Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wish schools would ban smartphones

167 replies

Sotiredofallthisnonsense · 10/02/2023 17:34

Aibu to think that its the very least schools should be doing so that schools and parents can work together to minimise the harm that smartphones cause - which imo far outweigh any benefits. By allowing smartphones even in the classroom, schools are the largest contributer to the peer pressure to have one. Am I in a minority of parents who wish schools didn't permit smartphones?

OP posts:
girlfriend44 · 10/02/2023 18:15

Isn't it up to the parents not to buy them in the first place?

Boomboom22 · 10/02/2023 18:13

So do you think it wise to give your child a phone at 18, ne experience? Like those parents who don't let their kids try alcohol and then think it's safe for them to live in halls at uni with everyone who has been drinking for 1-2yrs and knows how to handle themselves and what they can drink. It looked dangerous to me then and still does now. You have to teach them how to manage themselves. Confiscation of phones doesn't teach them how to manage in real life. Unless in a low skilled job with a locker like retail most people have their phones on them at work and have to control themselves, even the teachers.

Drywhitefruitycidergin · 10/02/2023 18:12

Dd's school they're not allowed. Switched off & kept in lockers. Confiscated for 5 days if caught using it (which i think is ridiculous but it hasn't happened yet so I've had no cause to object)

watchfulwishes · 10/02/2023 18:10

I agree they should not be allowed in school. Luckily our school has this policy!

I visited one school during the choosing process where when this topic came up, the head claimed they had 'never' had an incident where a pupil shared inappropriate material Hmm

I think banning them in school is simple and clear. Kids can do what they like (within the law) the second they leave the premises.

Theunamedcat · 10/02/2023 18:10

In my sons school they are encouraged to Google on their smartphones in some lessons others they are tasked with playing a specific online educational game on their phones

Prometheus · 10/02/2023 18:10

When we attended high school open days a few years ago, all the schools prided themselves on saying how they banned phones during school time. However on nearly every visit we’d walk into a class and the pupils were all sat on their phones doing research or homework. Turns out they need a phone as they don’t appear to have books, worksheets, dictionaries in class. This was the case at the grammar and non-grammar schools we visited. My son is now at secondary school and has to use his phone in classes pretty much every day. They even had to use them in maths the other day “for research”.

JudgeJ · 10/02/2023 18:10

but you can't make schools police before and after school.

But that's precisely what parents expect, how often are parents told to 'report it to school' whenever it occurs under the heading of 'safeguarding'. Maybe if parents practised safeguarding of their own children there would be fewer problems both in and out of school.

BooksAndHooks · 10/02/2023 18:10

Most schools I know don’t allow phones at all in school. If they see them or hear them at all they lose them until the end of term.

Dacadactyl · 10/02/2023 18:10

I agree with you OP. I think phones are an unnecessary distraction in school.

DDs school is very strict on phone use. They have to be off and in their bags the minute they go through the school gate and they're not allowed them out again til end of the day.

If a child is caught with the phone at all during the day (including lunchtimes) they are confiscated and then the parent has to collect the phone. They won't ever return a confiscated phone to a child. They deliberately inconvenience the parents.

cansu · 10/02/2023 18:09

I would prefer it if students were allowed a basic phone that makes calls and that is it. This would get round the argument that they were needed for safety on way home. I think the ship has sailed on smartphones and teens. They are the cause of much of the mental health angst that many teens display.

WhatWhereWhenHowWhy · 10/02/2023 18:09

Maireas · 10/02/2023 17:37

Parents allow their children to have them.
We ban them in the classroom, but they use them at break and lunch.

see above.
Parents often shout at us that were ridiculous for not allowing them or smart watches in school, and actively work against us!

Forestwalks · 10/02/2023 18:08

My sons secondary school do not allow phones in school time at all. Not at break or lunch either. They have to be switched off in bags all day.If they are seen they are confiscated and a parent has to collect at the end of the day.
My son turns his phone on at the end of the day once off school premises so that we can contact each other if there is an emergency or one of us is running late. I’m happy with the school rule regarding this.

corcaithecat · 10/02/2023 18:07

Phones aren't allowed out in the classroom in my son's secondary school and it seems to be well policed. I don't think they should ban the children having them though, as most children here have them for safety reasons.

We live very rurally and DS catches the bus to school but has missed it occasionally at home time so has had to contact me to arrange to collect him. On a couple of other occasions, the bus broke down en route and I drove to collect him. I doubt the school would have been interested in contacting the parents on either of these occasions.

However, the school requires children to have their own specified Lenovo tablet device to take to all classes to be used as a note taking device and for project work etc. It is meant to be fairly locked down to prevent kids using them for nefarious purposes but my son and presumably some of the other kids can easily bypass these settings.

As a parent, I think it's incredibly important that all parents engage with technology and learn more about keeping safe online, preferably in partnership with the schools and specialist organisations.

What they shouldn't do is rely solely on schools to monitor their children's access to the internet which is surely the parent's responsibility?

JudgeJ · 10/02/2023 18:06

Sotiredofallthisnonsense · 10/02/2023 17:34

Aibu to think that its the very least schools should be doing so that schools and parents can work together to minimise the harm that smartphones cause - which imo far outweigh any benefits. By allowing smartphones even in the classroom, schools are the largest contributer to the peer pressure to have one. Am I in a minority of parents who wish schools didn't permit smartphones?

Maybe the parents could be proactive for once and stop buying their prodigy these phones, it would reduce a lot of problems they cause which they then expect the schools to solve! Start being parents and not pseudo-friends.

pointythings · 10/02/2023 18:06

I think there's a balance to be struck. Our local secondary insists on phones off and in bags during lessons. They can be used at break. It's policed and it works pretty well - but then the school is really tough on bullying.

Local 6th form treats their pupils like adults - no uniform, phones allowed and expected to be used responsibly in lessons, access to school WiFi. Again, it works well.

RiktheButler · 10/02/2023 18:05

Nimbostratus100 · 10/02/2023 17:37

Ive worked in schools where they are banned and schools where they are not.

Sorry, but banning just does not work

students are required to do so much online, and there is no way the school can provide IT so we need students to bring in phones, It is a huge inconvenience when we have the odd child in the class without a phone

Maybe its just how I'm reading it - and apologies if so - but a child without a smartphone is "an inconvenience "?????

Sotiredofallthisnonsense · 10/02/2023 18:04

"I think that you are trying to abdicate responsibility here. You need to parent. Teachers have enough to do."

I was told by the school they recommend my child has a smartphone as they'd be the odd one out otherwise. I didn't want my child to have a smartphone but the school recommended they were bought one. I'm not sure what parents can do in that situation other than condemn their child to social ostracisation.

OP posts:
Pastorswife · 10/02/2023 18:01

Phones are banned at the school that I teach in, and I love it that way. Students still have phones of course, but you don’t see them unless they sneak into the bathroom to use them. Never in lessons and we have a strict confiscation policy that is enforced and supported from the Head of School right down to the janitor (who has been known to confiscate phones!).

My friend has a 13 year old DS without a phone, and the school he attends asked her to buy him a phone for ‘learning and classroom activities’. If a school asked me to do that for my kids, I’d enrol them in a different school. The classroom is no place for a phone, this is a hill I will die on.

luckylavender · 10/02/2023 17:56

Sotiredofallthisnonsense · 10/02/2023 17:34

Aibu to think that its the very least schools should be doing so that schools and parents can work together to minimise the harm that smartphones cause - which imo far outweigh any benefits. By allowing smartphones even in the classroom, schools are the largest contributer to the peer pressure to have one. Am I in a minority of parents who wish schools didn't permit smartphones?

I think that you are trying to abdicate responsibility here. You need to parent. Teachers have enough to do.

Johnnysgirl · 10/02/2023 17:56

Sotiredofallthisnonsense · 10/02/2023 17:34

Aibu to think that its the very least schools should be doing so that schools and parents can work together to minimise the harm that smartphones cause - which imo far outweigh any benefits. By allowing smartphones even in the classroom, schools are the largest contributer to the peer pressure to have one. Am I in a minority of parents who wish schools didn't permit smartphones?

Lots of schools do. My kid's schools (two different ones) included.

juliettesmother · 10/02/2023 17:54

My school is zero phones and smart watches too. It's a small school, so relatively easy to manage.

shard5 · 10/02/2023 17:54

At my son's school phones have to be handed in at reception and collected at hometime.
At dds school no smartphones allowed either, if the kids need to bring in a phone to contact parents at drop off or pick up a non smart phone has to be handed in at start of day again they can only have it back on the way out at hometime

Courgettecity · 10/02/2023 17:53

My kids school doesn't allow phones. It's so much better than their mates who go to a different school. Watching a hockey match yesterday, the other team subs were all on their phones ignoring the match, my kids team subs were all fully engaged in the match and shouting encouragement. They don't allow them out in breaks either.

whatanoddthingtoask · 10/02/2023 17:52

My dd has an exemption as her school banned phones and smart watches but she needs both to manage her medical conditions. The other pupils are constantly having a go at her she has to explain about 5/6 times a day why she’s allowed it

TeamadIshbel · 10/02/2023 17:51

Sotiredofallthisnonsense · 10/02/2023 17:34

Aibu to think that its the very least schools should be doing so that schools and parents can work together to minimise the harm that smartphones cause - which imo far outweigh any benefits. By allowing smartphones even in the classroom, schools are the largest contributer to the peer pressure to have one. Am I in a minority of parents who wish schools didn't permit smartphones?

I agree.
Parents need to enforce this though and unfortunately this is so out of the range of scope for many parents.

Many parents absolve practically all responsibility to schools and the staff in them. Which is really so odd considering DC spend 15% of their time at school!!!!