Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU electric bikes

66 replies

2023forme · 10/02/2023 16:17

AIBU asking this about electric bikes? We (DH) and have decided to buy two and take some U.K. breaks where we can see a bit more of areas without driving.

DH thinks we should just pop down to Halfords and get a couple as apparently Halfords can do no wrong!

AIBU to suggest we do a bit more research about what we will need WRT battery life, quality of the bike, expense of parts/tyres etc.

UABU - Halfords is fine and their electric bikes will suit your needs
YANBU and should consult a bike specialist

and if anyone uses an eBike and has any tips, I would welcome them!

OP posts:
rainylake · 10/02/2023 18:31

I would shop around and make sure you do some test rides. And I would also buy from a proper specialist bike retailer with trained knowledgeable staff. All e-bikes are definitely not equal and you need to be comfortable with what you are getting and where you are willing to compromise if you have a limited budget

Kazzyhoward · 10/02/2023 18:28

I'd never buy one from Halfords. We've bought a few childrens' bikes over the years for our son, and every time, the Halfords "specialist" fouled up the assembly, once was a loose front wheel (he forgot to tighten the bolts) and another time they didn't use long enough bolts for stabilisers so one fell off causing DS to fall off. If they're incapable of assembling simple children's bikes, I don't want their "experts" anywhere near an electric one!

technosausage · 10/02/2023 18:22

Do some research and get onto ebay, I got one which was basically brand new for under £300.

Hereforthedramaz · 10/02/2023 18:19

I have a Cowboy and it's amazing.

I bought it after reading a lot of reviews, not cheap and I ordered without trying so I did take a risk!

My mum has an older Raleigh one, it is lighter but she has to do gears whereas mine does that automatically to optimise the battery.

That was a big plus for me, between the motor and no gears riding is phenomenally easy!

Weight is a killer though, even without the battery it's a damn heavy bike! Obviously that doesn't matter while you are riding.

I ruled out some similar thing he's as the battery was inside the frame and I need to bring the battery in to charge (plus batteries don't last as well if you keep them too cold and my bike lives in a bike shed).

I would have liked to try a range in person but struggled to find many places with a range of brands in stock.

ohthejoys · 10/02/2023 18:15

Halfords are definitely over priced as their advice is pretty basic too. We bought ours from Amazon for £600 each and they are brilliant apart from being a slightly heavier frame if you need to lift very high onto bike racks!

also you may need a specialist bike each for e bikes due to their higher weight!

NotAHappyBunnyHugger · 10/02/2023 18:09

Agree with what others have said about going to a specialist bike shop. The staff at independent shops are generally more likely to cycle themselves so will be much more knowledgeable than at Halfords. If you happen to live in Yorkshire, Cycle Heaven in York are fantastic.

Some councils also team up with local bike shops to run hire schemes - my mum borrowed one from her local council for a week for free. It made her realise how easy it made riding and she felt she could justify the cost of a higher end ebike

Twwodoorsaway · 10/02/2023 17:38

We both have ebikes which we bought from a small local independent bike shop. He had a wealth of knowledge and could give us advice based on our needs. We bought relatively expensive bikes, but are very happy with them. They have at least 70km range on full charge (which is more than we need), built in lights and back pannier. I love mine, definitely get out more than on my non electric one. I bought one second hand before but the motor was basically rubbish. It burnt out and wasn’t worth repairing, so buyer beware!

JennyTheDonkey · 10/02/2023 17:34

By local I meant independent.

JennyTheDonkey · 10/02/2023 17:33

Do you have a local bike shop? Have found the ones local to me have given me great advice over the years rather than selling me something that's not quite right for me.

BanburyBun · 10/02/2023 17:22

I’m on my second ebike due to the first one being an impulse buy with no research! The second one (which I love) I got from Rutland Cycles, they were great and I test rode a few after narrowing it down due to power/battery life etc. I hated cycling before but we now go for miles and I love it. We’ve even done Coast to coast rides staying in B&Bs etc en route.

MrsAvocet · 10/02/2023 17:14

When you are buying an ebike you need to do double the research as you need to make sure you are getting both the E and the bike right. There are so many options now and therr is no one "best" motor any more than there is one "best" bike. It depends very much what kind of riding you are doing eg if you are going to be doing longer rides on mainly flattish terrain you want to look for a bike with fairly long range but you don't need a motor with a lot of torque. Someone who is into serious E mountain biking however will want a really high torque motor to get up very steep climbs but probably will be less concerned about range. There are also options regarding position of the motor - your 2 main choices are in the rear hub or adjacent to the bottom bracket and there are pros and cons of each system. Then of course there's weight. Bigger batteries will give you longer range but add considerably to the weight of the bike, and a high torque motor will use your battery up more quickly meaning that more "powerful" E bikes are often heavier E bikes too. Although the technology is improving rapidly you still have to sacrifice something as there isn't really a bike that is light, with a long range and a high torque motor. You also need to think about practicalities such as where you are going to charge it and if you need to be able to remove the battery or not. So there is a lot to consider, plus of course everything you need to consider about buying a regular bike too, so don't rush into it. Personally I would look for a bike shop that sells a range of different Ebikes and try to ride a few to get the feel of the different systems, as even relatively inexpensive ones are not cheap.

Alvinne · 10/02/2023 17:14

As others have said, definitely do your research and try different places, it's quite a big purchase and you don't want to end up with something that ends up not meeting your needs.

I bought one from a electric bike specialist small chain, but also found the local bike shops really helpful. The advantage they have over halfords is that you aren't just tied to halfords own brand bikes. Some of the components on these are quite poor and you'd get better value elsewhere. It's worth trying different styles of bike too, as the different riding positions with different frames do make a big difference.

Most ride to work schemes, even if they appear linked to halfords or another provider, allow you to purchase from any local shop and being able to spread the cost and gain a tax benefit was a huge plus to me.

I agree with the previous poster who said about hiring one first. This will help you get an idea of the sort of distances you want to cover and whether you enjoy it.

The range is important, because what sounds like a lot of miles really isn't when you have the pedal assist so while you think having a 20 mile range is plenty, that's only 10 miles each way in perfect flat conditions and can be quite limiting. Probably under 2 hours riding time. Fine for using it to pop to the shops or commute places but not necessarily for a relaxed longer day out.

My bike has a 90 mile range which means I don't have to think about whether I'm going to run out of battery too much. Last year I went on holiday to the lake district and happily spent all day riding about and going to different places which was so lovely.

The weight of the bike is worth considering I ended up getting something from the Specialized SL range, SL meaning super light and would really recommend, though it was about £2500 I couldn't be happier with it.

cestlavielife · 10/02/2023 17:14

Go and hire one for a day...try diff models...did so on a break snd one gaVe no oomph up hills while the other one did

Coffeellama · 10/02/2023 17:13

Sirius3030 · 10/02/2023 17:07

I would never describe Halford's as a bike specialist. If you are lucky one of their staff may now something about their own range.

I didn’t say they were specialists, I said they have all the available information - like bike specialists. The info is all provided for them. But also it varies loads by store obviously, we have 2 locally and the bigger one has bike specialists, the smaller one doesn’t really that I’ve seen.

Sirius3030 · 10/02/2023 17:10

CurlyKD · 10/02/2023 16:44

Look at the ones with the Bosch motors. They are the better option. We did our research before buying ours. Good luck.

I worked for an engineering company with keen cyclists. To a man/woman they all said make sure it is a Bosch motor. Advice I intend to follow.

Whosthebestbabainalltheworld · 10/02/2023 17:09

I got a Forme Morley btw, which is British made. Is fine EXCEPT the rear mudguard is too short and my jacket and helmet get destroyed if the road is wet or even damp. Is really annoying and not something I’d have even noticed buying it.

Sirius3030 · 10/02/2023 17:07

Coffeellama · 10/02/2023 16:25

Surely it’s just personal preference? Halfords have all the available information on their bikes just like any other bike specialist. You can research online and compare to Halfords online too.

I would never describe Halford's as a bike specialist. If you are lucky one of their staff may now something about their own range.

Whosthebestbabainalltheworld · 10/02/2023 17:06

Second the Bosch motor/battery and be really clear on the distances you intend to go each day vs the battery range. You could end up limiting yourself because of this. You can’t really pedal them without the battery - way too heavy.

ReviewingTheSituation · 10/02/2023 17:05

Most employers are on the Cycle to Work scheme. Check that before you do anything else (as some schemes are linked to specific retailers). If you can use that, you really should- it means you make a huge saving and also pay straight from your salary in installments, so there's no up front outlay.

You don't need to actually cycle to work to buy on the scheme.

But definitely do some research. If you do end up in Halfords (and one cycle to work scheme I came across only used them), you can have a 6hr trial of an ebike, which is a great initiative.

Theredcow · 10/02/2023 17:02

It is a big purchase so you need to do some research, not just buy what a salesperson wants to sell you. You need to try several with different motors and you will see the difference. Torque is very important, the higher the Nm the better for getting you up hills.

Agree with what someone else said and hire some first to find out what you are looking for in a bike.

I became obsessed during lockdown as I really wanted one but they were so hard to get hold of. I did so much research so knew exactly what I wanted in a bike.

ChocMarshmallows · 10/02/2023 17:00

I got an electric folding bike from halfords on bike to work scheme. I loved it for 2 years until I was knocked off by a truck and broke several bones! Back on it now and loving it again! But be careful - if you have a bike that looks like a slow bike, and you look like a slower cycle rider, cars may not realise how fast you are in fact travelling!

2023forme · 10/02/2023 16:55

Thanks for all the replies - most helpful!

  • will check out cycle to work scheme
  • I’m 5’2” too!
  • we are not hard core so it would be cycle paths and streets
  • good shout re decathalon - there’s one quite near us
OP posts:
BarbaraofSeville · 10/02/2023 16:51

Make sure you know what type of cycling you plan on doing. Halfords are well known for selling people poor quality full suspension bikes when they would be better off with a higher quality hybrid or front suspension mountain bike.

Both DP and I have Giant full suspension mountain bikes, but we do proper downhill mountain biking, we bought them from proper bike shops.

If you're only going to do towpath rides or similar, you don't need anything like this.

Fenella123 · 10/02/2023 16:50

Bikes in general you need to do your research for and get the right size and shape. Ebikes too. You're talking thousands of pounds per bike.
Who will service and repair it? How would you go about getting new batteries?
I got my e-bike in the mid noughties and I still use it - have had to replace the batteries several times, and there's a gear issue that I haven't found anyone to fix (it's buried in the motor unit so a bit different from a regular bike issue).

modgepodge · 10/02/2023 16:49

I got mine from Halfords without doing very much research! It was just under £1k this time last year and is fine for what I use it for (pottering around locally). I hadn’t owned a bike since I was 10 though so not an enthusiast!! I did have an issue when I first got it as it hadn’t been set up properly but they sorted that free of charge fairly quickly.