Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think by now non-commercial platforms for buying and selling goods and keeping in touch should have been developed?

97 replies

unsureatthispoint · 10/02/2023 09:57

Inspired by a few current threads

I'm not a big user of social media (as in FB or IG), just mainly to be reminded about events I may want to attend or buy second-hand items occassionally

But I've noticed for instance the frustration with IG about how they now push posts by users you don't follow - making the platform annoying and time wasting (plus the known change to non-cronological algorithms)

Other tools started as 'friendly' buy/sell virtual spaces but quickly have gone all dictatorial, blocking accounts for no reason or deleting someone's good ratings if not enough sales are made regularly (hence being heavily geared to big businesses that can drive commissions whilst small businesses are punished)

And don't get me started with the latests trend to require uploads of IDs and biometrics to global sites with users having no control whatsoever where such sensitive data is going!

Aren't IT people familiar with the technology already? Couldn't we develop non-commercial platforms that would enable all this genuine, much needed, community activity without all the aggravation and grief? No ads, no moderation, no commissions, no frills, run by volunteers?

Forums like MN and the big players would continue to exist, and are a different 'beast' IMO

The novelty of the early days has pretty much warn off already, right? Isn't it time we went back to basics?

OP posts:
WandaWonder · 10/02/2023 11:26

I presume if it was going to happen it would have by now?

My knowledge is not the best but i amongst others have or could one up with lots of reasons why it has assumed it hasn't

If you can't actually notcto do the technical side yourself you could arrange the volunteers etc. side yourself

Sure people come with lots of discussion topics and ideas thatctjry can't do the practical side themselves you do seem very incredibly intense about it

So I assume you have the people to back it all up seeing you have so much deep thought about it?

Allp · 10/02/2023 11:21

I don't think anyone is angry, but anyone who has worked in development has heard this pitch or ones like it a lot, asking why can't you recreate a major platform on no budget.

Running a donations based website is hard, mastodon instances are having a boom in donations right now, because of everyone riding the twitter wave, will they still have that in a year or even 6 months?
People get pissy when there Netflix goes up a couple of quid, its an entire website with a shit tonne of content on and yet people will still ditch it during increases. The amount of people who will regularly donate to a website or app for years and years is slim and you'd want to pivot towards adverts and affiliate links (like mumsnet) to keep income more steady so you know you can pay your costs, developers etc relying on donations means one day the website will go poof when you can't afford the ongoing costs.

Not promoting people to follow each other sucks on a social type network, you want to grow the circles, otherwise people sign up and leave after a couple of minutes/days/weeks
how do people find accounts they're interested in, you need that ooh you like x, y what about z to keep the platform alive with users interested in coming back, so so so often apps and websites die from lack of users or small amount.

If you're convinced though pitch it on reddit, LinkedIn etc and see if you can drum up volunteers, we might be wrong on here. But honestly the best bet is to use the tools on offer, for Instagram add favourites and use the bell, join local fb groups and use the pin function.

BertieBotts · 10/02/2023 11:20

The problem is that for something like this to work you need people to use it. People don't want to change from something that already works (even if imperfectly) and jump to a new platform where none of their friends are. Even if it's better, what's the point if nobody is there?

Big commercial companies can afford to spend a lot on marketing and advertising to make their platform interesting to potential users. A free one wouldn't have that.

I'm not angry but I think you are very naive in thinking it could compete with big commercial organisations.

unsureatthispoint · 10/02/2023 11:08

NoSquirrels · 10/02/2023 11:04

Like Wikipedia?

Have a look at what they cost to run:
donate.wikimedia.org/wiki/FAQ#How_is_the_Wikimedia_Foundation_funded?

It's still alive and kicking though

OP posts:
unsureatthispoint · 10/02/2023 11:08

The majority of ‘country fair’ type events in my area use Facebook to promote them as it’s free and has a massive reach. You can share posts in the groups for surrounding villages/towns to spread the message further. Local village Facebook groups probably have one if the widest total reaches of any online platform

Probably I need to explore this more

The thing is, maybe you are interested in an event in your local country fair or one in Italy. They are not mutually exclusive. It's handy to have a platform that includes everything and where, through 'following', you can control what you see. It shouldn't be this difficult

OP posts:
AffIt · 10/02/2023 11:08

@unsureatthispoint

Yes, there's always the risk of that. Maybe users should look at the track record or background of the founders? Their aims, etc?

Again, who is paying for this and how? Due diligence costs money in time, fees to access certain records etc.

With the best will in the world, I cannot see the sort of people with the skills required giving up tens, if not hundreds, of hours in time for free or dipping into their own pockets.

I see your point OP, and I get the principle, but as a PP said, good luck dissembling capitalism.

unsureatthispoint · 10/02/2023 11:04

If you have a site that has zero moderation you’ll likely end up with even more spam in your feed as people will post all sorts of irrelevant dross.

You wouldn't be spammed because you would only see posts from users you follow

Being banned unjustly does happen sometimes but if you’re livelihood depends on selling via Facebook or vinted, that’s the risk you take.

Some sellers cannot afford the high commisions of payment methods of other sites. There should be a marketplace for small sellers that do not want to abide by the draconian, everchanging rules of big platforms. Large platforms don't even want them there in the first place these days, they seem to have become a nuisance. Sad but true

OP posts:
NoSquirrels · 10/02/2023 11:04

Like Wikipedia?

Have a look at what they cost to run:
donate.wikimedia.org/wiki/FAQ#How_is_the_Wikimedia_Foundation_funded?

unsureatthispoint · 10/02/2023 11:01

NoSquirrels · 10/02/2023 10:57

So, the small businesses pay a subscription to be able to use the platform to buy/sell?

Remind me again how it’s not monetised to participate?

Look at it like a donation so that a free site can exist?

OP posts:
unsureatthispoint · 10/02/2023 11:00

So, the small businesses pay a subscription to be able to use the platform to buy/sell?

It wouldn't be a condition for selling (and there wouldn't be any profit). Just supporting the site

OP posts:
NoSquirrels · 10/02/2023 10:57

unsureatthispoint · 10/02/2023 10:54

Because you don’t have a common cause/specific aim in mind? What will unite these volunteers? Who will fund this (most NGOs and charities get subsidies/grants)?

Perhaps volunteers together with small businesses that have become disgruntled and have been pushed out of these giant platforms? A cooperative? Like Rotary? It could work

So, the small businesses pay a subscription to be able to use the platform to buy/sell?

Remind me again how it’s not monetised to participate?

MindatWork · 10/02/2023 10:55

Your two main issues seem to be having your account blocked on selling sites, spam and missing out on events.

If you have a site that has zero moderation you’ll likely end up with even more spam in your feed as people will post all sorts of irrelevant dross. Being banned unjustly does happen sometimes but if you’re livelihood depends on selling via Facebook or vinted, that’s the risk you take.

Honestly Facebook/Nextdoor do all the things you’re after. I’ve sold/given away/bought tons of stuff on there, both from marketplace and selling groups. Yes you get messed around a bit sometimes but I guarantee that would be worse on a site with no moderation or checks.

IG isnt an event marketing platform. The majority of ‘country fair’ type events in my area use Facebook to promote them as it’s free and has a massive reach. You can share posts in the groups for surrounding villages/towns to spread the message further. Local village Facebook groups probably have one if the widest total reaches of any online platform, but the ‘spam’ in your feed is the price you pay for all of those services.

It would take so long to build up an audience on a new site or app, people wouldn’t bother posting. If you’re promoting a local event or selling something, you want it to get in front of the biggest possible audience.

unsureatthispoint · 10/02/2023 10:54

Because you don’t have a common cause/specific aim in mind? What will unite these volunteers? Who will fund this (most NGOs and charities get subsidies/grants)?

Perhaps volunteers together with small businesses that have become disgruntled and have been pushed out of these giant platforms? A cooperative? Like Rotary? It could work

OP posts:
NoSquirrels · 10/02/2023 10:49

unsureatthispoint · 10/02/2023 10:46

But again, there are many charities and NGOs operating in our capitalist society (I'm not opposed to capitalism BTW), why couldn't this be one of those endeavours?

Because you don’t have a common cause/specific aim in mind? What will unite these volunteers? Who will fund this (most NGOs and charities get subsidies/grants)?

As a PP says, Mastodon is an option for you.

unsureatthispoint · 10/02/2023 10:47

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 10/02/2023 10:45

You do know you can search for specific pages right? If you want to know when your local fair is, or what similar events are on nearby, you can just look it up or ask even ask someone IRL, you don't need to rely solely on your IG feed for this.

I do, but it's very time consuming

OP posts:
unsureatthispoint · 10/02/2023 10:46

NoSquirrels · 10/02/2023 10:44

I’m not angry! Smile

As you point out, you’re not an IT expert. Herein lies the problem.

Posters are trying to explain why it’s fundamentally a flawed idea, in our capitalist society.

But again, there are many charities and NGOs operating in our capitalist society (I'm not opposed to capitalism BTW), why couldn't this be one of those endeavours?

OP posts:
unsureatthispoint · 10/02/2023 10:45

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 10/02/2023 10:42

What's stopping you, OP?

I've already said I'm no IT guru 🙂

OP posts:
Thebestwaytoscareatory · 10/02/2023 10:45

unsureatthispoint · 10/02/2023 10:25

How am I going to set a reminder in my diary if I don't know when it's happening in the first place? 🤔

Also, there may not be one event, what if there were 15 events I would like to know about?

You do know you can search for specific pages right? If you want to know when your local fair is, or what similar events are on nearby, you can just look it up or ask even ask someone IRL, you don't need to rely solely on your IG feed for this.

NoSquirrels · 10/02/2023 10:44

unsureatthispoint · 10/02/2023 10:42

I'm not an IT expert, otherwise I would absolutely do it myself and stop volunteering on other spaces as I do believe there is a social need for this

It's still a valid discussion. I don't know why everyone is so angry at the mere suggestion

I’m not angry! Smile

As you point out, you’re not an IT expert. Herein lies the problem.

Posters are trying to explain why it’s fundamentally a flawed idea, in our capitalist society.

unsureatthispoint · 10/02/2023 10:43

PeekAtYou · 10/02/2023 10:42

I think if enough people acted, these sites would change or evolve into what people are after. People moan about big sites but they have their strengths like large numbers seeing my "For Sale" post and picking the item up same day with cash.

Yes, that's still good on FB. But I wonder how long it'll last. It's also no good if you get your account blocked for no reason

OP posts:
unsureatthispoint · 10/02/2023 10:42

parietal · 10/02/2023 10:40

have you joined Mastodon? that is free & open & built and maintained by volunteer coders. it largely functions like twitter, but could do the selling / local stuff too.

it has grown massively since Musk took over twitter, but it still doesn't have the weight of users that FB and IG and twitter have. But if we all start using it, it might get there.

I'll look into it, thanks

OP posts:
PeekAtYou · 10/02/2023 10:42

unsureatthispoint · 10/02/2023 10:35

People are not all 'happy to use' these platforms, though. Many are closing FB accounts, complaining about IG algorithms, etc in forums. It's not all fine and dandy

I think if enough people acted, these sites would change or evolve into what people are after. People moan about big sites but they have their strengths like large numbers seeing my "For Sale" post and picking the item up same day with cash.

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 10/02/2023 10:42

What's stopping you, OP?

unsureatthispoint · 10/02/2023 10:42

NoSquirrels · 10/02/2023 10:39

I feel like this is one of those PTA discussions where some parent has a ‘brilliant idea!’ that they want someone else to research, set up, sort out the problems and run, but aren’t interested in doing any of the legwork themselves.

Build it and they will come, OP. So get on that.

I'm not an IT expert, otherwise I would absolutely do it myself and stop volunteering on other spaces as I do believe there is a social need for this

It's still a valid discussion. I don't know why everyone is so angry at the mere suggestion

OP posts:
parietal · 10/02/2023 10:40

have you joined Mastodon? that is free & open & built and maintained by volunteer coders. it largely functions like twitter, but could do the selling / local stuff too.

it has grown massively since Musk took over twitter, but it still doesn't have the weight of users that FB and IG and twitter have. But if we all start using it, it might get there.

Swipe left for the next trending thread