Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wish schools would ban smartphones

167 replies

Sotiredofallthisnonsense · 10/02/2023 17:34

Aibu to think that its the very least schools should be doing so that schools and parents can work together to minimise the harm that smartphones cause - which imo far outweigh any benefits. By allowing smartphones even in the classroom, schools are the largest contributer to the peer pressure to have one. Am I in a minority of parents who wish schools didn't permit smartphones?

OP posts:
TheSnugglyDuckling · 10/02/2023 18:40

Smart phones should be banned for under 16s. Under 16 they can have a basic Nokia to call and text. One day I think we’ll look back at smartphones like cigarettes

Partyandbullshit · 10/02/2023 18:39

neverbeenskiing · 10/02/2023 18:28

We tried this. The downside was our lovely receptionists being verbally abused by parents on the phone and in person because it wasn't convenient for them to come into school, parents threatening to call the police because we had "stolen their property". Several parents told their children to refuse to hand over phones for confiscation because they didn't want to have to come in and pick it up.

That’s just awful.

What hope do schools have, with parents like this? I’m not a teacher, but it’s so frustrating reading thread after thread of parents trying to push parenting responsibility onto teachers. If you’re this type of parent, or your child is at school with kids with these types of parents, I can see why you’d want it!

I don’t know if private schools are any better for this. Tbh, I can just imagine private school parents being the most entitled…

bigbluebus · 10/02/2023 18:37

Phones weren't allowed out at any time during the school day when my DS was at Secondary. Anyone caught with a phone out had it confiscated and had to collect it from reception at home time. They weren't even allowed to use it to phone home. They had to go to reception and use the school phone for 10p if they urgently needed to ring parents.

neverbeenskiing · 10/02/2023 18:33

Dacadactyl · 10/02/2023 18:30

@neverbeenskiing there would be consequences for this at DDs school. The child would likely be excluded for not handing the phone over.

Yep, same here. Refusal leads to further sanctions, but again some parents are not supportive of this and the issue is then the staff time it takes when things like this escalate, and the impact on staff wellbeing of being shouted at and threatened by parents. There is no ideal solution because you cannot please everyone.

Johnnysgirl · 10/02/2023 18:33

Kazzyhoward · 10/02/2023 18:31

How can you ban them when so many schools now use them in school, i.e. homework apps, emails, online learning platforms, even just for research during lesson times?

The ship sailed years ago.

None of that needs to take place in the classroom.

Kazzyhoward · 10/02/2023 18:31

How can you ban them when so many schools now use them in school, i.e. homework apps, emails, online learning platforms, even just for research during lesson times?

The ship sailed years ago.

Dacadactyl · 10/02/2023 18:30

@neverbeenskiing there would be consequences for this at DDs school. The child would likely be excluded for not handing the phone over.

Yopy · 10/02/2023 18:30

I believe French schools have banned phones . So it can be done

Minikievs · 10/02/2023 18:29

Testng123 · 10/02/2023 17:37

No phones allowed in my dc's school. They can bring them for before and after school for arranging lifts etc, but must be off and in locker during school hours. It's great

Exactly the same at our secondary too

neverbeenskiing · 10/02/2023 18:28

Partyandbullshit · 10/02/2023 18:22

Making a parent pick up a confiscated phone is a very good idea. I can’t see any downsides except for the parent abrogating responsibility, and many upsides for the child and the school community.

We tried this. The downside was our lovely receptionists being verbally abused by parents on the phone and in person because it wasn't convenient for them to come into school, parents threatening to call the police because we had "stolen their property". Several parents told their children to refuse to hand over phones for confiscation because they didn't want to have to come in and pick it up.

lbnblbnb · 10/02/2023 18:28

Sotiredofallthisnonsense · 10/02/2023 17:34

Aibu to think that its the very least schools should be doing so that schools and parents can work together to minimise the harm that smartphones cause - which imo far outweigh any benefits. By allowing smartphones even in the classroom, schools are the largest contributer to the peer pressure to have one. Am I in a minority of parents who wish schools didn't permit smartphones?

I don't know of any schools that permit them in the classroom. If you mean in the students bags, we can't search bags. So that is as much of a ban as is realistic.

Who is buying/paying for the phones? Surely, grow a backbone if you feel your child shouldn't have one?

Yet more blaming schools but weak parenting...

Yes I am a worn out teacher.

neverbeenskiing · 10/02/2023 18:24

cansu · 10/02/2023 18:09

I would prefer it if students were allowed a basic phone that makes calls and that is it. This would get round the argument that they were needed for safety on way home. I think the ship has sailed on smartphones and teens. They are the cause of much of the mental health angst that many teens display.

Parents are free to buy their child a "basic phone that makes calls and that is it" instead of a smartphone if they choose.

Nimbostratus100 · 10/02/2023 18:24

InsufficientMum · 10/02/2023 17:44

@Nimbostratus100 are all the pupils allowed on the school wifi then or do they expect them to have a large data package?

they are on the school wifi

Dacadactyl · 10/02/2023 18:22

@NeverDropYourMooncup and yet I am always able to get through to DDs school when I need to. 99% of your reasons for kids "needing" a phone are to do with them being on their way to and from school, not during school.

Partyandbullshit · 10/02/2023 18:22

Making a parent pick up a confiscated phone is a very good idea. I can’t see any downsides except for the parent abrogating responsibility, and many upsides for the child and the school community.

neverbeenskiing · 10/02/2023 18:22

Sotiredofallthisnonsense · 10/02/2023 18:04

"I think that you are trying to abdicate responsibility here. You need to parent. Teachers have enough to do."

I was told by the school they recommend my child has a smartphone as they'd be the odd one out otherwise. I didn't want my child to have a smartphone but the school recommended they were bought one. I'm not sure what parents can do in that situation other than condemn their child to social ostracisation.

I find this very difficult to believe.

thumbellinatinylittlething · 10/02/2023 18:21

Agree with @Nimbostratus100

Lidlfix · 10/02/2023 18:20

I teach in an excellent state school. Parents phone their DC when they are in class.

We would love to ban them.

Parent Council of school (Scotland) refuse.

Used to be able to confiscate phone and take it to the office to be collected at the end of the day for persistent use in class. I am not permitted to do this, a parent pointed out out our liability if theft/damage/loss occurred after confiscation. School cannot afford this and overwhelmed admin staff have more to do than be phone jailers.

MintJulia · 10/02/2023 18:20

My son's school requires all phones to be handed in at 8.45. and to be returned at 4pm. They have a secure storage unit in reception. Any pupil caught with a phone during school hours hands it over for a week or until the end of term. Or chooses to go elsewhere. It's part of the school contract.
It makes all the difference. No porn, no phone based bullying, no disruption in classes. It's great.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 10/02/2023 18:20

Banning smartphones would cause a complete meltdown of the switchboard - parents use them to monitor their children's locations, to text/msg, the kids use them for public transport apps, buy things from shops, use for travel if their Oyster doesn't cover it (they don't give free travel on trains, for example, they still need to pay 50%), other areas don't give free travel at all, so they're used for all travel costs, they're vital for some medical monitoring equipment and being the only child with a smartphone takes away their entitlement to medical confidentiality whether they like it or not - and some parents (the ones most likely to go ballistic in the event of a specific ban) expect to be able to message or call their children during the school day.

Dacadactyl · 10/02/2023 18:17

Boomboom22 · 10/02/2023 18:13

So do you think it wise to give your child a phone at 18, ne experience? Like those parents who don't let their kids try alcohol and then think it's safe for them to live in halls at uni with everyone who has been drinking for 1-2yrs and knows how to handle themselves and what they can drink. It looked dangerous to me then and still does now. You have to teach them how to manage themselves. Confiscation of phones doesn't teach them how to manage in real life. Unless in a low skilled job with a locker like retail most people have their phones on them at work and have to control themselves, even the teachers.

Yes I think it's very wise to confiscate them at school.

These are teens who need to work on social skills. If they had phones, their real life interactions would be more limited. There is no substitute in life for good social skills.

The pupils have plenty of time outside school to learn how to manage their phone use.

neverbeenskiing · 10/02/2023 18:17

Phones are one of many, many issues where schools simply cannot win. For every parent like OP who thinks it is the schools responsibility to police kids use of smartphones purchased by parents, there will be a parent who insists its none of our business and their child must be allowed their phone at all times or we are in violation of their basic human rights.

In the school where I work phones have to be off/on silent and in bags during the school day. If they are seen by staff they are confiscated. Most parents are supportive of this, but a significant (and very vocal) minority aren't. We have had parents tell their children to refuse to hand their phones in, staff have been verbally abused for confiscating phones. One parent tried to claim we were in breach of the Equality Act because not being able to read and respond to texts during lessons increased her child's (undiagnosed) Anxiety.

We cannot ban kids from bringing phones onto the premises altogether as the majority of parents would not support this, most want their child to be contactable on the journey to and from school.

If you don't want your child to have a smartphone, OP you could choose not to buy them one. If you don't want them to have it at school, you could choose to buy them a smartphone but make them leave it at home on school days. But I suppose it's easier to choose to buy them a smartphone and allow them to take it to school, then blame the school for the harm you believe it's causing them.

KittyMcKitty · 10/02/2023 18:16

Neither the school I work at or the school my children attend allow phones in school. They need to be kept in bags and if seen using it during the day they are confiscated.

Both schools require devices in school (eg chrome book). A school I used to work in allowed phones and it was a nightmare and they’re too small / inappropriate to use as a device in school.

Liglig · 10/02/2023 18:16

In my son's primary school phones have to be handed in upon entering school then collected on exiting school. Not sure how they keep up with so many phones though, maybe they don't get too many!

LlynTegid · 10/02/2023 18:16

Emmanuel Macron planned to ban them, don't know if it happened in the end.

Should be in lockers.