Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think a TA is not always beneficial

136 replies

Dancedanceswim · 10/02/2023 10:15

I should clarify that I’m both a TA myself and a mum of a (now adult) ASD child. I’m in now way against TA’s in general. This is specific to one child (mild ASD/ what would have been called Aspergers) I know of where I think that, in that case, him having a 1-1 TA is an error:

  • firstly, having a TA means that the whole experience at primary school is very “managed” and a bit sterile which may make it much harder for him to cope at secondary
  • This is an unpopular opinion but school really isn’t all about learning - the social aspect is vital. Therefore, if a child is sat with a TA all the time they won’t be able to freely socialise with their peers or enjoy any kind of childish behaviour without being constantly managed and having someone watching them
  • They’re already self conscious about being different- surely sitting a TA next to them will only make them feel more different to their peers. Also, it will signal to the other kids that they are different and potentially make them a target for bullying/ socially being ostracised
  • This child is actually very bright and there are many other kids in the class who could use 1-1 help in terms of improving their progress with work.

The reason they have a TA is because their parents absolutely fought tooth and nail. However, in my opinion I’m not sure it’s actually benefiting this child and this is perhaps a theme throughout.

This is about one child but I think in more general terms that while TA’s can be a valuable asset in the classroom and for some children can be brilliant, they’re not always beneficial. Aibu?

OP posts:
woodhill · 10/02/2023 14:19

lanthanum · 10/02/2023 13:47

As long as the TA's "named child" has first call on their time, it's not unreasonable for them to step back when not needed and help others. The child needs to begin to learn to work independently, and they are also entitled to their share of individual attention from their teacher.

I worked with a TA who was there for a named autistic pupil. When they started working on a task, she would check he knew what to do and was getting started, and then go round and check on the others on the special needs register, and then often some of the less confident girls. She kept an eye on her charge - if he'd lost focus then she could be straight back over to work with him.

I quite understand that parents who have fought hard for 1-1 time for their child need to know that their child has first call on that TA's attention, but I'm sure most would also understand the need to give them a little more independence. I think it's that "first call" thing which is important; the child should not be left floundering because the TA has been redeployed elsewhere.

Yes that makes sense

You are not a horse with blinkers on who can see no one else apart from the EHCP child

nothingleftttt · 10/02/2023 13:49

Wow. It's hard enough to get support and people make all sorts of judgements about a child not needing support.

My autistic child struggled to the point we were seriously concerned about self harm and mental health damage. According to the school child had no problems at school and was Fine. They didn't see the daily distress, the struggle because child masks.

We have support in place now and the difference is unbelievable.

lanthanum · 10/02/2023 13:47

As long as the TA's "named child" has first call on their time, it's not unreasonable for them to step back when not needed and help others. The child needs to begin to learn to work independently, and they are also entitled to their share of individual attention from their teacher.

I worked with a TA who was there for a named autistic pupil. When they started working on a task, she would check he knew what to do and was getting started, and then go round and check on the others on the special needs register, and then often some of the less confident girls. She kept an eye on her charge - if he'd lost focus then she could be straight back over to work with him.

I quite understand that parents who have fought hard for 1-1 time for their child need to know that their child has first call on that TA's attention, but I'm sure most would also understand the need to give them a little more independence. I think it's that "first call" thing which is important; the child should not be left floundering because the TA has been redeployed elsewhere.

SovietKitsch · 10/02/2023 13:36

I agree, but there’s a dearth of school places which are suitable for academically able kids with ASD. There’s no easy solution.

JustKeepBuilding · 10/02/2023 13:30

A good TA, trained well and deployed correctly does not hinder a child. The research such as Sharples et al., 2015 and Blatchford et al., 2009 backs that up and is what the government guidance is based on, although many LAs and schools like to misinterpret the research.

No child gets a 1:1 solely because their parents want one and fought for one, if it is included in their EHCP it has been deemed reasonably required.

wellbehavedwomenseldommakehistory · 10/02/2023 13:17

Sleepyblueocean · 10/02/2023 12:24

"The reason they have a TA is because their parents absolutely fought tooth and nail."

The child would not have have got a TA (not shared with other children) without an educational psychologist stating one was necessary. The LA won't fund one without this.

Correct. But nope, never mind this extremely relevant fact.

According to various people - school staff, other parents, randoms on the internet! - it's just us pushy parents using our sharp elbows and stompy feet we get our own way to get something our child doesn't really 'need'!

I don't think people realise how much the vast majority of us would much prefer that our child didn't need 1:1 TA support.

FrownedUpon · 10/02/2023 12:48

I agree & there's evidence a TA can hinder a child’s development. I’ve seen a lot of pupils who just rely on the TA far too much & their independence skills just don’t develop. Also, some TA’s are amazing. Some are awful & literally do the work for the child, so they learn nothing.

anomaly23 · 10/02/2023 12:45

whatsagoodusername · 10/02/2023 11:17

My child has 1:1 support - he doesn't access education well without it. Before TA: date on page. After TA: full page of work.

He's autistic, so the social stuff is iffy for him anyway. He is different, this doesn't bother him. His TA prevents bullying. He would get nowhere with socialisation without adult support.

We don't want him to rely on it. We hope his reliance on it will lessen. We are working towards this. A managed experience is better than a negative one.

This

Sleepyblueocean · 10/02/2023 12:24

"The reason they have a TA is because their parents absolutely fought tooth and nail."

The child would not have have got a TA (not shared with other children) without an educational psychologist stating one was necessary. The LA won't fund one without this.

woodhill · 10/02/2023 12:19

Makemetry · 10/02/2023 12:14

The TA should be there to enable the child to be integrated into the school as much as possible. There’s no need for a TA to be sitting next to a child at all times. If they are able to work independently, even if only for short amounts of time, then they should do so. At these times it’s entirely appropriate for the TA to help other children.

Yes

The TA should be able to assist others

It's good for dc to have a go at figuring things out themselves imo

BurbageBrook · 10/02/2023 12:16

You’re right and in some cases it can also be detrimental because the TA oversimplifies the work, therefore stultifying the child’s progress. There are some fantastic TAs but also some ineffective ones with relatively little training.

bigbluebus · 10/02/2023 12:16

This depends very much on the reason the child needs a TA, the personality of the TA and how the TA is used.

My DS had a TA throughout primary school. He was also very bright with an ASD diagnosis but struggled to stay on task so became disruptive. Some TAs were better at managing him than others. He could be quite manipulative and was very good at negotiating his way out of things or getting the TA to do stuff for him! As he moved up the school they found a more assertive TA to work with him and then worked better. The TAs often worked within a group of children and helped others but DS was always in that group.
The focus on transition to Secondary was very much about using different TAs so he was used to different people. As he got older he preferred the TAs to be at a distance and it was agreed they would only step in when needed. It became apparent that in the lessons which interested him most he did not cause any issues and remained focused so there was a gradual withdrawal in some lessons. This was always discussed with us and with the individual subject teachers. We did have one or two TAs where there was a definite clash and we had to ask for them to be removed from working with DS.

So I agree that a 1:1 marking with a TA can have it's down sides with some children but as you have pointed out, each case is individual and should be managed as such by the Senco.

MelchiorsMistress · 10/02/2023 12:15

I think you have a long but I would still say that overall it is beneficial to have a TA.

A good 1-1 will not hover around the child constantly and will be able to effectively support the child from a slight distance, or while sharing their support around so that it doesn’t put the focus solely on one child.

The problem is that they will pretty much recruit anyone that breathes as a TA, especially as a 1-1 as it’s not a popular job ime. It’s a job that does require skill and experience to be done well but the pay doesn’t reflect that so the best people go for other jobs instead.

Makemetry · 10/02/2023 12:14

The TA should be there to enable the child to be integrated into the school as much as possible. There’s no need for a TA to be sitting next to a child at all times. If they are able to work independently, even if only for short amounts of time, then they should do so. At these times it’s entirely appropriate for the TA to help other children.

MissingMoominMamma · 10/02/2023 12:08

hiredandsqueak · 10/02/2023 11:46

My experience of having 1 to 1 TAs is much like @Sirzy a good TA is worth their weight in gold and we have been lucky to have benefited from a few good TAs. The bad ones are little more than appendages though. The answer isn't to remove 1 to 1 TAs it's to ensure that the bad ones are weeded out or that they receive support and training necessary to make them good TAs.

This, with bells on!!

ExistenceOptional · 10/02/2023 12:05

Is a 1-1 TA always a good thing?
Of course not. The needs of children vary and for some children negative impacts have to be taken into account as well.

Bimbleberries · 10/02/2023 12:00

Depends hugely on the child!

I suspect with a lot of children with similar difficulties, it is not the presence of the TA that makes them feel different or that alerts other children to the fact that they are different - their actual differences do this. Without the TA, they will still be different, and potentially even more subject to being ostracised or bullied. The TA can hopefully prevent some of this, and allow them to develop confidence and ways of relating to other children.

The presence of a TA might allow the child to perform at his or her best. It doesn't matter if other children in the class are academically weaker and need more one-to-one help than they are getting; that's a separate issue.

There's no way to tell whether a child at secondary who finds it difficult without a TA would or wouldn't have got on better as a result of having one or not in primary - there is no control to this experiment. It could well be that the child who needed intensive support in primary woudn't have made it to mainstream secondary without one, and so the fact that they are there, even if struggling, may mean that having a TA was just what they needed in primary. That doesn't mean primary was 'sterile' or 'managed' in some negative way, but might have been the way that allowed that child to progress to their current point.

Of course the social experience may be different, but in many cases, it's not like the child would necessarily have a normal social experience anyway. They might not be able to socialise freely because of their difficulties. If they are able to, a good TA is not going to interfere in that way.

Yes there might be situations where a child doesn't need a TA all the time, but a good TA can foster independence as needed. There are times when children may depend too much on the TA for things, or when a TA provides unhelpful support that stops a child developing, but those are problems with the TA support, not from the fact that the child has a TA.

I think it's totally individual to the child, the TA, the type of difficulties, the classroom, and it would be extremely difficult for an outsider to make an informed judgement.

Jules912 · 10/02/2023 11:58

They tried giving my DD a 1-2-1 but she hated it as no one else in the class had one ( although she hasn't got funding for a 1-2-1 so she was actually the year group TA). What she actually needs is someone to take her out when it's getting too much.

hiredandsqueak · 10/02/2023 11:46

My experience of having 1 to 1 TAs is much like @Sirzy a good TA is worth their weight in gold and we have been lucky to have benefited from a few good TAs. The bad ones are little more than appendages though. The answer isn't to remove 1 to 1 TAs it's to ensure that the bad ones are weeded out or that they receive support and training necessary to make them good TAs.

woodhill · 10/02/2023 11:45

Sometimes they have to support other dc. They are not going off for a coffee

wellbehavedwomenseldommakehistory · 10/02/2023 11:44

You can't make a sweeping generalisation on this. It's entirely dependant on the child and their needs.

I am a parent of a child that fought tooth and nail for mine to have 1:1 TA. They have it, full time, and have done since Reception. Over a couple of years I've also had to fight tooth and nail repeatedly to bust the myth that they don't need it because they appear 'fine', aren't disruptive/violent and are academically able. I've also had to battle school staff sneakily taking my child's support for other children and lying about it, despite it being set out very clearly, and enforceably in their EHCP.

The fact is, without that 1:1 TA they couldn't access school or the curriculum at all. They likely would become extremely disruptive if forced to, or would not be able to attend at all.

Yes, there are almost certainly other children in the class that need the same level of support and some don't have it. I cannot do anything the fact that their parents haven't advocated in the same way as me. But I cannot allow my child's provision to be diluted to make up for that. I won't.

The plan is that as time goes the reliance lessens and independence is always encouraged and praised. Small steps here are actually happening already, under my child's own steam when they feel regulated and settled. It categorically wouldn't be happening if forced, and wasn't in line with my child's development and needs. A good TA knows their child and can read them/their behaviour to see when is and isn't a good time/day to promote more independence.

We hope that by the end of primary, the TA input will be minimal. With the right approach, for my child, this should be achievable. It won't be for all children though.

If a child still needs full time 1:1 TA support at secondary stage, is likely that mainstream education isn't going to work for them.

TheYearOfSmallThings · 10/02/2023 11:41

A good TA would assist the child to integrate with the other children. I see this in DS's year - the TAs work to get their pupils engaged socially, which often wouldn't happen successfully without them.

Sirzy · 10/02/2023 11:40

For a child to have full 1-1 there will be a proven need.

ds has had full 1-1 from year 3 to year 8 (now) and a good 1-1 is nothing like you outlined. They act to open doors not shut them.

Pegsmum · 10/02/2023 11:39

Very much depends on the TA imo. Even on a 1-1 support basis the TA should recognise that sitting next to a pupil in a mainstream setting, for all the reasons you stated, is not always helpful. A good TA will be discreet and promote independence as much as is reasonably possible.
I’m

woodhill · 10/02/2023 11:38

I do know what you mean about socialisation in the scenario you describe and sometimes some SN dc prefer the company of adults in the end