Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be annoyed with siblings?

37 replies

Kardelen · 10/02/2023 11:15

So, I am the youngest of 3. I currently live together with parents, DH and DS (who is 2) and 39 weeks pregnant. living together due to parents decision- feeling lonely etc, and there is space so it wasn’t an issue.

my older sister lives just next door. And another brother a few mins away by car.
after ds I reduced my hours to work part time so I can care for him. And now just starting mat leave. My sister is a stay at home mum, with her youngest aged 14.
I’ve been the one who takes parents to their appts normally ( quite a few) and had to change my shifts to work a way round it. Everytime I asked my siblings to take either it’s a work excuse or medical terminology excuse/child care excuse.

i also used to try take dm out for fresh air/shopping etc. but now I’m finding it difficult to even drive while pregnant, or just going out with a energetic toddler on my own and with dm. I feel bad as Im
struggling and can’t take her out anymore with ds on top.

so many times I suggested to my sister whether she can take mum with her when she goes out so that she can just get a bit of fresh air. Mum is independent mobilises with stick, so not much issues with mobility. However sister always finds excuses. Today I asked her again if she is doing anything and that if she goes out whether she can tell mum too ( even to Tesco). However, she replied saying are you not going anywhere? This annoyed me and I just released my frustration by saying you should also take her out sometimes, and how I am struggling atm.

i think she got offended, but I feel really overwhelmed that I have been left to do everything. am I being unreasonable?

Dm also wants to go out which makes me more sad.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
MelaniesFlowers · 10/02/2023 13:33

deeperthanallroses · 10/02/2023 13:11

Hmm. You do what you are comfortable with for your parents, but id rehearse some more pointed comments for your siblings. Brother says something about the house… you say my friends mum disinherited the brother who never visited or helped her out, made me think of you tbh. Sister asks for a favour, you say this year is very full on with the baby, I can only do favours for people who might sometimes do one for me and when did you last do anything helpful at all? I have a baby and toddler to look after and I’m the only one who helps mum also, you should be ashamed thinking I’m going to come and help you too.

This is emotional manipulation is and is totally unacceptable.

It isn’t healthy to treat people like this at all.

deeperthanallroses · 10/02/2023 13:11

Hmm. You do what you are comfortable with for your parents, but id rehearse some more pointed comments for your siblings. Brother says something about the house… you say my friends mum disinherited the brother who never visited or helped her out, made me think of you tbh. Sister asks for a favour, you say this year is very full on with the baby, I can only do favours for people who might sometimes do one for me and when did you last do anything helpful at all? I have a baby and toddler to look after and I’m the only one who helps mum also, you should be ashamed thinking I’m going to come and help you too.

Welfast · 10/02/2023 13:05

Do you think your mum would benefit from an electric mobility scooter? When mine got too old to drive and couldn't walk far she loved her scooter. Meant she could still get around locally

anomaly23 · 10/02/2023 12:56

Why are your siblings living independently and you're not op?

Your mum will be sad when you leave but you have a husband and 2 children to think about too.

I would never live with my mil, I love her and she's amazing but I wouldn't live with her.

You won't be driving for potentially 6 weeks when the baby is born so you physically can't take her out. I hope your siblings are going to pull their weight.

Move out.

saraclara · 10/02/2023 12:48

You are about to have a newborn. That's going to restrict you and mean that you can't be taking your parents out.

It needs to be your parents that ask your siblings for lifts to appointments, if they need them. It's not up to you to ask favours for them.

If your parents have done lots of favours for them, then it's up to them to ask for a return favour. If your dad was driving your sister around until recently, why isn't he going out now?

tattygrl · 10/02/2023 12:40

Look into carers in your local area. This can be done privately or through the LA. This is the exact thing carers are for, to ease the demands of caring and to make sure people maintain their independence, etc. That would allow your relationship with your parents to be just that, a relationship, rather than caregiver and receiver roles.

MelaniesFlowers · 10/02/2023 12:30

Relationships aren’t tit for tat. They’re not transactional. It’s not “I did X so you need to do Y”.

Of course parents do so much for their children; they are there to care for them. That’s why they had them.

Your ire should be directed at your parents because they are the ones that didn’t make provisions for their old age, they are the ones guilty tripping and emotionally manipulating you, and they are the ones who have caused this entire situation.

jacult · 10/02/2023 12:26

Stop trying to control the relationship between your siblings and their parents. Do what you feel you can do and leave it at that. You only have control over your own feelings. Is your husband happy with this arrangement as if the roles were reversed I would see my husband putting his parents’ needs above those of his wife and children.

Kardelen · 10/02/2023 12:24

Thank you so much x

OP posts:
Hydie · 10/02/2023 12:22

@Kardelen no worries! 73% currently agree with you too, take the comments with a pinch of salt x

Kardelen · 10/02/2023 12:20

thank you so much @Hydie . I really do appreciate your comment. I’m just so glad you understand where I am coming from. Made me Feel a lot better, glad to know I’m not insane! true, I should just explain that.

OP posts:
Hydie · 10/02/2023 12:12

@Kardelen morally you'd hope they want to help their Mum and spend time with her. But judging by the comments on here there's a lot of people who don't give 2 shites about whether they support their parents and give anything back in life. I am like you and like to make sure my Mum is sorted. But I leave my brother to it, its his choice. What you should do is just tell your Mum you can't at the moment, and it's not on you to worry that she's not been out. Your siblings will have to live with their choices should they ever regret it. They might not, just like it seems lots of people on here wouldn't either x

Kardelen · 10/02/2023 12:06

@Hydie yes this was my exact thoughts to begin with when I posted! and the most annoying thing is they still expect mum/dad to help them out when they need it, but don’t give anything in return.

I also do many favours for their children now, but again they forget so quickly and move on. So maybe I should just stop caring, I don’t know.

OP posts:
Hydie · 10/02/2023 12:00

I think you're getting a hard time on here which doesn't surprise me as its Mumsnet for you.

I dont think you're in the wrong. I do everything for my Mum and my brother does nothing. It's so annoying. I dont ask him to I just leave him to it, he's the one who will live with the regret of not doing things with her, I already hear him say stuff about he's missing out but that's his choice.

You're not unreasonable to ask that when they are nipping to Tesco could they just consider her and see if she wants to go. But people on Mumsnet will tell you that you are extremely unreasonable and that you're being a brat... x

Kardelen · 10/02/2023 11:59

I think I need to change the way I think, I.e not feel bad about not taking out etc. as I can only do whatever I am capable of?

maybe then I would feel less overwhelmed

OP posts:
MelaniesFlowers · 10/02/2023 11:58

Kardelen · 10/02/2023 11:56

Maybe I’m wrong I don’t know. Maybe just feeling overwhelmed with the whole situation as I can’t really do anything about it

You can do something about it. You’re choosing not to.

LampLamp · 10/02/2023 11:58

I hate this idea that adult children are beholden to their parents once they get old. Especially if one of their children decides it might be nice to take on the role and then expects others to fall in line.
There are many, many reasons they might not want to - and even family don’t know those individual reasons.

Why the need to mention your sister’s child’s age? Sounds like you feel her child is too old for her to be a SAHM and she should now offer up time to a caring role.
As an older daughter, has she potentially shouldered some of the “responsibility” for caring in previous years?

Why did you think moving in was a good idea?

If, as a family, you all feel family care is important than hold a meeting where things are set out in stone and you lay out your position.
You can’t ask people on the off to help out here and there and see that as a long term solution to something which is clearly bothering you.

If you want a decent solution, have a meeting with your siblings. Discuss the care you think your parents require and tell them the following:

  • what kind of care you’re currently providing
  • what kind of care your parents require
  • how you best feel those needs can be met
  • how your ability to provide care is changing
  • if you need non-family help

Then have an open forum to discuss what can be done. Keeping in mind your siblings might not want a caring role for a variety of reasons.

Could your parents be involved in later discussions?

It is clear you’re angry and upset about your siblings but you need to go to them with a larger proposal/discussion about their care rather than a passive aggressive “can you take mum today?” hint every now and then.
Be prepared for “no” as it is a valid reply.

MelaniesFlowers · 10/02/2023 11:57

No, of course you shouldn’t feel obligated either. There is no moral obligation, that is something you are putting on yourself.

Your parents chose to have children and care for them. It doesn’t go the other way round; you are not there to care for your parents.

You need to put healthy boundaries in place like your siblings have.

Kardelen · 10/02/2023 11:56

Maybe I’m wrong I don’t know. Maybe just feeling overwhelmed with the whole situation as I can’t really do anything about it

OP posts:
Kardelen · 10/02/2023 11:54

So I shouldn’t feel obliged either? As I am not the carer? I feel that it’s more of a moral obligation. Because my parents went out their way multiple times for them, including looking after their children for free, or giving out large amounts of money- ( still waiting for them to pay). I don’t think parents were obliged to look after or give money towards adult children but I agree it was their own choice. But as it has been done, I believe they should give something back too.
and still my parents are there to support them in different ways, I.e till last year my dad was driving my sister around to shops because she had no car.

OP posts:
Harlow19 · 10/02/2023 11:52

It sounds like your parents have become very dependent on you. What you have done is a lovely thing but you need your own space. You have your own husband and now 2 kids. Does your husband mind your parents staying? I love my parents a lot and always make time for them but the thought of moving them in when I’ve got my own DH and baby on the way just because they’re lonely makes me cringe a bit.
You now feel inclined to constantly take your mum out all the time and are not having your own life. Yeah I do think your siblings should make an effort but their reasons are valid. Maybe deep down they also feel like you’ve become your parents carer.

DinaFox · 10/02/2023 11:49

@MelaniesFlowers I completely agree with you. OP: you can't expect other people to have the same type of relationship with somebody as you do.

Maybe your siblings don't enjoy your parents' company? Maybe they are more focused on their own lives? Maybe they are better at drawing their own boundaries?

I tend to say the same phrase in instances like this: your inability to draw adequate boundaries is not your siblings' problem. It's yours. You have no right to expect other people to behave in ways you deem to be best or to take the load off you because you can't say no.

MelaniesFlowers · 10/02/2023 11:47

Also doesn’t drive and there are no good transport links in the area.

They should have foreseen this and planned for how they would live in their old age.

They didn’t, and now they’re stuck and expecting their kids to look after them. It isn’t your job.

mynameisbrian · 10/02/2023 11:46

You have chosen to live with your parents. I am also assuming you are benefiting financially from this decision, hence you being able to cut your hours. Whether your sister is a SAHM or not, it is not up to you to instruct her how to use her time. Does sound like her view is you moved in and you can suck it up.

saraclara · 10/02/2023 11:46

I can see why your parents encouraged you to move in. They see you as their carers now.
Why does your dad not go out?

Your siblings are dealing with the situation in a healthy way. It would be nice if they helped occasionally, but it sounds as though there's an unhealthy expectation on your parents' part, that they don't want to get sucked into.