Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do I need a EHCP for my son?

107 replies

swingsandroundaboutsss · 10/02/2023 19:01

Trying to cut a long story short..
My son is diagnosed with autism and is struggling at school. There are some things in place to help him but I'm beginning to wonder how much help they actually are.
He struggles with his emotional regulation and can get stressed quite easily. He's very impulsive. He's also very clever, in the top 10% of the class in maths and reading.
We've recently been doing some occupational therapy sessions outside of school and whilst speaking to the therapist she suggested an EHCP. We were discussing my son getting frustrated in class and one of the reasons being he always has his hand up and the teacher not being able to answer his questions. When I spoke to the teacher she said he always has his hand up and can't answer his questions otherwise she'd be stopping the class every 5 seconds. The therapist suggested the EHCP could provide 1 to 1 support and that person could answer these questions. He gets frustrated in maths because he has to listen to all of the things he already knows and the teacher needs him to be present for the last 10% of input for the more challenging activity.
I suggested the EHCP and she said she'd get back to me.
She asked me to come in for a chat after school about an overnight trip they're going on and she'd talk about the EHCP and feedback from O.T.
When I went in to the classroom my son asked her to remember about the form, she sternly replied to him "it's my turn to talk, not yours, I'm talking to parents, go and sit in the reading corner". We spoke about the trip and she tried to finish it there and said she had a meeting. I mentioned the EHCP and she said "in a nut shell, it's only provided when the school isn't meeting the child's needs and we have things such as brain breaks in place for when it gets too much for him. There are other children out in the SEN hub who have more serious, severe, visible needs that get an EHCP. He doesn't get one because he gets frustrated because I can't answer his questions. If you want to speak more then email the head of senco". She then got up, said she had a meeting so had to go. I felt frustrated, never mind my child. When I've spoke to other parents or teachers they've just said she's strict. When my son is doing everything he's supposed to she's the happiest person ever but when he's had a challenging day, she can't cope. He's basically told me he feels as though she picks on him, singles him out and entices him to get upset. That's a lot coming from a 7 year old. I understand schools are under pressure and I'm thinking of this as a way to get him extra support and take some of the pressure off them. I've spoken to the deputy head about his issues with the teacher and she said "She really likes you, in fact, she chose you to be in her class this year because she had you last year and knows you quite well already".
I'd be lying if I said I wasn't gutted he had her again. I remember one incident where he ran across the playground to me at home time and she chased him and grabbed his arm and told him off for going without telling a teacher. I said I understood but could she take her hand off him as she had no right to grab him. She apologised and then back tracked and said she never grabbed him 🤦‍♀️.
Do I request a change of class, wait until next year and hope things improve, go down the EHCP route on my own or just stick it out?

OP posts:
Spendonsend · 11/02/2023 09:07

mynamesnotMa · 11/02/2023 08:28

Apply for an assessment now. That will have input from OT SALT EP and Camhs. That's every childs legal right who might have SEND.
Look at IPSEA for template letters.
Read the SEND code of practice.

This.

JustKeepBuilding · 11/02/2023 09:01

@ofwarren You don’t need a diagnosis or assessments to apply.

If the LA agree to assess during the EHCNA they must seek advice from:
a) the child’s parent or the young person;
b) educational advice (usually from the head teacher or principal);
c) medical advice and information from a health care professional;
d) psychological advice and information from an educational psychologist;
e) advice and information in relation to social care;
f) advice and information from any other person the local authority thinks appropriate;
g) where the child or young person is in or beyond year 9, advice and information in relation to provision to assist the child or young person in preparation for adulthood and independent living; and
h) advice and information from any person the child’s parent or young person reasonably requests that the local authority seek advice from.

H can include things like SALT, OT, psychiatrist, clinical psychologist.

Unless money is no object I wouldn’t seek independent assessments before applying for an EHCNA. That just delays the process. Also, they are expensive and if you get them now but e.g. the LA agree to assess but not issue and you appeal you may find they are out of date before you get to a hearing. They used to be considered up to date for around 2 years, but over the last few years SENDIST have considered reports much younger out of date. You don’t know whether e.g. the LA EP assessment will be sufficient but you desperately need to prioritise funding an independent SALT either.

ofwarren · 11/02/2023 08:50

We are looking at applying for the EHCP ourselves and was just wondering about the assessments. What assessments will we need to get and I'm assuming we get these privately? What kind of cost are we looking at?
Also, my son is on the pathway for ASD assessment and obviously the waiting list is a long time. He's already year 4. Can we apply without the diagnosis in place?

JustKeepBuilding · 11/02/2023 08:45

Just be aware, if your child is able but gets a 1-2-1 TA they may not be sat on your child’s shoulder the whole lesson.

This would depend on what is written in F. For some DC they very much are.

The TA would also be used for some group interventions and general TA activities. That’s not what your child’s funding would be for but I guarantee the school would utilise that TA.

If 1:1 is specified and quantified in F then it must be provided. If the school are not providing it they leave themselves and the LA open to legal proceedings. The parent can enforce the provision.

Anewuser · 11/02/2023 08:37

Just be aware, if your child is able but gets a 1-2-1 TA they may not be sat on your child’s shoulder the whole lesson. It would be distracting for the teacher and the child sat next to your son or his table if they are constantly answering questions. The TA would also be used for some group interventions and general TA activities. That’s not what your child’s funding would be for but I guarantee the school would utilise that TA.

However, as others have said, now it the time to start the process to ensure their eventual move into secondary school is supported.

mynamesnotMa · 11/02/2023 08:28

Apply for an assessment now. That will have input from OT SALT EP and Camhs. That's every childs legal right who might have SEND.
Look at IPSEA for template letters.
Read the SEND code of practice.

Punxsutawney · 11/02/2023 08:26

teachingbean · 11/02/2023 07:48

Genuinely interested what grounds he got this on?

Ds is autistic, has significant MH difficulties, communication difficulties and an eating disorder. He has always struggled in a mainstream environment and had pretty much been let down by the education system, since the day he walked into reception at 4 years old. He has never had any behaviour difficulties at school though and only needs minimal 1-1 support in an educational environment.

At 18 he needs support with daily living, can't leave our home independently and his more complex needs means that he needs a special school.
Our LA pay over £74k a year for his placement and also provide taxi transport there and back every day ( it's 20 miles away).
The need for an EHCP and this particular placement was supported by a multitude of professionals including NHS but also the LA Educational Psychologist and their Head of Send. We did not need to go to tribunal to secure this placement.

Ds's GCSEs are from 2020, so he didn't actually take them but they are very much an indication of what he is capable of. In fact when I first applied for an EHCP he was at a state selective grammar school.

Many on here think that a child being academic, not needing 1-1 or having no behaviour difficulties means that an getting an EHCP or a specialist placement will be impossible and that is absolutely not the case.

Lougle · 11/02/2023 08:23

teachingbean · 11/02/2023 07:48

Genuinely interested what grounds he got this on?

For DD2, who is 'of at least average intelligence', it was on SEMH (Social Emotional and Mental Health) grounds, with ASD as her primary need. She now attends a school with 3 in her class and a TA that accompanies them to each class throughout the day.

BigMacAttack · 11/02/2023 08:17

Teatime55 · 10/02/2023 22:30

Just because he copes in primary doesn’t mean he will in secondary, probably best to get it in place now. We’ve wasted lots of time in secondary waiting to get things changed for DD.

Absolutely! So many kids arrive in secondary and FE without an EHCP who clearly would benefit from an EHCP and support.

Lots of parents don't pursue it because the schools tell them not to and then these kids fall apart in the next step of their education.

teachingbean · 11/02/2023 07:48

Punxsutawney · 10/02/2023 19:13

As your child is doing so well academically, it will be tough going to get an EHCP.

Ds got an EHCP the autumn after he achieved 5 grade 9 GCSES and now attends an expensive specialist independent school funded by our LA. Academically able children can get EHCPs.

I also applied without the support of Ds's school at the time, the Senco said she would tell the LA an EHCNA wasn't necessary. She did just that and he still got one...

Genuinely interested what grounds he got this on?

Teatime55 · 10/02/2023 22:30

Just because he copes in primary doesn’t mean he will in secondary, probably best to get it in place now. We’ve wasted lots of time in secondary waiting to get things changed for DD.

PlinkyPlonk1 · 10/02/2023 20:40

They now have places at special schools.

PlinkyPlonk1 · 10/02/2023 20:39

And our kids won't go anywhere near the primary school. They have such bad memories of the place.

PlinkyPlonk1 · 10/02/2023 20:36

I think that you should trust your own instincts.

I would ask to change to the other class.

I would also consider my experience:

2 academically highly able autistic children.

The primary school continuously told us that they could meet needs, that they were highly able, that they were "fine" at school and doing well and that they wouldn't get an EHCP.

The EHCP needs assessment process identified needs that the primary school pretended weren't there but my gut feeling knew.

You will need private reports because the NHS and LA reports were next to useless.

In my experience, SENDIASS are also next to useless given that they're supposed to be independent but are funded by the LA.

IPSEA/SOS SEN! will help you.

Apply for the EHCP. Use the SOS SEN! guides (£5 each) to give you some guidance.

Expect to go to Tribunal to get what you need and you will have a year long wait to get to Tribunal which is why I think that you should apply sooner rather than later, in time for secondary.

We found that secondary school offered more help and support.

Stomacharmeleon · 10/02/2023 20:31

Two of my sons have EHCP's. Eldest had a statement. All academic.
I am so glad I persevered with the process particularly with my eldest as although they all performed academically they fell apart in secondary schools and ended up in special Ed settings and having them helped them with their disability funding at university.
I had to take my local authority to tribunal the first time :/

Sometimeswinning · 10/02/2023 20:28

Choconut · 10/02/2023 19:32

It's funny that teachers sometimes have a real problem with a child always having their hand up. DS has ASD and in his favourite subject at secondary he always has his hand up and always knows the answers, he is often one step ahead of the teacher as he does a lot of learning around the subject at home. The teacher gave him a 4 out of 5 for effort and when we asked why he said it was because he always has his hand up and others didn't get a chance. DS said that no one else puts their hand up - so basically the teacher is annoyed that ds always knows the answer and no one else bothers to put their hand up - what does he want him to do? pretend he doesn't know the answer? And how will that help if no one else has their hand up any way. He's not shouting the answer out by the way, just sat with his hand up keen to answer.

Why doesn't the teacher give your child a notebook and pad so he can write any questions down rather than just getting annoyed when he gets frustrated having his hand up - telling him to put it just put it down/ignoring him obviously isn't working. She's obviously finding him annoying and doesn't sound very nice but I don't understand why she hasn't tried anything else to help him with this. The questions could then have already been answered by her by the end, could be answered by her at a better time/all at the same time or he could be encouraged to find the answers out himself (if they are that sort of question).

I would see if you can get someone from SEND in to observe him, the lady that saw DS was bloody brilliant - school was useless and didn't do any of it - but she was great, I spoke to her too and she was lovely. They might be able to give the teacher lots of ideas on things she could do to help ds with his issues.

Teachers don't. Your ds' teacher may do. They are not one step ahead of the teacher but most probably the class. I do think there should be different groups for those who think ahead and excell, Understand the work. Still working 4 years below their year group. That takes at least an extra 2 TAs. That's the dream and what our children should expect. Strangely no one wants the job of a TA. Puzzling, when we have the complete support of parents and SLT!!

Lougle · 10/02/2023 20:27

DD2 was in year 10. The SENCO wouldn't support my request for a EHC needs assessment application. At all. She point blank refused the request of her manager, an Assistant Head, twice, on the grounds that DD2 'didn't meet the criteria'. I did a Subject Access Request and used that information to apply myself. DD2 ended up at a PRU in their vulnerable children section.

Not only was DD2 given an EHCP, but she was allocated a very expensive independent specialist school, once the assessment was complete. Then the LA agreed to pay for an extra year, so that she could restart as a year 10.

JustKeepBuilding · 10/02/2023 20:19

That's as may be but there are lots of sneaky unofficial ways LEAs use to try getting out of doing EHCP assessments.

There are, but they are all unlawful and can be challenged. They shouldn’t just be accepted by parents.

We had to go to mediation

In case you need to appeal again, you don’t actually have to partake in mediation. You only have to consider it. You can get the certificate and submit straight to SENDIST. LAs often use mediation as a delaying tactic, if they are going to concede they will do so regardless of whether you actively partake or not.

@BigMacAttack I know, SENDIASS receive LA funding so aren’t truly independent and will ultimately toe the party line. Some are better than others.

BigMacAttack · 10/02/2023 20:13

EHCPs can also be granted purely for SEMH needs.

Apply yourself. Templates on the IPSEA website. There are individuals who offer consultancy services to help you apply, represent you in parent meetings, go over the draft EHCP and so on.

OodieSmoodie · 10/02/2023 20:13

asleeponthetable · 10/02/2023 19:54

Can be, often aren’t. Often to the tune of more than the £6k. There are a multitude of reasons why schools don’t want the hassle, very frustrating for parents and much easier if the OP can to just do it herself.

I kept being told my son wouldn’t get one. Strangely enough he we were granted straight away and the school even had the cheek to say they couldn’t meet need.

Our school kept insisting DD didn’t need any support as she was fine and that she definitely didn’t need an EHCP.

Later on, when the LA started putting pressure on school to explain what they had been doing, and reminding them of their legal responsibilities to make adjustments, school suddenly declared that they couldn’t meet her “extremely complex” needs.

Same child, no change in needs during this period 😂

Sirzy · 10/02/2023 20:10

cravingtoblerone · 10/02/2023 20:06

The legal bar for assessment is very low

That's as may be but there are lots of sneaky unofficial ways LEAs use to try getting out of doing EHCP assessments. Our son has ASD and was barely verbal, had major issues with balance and motor skills when he went to school. Our LEA still initially refused to assess and tried to adopt a 'let's see how he goes' strategy. We had to go to mediation and threaten them with a tribunal before they would back down.

That’s why sadly it is essential that parents are educated in the lies spouted and able to fight to what their child needs

swingsandroundaboutsss · 10/02/2023 20:09

There's so much useful information, thank you!

I've tried to explain to him about other children needing their turn and that him not being chosen is sometimes because the teacher knows that he knows and it gives other children an opportunity for help. He understands what I'm saying but in the moment he just needs to get it out. He's worked so hard to not shout out but will keep his hand in the air for so long it's painful to watch (he's done it in front of me when we're having a meeting with the teacher).

It was me who suggested the book and she said it was a good idea but then said it would distract him. He's got it but wants to hide it so people don't think he's 'different'.

OP posts:
Sirzy · 10/02/2023 20:09

Nightlystroll · 10/02/2023 19:52

Can I ask, from a place of ignorance, if children are academic and achieving high grades, why do they need more support?

Ds is now in year 8 snd has had 1-1 via his ehcp since year 3 (before that section f was less specific)

he is on the whole academically able (but with a spikey profile) but his complex combination of needs means he needs the 1-1 to be able to access the curriculum. As a team we have tried to have the 1-1 take a step back more but the consequences have shown he is far from able to deal with it.

needs go much deeper than just academic ability

BigMacAttack · 10/02/2023 20:07

JustKeepBuilding · 10/02/2023 19:30

Be careful with SENDIASS, some are good but too many repeat the LA’s unlawful policies. IPSEA and SOSSEN are better.

SENDIASS are usually associated with the LA.

cravingtoblerone · 10/02/2023 20:06

The legal bar for assessment is very low

That's as may be but there are lots of sneaky unofficial ways LEAs use to try getting out of doing EHCP assessments. Our son has ASD and was barely verbal, had major issues with balance and motor skills when he went to school. Our LEA still initially refused to assess and tried to adopt a 'let's see how he goes' strategy. We had to go to mediation and threaten them with a tribunal before they would back down.

Swipe left for the next trending thread