Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think a TA is not always beneficial

136 replies

Dancedanceswim · 10/02/2023 10:15

I should clarify that I’m both a TA myself and a mum of a (now adult) ASD child. I’m in now way against TA’s in general. This is specific to one child (mild ASD/ what would have been called Aspergers) I know of where I think that, in that case, him having a 1-1 TA is an error:

  • firstly, having a TA means that the whole experience at primary school is very “managed” and a bit sterile which may make it much harder for him to cope at secondary
  • This is an unpopular opinion but school really isn’t all about learning - the social aspect is vital. Therefore, if a child is sat with a TA all the time they won’t be able to freely socialise with their peers or enjoy any kind of childish behaviour without being constantly managed and having someone watching them
  • They’re already self conscious about being different- surely sitting a TA next to them will only make them feel more different to their peers. Also, it will signal to the other kids that they are different and potentially make them a target for bullying/ socially being ostracised
  • This child is actually very bright and there are many other kids in the class who could use 1-1 help in terms of improving their progress with work.

The reason they have a TA is because their parents absolutely fought tooth and nail. However, in my opinion I’m not sure it’s actually benefiting this child and this is perhaps a theme throughout.

This is about one child but I think in more general terms that while TA’s can be a valuable asset in the classroom and for some children can be brilliant, they’re not always beneficial. Aibu?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
leafittome · 12/02/2023 18:33

Well the parents (who know the child best) think the child benefits from it AND the LA will very likely have had professionals (an Ed Psych) recommend it in order for the funding to have been awarded/have it stipulated in the EHCP.... So I'm more inclined to think the child does benefit from it regardless of your opinion on the subject.
Personally my children may take longer to be independent because of their 1:1 support and i'm fine with that. They were miserable and stressed without 1:1 support so not in a place to develop independence then anyway. Ideally they will access a specialist provision where 1:1 isn't necessary but that isn't forthcoming at the moment. A good 1:1 helps build independence when they are ready anyway 🤷‍♀️

hiredandsqueak · 12/02/2023 18:17

@Skiphopbump yes both mine did as well. Out of County independent specialist with hefty fees and travel costs. The failure though to meet the EHCP whilst in maintained provision did an awful lot of harm to both of them.

JustKeepBuilding · 12/02/2023 18:16

@Spendonsend 1:2 is sometimes in EHCPs. It’s not as common. Although I think that is potentially less to do with the frequency it’s required and more to do with parents whose DC need 1:1 are more likely to pursue the provision through SENDIST when the LA refuses to include it. Also, rather than 1:2 the woolly “small group” phrasing is often used.

ExistenceOptional · 12/02/2023 18:15

@FatGirlSwim That is an exceptionally skilled TA. TAs are not well paid and do not need to be exceptional for the post.

JustAnotherManicNameChange · 12/02/2023 18:06

woodhill · 12/02/2023 17:45

Yes I take your point but couldn't a non Eh Dc do the same thing

That's irrelevant really.

The fact that you mentioned it, once again shows why the ECHP must be a legal document that can be followed. Theoretically it should avoid "judgement calls", "what ifs" , " what abouts" and so on that can be very detrimental to children (academically,physically,mentally and emotionally) but some schools/LA's/staff still try to work around it.

Spendonsend · 12/02/2023 18:06

I was just thinking i have seen children who need 1:2 really, in that their needs can be balanced with another childs - but you never see that as a provision. I guess it depends on the other childrdn around. You couldnt give a child a legal document that depended on a complimentary child just happening to be there. You do see 1:1 for specific bits of the day so 1 TA can teselate a couple of children.

FatGirlSwim · 12/02/2023 18:01

The TA should be promoting their social development.

If they need a TA in primary they may also need one in secondary. Part of the job of the TA is to help prepare for transition and build the independence skills that the child otherwise might not develop.

The fact that other children are in need and don’t have a TA is not the fault of the child with ALN or their parents. It is wrong, but doesn’t negate the need of the child who does have one.

If the TA is sitting next to the child and isolating them, they’re not doing a very good job! My child’s TA was so subtle that nobody in the class other than my child knew who the TA was there for.

JustKeepBuilding · 12/02/2023 17:59

A pupil with full time 1:1 specified and quantified in F needs full time 1:1 otherwise it wouldn’t be in their EHCP.

Other pupils needing support isn’t relevant to whether the pupil with 1:1 in their EHCP should receive 1:1 or not. If those other pupils don’t have EHCPs the school/parents should apply rather than the school failing to provide provision in EHCPs.

Skiphopbump · 12/02/2023 17:57

hiredandsqueak · 12/02/2023 15:53

My experience is that it's a fight to secure provison and then once secured your child gets to school and meets up with TAs, class teachers and SENCos who neither respect nor adhere to the specified provision in the EHCP and use the child's resources to prop up shortfalls in teaching and support within the class and school. The effect being that the placement breaks down and parents look to independent specialist schools to make the provison their child needs instead thus costing LA's significantly more instead.

You’ve described the situation I ended up in. DS is now in independent specialist provision with a hefty taxi bill (school is 40 miles away).

Busybody2022 · 12/02/2023 17:52

woodhill · 12/02/2023 17:28

Surely it's a totally different scenario not to give the elderly person meds

Child A's learning wouldn't suffer if you went to assist another dc for 5 mins.

Have you not seen how situations can develop? Children can go from fine to throwing tables in less than a minute.

Busybody2022 · 12/02/2023 17:50

My DD has zero friendships or social skills because of her autism. Her 1-1 helps her navigate socially so she has a fighting chance.

A properly written EHCP will detail the support for a child who doesn't want a TA sat next to them to provide the support in a way that meets their needs.

Teachers and TAs are teachers and TAs. They are not psychologists, they are not speech and language therapists, they are not autism experts, they are not OTs, they are not physios. It's laughable to suggest teachers and TAs have more expertise than actual specialists. It is absolutely not up to a teacher nor TA to decide these specialists are not the experts. The training teachers and TAs receive is shameful and a big part of the issue parents face is teachers who think they know best and dismissing actual specialist input.

woodhill · 12/02/2023 17:45

Yes I take your point but couldn't a non Eh Dc do the same thing

JustAnotherManicNameChange · 12/02/2023 17:41

@woodhill it's not different at all. That's exactly why it's a legal document . And it's because of people who don't understand that that it has been made enforceable by law.

Depending on the situation, leaving a child unattended for 5 minutes, would definitely affect their education (or at least that lesson) , it could endanger themselves or their peers, it could disrupt everyone's learning for that lesson. Hell, even the whole school's like that one time when one child ran off and triggered the fire alarm so everyone had to evacuate.

I've seen things happen in the split of a second, a 5 whole minutes would've meant a serious incident with significantly fall out.Following the plan keeps everyone safe,including staff.

woodhill · 12/02/2023 17:28

JustAnotherManicNameChange · 12/02/2023 12:38

@woodhill not at all. The EHCP is based on the child's needs . While a case can be made about a specific thing mentioned that is no longer needed/applicable (toileting needs or getting changed for example that can sometimes change before the document is reviews) we can't just pick and choose .

Imagine an elderly person with a specific care plan and medication, and one of the carers deciding they don't need the meds, or they change them or whatever with no review,no proof, no other medical professionals involved. Would you think that having to stick to a plan is undermining their experience?

There's a reason children get an EHCP. It is for their safety,the safety or staff and peers and to enable them to actually access education. It is a lengthy and difficult process , they don't just get handed out willy nilly or for spurious reasons.

Surely it's a totally different scenario not to give the elderly person meds

Child A's learning wouldn't suffer if you went to assist another dc for 5 mins.

hiredandsqueak · 12/02/2023 15:53

My experience is that it's a fight to secure provison and then once secured your child gets to school and meets up with TAs, class teachers and SENCos who neither respect nor adhere to the specified provision in the EHCP and use the child's resources to prop up shortfalls in teaching and support within the class and school. The effect being that the placement breaks down and parents look to independent specialist schools to make the provison their child needs instead thus costing LA's significantly more instead.

ExistenceOptional · 12/02/2023 15:44

GrimDamnFanjo · 12/02/2023 13:00

Interestingly we discussed this at our Governing Body.
The research presented agreed with the OPs perspective.

I have read adults who had a 1-1 TA as children complain it did them a disservice.

JustKeepBuilding · 12/02/2023 13:01

Your post would be laughable if it wasn’t so far from the truth.

I’m not a solicitor and have never made money out of individual cases. Over the years I have helped hundreds of people on MN and IRL secure provision for their DC and then enforce said provision if it isn’t provided completely free of charge.

Last year I started working very part time for a local charity supporting parents with disabled children after they approached me. I don’t make any money from individual cases, many of whom pay nothing for the support they receive.

It’s not argumentative or a superiority complex to want provision that must legally be provided to actually be provided and enforce it if it isn’t. Unfortunately parents who know the system, advocate and enforce DC’s rights get better support.

Please quote where I posted what is written in the EHCP is more important than “being empathetic and treating each child like an individual”? It doesn’t have to be one or the other, and EHCPs do treat each child as an individual. No 2 are the same as every child’s needs are different.

Can you also please also quote where I posted you could force a pupil to accept help? Or that providing support they are legally entitled to and the pupil liking you can’t both happen at the same time. If a pupil can’t engage with the SEP the EHCP isn’t meeting their needs and there should be an early review so the EHCP and SEP within it needs can be amended and adapted so it does meet their needs and they reach a point where they can engage. It isn’t for the TAs, schools or LAs to just decide not to provide SEP within legally binding EHCPs.

GrimDamnFanjo · 12/02/2023 13:00

Interestingly we discussed this at our Governing Body.
The research presented agreed with the OPs perspective.

Twiglets1 · 12/02/2023 12:44

JustKeepBuilding · 12/02/2023 12:31

No it’s not. It’s acknowledging the EHCP is a legal document that must be adhered to. It’s not optional. The SEP within it stems from assessments from professionals far more qualified to make decisions on what SEP is necessary. LAs and schools wouldn’t be able to successfully defend a disability discrimination case or JR on the basis teachers and TAs thought they had the expertise to decide whether SEP specified and quantified in F needed to be provided.

You sound so up yourself honestly. You wouldn’t make a good TA because you’re argumentative and have a superiority complex. You think what’s written down in a document is more important than being empathetic and treating each child like an individual who may or may not want a TA sitting next to them. Guess what? You can’t force a child to accept help from a TA no matter what is written on their EHCP. There are ways of getting them to like you and accept your help but forcing it is not one of them.
You sound like some kind of solicitor or similar. Making money from picking apart teachers and TAs. Pointless to debate any further as you’re just ticking boxes to see if you can win a case that will take even more money out of a broken system.

JustAnotherManicNameChange · 12/02/2023 12:38

@woodhill not at all. The EHCP is based on the child's needs . While a case can be made about a specific thing mentioned that is no longer needed/applicable (toileting needs or getting changed for example that can sometimes change before the document is reviews) we can't just pick and choose .

Imagine an elderly person with a specific care plan and medication, and one of the carers deciding they don't need the meds, or they change them or whatever with no review,no proof, no other medical professionals involved. Would you think that having to stick to a plan is undermining their experience?

There's a reason children get an EHCP. It is for their safety,the safety or staff and peers and to enable them to actually access education. It is a lengthy and difficult process , they don't just get handed out willy nilly or for spurious reasons.

JustKeepBuilding · 12/02/2023 12:35

Not providing the SEP specified and quantified in F is ignoring it. It is ignoring the fact it must be provided.

woodhill · 12/02/2023 12:32

I don't think educators ignore it but they are not working in an ideal world

JustKeepBuilding · 12/02/2023 12:31

woodhill · 12/02/2023 12:21

Isn't that diminishing of the expertise of the teacher and TAs though

No it’s not. It’s acknowledging the EHCP is a legal document that must be adhered to. It’s not optional. The SEP within it stems from assessments from professionals far more qualified to make decisions on what SEP is necessary. LAs and schools wouldn’t be able to successfully defend a disability discrimination case or JR on the basis teachers and TAs thought they had the expertise to decide whether SEP specified and quantified in F needed to be provided.

JustKeepBuilding · 12/02/2023 12:28

All my posts are realistic. Just because you think it is acceptable to act unlawfully doesn’t make my posts unrealistic.

What part of my post acknowledging for some DC their SEN will prevent or hinder “normal peer friendships from developing” regardless or whether 1:1 is provided or or not is unrealistic?

I am perfectly aware of what goes on in classrooms. I’m am also perfectly aware an EHCP is a legal document and the SEP within it must be provided. I have helped hundreds of parents enforce their DC’s EHCP where schools and TAs like you think they can ignore the DC’s EHCP.

Many LAs, schools and staff, including TAs, act unlawfully, that doesn’t excuse it. Good luck defending a disability discrimination case or JR on the basis you think the SEP specified and quantified doesn’t need to be provided.

woodhill · 12/02/2023 12:21

JustKeepBuilding · 12/02/2023 11:55

But that’s the problem. It’s not for you or the school to decide to “behave the way I think is most beneficial for the children in the room, especially the ones with SEN.”

An EHCP is a legal document. If full time 1:1 is specified and quantified in an EHCP it must be provided. To not provide it is unlawful and leaves the school and LA open to legal proceedings. It’s not for you or the school to decide differently.

A good 1:1, trained well and deployed correctly does not need to “prevent normal peer friendships from developing.”

Isn't that diminishing of the expertise of the teacher and TAs though