Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think a TA is not always beneficial

136 replies

Dancedanceswim · 10/02/2023 10:15

I should clarify that I’m both a TA myself and a mum of a (now adult) ASD child. I’m in now way against TA’s in general. This is specific to one child (mild ASD/ what would have been called Aspergers) I know of where I think that, in that case, him having a 1-1 TA is an error:

  • firstly, having a TA means that the whole experience at primary school is very “managed” and a bit sterile which may make it much harder for him to cope at secondary
  • This is an unpopular opinion but school really isn’t all about learning - the social aspect is vital. Therefore, if a child is sat with a TA all the time they won’t be able to freely socialise with their peers or enjoy any kind of childish behaviour without being constantly managed and having someone watching them
  • They’re already self conscious about being different- surely sitting a TA next to them will only make them feel more different to their peers. Also, it will signal to the other kids that they are different and potentially make them a target for bullying/ socially being ostracised
  • This child is actually very bright and there are many other kids in the class who could use 1-1 help in terms of improving their progress with work.

The reason they have a TA is because their parents absolutely fought tooth and nail. However, in my opinion I’m not sure it’s actually benefiting this child and this is perhaps a theme throughout.

This is about one child but I think in more general terms that while TA’s can be a valuable asset in the classroom and for some children can be brilliant, they’re not always beneficial. Aibu?

OP posts:
Prescottdanni123 · 11/02/2023 08:13

I've worked as a TA in school. I never sat next to them the whole time during lessons. I would often be helping other students with work too while keeping an eye on the child and making sure they stayed focused. At breaktimes and lunchtimes they were on there own with their friends.

I now work in secondary and a number of kids there have TAs so they don't necessarily go from having support to zero support.

EnglishRose1320 · 11/02/2023 07:54

I stopped paying attention to what you thought about the situation when you decided the child had "mild" autism, which doesn't exist and it's very depressing but sadly not surprising that someone who works as a t.a would still believe that "mild" autism is a thing.

As previous posters have said, you don't get a 1:1 easily, so if a child has one, they need one. However a 1:1 role can be really varied and you probably don't see the whole role, the discreet independence building/the scaffolding they are putting in place to prepare the child for secondary etc....

Futurethoughts · 11/02/2023 07:46

My experience has been that TAs either become over involved in classroom management or they step back to the point that they might as well not be there.

It’s a huge shift that came about in the last twenty years - we now think they are indispensable. I actually think most schools could manage fine without them.

marcopront · 11/02/2023 07:42

As others have said a good TA is beneficial a bad TA isn't.

tiredhadenough · 11/02/2023 07:29

EHCPs state 1:1 but never come with enough funding which is why we no longer have general TAs

Trying to employ good TAs/1.1s is really tricky. The wage is shit. I have had to sort through some awful job applications of people thinking they can do the job and have actually not appointed on some occasions as they have been so awful.

We have some amazing support staff at school but most struggle to realise when to step back and when to intervene.

S1ng1ngSpr1ng · 11/02/2023 07:19

There is no such thing as mild ASD which is a hugely offensive thing to say. You either have it or you haven’t. It varies in how it presents and if you’ve met one person with autism you’ve met one person with autism. You aren’t in the child’s head so will have no idea of the difficulties they will be challenged with daily.

I’m suspicious that either your op isn’t true, you’re not a TA or your school is doing a dreadful job re training. At our school the whole staff has autism training so would know the above. Everybody would know the difference between a 1:1 and a general TA. We’d also know how to do both correctly, having had training and are measured on progress and work done to attain goals on very detailed EHCPs.

You’d need an EHCP with a lot of funding to get a full time 1:1. It’s very difficult to get however much parents fight. Something in the op doesn’t ring true.

tiredhadenough · 11/02/2023 06:18

Crunchymum · 10/02/2023 11:35

How can you be a TA (or have been a TA) when you seem to have no idea what a TA is or does? You seem to be talking about SEN TA who liaise with certain children depending on needs / EHCPs.

That's all we have in our school now! There are no general TAs. No money 🤷🏼‍♀️.

It depends on the TA. Many do not understand when to step back and it causes no end of issues

itsgettingweird · 10/02/2023 20:43

If a Ta is sat like glue to a child that could benefit from time to socialise alone then the Ta is doing it wrong - not the ehcp.

The Ta should be teaching the skills, they should be experienced enough to know when to step back and allow them to use those skills and when to step in again to support new learning and prevent crisis.

My ds had a TA in secondary school. She was called his mentor. During some lessons which required a lot of writing and language she was deployed for him 1:1. But she worked with other students (including his best friend) to support them once she'd set ds up.

As long as she supported him primarily where required she was doing her job.

I was a TA and now do something specialist in education. I'm a massive promoter of using TAs effectively and supporting them to get it right professionally.

Busybody2022 · 10/02/2023 20:31

@Mrsuntidy In schools you are familiar with. Ours call them all TAs. There's a huge variance in terminology

JustKeepBuilding · 10/02/2023 20:03

The terminology varies area to area and school to school. Some schools call 1:1s TAs.

For example, the first 2 1:1 TA job adverts on Google -
one
two

Mrsuntidy · 10/02/2023 19:46

A TA is a teaching assistant and supports the whole class and the class teacher. An LSA is a 1:1 and supports one child.

SunnySnowdrop · 10/02/2023 19:19

No one gets a 1-1 (especially full time just for them) unless it's needed. Do you know how hard it is to get even basic provision in place? Let alone a 1-1.

JustKeepBuilding · 10/02/2023 19:15

In many schools 1:1s are called TAs.

Talapia · 10/02/2023 19:15

JustKeepBuilding · 10/02/2023 19:08

A TA can be a 1:1…

They could be. However, where I work they are two very different roles.

JustKeepBuilding · 10/02/2023 19:08

Talapia · 10/02/2023 19:07

Surely you are describing a 1 to 1 rather than a TA?

In the case you specify, they are not carrying out their role properly. The job of a 1 to 1 is to support a child to achieve independence to the bestvof the child's ability.

A TA can be a 1:1…

Talapia · 10/02/2023 19:07

Dancedanceswim · 10/02/2023 10:15

I should clarify that I’m both a TA myself and a mum of a (now adult) ASD child. I’m in now way against TA’s in general. This is specific to one child (mild ASD/ what would have been called Aspergers) I know of where I think that, in that case, him having a 1-1 TA is an error:

  • firstly, having a TA means that the whole experience at primary school is very “managed” and a bit sterile which may make it much harder for him to cope at secondary
  • This is an unpopular opinion but school really isn’t all about learning - the social aspect is vital. Therefore, if a child is sat with a TA all the time they won’t be able to freely socialise with their peers or enjoy any kind of childish behaviour without being constantly managed and having someone watching them
  • They’re already self conscious about being different- surely sitting a TA next to them will only make them feel more different to their peers. Also, it will signal to the other kids that they are different and potentially make them a target for bullying/ socially being ostracised
  • This child is actually very bright and there are many other kids in the class who could use 1-1 help in terms of improving their progress with work.

The reason they have a TA is because their parents absolutely fought tooth and nail. However, in my opinion I’m not sure it’s actually benefiting this child and this is perhaps a theme throughout.

This is about one child but I think in more general terms that while TA’s can be a valuable asset in the classroom and for some children can be brilliant, they’re not always beneficial. Aibu?

Surely you are describing a 1 to 1 rather than a TA?

In the case you specify, they are not carrying out their role properly. The job of a 1 to 1 is to support a child to achieve independence to the bestvof the child's ability.

Trinifriedchicken · 10/02/2023 19:05

If a TA is not building independent work and social skills they aren't doing their job. (I'm a TA too)

x2boys · 10/02/2023 19:03

Dancedanceswim · 10/02/2023 10:15

I should clarify that I’m both a TA myself and a mum of a (now adult) ASD child. I’m in now way against TA’s in general. This is specific to one child (mild ASD/ what would have been called Aspergers) I know of where I think that, in that case, him having a 1-1 TA is an error:

  • firstly, having a TA means that the whole experience at primary school is very “managed” and a bit sterile which may make it much harder for him to cope at secondary
  • This is an unpopular opinion but school really isn’t all about learning - the social aspect is vital. Therefore, if a child is sat with a TA all the time they won’t be able to freely socialise with their peers or enjoy any kind of childish behaviour without being constantly managed and having someone watching them
  • They’re already self conscious about being different- surely sitting a TA next to them will only make them feel more different to their peers. Also, it will signal to the other kids that they are different and potentially make them a target for bullying/ socially being ostracised
  • This child is actually very bright and there are many other kids in the class who could use 1-1 help in terms of improving their progress with work.

The reason they have a TA is because their parents absolutely fought tooth and nail. However, in my opinion I’m not sure it’s actually benefiting this child and this is perhaps a theme throughout.

This is about one child but I think in more general terms that while TA’s can be a valuable asset in the classroom and for some children can be brilliant, they’re not always beneficial. Aibu?

Well.as a TA you should know that it it's written into a child's EHCP,that they require X hours of1:1 support / day than it's a legal.document ,if the TA is employed as a childs1:1 than that's their job and it doesn't matter how many other children in the class might need 1:1 support that's not what they are there for.
there will.be an annual.review and the which will.look wether the support offered is still necessary

Arguelikeagrownup · 10/02/2023 18:43

My child's TA is helping her learn to navigate the social stuff in a way she wouldn't be able to without her.

Busybody2022 · 10/02/2023 18:39

Sirzy · 10/02/2023 18:21

Exactly.

ds being academically able has actually created a whole host of problems for us educationally as he doesn’t really fit anywhere in the system. Having a full time 1-1 means we get the best possible for him as he can on the whole access mainstream curriculum

This is exactly our situation.

Sirzy · 10/02/2023 18:21

Willyoujustbequiet · 10/02/2023 15:17

Yabvu to say the child is very bright so doesn't need one

That comment is so ignorant. Lots of disorders and SEN are nothing to do with intelligence.

You can be a straight A student but still need access support.

Exactly.

ds being academically able has actually created a whole host of problems for us educationally as he doesn’t really fit anywhere in the system. Having a full time 1-1 means we get the best possible for him as he can on the whole access mainstream curriculum

wellbehavedwomenseldommakehistory · 10/02/2023 15:19

Also, with al respect OP, you say this:

"This is specific to one child (mild ASD/ what would have been called Aspergers) I know of where I think that, in that case, him having a 1-1 TA is an error"

  1. There no such thing as mild ASD. Children are autistic or they are not. When people call it 'mild' really, what you're saying is the impact on SOME of the people around them - in this case. at school - seems mild. The impact on the child will not be mild whatever their appearance/presentation is (especially if they've got 1:1 support approved!) and it is also highly unlikely to have a mild impact on their family!

  2. In your capacity as a TA quite frankly it's not your business nor are you qualified to make such a judgement. It's your business to get on with the job you're paid to do. As it's been explained qualified expert individuals such as Educational Psychologists (whose job it is to make such judgment calls) will have made their decision based on numerous observations, medical reports etc.

There are far too many staff in schools (not teacher bashing, most are wonderful and doing a difficult job in difficult circumstances) who wrongly think they know better than the people who are actually qualified and able to assess special educational needs. They don't. Even class teachers. It's not in their remit to argue about or even particularly have an opinion on a child's EHCP provision. It's their job, along with the school SLT to ensure that it's implemented in the classroom.

Willyoujustbequiet · 10/02/2023 15:17

Yabvu to say the child is very bright so doesn't need one

That comment is so ignorant. Lots of disorders and SEN are nothing to do with intelligence.

You can be a straight A student but still need access support.

Kitkatfiend31 · 10/02/2023 15:14

The issue you describe is actually to do with how that child's support is being managed. The TA can sit with other children to allow the teacher to give more support to the child. Or can observe from afar and intervene if necessary... They don't have to stick like glue and even if necessary at a young age a planned increase in independence should be made.

JustKeepBuilding · 10/02/2023 14:33

If a pupil has full time 1:1 specified and quantified in their EHCP they have that for a very good reason, the 1:1 should not be helping other pupils. It is not for the school or TA to decide 1:1 isn’t necessary. Any school which uses the 1:1 for other things leaves the school and LA open to legal proceedings.