Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

State of the NHS & GPs

119 replies

ChocMarshmallows · 10/02/2023 14:17

AIBU to worry about the state of the NHS and accessing GPs

It used to be hard to get through to the surgery, with long cues on the phone to get an appointment.

But now .... What kind of new hell is this?

We are no longer allowed to phone the surgery and have to book appointments online. The online portal opens at 8am and shuts within a couple of minutes until the next day.

If u r lucky enough to get a GP appointment after the triage, they r no help, won't prescribe anything because it's all too costly, and won't do any tests for the same reason

My son (age 11) hasn't been to the GP since he was about 5. Finally got him an appointment as he's really ill and we've had various probs over the year which are concerning me. Asked for a blood test because of these problems, and told 'we don't do them anymore unless X, y, z' and although he's really poorly and hasn't had antibiotics for years, he can't have them now because 'we don't give them anymore'.

What is the point of GPs now if you can't access them and they do nothing.

Don't get me started on A&E - a friends waited 18 HOURS to be seen last week

My mum died 2 years ago in an NHS hospital, pretty sure lack of staff, no consistent care, a too long wait time for operation (too late she died before it could happen) contributed.

It's scary and I want this government out NOW before it becomes a case of 'only those rich enough can access health care and expect to live a long healthy life'.

OP posts:
nolongersurprised · 10/02/2023 21:16

I am a paediatrician in Australia and work publicly and privately. In our private clinic we are all pretty busy, months long waiting lists but over the clinic there’s some movement on a day to day basis with people rebooking, rescheduling.

For what it’s worth, we would triage a referral like that to be seen within a week or so. I agree it’s most likely going to be nothing serious but it’s somewhat unusual to be feverish that often, at that age:

DotAndCarryOne2 · 10/02/2023 21:15

memorial · 10/02/2023 18:55

I'll finish properly.....20 issues and symptoms into one apps. So much so that my brain was scrambled and entirely unable to diagnose or manage anything. Funnily enough there are good reasons for things but why actually listen to those that know what they're talking about.

20 issues at one appointment doesn’t sound typical though. My DH had a handful of other symptoms, each treated as a separate issue, but if our GP and the walk in centre had listened to us when we tried to explain what else was going on alongside the shoulder pain, instead of dismissing us as ‘self diagnosing via the internet’ as the walk in centre nurse put it, things may have been different.

I can only speak from experience. My friends’ mother had the same type of cancer and was suffering with a swollen, weeping and red eye, which was pulled down at the lid. She was told this was nothing to do with the shoulder pain, which, like my DH, was diagnosed as a trapped nerve. She was actually sent away with anti depressants - because she had been to the surgery several times with the same issue, for some reason they thought she was depressed !! She was advised to see her optician about the eye issue, and on doing so was told to go straight to A&E - the optician rang ahead and it transpired that they had seen signs of a tumour during the exam, later confirmed as lung cancer. The eye problem was part and parcel of the same disease and the GP missed it because they treated it as a separate issue.

In both instances the patient knew better than ‘those who know what they’re talking about’ but the concerns were dismissed. OK, so I understand that multiple issues can confuse things, and I agree. But given that cancer can present with diverse symptoms which can seem unconnected, I don’t think ‘one issue, one appointment’ is the way to go. Don’t know what the answer is, but given that GPs are the gateway to the referral services something has to change.

ReformedWaywardTeen · 10/02/2023 20:56

gloriawasright · 10/02/2023 20:33

"I'll finish properly.....20 issues and symptoms into one apps. So much so that my brain was scrambled and entirely unable to diagnose or manage anything. Funnily enough there are good reasons for things but why actually listen to those that know what they're talking about."

Things are very different post covid,some surgeries have not returned to normal .face to face and appointments are like gold dust ,patients can't really be blamed for trying to get as much seen to all in one go .
Trying to get through on the phone line which never seems to get picked up .
when it is we are told all the ( telephone) appts are gone .
try again tomorrow morning .
Or the next one .
When we do actually get to speak to the receptionist ( who has no more medical training than joe blogs ) we have to explain why we want to see a doctor .
And even then the face to face appointment will not be given until the doctor calls and decides whether we need to be seen .
The frustration and stress this all causes is sometimes why patients don't actually even bother trying trying to be seen .
It is a horrible situation for everyone ,and I get that it is not the way a face to face should go.
But some conditions do present with more than one issue .we as patients don't have the knowledge that you do therefore we don't know which problem to prioritise when we finally get the golden ticket giving entry to the surgery

Exactly this.

But no doubt you'll receive the same "I'm a GP so more superior than you" response as I did.

ReformedWaywardTeen · 10/02/2023 20:54

memorial · 10/02/2023 18:55

I'll finish properly.....20 issues and symptoms into one apps. So much so that my brain was scrambled and entirely unable to diagnose or manage anything. Funnily enough there are good reasons for things but why actually listen to those that know what they're talking about.

You are demonstrating the worst kind of GP attitude.

The poster explained that due to a GP ignoring her DG several times, his cancer was missed and he passed away.

And all you can do is act all woe is me, hard done by?

I cannot imagine how you behave towards patients frankly, I've had ones who made me feel bad for mentioning symptoms which presented together and you sound exactly that type who rolls their eyes and makes me feel a burden for attending an appointment for the first time in years. Most of us have to beg and plead almost for even a phone call, then have to wait weeks (or they do in my surgery) only to see a GP who couldn't be less interested. Then the cycle begins again of self care, pain and illness, pharmacy saying you need a GP, constant 8am phone calls where you then get a rude and disinterested and deliberately obtuse and obstructive moron on the phone line try and fob you off or say nothing left.

ChocMarshmallows · 10/02/2023 20:45

gloriawasright · 10/02/2023 20:33

"I'll finish properly.....20 issues and symptoms into one apps. So much so that my brain was scrambled and entirely unable to diagnose or manage anything. Funnily enough there are good reasons for things but why actually listen to those that know what they're talking about."

Things are very different post covid,some surgeries have not returned to normal .face to face and appointments are like gold dust ,patients can't really be blamed for trying to get as much seen to all in one go .
Trying to get through on the phone line which never seems to get picked up .
when it is we are told all the ( telephone) appts are gone .
try again tomorrow morning .
Or the next one .
When we do actually get to speak to the receptionist ( who has no more medical training than joe blogs ) we have to explain why we want to see a doctor .
And even then the face to face appointment will not be given until the doctor calls and decides whether we need to be seen .
The frustration and stress this all causes is sometimes why patients don't actually even bother trying trying to be seen .
It is a horrible situation for everyone ,and I get that it is not the way a face to face should go.
But some conditions do present with more than one issue .we as patients don't have the knowledge that you do therefore we don't know which problem to prioritise when we finally get the golden ticket giving entry to the surgery

This

OP posts:
gloriawasright · 10/02/2023 20:33

"I'll finish properly.....20 issues and symptoms into one apps. So much so that my brain was scrambled and entirely unable to diagnose or manage anything. Funnily enough there are good reasons for things but why actually listen to those that know what they're talking about."

Things are very different post covid,some surgeries have not returned to normal .face to face and appointments are like gold dust ,patients can't really be blamed for trying to get as much seen to all in one go .
Trying to get through on the phone line which never seems to get picked up .
when it is we are told all the ( telephone) appts are gone .
try again tomorrow morning .
Or the next one .
When we do actually get to speak to the receptionist ( who has no more medical training than joe blogs ) we have to explain why we want to see a doctor .
And even then the face to face appointment will not be given until the doctor calls and decides whether we need to be seen .
The frustration and stress this all causes is sometimes why patients don't actually even bother trying trying to be seen .
It is a horrible situation for everyone ,and I get that it is not the way a face to face should go.
But some conditions do present with more than one issue .we as patients don't have the knowledge that you do therefore we don't know which problem to prioritise when we finally get the golden ticket giving entry to the surgery

QueenOfHiraeth · 10/02/2023 20:32

I work in a surgery (I'm not a GP) and agree with all that the GPs on here have pointed out. We are not rationed on tests or prescribing, other than they should be clinically appropriate.
I do feel sorry for GPs now, it is an ever-increasing workload and a more demanding public with a greater sense of entitlement alongside the media constantly drumming up negativity with the narrative that GPs are all skiving off somewhere.

Our surgery is swamped, we deal with hundreds of patients every day by phone and see considerable numbers face to face too. I worked last week with a task list of over 100 patients waiting for calls or prescriptions the whole time and as one was sorted another added on. The pressure is huge.

...and just to give the other side of the coin to @ReformedWaywardTeen that GPs are responsible for A&E numbers, can I tell you that a large amount of the GP workload is caused by hospital outpatient clinics still running by phone and telling patients to go to the GP for medication, tests and follow-ups. We have now started sending a letter to these consultants saying this is inappropriate and we do not have the capacity to do it but guess who will get the blame from the patients for any delay?

@memorial I agree things will have to change in the NHS and all we can do is try to tread water until things improve. Hope it doesn't grind you down too much.

Tinkerbyebye · 10/02/2023 19:33

My sister works in the health service. She advises ring 111. They have the ability to book appointments with your dr. Seems some appointment are kept for those phoning the surgery and some for 111

rockpoolingtogether · 10/02/2023 19:31

@ChocMarshmallows I think you are getting a rough ride here. I would recommend keeping a diary of your sons temperature (even on days when he is well). Sometimes this sort of thing can highlight something eg an activity or food that might make him unwell. I would hope they would re consider bloods for anemia and many coeliac

rockpoolingtogether · 10/02/2023 19:24

gonnabeok · 10/02/2023 15:28

Ive just received a letter from my GP surgery saying g the doctors there have resigned from their NHS contract. The reason? Only 2 GP's left when there used to be 6.they have tried and couldn't recruit any more GP's. Very sad so now who knows where all the patients will have to go to access a GP.

Worrying. What part of the country? There is a massive recruitment crisis but evidently felt in certain places more than others

memorial · 10/02/2023 18:58

Threads like that make me truly belive that NHS GP is over and should be. Let the government bring in the privatised hybrid salaried mostly non doctor service
Cheap fast or good. You can only have 2. We know whi h 2 the government want. So be it. We're tired of flogging a dead horse.

memorial · 10/02/2023 18:55

memorial · 10/02/2023 18:53

Well I missed a heart failure because the patient literally crammed 20 various non related issues into knee apps so

I'll finish properly.....20 issues and symptoms into one apps. So much so that my brain was scrambled and entirely unable to diagnose or manage anything. Funnily enough there are good reasons for things but why actually listen to those that know what they're talking about.

memorial · 10/02/2023 18:53

gloriawasright · 10/02/2023 17:50

"One problem is that GPs seem to be still sticking to the ‘one complaint, one appointment’ system - there is a notice up in our surgery to this effect. So a series of seemingly unrelated symptoms, which taken together can point to cancer, will continue to be missed"

The most relevant thing I have read on this thread.

Well I missed a heart failure because the patient literally crammed 20 various non related issues into knee apps so

ChocMarshmallows · 10/02/2023 18:05

Thanks for sharing that DotandCarryone2.

I'm so sorry to hear what happened to your DH.

Yes, I think sometimes we need to push for when what feel we need. And in this case, I want the GP to do more then just chat to my son. I want a thorough check over and some bloods. Just my mum intuition maybe, but intuition I am not prepared to ignore just in case there is something serious going on.

I completely agree about the 'one issue, one appointment' thing. I have long thought this will lead to things being missed due to people not reporting all symptoms assuming them to be unrelated. Or not reporting something more serious than the presenting problem, because the patient thinks they can't take up the appointment time and is going with what they feel is the more pressing issue. Eg. My mum had a bloated stomach, told the doctor, they went down rabbit holes looking into gastro problems. They didn't ask about her shortness of breath, heart palpitations, and other symptoms and she didn't raise them altogether in the same appointment. Thus v severe heart trouble was missed for ages. The bloating was fluid in her stomach as a result of heart failure.

OP posts:
gloriawasright · 10/02/2023 17:50

"One problem is that GPs seem to be still sticking to the ‘one complaint, one appointment’ system - there is a notice up in our surgery to this effect. So a series of seemingly unrelated symptoms, which taken together can point to cancer, will continue to be missed"

The most relevant thing I have read on this thread.

DotAndCarryOne2 · 10/02/2023 17:45

Twentywisteria · 10/02/2023 15:35

A huge reason why GPs are retiring or leaving is because of patients like OP and the myriad other posts like this.

A GP is a highly trained professional (5/6 years medical school + 5 years postgraduate training). They are not a McDonald's. You go for a medical assessment, not to order tests and medications off a menu.

And the other side of the coin. A couple of years ago DH went to see his GP because he was having pain in his shoulders and a few other symptoms. He was diagnosed with a trapped nerve, given painkillers and anti inflammatories and advised to rest. A friend had lost her mum to lung cancer a few months before and had had some similar symptoms so DH mentioned this and was told the symptoms didn’t fit lung cancer. Told that if symptoms didn’t clear up he would be referred for x rays and physio.

The pain got worse and when we couldn’t access a GP appointment for couple of weeks we went to the local walk in centre and explained what was happening. They examined him, said it was indeed a trapped nerve and advised we see our GP again if things were no better - they weren’t, and he was starting to have breathing difficulties. We went to see our GP together and I explained that I had done a bit of research on the internet and was worried it could be a lung tumour. GP examined him and listened to his chest - declared it clear, but after a fair bit of insistence the GP reluctantly agreed to refer him for a CT scan and blood tests.

We never got as far as that. He collapsed a few days later and was rushed to hospital where the attending doctor said he had one of the worst chest infections he had ever seen. He was quite angry because it was clear DH was very unwell and he asked why we had not sought help earlier. When I recounted how many times we had seen our GP, and the fact that a few days earlier they had declared his chest clear, he clammed up and never said any more. DH ended up on a ventilator in ITU as they couldn’t clear the infection and a CT scan later revealed a large inoperable tumour at the top of his lung, sitting on the nerve. He died two days after the diagnosis. We later found out that for this type of tumour, shoulder pain, together with the other symptoms he was having, is quite common.

So I disagree. Not saying all GP’s are the same, but given that the UK has one of the worst rates of early cancer diagnosis, something is amiss. And if I think something is wrong I now have no hesitation in insisting I am listened to properly, instead of being fobbed off with drugs. One problem is that GPs seem to be still sticking to the ‘one complaint, one appointment’ system - there is a notice up in our surgery to this effect. So a series of seemingly unrelated symptoms, which taken together can point to cancer, will continue to be missed.

ChocMarshmallows · 10/02/2023 17:41

Thanks oranges ...

OP posts:
Orangesandlemons77 · 10/02/2023 17:39

ChocMarshmallows · 10/02/2023 17:35

Thanks! Just googled and I think there's a benenden at Nuffield health near me, so I'll investigate. Thanks

I've recently used Benenden along with my usual GP and it has been really helpful. It is supposed to work with the NHS. Glad to help. It's worth the money, not all things are covered in terms of treatment so it is worth looking on the website.

ChocMarshmallows · 10/02/2023 17:35

Orangesandlemons77 · 10/02/2023 17:30

Try Benenden

Thanks! Just googled and I think there's a benenden at Nuffield health near me, so I'll investigate. Thanks

OP posts:
Orangesandlemons77 · 10/02/2023 17:30

ChocMarshmallows · 10/02/2023 17:22

I'm thinking of BUPA or another private provider for my son. I think you can get one off private GP appointments. It's likely quite expensive but I do want to be taken seriously.

Try Benenden

HermioneHerman · 10/02/2023 17:26

I work in hospital based medicine (oncology to be precise) and you couldn't pay me enough to be a GP. An absolute thankless job most of the time with frequent undeserved abuse, rude, entitled patients who think they can demand whatever they want and made out to be lazy and uncaring with constant media bashing full of lies and gross exaggerations. I don't know a single GP, part time or otherwise, who doesn't work themselves into the ground at the expense of their mental and physical health, work life balance and time with family and friends. And for what, to be treated like utter cr*p and told to suck it up because they chose a caring profession? Is it any wonder that GPs are leaving, reducing hours and retiring early in droves? Why would they stay under such conditions? Of course you get some bad eggs in all jobs but the overwhelming majority care deeply, face very real burnout and get little back for their trouble except constant criticism and hugely unrealistic expectations.

OP, you are not being unreasonable to be concerned about your son at all but do need to understand how the system works. I won't go over what others have already explained but it is the GPs' job and expertise to make any clinical decisions of this type. Certainly seek a second opinion or a new surgery if that's an option for you though.

I will also say that working on the other side, hospitals will not accept referrals for many things such as suspected cancers if a hell of a lot of eligibility criterion are not met. Referral forms are very detailed and need good evidence of a specific concern or will be rejected. Most services are so incredibly stretched after the pandemic (was bad before however) that 'just in case' requests just cannot be accommodated at all.

Others on this thread are VERY VERY much being unreasonable though (I'd love to use a stronger word) and I've had to massively bite my tongue because their comments are just so unfair, untrue and ridiculous, that there is no point arguing with such ill-informed claptrap. Some of the comments are truly despicable. Not hard to see who is actually 'the worst' here.

pinkandyellowtulips · 10/02/2023 17:23

ReformedWaywardTeen · 10/02/2023 16:37

And "people like you" are no loss to the service

Our surgery advertises having 8 GPs. 4 nurses. And 3 HCAs. They have two prescriptions nurses too.

So why is only 1 GP working per day? What are the rest doing?

It wasn't like this prior to lockdown. It's just GPs realised they could do phone calls and not much else.

Our GP surgery was recently voted one of the worst in the county. They are letting people down from the admin staff who couldn't be more dismissive and who ask all the juicy details to the point where even saying "it's a personal matter" isn't good enough.

I'm sure with the number of staff they have they could do more.

And I said, I am pro-NHS and the strikes. But as someone with family in the NHs who all say GPs are not helping matters with their part time work strategy and their refusal to accept that every other service in the country has gone back to non-lockdown working.

Out of interest, what roles do your family have in the NHS? I am a hospital doctor and would never dream of saying such a thing. My team and I all know how hard GPs are working. I did a GP placement during my foundation training and it was by far the most difficult job I have had (despite my previous job involving 80 hour weeks and frequent night shifts) - it was utterly relentless.

Also, not sure it's super relevant anyway, but why shouldn't someone be able to work part time? GPs have families and other commitments too, and their part time hours are often close to what people consider full time hours anyway!

ChocMarshmallows · 10/02/2023 17:22

HalfasleepChrisintheMorning · 10/02/2023 17:19

Have you tried changing practice?
We moved last year from an absolutely appalling one (N&S Modality Partnership) to a brilliant one. They are a teaching practice and have about 8 trainee Drs who have longer appointments and are supernumerary so extra staff.
We have gone from a practice who refused to see my Dad with cancer symptoms to one who gave my son a FTF appointment this week - from ringing up to being at home with an appropriate prescription (not antibiotics) was just over an hour.
My Dad rang BUPA who gave him a direct access consultant appointment and he’s currently in hospital recovering from the surgery.

I'm thinking of BUPA or another private provider for my son. I think you can get one off private GP appointments. It's likely quite expensive but I do want to be taken seriously.

OP posts:
Chickpea17 · 10/02/2023 17:20

YABU not sure what part of the UK you in but this procedure is definitely not all surgeries. Maybe you should move to a different surgery

HalfasleepChrisintheMorning · 10/02/2023 17:19

Have you tried changing practice?
We moved last year from an absolutely appalling one (N&S Modality Partnership) to a brilliant one. They are a teaching practice and have about 8 trainee Drs who have longer appointments and are supernumerary so extra staff.
We have gone from a practice who refused to see my Dad with cancer symptoms to one who gave my son a FTF appointment this week - from ringing up to being at home with an appropriate prescription (not antibiotics) was just over an hour.
My Dad rang BUPA who gave him a direct access consultant appointment and he’s currently in hospital recovering from the surgery.