Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Request a full refund

63 replies

Adventureoflife · 10/02/2023 07:52

bit of a silly one but would like to know if I’m being unreasonable here requesting a full refund for a relatively expensive gift.

I ordered a friend a gift for her baby shower last weekend. Bought it from a website simply because they offered ‘next day delivery if ordered before 1pm’ for &6.95. It was 12:57pm at the time on the Thursday afternoon so didn’t think it’d be a problem as the shower wasn’t until Sunday.

Gift didn’t arrive until Tuesday afternoon. I ended up going shopping on Sunday before the shower to buy something else instead.

AIBU to expect the seller to give me a full refund? They’re expecting me to cover the cost of the return.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Greblegable · 14/02/2023 09:24

I think the 1pm thing goes out the window anyway because the item arrived on Tuesday. If it arrived Saturday or Monday she’d have an argument but it didn’t so she doesn’t.

Glitteratitar · 14/02/2023 09:17

Tell the seller you are cancelling the contract returning in accordance with the consumer contract regulations and you should be refunded the delivery cost.

Refund cost is on you though.

I agree that a 1pm cut off should be 1pm, but it was a gamble ordering at 12.57pm. Yes it’s on them but it was very close to the wire and I’ve been in a similar situation with John Lewis where they couldn’t deliver for the same reason.

Adventureoflife · 14/02/2023 09:12

Thanks for all your replies.

the reason I didn’t order until then is because I was waiting for my friends husband to confirm it was a gift that she would actually like/use. I didn’t want to spend so much money if it was going to be wasted.

This friend is really good to me and so I thought it rude and a little embarrassing if I turned up empty handed. As a previous poster has said, if she had opened them all on the day it would have been very obvious I was gift-less and didn’t want to then have to publicly explain myself. I was also mad at myself that it was close to the wire as I didn’t speak to her husband until the weekend before so wanted to make sure I had my shit together on the day.

The NDD was via DHL (sorry I said DPD before). I received a confirmation of my order email at 12:58 saying I’d receive a tracking notice upon it being en route. I emailed the seller to politely ask if she could give me an update on the Friday AM as I hadn’t heard anything with regards to a tracking number and she said:

‘Thank you very much for your order and your message.

I'm afraid your order was placed only 3 minutes before 1pm and there was not enough time to dispatch your order that day.

Your order was dispatched on 3rd February with DHL UK next day delivery, tracking number xxxxxxxx’.

When it still didn’t arrive on Monday I emailed again to say that I needed the parcel at the weekend and as it failed to arrive within 2 working days, I would really appreciate being able to return it for a refund and she said:

‘Of course, please see our returns information below:

Please repack the item with care using all the original packaging. As the goods are your responsibility until they reach our warehouse please ensure you package your return to prevent any damage to the items or boxes. This does not affect your statutory rights.

With the exception of faulty and damaged goods we are not responsible for the return postage and we do advise that you obtain a certificate of postage in case the parcel fails to reach us.

Please ensure the item is received by us within 14 days of today's date in order to receive a refund as per the Consumer Contracts Regulations 2014.

Please add a note with your order number and reason for the return (if this information isn't included the return will be put to one side and not processed until that information is provided, causing a delay with the processing of the refund).

The address (in case you no longer have the dispatch note) is:
xxxxxx’

I know I’m being OTT and dramatic saying this but I’m just so tired of nothing being straight forward. I ordered from this site as I prefer to give my money to local businesses (and the bonus of NDD) and not large corporations but the level of customer service sometimes is disappointing. I don’t want to have to twist her arm to cover the cost of the return but equally don’t see why I should be out of pocket for something that turned up on Tuesday when expected on the Friday. Just yet another thing to add to my never ending to do list!

thanks all for your replies

OP posts:
Motherknowsbest20 · 12/02/2023 12:26

Unfortunately distance selling regulations cover you and the seller to a certain degree. You are entitled to a refund for your original postage and the item, by notifying the seller in writing that you wish to cancel the contract of sale. You are not however entitled to the return postage to be paid by the seller. You are only entitled to this if the item is faulty. All sellers have 28 days to get your parcel to you, regardless if you paid for for expedite shipping. The seller can claim with their shipper for the parcel not being delivered next day, but that’s if their shipper offers compensation, all shipping times are estimated and are never guaranteed.

Glitteratitar · 12/02/2023 09:13

Jellybean23 · 11/02/2023 20:30

In law, if you are returning the whole of the order (ie not keeping one item from the parcel) you are entitled to have a refund of the postage you paid for it's delivery to you. If they don't refund this, you need to remind them of your consumer rights.

The last time I checked this, you have to specifically notify them that you are returning in accordance with the Consumer Contract Regulations for this to apply.

If OP does this, then she should get delivery cost refunded.

AllThatFancyPaintsAsFair · 12/02/2023 08:42

Dijoduo · 10/02/2023 11:48

Why should she have to? Just because you say so?

Lots of reasons not to do that:

  1. It makes her look disorganised.
  2. It could be construed as rude.
  3. She’d have to make a whole journey separately to deliver the gift.
  4. Many baby showers have the gift opening as part of the event and so this would be missed.

You asked a pointless question that you already knew the answer to. She bought another gift because she wanted to have one to give at the baby shower itself, which is in line with social convention and is what she actually paid for from the online retailer. I’m not sure why you’re pretending to be confused as to why she did it.

We clearly live in very different worlds, no one I know would think it rude to not be able to hand or a gift on the day because of delivery issues. Imo that's ridiculous, if there's a postal strike are we all expected to go out and buy replacement gifts?

Unles the OP tells everyone she made the order at 12.57, which surely no one would do, whyould anyone thinks her disorganised

And uness the OP is the only guest what difference would it make to have a gift on a later day? Would that really bother you if you were the mum to be?

Liz811 · 12/02/2023 08:12

You should either be refunded the next day delivery cost and get to keep the item, or you should pay to send it back for a full refund. Even amazon expect you to pay for returns if there’s no fault with the item.

Licencetopenandnotafraidtouseit · 11/02/2023 23:14

You’re entitled to all of the cost back including return delivery fees and your original delivery fee.

TheCave · 11/02/2023 23:08

Look at section. 28 of the Consumer Rights Act and take it from there. In your situation I'd request a full refund including of the delivery fee and return cost. They didn't deliver when they promised.

IWonderWhyIBother · 11/02/2023 23:01

AllThatFancyPaintsAsFair · 10/02/2023 09:15

Why did you need to buy another a gift? Youve made yourself a problem where there didn't need to be one

Exactly this. You could easily explained that the gift hadn’t arrived, maybe leaving out that you didn’t try to get anything until the last minute, then either pop round with it or post it if they are far away. It’s a baby shower so presumably there’s plenty of time before the baby arrives.

Imtryingnottobother · 11/02/2023 22:41

Yes but I’d assume they do the last check at 13:01 and then pick any remaining orders. Otherwise they should change the website to say 12:30 and not change their processes.

A lot of websites have countdowns to the second of the cut off because the deadline is the deadline, not seconds/minutes before

I’m only speaking as a small retailer, but during busy periods you won’t always get all the orders out to a cut off time. I do have a disclaimer on my site explaining and ask people to message me if something is urgent, but even the likes of Amazon will experience delays when they can’t meet demand, they probably have a system that can give a better delivery time estimate, but it’s not infallible.
To me the time deadline is a guide for customers, that I generally stick to, but mostly it’s to stop people placing orders at 5:30pm and expecting it in their lap the next day.
I would advise messaging the retailer to check and not leave it to the very last minute before ordering.

JudgeRudy · 11/02/2023 22:29

Morally I think they should but it really does depend on T&Cs.

BloodyMabel · 11/02/2023 22:20

You’re entitled to the original delivery cost back because you’re returning the whole order. I would also refuse to pay the return delivery because you ordered on the understanding it would be sent the same day.

I think maybe this could be reported to the advertising standards authority because they’ve admitted they didn’t do, or have any intention of doing, the service they’re advertising?

VeggieSalsa · 11/02/2023 22:00

Imtryingnottobother · 10/02/2023 12:19

I don’t understand this. The deadline was 1pm, not 12.57pm. If items ordered at 12.57pm couldn’t be sent that day, they should have had an earlier deadline. It’s the whole point of a deadline… anything sent before it (even at 12.59) meets the deadline. Anything after that doesn’t.

Someone still has to pick the order, leaving till the last minute isn’t a good idea. If you need something quickly, it’s worth messaging the retailer to confirm they are able to meet the deadline, it alerts them to your order - most e commerce sites don’t highlight urgent orders, and it can be easy to miss on a busy day. It also gives you the chance to go elsewhere if they can’t.
Although I think the retailer should have contacted the op to check they still wanted the order, when they saw the NDD option has been chosen.

Yes but I’d assume they do the last check at 13:01 and then pick any remaining orders. Otherwise they should change the website to say 12:30 and not change their processes.

A lot of websites have countdowns to the second of the cut off because the deadline is the deadline, not seconds/minutes before

GoodChat · 11/02/2023 21:59

You're only entitled to the difference between the next day delivery price and the standard delivery price if they didn't fulfil next day delivery.

If you return the item you get the full cost of the item refunded.

surreygirl1987 · 11/02/2023 21:54

You were 3 mins before the deadline. I don't u derating why people are saying it's iffy etc. They offered a service and have not met it. Of course they should cover the cost of the return. Tell them you'll make a case with Trading Standards if the refund isn't given as they have not provided the service you paid for. Most places fold and refund me when I say that.

DotAndCarryOne2 · 11/02/2023 21:45

FredaFox · 11/02/2023 20:18

I had this with house if Fraser last week, paid for next day delivery 3 weeks ago, Evri confirmed they had it, same day Evri advised it had a delay, house if Fraser wouldn't refund despite me missing both birthdays the items were for , it finally turned up this week, tried to return it and they wanted to charge me £4.99! I eventually got given a discount code to cover my costs, now waiting 14 days for my refund 🙄

Was your order completed by 1257 or were you just starting it then? What time was your order confirmation? Did that confirm delivery for the date you wanted?

I despair of Evri. Customer service means nothing to them - never yet had a next day delivery on time from them. Three parcels missing from before Christmas - three gifts I had to replace. Still not arrived and had to open non receipt cases with the retailers as Evri don’t deal with recipients, only sellers. They send recipients an email just after delivery window has expired, advising that they’ve tried to deliver but you’re not home. This is so the courier gets paid for a delivery attempt that they have actually never made (ring doorbell footage to prove it ). I make a point of finding out which couriers retailers use before buying now. If it’s Evri I don’t touch them with a barge pole. Surprising the big names that use them though - M&S, House of Fraser, John Lewis, Tu at Sainsburys, Next, J D Williams. Can only think that they don’t care about their reputations.

PuddlesPityParty · 11/02/2023 21:44

By they I mean the company of course.

PuddlesPityParty · 11/02/2023 21:44

DotAndCarryOne2 · 11/02/2023 21:31

Don’t think it makes a difference whether it’s being returned or not - if the customer pays for next day delivery and the company haven’t used the appropriate service because the cut off time has been passed, then they should refund the difference. Royal Mail are currently taking the pee due to the strikes - warning that services will take longer than normal but quite happy to take payment for a service they can’t honour !!

I think asking for the price difference is fine, or they can cover the cost of the return. If the gift was so essential you have to ask why the OP left it so late to order it in the first place to be quite honest. Anything could have gone wrong.

Plus - Usually it’s in T&Cs of a lot of places that the delivery dates are estimated and not guaranteed. Most next day deliveries are also usually classed as 1-2 working days in their description, even if they’re called next day. So the OP needs to check this before they go back to the company. If they do state this in their t&cs then they might be nice and do a goodwill but 🤷‍♀️

MadeOfSteel · 11/02/2023 21:36

I will the refund of your next day delivery postage fee cover the cost of return postage? Hopefully it'll cancel out the cost so you won't be out of pocket.

Saying that, I'd still ask them to send you a postage paid return label first.

I'm tired of having to contact retailers to request refunds of next day delivery costs. I've had 3 already in the last couple of weeks and need to contact another on Monday. I know it's the couriers/Royal Mail letting us all down, but the retailers are complicit in going for the cheapest delivery services possible.

DotAndCarryOne2 · 11/02/2023 21:35

Jellybean23 · 11/02/2023 20:30

In law, if you are returning the whole of the order (ie not keeping one item from the parcel) you are entitled to have a refund of the postage you paid for it's delivery to you. If they don't refund this, you need to remind them of your consumer rights.

Wouldn’t have thought keeping one item makes a difference to your statutory rights if you paid for NDD and the company didn’t honour it.

DotAndCarryOne2 · 11/02/2023 21:33

5YearsLeft · 11/02/2023 20:47

I’m a bit confused, OP. You say in your second comment:

It wasn’t sent NDD no

So you paid the £6.95, but they didn’t send it NDD? Because even if they sent it Friday, it should have arrived Saturday or Monday. In no way should NDD arrive Tuesday. What is their excuse for not sending it NDD? It’s ridiculous they’re not refunding you.

@Jellybean23 and @TheWomanTheyCallJayne both have good points re: the law protecting your refund and when NDD should arrive.

This is what I thought - certainly RM next day delivery if sent on Friday, should be guaranteed to arrive by 1pm Saturday.

DotAndCarryOne2 · 11/02/2023 21:31

PuddlesPityParty · 11/02/2023 21:01

If you’re returning it - yes
if you’re not - no

Did you go to checkout at 12:57? Or was it processed etc with confirmation email at that time? I think you need to see when the order actually went through

Don’t think it makes a difference whether it’s being returned or not - if the customer pays for next day delivery and the company haven’t used the appropriate service because the cut off time has been passed, then they should refund the difference. Royal Mail are currently taking the pee due to the strikes - warning that services will take longer than normal but quite happy to take payment for a service they can’t honour !!

DotAndCarryOne2 · 11/02/2023 21:27

Have ordered online quite a few times from Tu by Sainsburys and have learned the hard way that you don’t order anything for next day delivery because they use Evri as their courier, and they are incapable of honouring a next day delivery commitment - at least where I live. Don’t understand why large retailers use cheap crap couriers as it reflects badly on them when the customer is inevitably let down.

EasterIssland · 11/02/2023 21:17

She’s willing to refund you. Just wants you to cover the postage of sending it back. Many companies do this as well

Swipe left for the next trending thread