Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think a TA is not always beneficial

136 replies

Dancedanceswim · 10/02/2023 10:15

I should clarify that I’m both a TA myself and a mum of a (now adult) ASD child. I’m in now way against TA’s in general. This is specific to one child (mild ASD/ what would have been called Aspergers) I know of where I think that, in that case, him having a 1-1 TA is an error:

  • firstly, having a TA means that the whole experience at primary school is very “managed” and a bit sterile which may make it much harder for him to cope at secondary
  • This is an unpopular opinion but school really isn’t all about learning - the social aspect is vital. Therefore, if a child is sat with a TA all the time they won’t be able to freely socialise with their peers or enjoy any kind of childish behaviour without being constantly managed and having someone watching them
  • They’re already self conscious about being different- surely sitting a TA next to them will only make them feel more different to their peers. Also, it will signal to the other kids that they are different and potentially make them a target for bullying/ socially being ostracised
  • This child is actually very bright and there are many other kids in the class who could use 1-1 help in terms of improving their progress with work.

The reason they have a TA is because their parents absolutely fought tooth and nail. However, in my opinion I’m not sure it’s actually benefiting this child and this is perhaps a theme throughout.

This is about one child but I think in more general terms that while TA’s can be a valuable asset in the classroom and for some children can be brilliant, they’re not always beneficial. Aibu?

OP posts:
Hankunamatata · 10/02/2023 11:37

A good TA doesn't hover over a child especially in the upper end of primary. My sons TA moved a little away from him but in line of sight so he could signal. The primary were very good at transition the last two years towards more independence. A good TA helps engage socially especially in playground. My sons starts games and get other kids involved then they step back and watch and don't intervene unless needed.
Good TA are worth their weight in gold.
Also the child in question may need that level of support esp if they explode at home from masking at school all day.

Crunchymum · 10/02/2023 11:35

How can you be a TA (or have been a TA) when you seem to have no idea what a TA is or does? You seem to be talking about SEN TA who liaise with certain children depending on needs / EHCPs.

blackearth · 10/02/2023 11:31

I guess you either need one or you don't. You aren't going to have one given the economical states of LEAs / schools otherwise.

That said, a lot of it is due to the environment. In a mainstream environment, autistic children offer need significant levels of support to manage which I do agree hinders on all levels. If the environment was different, they wouldn't need so much support and could be more independent.

My ds was a classic example. In MS at times needed 2:1 support. Now in a autism school and needs no individual support at all. The school itself is a totally different environment and he thrives there.

IncompleteSenten · 10/02/2023 11:28

Depends on the child.

Both mine are intelligent and could have done the work if intelligence was all that was needed.

One of them was completely unable to function socially although he desperately wanted friends the other children were unable to see past his autism. He was bullied, laughed at, mocked and excluded his entire school life.

My other son would yell, throw himself about and sometimes even punch people if they got into his space. Which they did. Because they were children. And some of them would set him off on purpose because they thought his meltdowns were funny. Except when they got a punch of course.

If you have a child with autism who doesn't need a differentiated curriculum, extra processing time, a quiet spot to be able to go to etc, who has no problems understanding social behaviours and is able to mix with their peers without issue, isn't a flight risk, doesn't have any challenging behaviours, etc then yeah, no reason for a TA.i suspect that type of autistic child is quite rare though.

As are the completely understanding, inclusive, nice and supportive NT classmates ime.

Grumbleofpugs · 10/02/2023 11:24

It's not a one size fits all solution just as the education system isn't in this country unfortunately. For some children the 1.1 helps them immeasurably and in other cases its largely for the benefit of the rest of the class. The actual solution would be better funding so schools can increase staffing (more might find it an appealing career too), increase facilities such as nurture rooms, expand on mainstream plus schools etc.

Busybody2022 · 10/02/2023 11:21

My child can't access education at all without her TA despite being academically fine. A good TA knows when to step back and encourage independence

ThighMistress · 10/02/2023 11:20

My friend who teaches at a secondary school for those with severe LD said the same. If they have had a 1-1 at primary school their transition is harder.

There was a girl at dd’s school with global needs. She had a permanent 1-1 and spent virtually no time with the other children - no playtime, no assembly, no class time. Obviously the parents wanted her in a mainstream setting, but I couldn’t help thinking she would have had a better experience in a special school.

Pootleplum · 10/02/2023 11:19

TAs have enhanced my DDs experience of school immeasurably. Extra attention, pastoral care, facilitating friendships. She's had 3 and warmly bonded to two. But the TAs weren't 1-1 care for a sen child so isn't that a different role?

whatsagoodusername · 10/02/2023 11:17

My child has 1:1 support - he doesn't access education well without it. Before TA: date on page. After TA: full page of work.

He's autistic, so the social stuff is iffy for him anyway. He is different, this doesn't bother him. His TA prevents bullying. He would get nowhere with socialisation without adult support.

We don't want him to rely on it. We hope his reliance on it will lessen. We are working towards this. A managed experience is better than a negative one.

OhClunge · 10/02/2023 11:14

I've never known a TA in a mainstream school stick like glue to a pupil unless they are a risk to other children or likely to run
I believe that the whole well being is important, including them making mistakes and learning to manage it
How are you involved in this ?

mynamesnotMa · 10/02/2023 11:06

No and there's lots of evidence to support your assertion.