Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think a TA is not always beneficial

136 replies

Dancedanceswim · 10/02/2023 10:15

I should clarify that I’m both a TA myself and a mum of a (now adult) ASD child. I’m in now way against TA’s in general. This is specific to one child (mild ASD/ what would have been called Aspergers) I know of where I think that, in that case, him having a 1-1 TA is an error:

  • firstly, having a TA means that the whole experience at primary school is very “managed” and a bit sterile which may make it much harder for him to cope at secondary
  • This is an unpopular opinion but school really isn’t all about learning - the social aspect is vital. Therefore, if a child is sat with a TA all the time they won’t be able to freely socialise with their peers or enjoy any kind of childish behaviour without being constantly managed and having someone watching them
  • They’re already self conscious about being different- surely sitting a TA next to them will only make them feel more different to their peers. Also, it will signal to the other kids that they are different and potentially make them a target for bullying/ socially being ostracised
  • This child is actually very bright and there are many other kids in the class who could use 1-1 help in terms of improving their progress with work.

The reason they have a TA is because their parents absolutely fought tooth and nail. However, in my opinion I’m not sure it’s actually benefiting this child and this is perhaps a theme throughout.

This is about one child but I think in more general terms that while TA’s can be a valuable asset in the classroom and for some children can be brilliant, they’re not always beneficial. Aibu?

OP posts:
Stompythedinosaur · 11/02/2023 17:08

A decent TA will support social interactions as well as learning.

But, basically, no one is getting a TA without quite significant need for one.

wellbehavedwomenseldommakehistory · 11/02/2023 17:06

Sounds like we're in the same or a similar profession, @JustKeepBuilding!

Agree with you there too, these things do prompt action. The issue I find is that parents (especially at the moment) can't afford a letter before action or a JR. It's wholly unfair, but there are costs associated.

Our Director of Children's Services gives zero shits about receiving letters before action, etc. Honestly, it's dire.

JustKeepBuilding · 11/02/2023 13:36

wellbehavedwomenseldommakehistory · 11/02/2023 13:31

Absolutely true but have you tried getting an LA to provide it (I do on a weekly basis!).

Like getting blood out of a stone. Again often ends up at Tribunal!

Yes, I have, for DS1 and I have supported hundreds of other parents IRL and on MN to secure it too. Often a well worded threat of judicial review to the Director of Children’s Services works. If that and a pre-action letter doesn’t JR will and that is a much quicker resolution than Tribunal.

wellbehavedwomenseldommakehistory · 11/02/2023 13:31

JustKeepBuilding · 11/02/2023 12:33

CSA pupils who are unable to attend school full time are entitled to a suitable, full time education by other means. LAs often fail to provide this but parents can force them to, so they don’t need to be at home unable to access education entirely.

Absolutely true but have you tried getting an LA to provide it (I do on a weekly basis!).

Like getting blood out of a stone. Again often ends up at Tribunal!

woodhill · 11/02/2023 12:56

Cuckoosheep · 11/02/2023 12:46

As a ta you're not qualified to say what needs this child has or how they should be met, that us down to the professionals providing the input for the ehcp. (I do believe TA's sre professionals and do a very difficult and under valued job).

The TA should be trained so that they know what support to give and when including how to aid in social activities.

Children can have 1:1 in a special school. Every child in my ds's sen school has at least 1:1 at all times. It is an autism school.

If you deem other children in the class to need a TA more then talk to the school about providing it for them and why their needs aren't being met. It isn't about who needs it more, it should be about them all having their needs met.

Yes I know

Cuckoosheep · 11/02/2023 12:46

As a ta you're not qualified to say what needs this child has or how they should be met, that us down to the professionals providing the input for the ehcp. (I do believe TA's sre professionals and do a very difficult and under valued job).

The TA should be trained so that they know what support to give and when including how to aid in social activities.

Children can have 1:1 in a special school. Every child in my ds's sen school has at least 1:1 at all times. It is an autism school.

If you deem other children in the class to need a TA more then talk to the school about providing it for them and why their needs aren't being met. It isn't about who needs it more, it should be about them all having their needs met.

Spendonsend · 11/02/2023 12:45

My son goes to special school and still has 1:1 so special schools dont always mean no 1:1

In mainstream, 1:1s used well are beneficial. but I do think some ehcps dont really outline what the 1:1 is supposed to do to help, and some 1:1s arent trained enough to do what they should be doing. It means you end up with an untrained person just trailing round with an unregulated child.

Littlefish · 11/02/2023 12:38

ThighMistress · 10/02/2023 11:20

My friend who teaches at a secondary school for those with severe LD said the same. If they have had a 1-1 at primary school their transition is harder.

There was a girl at dd’s school with global needs. She had a permanent 1-1 and spent virtually no time with the other children - no playtime, no assembly, no class time. Obviously the parents wanted her in a mainstream setting, but I couldn’t help thinking she would have had a better experience in a special school.

But if, via an EHCP, they have had a 1:1 at primary school, then they should still have one at secondary school.

I'm not sure why the transition would be any more difficult in this case.

Are you thinking about circumstances which are different to this?

JustKeepBuilding · 11/02/2023 12:33

CSA pupils who are unable to attend school full time are entitled to a suitable, full time education by other means. LAs often fail to provide this but parents can force them to, so they don’t need to be at home unable to access education entirely.

wellbehavedwomenseldommakehistory · 11/02/2023 12:30

To add to the below, you only have to look at all the parent protests that are cropping up around the country to see how the SEN system is current utterly fucked. It's not a local issue, it's everywhere. Devon, Bristol, Oxford...and loads more. All have recently protested/had media coverage and it's only getting worse.

TwilightSilhouette · 11/02/2023 12:30

*really are

TwilightSilhouette · 11/02/2023 12:29

If you resonate a TA OP then you are doing it wrong and need better training. A TA shouldn’t be glued by the chip’s side, they should enable the child to get started and move away, checking back regularly. They should deliver targeted interventions. They should facilitate social skills and interactions. They should perform any physical assistance or physio that is necessary.

wellbehavedwomenseldommakehistory · 11/02/2023 12:26

woodhill · 11/02/2023 10:39

Do you think we need more places in specialist schools again?

Yes! Yes there is a huge need here. All of our county ones are full and parents who need them for their child are forced to go to Tribunal to get a spot. At a wait of oner a year. In the interim these children are either forced to remain in an unsuitable mainstream which has a detrimental effect on all of the children, not just them, or they can't cope and are at home unable to access education entirely.

The answer is more special school places PLUS hubs in all mainstream schools for those who do not qualify for or where a special school places wouldn't be appropriate but they cannot cope even if well supported in a mainstream environment. Trouble is, as always, with funding!!

Add in the fact that obtaining a decent EHCP (as in one that it quantified, specific and detailed) is nigh on impossible as a parent unless you're trained to get one and it's not wonder that children and our schools are floundering.

x2boys · 11/02/2023 11:29

woodhill · 11/02/2023 10:39

Do you think we need more places in specialist schools again?

All.four of the special.schools in my LEA have doubled in capacity in the last five years so there is certainly a need for more spaces ,but that's both the whole answer as special schools are not a one size fits all.

RedToothBrush · 11/02/2023 11:28

This is an unpopular opinion but school really isn’t all about learning - the social aspect is vital. Therefore, if a child is sat with a TA all the time they won’t be able to freely socialise with their peers or enjoy any kind of childish behaviour without being constantly managed and having someone watching them
^^
There's a kid in my son's class who needs a TA because they need to be constantly managed and supervised. But in the name of socialisation this isn't happening. Instead my son and the rest of the class are part of an experiment in finding out the long term effects of not intervening when it should have. My son has had bruises from it and has expressed fear of this child and there are obvious signs of coercion from this child. But 'socialisation'.

Nope. Doesn't work. Some kids need that supervision and there's no way around it

JustKeepBuilding · 11/02/2023 11:16

@Busybody2022 Similar for DS3, his EHCP has over £35k attached to it. I know others with more than that too. Not only does DS3 have full time 1:1 with break and lunch covered the 1:1s are funded for prep time on top of that - something many say isn’t possible.

Busybody2022 · 11/02/2023 11:07

JustKeepBuilding · 11/02/2023 10:40

It can and does happen.

Schools and parents can force the LA to fully fund. If your school doesn’t have enough funding then you can force the LA to provide it. LAs won’t fully fund unless forced to.

I have helped hundreds of parents to secure fully funded EHCPs.

The SEN system is a mess, but that doesn’t mean EHCPs can’t be fully funded.

Yes, my DDs school are funded 30k for her provision and full time 1-1

JustKeepBuilding · 11/02/2023 11:01

There’s certainly not enough SS places for those who want them, but as Sirzy posted, it isn’t the answer for all.

DS3 has a lot of provision in his EHCP and because of that is thriving in MS secondary. He wouldn’t want and doesn’t need a SS.

It also wouldn’t solve the problem of no suitable school for all DC. DS1 has EOTAS because there are no schools that can meet his needs. That wouldn’t change with more SS places.

Sirzy · 11/02/2023 10:57

woodhill · 11/02/2023 10:39

Do you think we need more places in specialist schools again?

I don’t think specialist school places are the whole answer but having a wider range of specialist schools, and just schools in general, I think would help many pupils and not just those with SEN.

in DS case he is to academically able for any of the local specialist schools, none offer the chance to do a full range of GCSEs. Mainstream isn’t an ideal for him but it’s better than specialist would have been, he goes to school to learn and if he isn’t being pushed then that’s when the issues really ramp up.

but the whole issue with mainstream education is it’s too much one size fits all and when children don’t fit into that box it’s too easy for them to slip through the net. Persoanlly i think having more alternative provisions for all pupils who need it would lead to much better outcomes long term.

JustKeepBuilding · 11/02/2023 10:40

tiredhadenough · 11/02/2023 10:31

@JustKeepBuilding I wish that happened. Our EHCPs do not give us the correct amount we need for support. It's even worse in nursery, a child on the highest band gets £880 for a term (15 hours). This does not pay for 1:1!!!! This is a child where it states 1:1 on the ehcp.

Special needs education is a shit show currently.

It can and does happen.

Schools and parents can force the LA to fully fund. If your school doesn’t have enough funding then you can force the LA to provide it. LAs won’t fully fund unless forced to.

I have helped hundreds of parents to secure fully funded EHCPs.

The SEN system is a mess, but that doesn’t mean EHCPs can’t be fully funded.

woodhill · 11/02/2023 10:39

Do you think we need more places in specialist schools again?

tiredhadenough · 11/02/2023 10:31

@JustKeepBuilding I wish that happened. Our EHCPs do not give us the correct amount we need for support. It's even worse in nursery, a child on the highest band gets £880 for a term (15 hours). This does not pay for 1:1!!!! This is a child where it states 1:1 on the ehcp.

Special needs education is a shit show currently.

JustAnotherManicNameChange · 11/02/2023 09:38

If the TA is not beneficial, then that ultimately falls on SLT/SENCO. Children that have 1 2 1' s should still be monitored, progress checked,planned for , the teacher should still work with them , clear expectations for the child and the TA etc. If this is done accurately and regularly, any issues would soon become apparent and changes put in place.

Createausername1970 · 11/02/2023 09:06

My DS was given a 1-2-1 in primary. He seemed, at the time, to be doing better because of it. Roll on secondary school. No 1-2-1 and suddenly moving around from one class to another every lesson. Plus we realised he was actually working at a much lower level than we thought, because the 1-2-1 had been doing the work!

I ended up homeschooling as he was so out of his depth. He is now nearly 20 and awaiting a Stage II asd assessment.
It would have been better if he hadn't had 1-2-1 in primary and things had come to a head in Y4 not Y8.

JustKeepBuilding · 11/02/2023 08:47

EHCPs state 1:1 but never come with enough funding

EHCPs can be fully funded.

I've worked as a TA in school. I never sat next to them the whole time during lessons. I would often be helping other students with work too while keeping an eye on the child and making sure they stayed focused. At breaktimes and lunchtimes they were on there own with their friends.

Presumably none of them had 1:1 specified and quantified in F otherwise the school was acting unlawfully. 1:1 for break and lunch can also be included if necessary.