Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think a TA is not always beneficial

136 replies

Dancedanceswim · 10/02/2023 10:15

I should clarify that I’m both a TA myself and a mum of a (now adult) ASD child. I’m in now way against TA’s in general. This is specific to one child (mild ASD/ what would have been called Aspergers) I know of where I think that, in that case, him having a 1-1 TA is an error:

  • firstly, having a TA means that the whole experience at primary school is very “managed” and a bit sterile which may make it much harder for him to cope at secondary
  • This is an unpopular opinion but school really isn’t all about learning - the social aspect is vital. Therefore, if a child is sat with a TA all the time they won’t be able to freely socialise with their peers or enjoy any kind of childish behaviour without being constantly managed and having someone watching them
  • They’re already self conscious about being different- surely sitting a TA next to them will only make them feel more different to their peers. Also, it will signal to the other kids that they are different and potentially make them a target for bullying/ socially being ostracised
  • This child is actually very bright and there are many other kids in the class who could use 1-1 help in terms of improving their progress with work.

The reason they have a TA is because their parents absolutely fought tooth and nail. However, in my opinion I’m not sure it’s actually benefiting this child and this is perhaps a theme throughout.

This is about one child but I think in more general terms that while TA’s can be a valuable asset in the classroom and for some children can be brilliant, they’re not always beneficial. Aibu?

OP posts:
Twiglets1 · 12/02/2023 12:18

JustKeepBuilding · 12/02/2023 11:57

Posted too soon, on my last sentence, for some DC their SEN will prevent or hinder “normal peer friendships from developing” regardless of whether there is a 1:1 present or not.

Now you sound unrealistic. I know what goes on in classrooms in reality not what is on a statement, do you? I have dozens of TA friends who talk honestly about their experiences, do you?

JustKeepBuilding · 12/02/2023 11:57

Posted too soon, on my last sentence, for some DC their SEN will prevent or hinder “normal peer friendships from developing” regardless of whether there is a 1:1 present or not.

JustKeepBuilding · 12/02/2023 11:55

But that’s the problem. It’s not for you or the school to decide to “behave the way I think is most beneficial for the children in the room, especially the ones with SEN.”

An EHCP is a legal document. If full time 1:1 is specified and quantified in an EHCP it must be provided. To not provide it is unlawful and leaves the school and LA open to legal proceedings. It’s not for you or the school to decide differently.

A good 1:1, trained well and deployed correctly does not need to “prevent normal peer friendships from developing.”

Twiglets1 · 12/02/2023 11:46

JustKeepBuilding · 12/02/2023 10:27

If you genuinely think that is the main reason why 1:1s are used to support others that is a very naive view. The biggest reason by far 1:1s are used to help others is for the benefit of others/the school, not because it is in the best interests of the child with full time 1:1 specified and quantified in F.

I’ve been a TA for 12 years and no one tells me how to behave in a classroom. I behave the way I think is most beneficial for the children in the room, especially the ones with SEN. The senior leadership group rarely see TAs in the classroom as they tend to take the top set classes if they teach at all.
Occasionally a SEND child will need a lot of 1:1 support and then I will provide it though I feel sad for them because as I said before, having a TA sat with them all the time will prevent normal peer friendships from developing. But most pupils by the time they are teenagers don’t want a TA with them all the time on a 1:1 basis so we tend to walk away, help other pupils then return to check they are still working/able to understand the work

woodhill · 12/02/2023 11:41

@TwilightSilhouette

I think that is a good strategy to some extent and obviously you put your EH first

One pupil used to ask me to help the others (this was prior EH)

wellbehavedwomenseldommakehistory · 12/02/2023 10:49

TheSnowyOwl · 12/02/2023 10:35

At my children’s school a TA is just that. A 1:1 is a 1:1 and they are completely different roles with different expectations. Children with a 1:1 can still play with others, depending upon their EHCP, as some have them for differing reasons and did some children, having a 1:1 is the difference between them attending mainstream school or not (and usually mainstream school is the better option for them).

You're right. A 1:1 is a specific role. In our area they're still called TAs although some schools differentiate between TAs and LSAs (with TAs being classroom assistants and LSAs being 1:1s). My child's is called a '1:1 TA' and they also have in the school 'class TAs' (though not many, and those they do have actually end up being used as 1:1s for those children who do not have EHCP provision to fund their own).

A good 1:1 TA will support the child, if they're able, to play/interact/socialise/participate. Not being stuck to them like glue, perhaps setting up a game at break, then stepping back and observing. They can oil the wheels to help with these sorts of interactions. They might do small group work if it's within the EHCP. My child has full time 1:1 but also provision for weekly work with up for four others, plus social skills building activities with 1 or 2 other children at a time. They also spend time doing interventions 1:1 in a quiet space which help to teach and improve social skills.

A 1:1 TA does not, and should not mean that the child is isolated and not able to interact with the other children or participate in class. If a child does need this level of support because they really cannot cope with any interaction with other children (and some do) then I would be questioning if mainstream education, or that environment, is the best place for them. Unfortunately with the lack of special school places it is not easy to access them!

TheSnowyOwl · 12/02/2023 10:35

At my children’s school a TA is just that. A 1:1 is a 1:1 and they are completely different roles with different expectations. Children with a 1:1 can still play with others, depending upon their EHCP, as some have them for differing reasons and did some children, having a 1:1 is the difference between them attending mainstream school or not (and usually mainstream school is the better option for them).

JustKeepBuilding · 12/02/2023 10:29

@wellbehavedwomenseldommakehistory I completely agree, that’s why I said parents should be supported to. There are many parents who, for a multitude of complex reasons, can’t or don’t feel able to advocate themselves or advocate alone &/or can’t or don’t feel able to access support services. But for the majority of those parents the right support can overcome the barriers. That’s not to say it’s easy or the first kind of support is the right one for that particular family. Or that they do actually receive that support (but they should).

There are services that can hand hand all the way through the process for free where needed. I work for a local independent charity (truly independent, not like SENDIASS who is in the LA’s pocket) that supports parents of disabled children, not just focused on EHCPs but it forms a large part of the caseload. I, and other colleagues, when needed, basically undertake the whole process. I know there are other charities in other LAs who do similar.

If people can’t afford to access IPSEA training they often have free or vastly reduced prices for those unable to afford it.

JustKeepBuilding · 12/02/2023 10:27

Twiglets1 · 12/02/2023 10:12

By secondary age, very few SEN pupils in a mainsteam school like the one I work in want "their" TA hanging around them constantly singling them out as different. TAs have to be very sensitive to this or the pupil could and sometimes does reject TA support entirely. That is why we help other pupils also, to make it appear that we are more like general classroom support whereas in fact we are keeping a close eye on the child we are there to support.

If you genuinely think that is the main reason why 1:1s are used to support others that is a very naive view. The biggest reason by far 1:1s are used to help others is for the benefit of others/the school, not because it is in the best interests of the child with full time 1:1 specified and quantified in F.

Twiglets1 · 12/02/2023 10:12

JustKeepBuilding · 10/02/2023 14:33

If a pupil has full time 1:1 specified and quantified in their EHCP they have that for a very good reason, the 1:1 should not be helping other pupils. It is not for the school or TA to decide 1:1 isn’t necessary. Any school which uses the 1:1 for other things leaves the school and LA open to legal proceedings.

By secondary age, very few SEN pupils in a mainsteam school like the one I work in want "their" TA hanging around them constantly singling them out as different. TAs have to be very sensitive to this or the pupil could and sometimes does reject TA support entirely. That is why we help other pupils also, to make it appear that we are more like general classroom support whereas in fact we are keeping a close eye on the child we are there to support.

MidgeHardcastle · 12/02/2023 10:11

A TA should be directed by the teacher. Unfortunately some 1-to-1s have no training and/or are left to their own devices. Any problems should be brought to the teacher's attention first.

wellbehavedwomenseldommakehistory · 12/02/2023 10:02

MissingMoominMamma · 12/02/2023 09:56

There’s a TA in my school who does the work for the children. I’ve spoken to her about it because this is really irresponsible. How can a child with LD be adequately supported and protected when they are older if their intellect has been fabricated by someone who wants to appear a better teacher than they are?

Yeah that's just silly, and does the child no favours.

Twiglets1 · 12/02/2023 10:02

Dancedanceswim · 10/02/2023 10:15

I should clarify that I’m both a TA myself and a mum of a (now adult) ASD child. I’m in now way against TA’s in general. This is specific to one child (mild ASD/ what would have been called Aspergers) I know of where I think that, in that case, him having a 1-1 TA is an error:

  • firstly, having a TA means that the whole experience at primary school is very “managed” and a bit sterile which may make it much harder for him to cope at secondary
  • This is an unpopular opinion but school really isn’t all about learning - the social aspect is vital. Therefore, if a child is sat with a TA all the time they won’t be able to freely socialise with their peers or enjoy any kind of childish behaviour without being constantly managed and having someone watching them
  • They’re already self conscious about being different- surely sitting a TA next to them will only make them feel more different to their peers. Also, it will signal to the other kids that they are different and potentially make them a target for bullying/ socially being ostracised
  • This child is actually very bright and there are many other kids in the class who could use 1-1 help in terms of improving their progress with work.

The reason they have a TA is because their parents absolutely fought tooth and nail. However, in my opinion I’m not sure it’s actually benefiting this child and this is perhaps a theme throughout.

This is about one child but I think in more general terms that while TA’s can be a valuable asset in the classroom and for some children can be brilliant, they’re not always beneficial. Aibu?

I'm a TA too in a large secondary school and I agree with you - TAs aren't ALWAYS beneficial (though they often are, of course).

I often feel sorry for the children who are so vulnerable they have to have a TA glued to them at all times. Even in PE lessons, even walking between lessons and at break time. They are never unsupervised and this makes it very hard for them to make friends with their peers. They become dependent on the TA for help with lessons but also socially to get through the day.

A big current issue is too many extremely vulnerable children in mainstream schools. But that's another debate.

Skiphopbump · 12/02/2023 09:58

My child had a 1-1 in primary. She was amazing as she knew exactly when to step in and when to hang back. The other students in the class used to like sitting near my DS as they knew the TA would also help them if needed.
I always knew she was great but until DS reached secondary I didn’t realise how exceptional she was.

Having a 1-1 at secondary didn’t work out. DS had 2 or 3 over the course of a week. None of them were intuitive so couldn’t read the signs of when to help/stand back. A couple decided that there were others that needed more help so would help them rather than DS, DS was the only child in the class with funding/EHCP. DS was quiet and a couple of others were disruptive so got support over DS. It left DS feeling unsupported. The SENCO even sent me an email stating that the one of the TAs wasn’t happy that DS didn’t want her support and there were better uses of her time - she hadn’t built a rapport with DS, often was helping others when he needed help so he ended up pushing back.

Some TAs are amazing but a poor TA can do more damage than good.

wellbehavedwomenseldommakehistory · 12/02/2023 09:58

I'm not disagreeing with you in any way @JustKeepBuilding. It's great that you help families free of charge (I do too). There are resources available, the information on the IPSEA website is brilliant (as is their training if people can afford to access it).

I just know, from what I do, that there are an awful lot of parents who can't access them. Or maybe they could, but they don't even know they exist. I meet parents who have disabilities themselves, who are so overwhelmed by their lives and caring for their child/children with SEND themselves, who maybe also have their own learning difficulty or disability. None of these parents would have the first clue about how to access these spaces. It's not uncommon. They might not have a laptop or tablet, or be very computer literate, or be able to fill out the paperwork properly (especially an EHCNA!). They don't know what their children's rights are or where to access help that they're not automatically excluded from because they can't afford it.

I try my best to empower them with some knowledge and confidence, show them where to go and what to do but often what these individuals need is someone to handhold them through the entire process or more often, in all honesty, for someone to do it all for them. Without paying, you're hard pushed to find someone that will do that especially on a larger scale.

So it continues. The children (like my own, i have no problem in admitting it and perhaps this is why I give my time for free to help other families, because the unfairness rankles) who have parents who are qualified, educated, confident, with time to dedicate to advocating for their child, computer literate and able to afford things like independent assessments when the local authority is crap etc etc etc will generally receive better levels of support. My child's needs are met in school because I have (as the OP describes) fought tooth and nail for them to be. There are children in their class who most definitely need similar levels of support but do not have it. I know the parents fairly well, and I make an educated guess as to why this is.

What should happen is needs are identified and families should not need specialised knowledge, help and support because 'the system' should take care of it all in a fair and proper way. The system does not. But we are where we are and we do what we can, I suppose.

MissingMoominMamma · 12/02/2023 09:56

There’s a TA in my school who does the work for the children. I’ve spoken to her about it because this is really irresponsible. How can a child with LD be adequately supported and protected when they are older if their intellect has been fabricated by someone who wants to appear a better teacher than they are?

wellbehavedwomenseldommakehistory · 12/02/2023 09:42

I'd be really interested for this thread to be moved to The Staffroom. I wonder what teachers/school staffs views on it are?

@MNHQ is that possible?

JustKeepBuilding · 11/02/2023 21:55

I agree that it should be a fairer system, however that’s not going to change any time soon, so all parents should be supported to enforce their DC’s rights within the system as it is.

There is support for parents who can’t afford expert advice and independent reports. For example, Parents in Need can sometimes help fund assessments, and if eligible legal aid can (although that’s a separate system with its own problems). IPSEA sometimes have case workers who can support through tribunal and they offer free or reduced price courses to those on low incomes. Even online there are parents who will support other parents through the process. The SN and SEN boards on here are helpful. I have written correspondence and completed forms for posters on here. I have helped parents secure gold plated EHCPs where they haven’t spent a penny. No it’s not easy, but it is possible.

Busybody2022 · 11/02/2023 21:44

My DD's EHCP to properly meet her needs
£2300 Ed Psych
£735 SALT
£580 OT

Everything the LA wrote was awful. I also paid whatever the rate was to do all 3 levels of IPSEA training.

My DS so far has cost

£580 OT
£735 SALT
£2250 independent ASD assessment

I haven't taken on the EP yet but that will inevitably need doing.

This was all just to get properly written reports. Before I sorted DD's she was in school 90 minutes a day as school had no idea what to do with her, only specialist who would take her was a behavioural as her EHCP was a long list of behaviours when her needs weren't met. Now her ehcp has been rewritten she is thriving in mainstream with full 1-1 support provided by 2 members of staff.

My DS has a severe speech disorder and a speech level of a 4 year old (he's 6). He did have in his original plan 6 sessions per term of SALT. Out of 24 he received 8, the LA told me it was "regrettable" and he's made some progress despite this. I sent them a long complaint of what is regrettable. They then tried to remove his SALT provision entirely because they didnt want to offer it anymore. I had to pay to get an independent report to stand a chance of arguing against it.

I'd do it every single time but it is disgustingly unfair that because I can afford around 7k so far my kids get the support they need.

I'm already saving for DD's transition to secondary as she won't survive in mainstream at that point.

wellbehavedwomenseldommakehistory · 11/02/2023 21:12

hiredandsqueak · 11/02/2023 19:19

As @JustKeepBuilding says SOSSEN charge roughly half of what a solicitor would charge for pre action protocol letters (£145) I have used them and always got the desired result. I then pursue the formal complaint to get the LA to refund my costs. Last time I didn't even need to pursue to LGO they refunded me at first asking after a FOI I put in showed they met legal timescales on fewer than 34% of transition EHCPs. Not sure they wanted that fact publicising.

SOSSEN are great, they do a wonderful job. Sadly lots of parents can't afford them though.

It should be a level playing field. Parents shouldn't need to have expertise in SEN law, or be able to afford independent assessments or to pay for legal advice just so their child can have their needs met. Sadly, they seem to. SOSSEN are overwhelmed. Local DIASS services (free) are overwhelmed.

I agree with the PP. The system is broken.

hiredandsqueak · 11/02/2023 19:19

As @JustKeepBuilding says SOSSEN charge roughly half of what a solicitor would charge for pre action protocol letters (£145) I have used them and always got the desired result. I then pursue the formal complaint to get the LA to refund my costs. Last time I didn't even need to pursue to LGO they refunded me at first asking after a FOI I put in showed they met legal timescales on fewer than 34% of transition EHCPs. Not sure they wanted that fact publicising.

GetTheBehind · 11/02/2023 19:16

Sorry...I mean yabu to say that TAs are generally providing 1:1 support. IME that isn't the case

GetTheBehind · 11/02/2023 19:14

I used to be an LSA in a secondary school and was mainly a 1:1. I was also a TA in primary and we had separate 1:1 workers for the children who needed it.

So, I think yabu, however, I do think that some of the 1:1 work in primary can end up being a bit counterproductive if the child relies heavily on one person for their emotional needs. I saw this in the primary I worked in and did wonder how the child would get on in secondary. The child's EHCP hadn't even come through halfway through year 6 but they had intensive support every day from a dedicated LSA in school. I think there are huge issues with the system in place to support children with SEN and that transition between primary and secondary can be very difficult.

Sirzy · 11/02/2023 19:07

The move from statements to EHCPs was supposed to make it fairer, easier to navigate and specify needs etc. Seems to have had the opposite effect though.

JustKeepBuilding · 11/02/2023 18:17

It's wholly unfair

It certainly is. Especially when DC whose parents know the system and can advocate for them get better support than those whose parents, for a myriad of reasons, can’t or don’t. Arguably it’s those DC who need the system’s support more.

SOSSEN are reasonably priced for pre-action letters, but the problem is they are inundated.

The whole system is broken. I don’t see how it will ever recover.

Swipe left for the next trending thread