Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think “Don’t cook with wine you wouldn’t drink” is bollocks?

64 replies

WomanStanleyWoman2 · 10/02/2023 09:24

I’ve always thought this, but it came into my head again the other day because I tried a new wine on a whim - and wished I hadn’t 🤢 It was too sweet and had an aftertaste. I thought about pouring it down the sink, but I needed some cooking plonk,
so I just threw a bit into my sauce and hoped for the best. It was fine. I ended up using the rest of it across a couple of different recipes.

Whilst I wouldn’t deliberately buy bad wine, I think there’s quite an important difference between a wine where you’d sit and actively enjoy and savour a glass, and one that you wouldn’t keep for a special occasion, but would add a bit of extra flavour to a sauce (and would do for a quick glass while you were cooking). They’re very different experiences.

I was reading years ago about the launch of New Coke in the USA in the 80s (which, for the youngsters amongst you, failed spectacularly). One of the possible reasons for failure highlighted was that, although it had performed well in taste tests, the experience of drinking a whole bottle or can is very different from sipping a small amount from a sample cup. The theory was the sweeter taste of New Coke was pleasant in a small amount, but too much in a larger quantity.

It makes sense, doesn’t it? Lots of people enjoy drinking gin and tonic or vodka and coke, but far fewer drink neat alcohol. I like salt on my food, but I wouldn’t use a whole cellar-full on one meal. And I think it’s the same with wine - one that doesn’t stand up as a great wine in its own right can still enhance a dish when it’s one of several ingredients.

I also can’t help thinking that the “Don’t cook with wine you wouldn’t drink” and “Always use the best ingredients you can possibly afford” mantras are most commonly used by celebrity chefs who a) earn a lot more than the average person and b) probably have their own branded food and wine range, or a column in the Waitrose or M&S magazine where they’re expected to recommend the wines that make the most profit.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
LadyBird1973 · 03/02/2024 21:50

I'm often seduced by the descriptions on red wine bottles. They invariably taste horrible and I use them for cooking. When I do stumble across a nice red, I wouldn't want to waste it in a sauce.

mumda · 03/02/2024 21:41

@FallopianTubeTrain I am huge fan of Keith's.
Bless him.
He cooked some gross looking food around the world whilst getting drunk and arguing with the camera man.

Every rerun of a clip is wonderful.

HiccupHorrendousHaddock · 10/02/2023 16:21

If it's oxidised, bin it, otherwise yeah, any old plonk will do.

That said, the Jam Shed stuff is disgusting. I wouldn't even cook with it. Positively sickly stuff.

RinklyRomaine · 10/02/2023 16:13

MissHavishamsMouldyOldCake · 10/02/2023 14:25

I always have a bottle of marsala knocking around in the cupboard too. I don't drink it but every so often I get a craving for marsala chicken.

I would just drink the Marsala!

Piglet89 · 10/02/2023 14:32

Ina Garten (the Barefoot Contessa on food network) always says “use something you would drink”. And I’m always like: nonsense.

it doesn’t strike me that she is on her uppers, though!

MissHavishamsMouldyOldCake · 10/02/2023 14:25

I always have a bottle of marsala knocking around in the cupboard too. I don't drink it but every so often I get a craving for marsala chicken.

MissHavishamsMouldyOldCake · 10/02/2023 14:24

LaviniasBigBloomers · 10/02/2023 14:01

The vermouth is a Nigella tip, I do it too as we don't drink white. She suggests Marsala for red, but we do have red in the house.

I use Nigella's vermouth tip too. It lasts for ages.

OneTC · 10/02/2023 14:22

I don't use wine in much cooking but got a few dishes that I use marsala or Madeira for and normally have a bottle of each knocking about. Wouldn't particularly drink either of these but both fantastic in the right dishes

tommika · 10/02/2023 14:14

FallopianTubeTrain · 10/02/2023 09:36

😆 I love watching the old Keith Floyd shows. There's a particularly good one where he cooks something in a French woman's kitchen, she tastes it at the end and goes to town on how bad it is. You just wouldn't get that now. He took it in very good humour.

I love your vibe OP, these should be the things we consider on a Friday morning. Screw work and other boring head space fillers.

Also I agree, supermarket wine for cooking, wine shop wine for drinking.

Classic TV…..

You would never get a chef on TV again who would show their recipie & technique being destroyed throughout

In the above clip it cuts as he translates her description. I’m convinced that I remember him then saying she’s right

My other favourite Floyd moment is this with my mad uncle. The pair of them are made from the same mould
LaviniasBigBloomers · 10/02/2023 14:01

RinklyRomaine · 10/02/2023 11:43

I have a litre of dry vermouth (not the posh stuff!) and the dregs of a cheapo bottle of red in the cupboard at all times for cooking with. I quite like a sweeter red, like the Jam Shed Shiraz, but they are vile in savoury dishes, and a bone dry white which often is too dry for a roast chicken gravy for eg. I certainly wouldn't use a nice Chablis in my dinner. Also love a Barolo and I will never be rich enough to use that in a bolognese.

The vermouth is a Nigella tip, I do it too as we don't drink white. She suggests Marsala for red, but we do have red in the house.

JudgeJ · 10/02/2023 13:47

WomanStanleyWoman2 · 10/02/2023 09:24

I’ve always thought this, but it came into my head again the other day because I tried a new wine on a whim - and wished I hadn’t 🤢 It was too sweet and had an aftertaste. I thought about pouring it down the sink, but I needed some cooking plonk,
so I just threw a bit into my sauce and hoped for the best. It was fine. I ended up using the rest of it across a couple of different recipes.

Whilst I wouldn’t deliberately buy bad wine, I think there’s quite an important difference between a wine where you’d sit and actively enjoy and savour a glass, and one that you wouldn’t keep for a special occasion, but would add a bit of extra flavour to a sauce (and would do for a quick glass while you were cooking). They’re very different experiences.

I was reading years ago about the launch of New Coke in the USA in the 80s (which, for the youngsters amongst you, failed spectacularly). One of the possible reasons for failure highlighted was that, although it had performed well in taste tests, the experience of drinking a whole bottle or can is very different from sipping a small amount from a sample cup. The theory was the sweeter taste of New Coke was pleasant in a small amount, but too much in a larger quantity.

It makes sense, doesn’t it? Lots of people enjoy drinking gin and tonic or vodka and coke, but far fewer drink neat alcohol. I like salt on my food, but I wouldn’t use a whole cellar-full on one meal. And I think it’s the same with wine - one that doesn’t stand up as a great wine in its own right can still enhance a dish when it’s one of several ingredients.

I also can’t help thinking that the “Don’t cook with wine you wouldn’t drink” and “Always use the best ingredients you can possibly afford” mantras are most commonly used by celebrity chefs who a) earn a lot more than the average person and b) probably have their own branded food and wine range, or a column in the Waitrose or M&S magazine where they’re expected to recommend the wines that make the most profit.

When we lived abroad and were fairly flush we brought back a bottle of duty free Remy Napoleon brandy for my parents, they were not big drinkers but usually kept a bottle of brandy in the sideboard. Later in the year my brother dropped in and she had just made the family's Christmas cakes, she told him that she'd used 'that bottle of brandy, to save the Martells for best'. When he took her shopping later he took her down the alcohol section and pointed out Remy, he then told her that a supermarket would probably not stock the Napoleon version as it was too expensive!
Bloody goos cakes though!

JudgeJ · 10/02/2023 13:42

I’m amazed there’s a wine Keith Floyd wouldn’t drink

If my memory serves me well I'm amazed that there was anything Floyd wouldn't drink, not just wine!

LancreWowhawk · 10/02/2023 13:02

I used to subscribe to this. And then one day, I just.... stopped. I have never noticed a difference in the standard of the food I produce.

I am a wine drinker, and I am fairly well informed about it. I am also a very keen cook. I honestly see no reason to use anything other than cheap plonk in my bolognese, it makes absolutely no difference once it has simmered for 2 hours.

I might make an exception wine was the main ingredient and leading flavour, but this is very rarely the case, it's usually in the background.

DialsMavis · 10/02/2023 12:44

I took a really nice bottle of Chablis (I thought) round to a friends for Sunday lunch once and she bunged most of it in the meal... She is wonderful but both her taste and budget are clearly far superior to mine.

Oblomov23 · 10/02/2023 12:31

Grin I too used to love Keith Floyd programmes. Wine

PenCreed · 10/02/2023 12:30

Choconut · 10/02/2023 12:25

I'm not that keen on wine so I just use anything to cook with. Often you don't need a lot so I just buy those mini bottles for a few quid.

I am quite keen on wine, but we buy the mini bottles for cooking as well. Saves me using my decent stuff, and is often actually the amount that I want for eg a risotto anyway!

The wine tasting course I went on also recommended eating an olive if you don't like your white wine as the salt will change your palette of it, and eating something peppery if you don't like your red wine at a party.
I'm taking this bit of guidance to confirm my opinion that those Salt & Pepper Kettle Chips are perfect with a glass of wine. And nicer than olives.

Choconut · 10/02/2023 12:25

I'm not that keen on wine so I just use anything to cook with. Often you don't need a lot so I just buy those mini bottles for a few quid.

SiobhanSharpe · 10/02/2023 12:13

LavenderHillMob · 10/02/2023 11:58

I hear snobbery in the whole don't cook with wine you wouldn't drink. it sounds like a way to put down the peasants.

That said. I know it's sacrilege but I can't bear St Keith of Floyd. We shouldn't be celebrating someone who got drunk and was vile to his camera crew. See Jeremy Clarkson.

My SIL used to work for the Beeb and one of the series she worked on was Keith Floyd in Spain.
The great man would not travel with the crew and insisted on driving his Rolls-Royce to Spain, and then driving it from location to location for the entire series while being reimbursed ££££ for doing so. In addition to his very hefty fees for the programme.
She was not impressed by the man, and that's putting it mildly.

5foot5 · 10/02/2023 12:09

Absolutely. If I need wine in a dish and have no leftovers I always buy the cheapest "house" wine from the supermarket.

It wasn't Jammy Rammy Roo was it? One if the few wines I found undrinkable.
@Iwantmyoldnameback is that Jammy Red Roo or Jam She'd? I fndboth eminently drinkable

SapphireSunday · 10/02/2023 12:08

I always have cheapo bottles knocking around for cooking, nobody has ever complained!

But I love Jammy Red Roo, to drink and in a chilli 🍷

SiobhanSharpe · 10/02/2023 12:02

I read an interesting snippet in an Elizabeth David cookbook aeons ago, she had made a beef bourguignon type casserole and a friend who ate it and asked her for the recipe.
The friend came back a few days later complaining that she (David) hadn't given the correct recipe as her version didn't turn out nearly as well. ED insisted she had given her the full and correct recipe until she remembered she had used half a bottle of leftover wine (something very good like Côte Rotie) while the friend used a cheapo. ED concluded the richer, expensive wine made all the difference...
But I use whatever I have to hand and I've never noticed any difference, especially if it's a casserole type dish.

LavenderHillMob · 10/02/2023 11:58

I hear snobbery in the whole don't cook with wine you wouldn't drink. it sounds like a way to put down the peasants.

That said. I know it's sacrilege but I can't bear St Keith of Floyd. We shouldn't be celebrating someone who got drunk and was vile to his camera crew. See Jeremy Clarkson.

RinklyRomaine · 10/02/2023 11:43

I have a litre of dry vermouth (not the posh stuff!) and the dregs of a cheapo bottle of red in the cupboard at all times for cooking with. I quite like a sweeter red, like the Jam Shed Shiraz, but they are vile in savoury dishes, and a bone dry white which often is too dry for a roast chicken gravy for eg. I certainly wouldn't use a nice Chablis in my dinner. Also love a Barolo and I will never be rich enough to use that in a bolognese.

gingercat02 · 10/02/2023 10:50

I buy a 3l box of red and white wine for cooking. Cheapest own brand supermarket "house" wine. It's fine for cooking and keeps for ages

Oysterbabe · 10/02/2023 10:49

Yanbu.
I'll fling any old wine in a bolognaise and it will be delicious. Anyone who says they can taste it was made with cheap wine are talking shite.