get on with leading the meeting.

Swipe left for the next trending thread