Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To find DH’s family’s gifting etiquette weird?

115 replies

KarenBradysHair · 10/02/2023 15:56

DH’s family are lovely, they really are. But I find they have no sense of occasion about birthdays/Christmas. There’s always a text a week or two before the event, asking what the person wants, and that’s what they get. It’s not even like ‘oh I’d like some new socks’ and the person then chooses them nice socks, it’s ‘here is the link to the exact socks’. I feel like they might as well all save themselves the bother as no one is surprised, and everyone gets roughly the same amount spent on them.

Don’t get me wrong, getting what you want is great, but if there’s no mystery, why not cut out the middle man (and the faff of ordering/delivery etc) and everyone could just buy their own gifts?!

OP posts:
HufflepuffRavenclaw · 10/02/2023 17:06

DH's family is the same. They stopped buying presents about 15 years ago. They just transfer money into our bank account. They don't even bother their backsides to buy a voucher or something. No thought, no effort. If we want the kids to have something to open at Christmas or birthday from their uncle/grandparents, we have to buy it, wrap it, and tell the kids it's from grandparents or uncle.

My parents and sister don't always get it right. But they at least put a bit of effort into it and try to choose something we'd like.

gogohmm · 10/02/2023 17:06

Growing up my dad's mother used to ask us for the Argos catalogue reference numbers, she was generous in amount she would spend but nothing was a surprise and everything had to come from argos.

Theresahippopotamusonourroofeatingcake · 10/02/2023 17:04

This is a lot better than when you have a wish list and then people go off-list and by something similar but not the one you wanted.

For example you add a nice le creuset mug and they buy you a random equally expensive mug from a garden centre that you don't want and then you have a mug so you can't buy another one but every time you drink from it you remember the one you actually wanted. The bastard cuckoo mug is the one that never smashes either and you have to use it in front of them because it was an gift. Grrr.

LorneSausage · 10/02/2023 17:03

My brother and I have a system where we buy ourselves something we couldn't really justify spending our own money on. This way, we get exactly what we want and we then tell each other what a lovely gift we got from them!

Lcb123 · 10/02/2023 16:58

My and DH family do this, it’s great. So much less wasteful.

redskydelight · 10/02/2023 16:57

It's nice to get something you actually want but might not have felt you could buy yourself.

It's better than the etiquette in my family (well, with my parents, my siblings and I have worked out the nonsense of it) where you are bought something you don't want (at best, actively hate at worst) and then are expected to show undying gratitude.

blackteaplease · 10/02/2023 16:56

I love this, everyone gets what they want, no waste and no having to pretend to like something. Most people in my DH family do this and are happy with it. MIL always insists on extras from santa. DD got earrings made from metal she is allergic to, ds1 got a book he already owns. Both went straight to charity

myveryownelectrickitten · 10/02/2023 16:54

Sounds perfect to me, OP! Better than having relatives who give distinctly odd presents which end up getting wasted. For five years my MIL only gave me chutney. (I quite like chutney, but only eat it about once a year...) One birthday she randomly got me rubber car floor mats. And always lots and lots of toiletries I can’t use even though she knows I’m allergic to them.

Her family believe firmly that nobody should ever be bought anything they actually want (or have expressed a desire for) 😂 The idea is that you are meant to be performatively grateful for a gift whatever it is. It’s a kind of fanatical adherence to “surprise” gift-giving, but it ends up hugely wasteful, but also a little bit insulting to be honest, as the whole point of it seems to be not actually thinking about what someone might genuinely like, just the satisfaction of watching them pretend to be delighted whatever you give them!

And that to me isn’t really what giving presents is about. Yes you shouldn’t “expect” anything, but at the same time it’s also pretty inconsiderate to keep giving people generic presents that may be unsuitable or unusable or unwanted, kind of just for the hell of it. So the other extreme - no surprises but everyone gets something they actually want - seems a much better alternative in both ecological terms and just all round pleasantry, even if it’s a teensy bit dull.

reluctantbrit · 10/02/2023 16:54

I very much prefer this to getting "socks" in the wrong size or fluffy instead of plain black I can use with shoes.

At least people can and want actually use the present instead of donating it or gathering dust in the cupboard.

We normally offer a couple of itmes so it's still a bit of a surprise but I get what I actually like and want.

EmmaDilemma5 · 10/02/2023 16:47

I can see why you say it, it does take any meaning and excitement from gift giving.

But when you have poor present buyers in the family, it's better than leaving it to chance. I get some random crap some years and regularly wish I'd have given specifics.

starlingdarling · 10/02/2023 16:46

I like being told what to get people. We only do gifts for children in my family anyway so that's ok but for gifts between me and DH, we send links or ideas. It's still a bit of a surprise because our lists are bigger than our budget so we have to choose. I'm quite tight with money and rarely buy myself things so there are always things I'd like to have but can't justify to myself.

Passerillage · 10/02/2023 16:43

My husband's family is like this (he's from another country) and I hate it. So transactional. Literally a list of links. I thought it was about surprise and delight.

Anyway, I'm used to it now. DH and I make a master list on Google Keep for me, him and the kids, and then he sends a selection of them to his family, and we tick off what has been bought. I suppose we're all quite hard to buy for, so maybe it's not a bad idea.

UWhatNow · 10/02/2023 16:42

My SIL used to send us Argos catalogue numbers for us to buy her son’s Christmas presents. It just took all the spirit of gift giving out of it and made me feel like we were just a courier company.

It’s the choice of selfish, unimaginative people who can’t be arsed putting in the effort required for a really thoughtful gift.

CaptainMyCaptain · 10/02/2023 16:34

We do it so we get what we want although there might be smaller surprise presents. I have teenage grandsons, there is no point getting them something they will never use (like my sister does)

Meganlp · 10/02/2023 16:27

DH family is the same. We have to send links to what we want, they then order and have it delivered to us. They don’t even bother ordering it to theirs and wrapping it up.
I find it odd but just accepted it is their way. We have suggested stopping buying on multiple occasions but they won’t stop.

RoseMarigoldViolet · 10/02/2023 16:27

I guess on the positive side, you don’t end up with some freakish present that you don’t want that you end up donating to the charity shop (if they’ll take it!) which is my DH’s family!
I would just love to request a pot of Body Shop cream of my choice and actually get that!

BooksAndHooks · 10/02/2023 16:25

Much prefer it like this. We don’t buy much for ourselves so when we do get gifts it’s much nicer to have the exact things we want. Still better to get as a gift than buying ourselves.

Also have several neurodivergent family members who like presents but hate surprises so far better for them.

NewShoes · 10/02/2023 16:25

This is the system in our family. Means we always get things we actually want and like. Makes total sense!

Alwaysworryingoversomething · 10/02/2023 16:25

My DH & family are also like this but he's not like it with me.
But with his children they just all send each other Amazon links a few weeks before birthday/ Christmas.

It just seems dull and pointless to me but I suppose that's because my family is different.

FlowerArranger · 10/02/2023 16:23

Personally I don't see the point of adults giving each other presents, unless maybe a bunch of flowers or a bottle of champagne if it's a 'big' birthday.

I really don't 'need' or want anything - other than stuff that would be too expensive to be affordable or appropriate for a Christmas or birthday present.

Harlow19 · 10/02/2023 16:22

So I’ll start off by saying obviously I know it’s not all about gifts.

But my family do this and yes it is a bit weird. Christmas and birthday gifts are never a surprise and despite being an adult I wish they got me a surprise present that they thought I’d like rather than me have to choose the exact thing I want.

I personally love buying people gifts because I enjoy the experience of thinking of what they’d like but as my family don’t do this they just send me a link over and it takes the excitement out of it

Yanbu

I guess in a way it stops getting or buying gifts you wouldn’t use but personally I prefer surprises

butterfliedtwo · 10/02/2023 16:22

It's sensible to me. I'd rather that than them not liking the present.

parietal · 10/02/2023 16:22

I'd much rather get exactly the gift off my list than something random or something that I'm not going to use.

My family have lists but not normally in detail as in 'here is the link to exactly this product'. more like 'I like'd like a nice serving dish for the table' etc.

UsingChangeofName · 10/02/2023 16:21

I love your dh's family.
It makes buying presents so stress free.
It means receiving presents, you actually get something you want / will use / will like.
FAR better than people who say "I always choose something really thoughtful" and everyone else smiling politely and saying thank you, but really thinking 'how long until I can take this to the charity shop' / 'I wonder if the shop will change it without a receipt' / 'why does she keep buying me this stuff' / etc.

tattygrl · 10/02/2023 16:21

Obviously this is fine, and I can totally see the logic in why people may do this, but on an emotional level, I absolutely cannot stand this 😅

I'm all for stress and worry being taken out of gifting, but I really find this custom so cold and charmless. I feel there should be a middle ground somehow. But again that's just my heart talking.

Swipe left for the next trending thread