Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think most people are concerned about climate change... but

315 replies

hopewithoutpanic · 10/02/2023 06:43

Don't know what they can personally do to make an impact?

We can see the fires, floods and impact climate change is having in both near and far places.

It has to be a concern, right? This is something that could make our planet dramatically different within our and our children's lifetimes.

Would I be correct in thinking the issue is that is individuals just don't know what (aside from recycling / trying to reduce meat etc) they can do to make a real difference?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
CoffeeMama1 · 10/02/2023 09:51

lifeinthehills · 10/02/2023 09:44

Paper straws and less plastic bags makes a difference to the animals alive now, who eat them or get straws stuck up their nose, or other horrible injuries and deaths. Just for the immediate benefits and for the sake of preventing that suffering, it is worth focusing on those small things.

Oh absolutely, it's just not going to have a huge impact on climate change as a whole, my point was the small things we can do as individuals is a drop in the ocean of what's actually needed and no matter how hard individuals try it's a huge cultural change needed from the top.

lifeinthehills · 10/02/2023 09:51

I do think there will always be humans inhabiting the planet, just maybe not in the same way we are now.

Until the sun burns out at the longest.

yetanothercleverusername · 10/02/2023 09:48

Gatehouse77 · 10/02/2023 07:54

And at least be honest, it's not abut saving the planet - it can look after itself as has been proven way before man evolved.

It's about preserving humans, and I'm not sure we deserve it...

This exactly.
Humans may or may not be causing "climate change" TBH it doesn't really matter.
Can we stop it? Very unlikely.
I find it interesting that the focus in public thinking has changed from the Greenpeace type movement, which was about saving the planet, to Extinction Rebellion which is basically just about saving the human race.
Just shows the general selfishness of the human race in a nutshell.

However, if there is one thing humans are good at, that is adapting and innovating so I do think there will always be humans inhabiting the planet, just maybe not in the same way we are now.

Daftasabroom · 10/02/2023 09:48

ForTheLoveOfSleep · 10/02/2023 09:07

I understand per capita however that means not a lot in terms of the whole picture. All that really matters is total emmissions. The UK makes no impact on overall numbers as a nation as if we suddenly didn't exist no difference would be made to the current climate change models.

The only way to stop climate change is to research and develop renewable energies that are cheaper for the world.

If all that matters is total emissions why are you singling out China, USA and India and claiming there is nothing we can do. Classic whataboutism.

MintyFreshOne · 10/02/2023 09:46

Paper straws and less plastic bags makes a difference to the animals alive now, who eat them or get straws stuck up their nose, or other horrible injuries and deaths. Just for the immediate benefits and for the sake of preventing that suffering, it is worth focusing on those small things

It is better to focus on stuff like this that you can actually improve; not much you can do about global emissions after all

lifeinthehills · 10/02/2023 09:44

CoffeeMama1 · 10/02/2023 09:40

The difficulty is even with all the paper straws and reusable bags in the world it won't make a difference until the largest corporations are held accountable for thier part. I don't know the exact numbers but it's something insane like the top 10 corporation's are responsible for like 80% of the world emissions, so it doesn't really matter what us normal folk do.

Paper straws and less plastic bags makes a difference to the animals alive now, who eat them or get straws stuck up their nose, or other horrible injuries and deaths. Just for the immediate benefits and for the sake of preventing that suffering, it is worth focusing on those small things.

MintyFreshOne · 10/02/2023 09:44

First, my point is that our holier than thou 'look at our domestic emissions' posturing is at best skewed and is a bit of a silly argument particularly in the context of individual action. A bit like saying flying doesn't count if the plane takes off and lands in other countries

Their point is that the UK can only control UK emissions. At best, you can onshore companies that are manufacturing abroad—but that’s not going to do much of anything anyway, since China is pretty much required to be joint venture and they’d just move on without you.

Second, we have a degree of purchasing power that isn't represented in our domestic emissions. We can make decisions about how that purchasing happens and, on a national level, set our trade policies in a way that reflects our domestic commitments

Of course that is the UK’s right to do. It’s probably a better way on many levels tbh

And third, moneymoneymoneymoney. We're still the world's sixth largest economy. Are people really suggesting all that money isn't influential?

You still need a return on those investments. Do you really think you could pick green winners and satisfy share holders? An investment should be still a good investment without the green angle

JassyRadlett · 10/02/2023 09:44

secretllama · 10/02/2023 09:34

I'm talking about plastic waste being thrown away into the environment. Not production of plastic.

I was referring to posts where PPs have said why does charging for plastic bags make a difference if xyz is producing x amount of emissions. Say I completely didn't care about climate change, I can still care about someone buying a plastic bag every time they shopped and chucking it away for animals to suffocate with. To me that's a separate issue altogether. And if charging makes people do this less then I'm all for it, even if it makes 0 difference to climate change.

Plastic waste is a double/treble issue isn't it?

Charging for single use plastics brings down litter and reduces environmental/wildlife harm.

It also reduces landfill (especially if you look beyond single use plastics bags to broader plastics that end up in landfill).

And reducing plastics use via whatever means means you're producing less emissions.

It's a bit of a symbolic one in emissions terms of course. But waste and emissions are linked.

CoffeeMama1 · 10/02/2023 09:40

The difficulty is even with all the paper straws and reusable bags in the world it won't make a difference until the largest corporations are held accountable for thier part. I don't know the exact numbers but it's something insane like the top 10 corporation's are responsible for like 80% of the world emissions, so it doesn't really matter what us normal folk do.

JassyRadlett · 10/02/2023 09:39

China put more new coal energy plants into use last year than the rest of the world combined. It's not demonising China to note this is pretty crazy when much of the world is trying to lose them. Criticising the Chinese government's choices surely is no different to criticising the Tories. But no one ever says they're being demonised.

Didn't they also put more renewables into use last year that any other country? Likely to meet its goal of a third of its overall consumption to be renewable by 2025 early. Why only talk about the coal, why not the overall picture?

I reckon you can demonise plenty about the CCCP, and China has a fuckload of a long way to go on climate still (don't we all) but the very one-sided 'it's China innit' narratives around climate are an easy way of shrugging off the role of other countries' choices.

secretllama · 10/02/2023 09:34

NerdyBird1 · 10/02/2023 08:41

No they're all interlinked. Production of plastic contributes to climate change.

I'm talking about plastic waste being thrown away into the environment. Not production of plastic.

I was referring to posts where PPs have said why does charging for plastic bags make a difference if xyz is producing x amount of emissions. Say I completely didn't care about climate change, I can still care about someone buying a plastic bag every time they shopped and chucking it away for animals to suffocate with. To me that's a separate issue altogether. And if charging makes people do this less then I'm all for it, even if it makes 0 difference to climate change.

JassyRadlett · 10/02/2023 09:34

MintyFreshOne · 10/02/2023 09:14

Our balance of trade is vastly different to eg China's. A lot of their domestic emissions are tied up in the goods they produce for export

If they didn’t have UK as a market, you think they’d stop manufacturing?

Life has become so much better in China since they’ve developed their export-oriented economy (like Japan, Taiwan and South Korea before them), and they have markets outside of the UK to sell their products to as well. They don’t need the UK specifically.

Im not in the West these days and I have seen cheap Chinese goods flood our markets in the last few years, which has been only a good thing, as the local alternatives were too expensive and not that much better in quality tbh.

🙄

I love these threads, there's so much creative fiction about what people have actually said.

First, my point is that our holier than thou 'look at our domestic emissions' posturing is at best skewed and is a bit of a silly argument particularly in the context of individual action. A bit like saying flying doesn't count if the plane takes off and lands in other countries.

Second, we have a degree of purchasing power that isn't represented in our domestic emissions. We can make decisions about how that purchasing happens and, on a national level, set our trade policies in a way that reflects our domestic commitments.

And third, moneymoneymoneymoney. We're still the world's sixth largest economy. Are people really suggesting all that money isn't influential?

lifeinthehills · 10/02/2023 09:28

MonicaFree · 10/02/2023 09:20

It’s great that you buy local fruit and veg.

However, you don’t buy local welly boots and plumbing supplies.

If I can, I do. I like to support local business. But that has nothing to do with environmental concerns. The reason I buy local produce is that it's fresher, and I think we're probably better attuned to eating things from the local climate and environment. I think people would benefit from less rat race and slower, simpler lives overall. Again, nothing to do with environmental concerns directly. If I'm honest, I don't have the energy to worry about that.

MintyFreshOne · 10/02/2023 09:26

China put more new coal energy plants into use last year than the rest of the world combined. It's not demonising China to note this is pretty crazy when much of the world is trying to lose them

It used to be a shithole country but things have been 1000% better for the average person in the last thirty years. They should never apologise for it.

They accomplished the greatest anti-poverty program in the history of the world, basically.

(and I absolutely loathe the ruling party but nobody can take that accomplishment away from them)

JassyRadlett · 10/02/2023 09:25

ForTheLoveOfSleep · 10/02/2023 09:07

I understand per capita however that means not a lot in terms of the whole picture. All that really matters is total emmissions. The UK makes no impact on overall numbers as a nation as if we suddenly didn't exist no difference would be made to the current climate change models.

The only way to stop climate change is to research and develop renewable energies that are cheaper for the world.

I do think stopping funding burning things in other countries is probably a worthy goal too.

Three trillion in UK pension funds - just read a report that suggests the funds represent more emissions than the entire UK carbon footprint and if the pensions industry was a country it would be a top 20 emitter.

Daftasabroom · 10/02/2023 09:24

JassyRadlett · 10/02/2023 09:13

This could be the great Brexit benefit - trade deals that give preferential tariffs access for lower emission imports eg non-deforestation palm oil and soya.

Somehow I'm sceptical that this government would do it....

It won't be a Brexit benefit. The EU heavily regulates polluting industries and pours massive investment into sustainability through Horizon Europe. But we're in process of give ministers the power to scrap those regulations without any consultation to either Parliament or other stakeholders. We do have limited access to Horizon Europe but funding needs to come through IUK. The admin burden is triple what it was.

brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr · 10/02/2023 09:20

Individual behavioural change en masse can have a measurable impact. The only times GHG emissions dropped in the 30+ years since the UNFCCC was formed and Kyoto / Paris agreements were put in place were 2008 and 2020/21.

And I think we all know what happened in those years.

Individuals are “demand” - shops, manufacturers and ultimately fossil fuel companies respond to demand. So it’s up to individuals to make changes en masse, and be brave and open and talk about it.

Renewable energy is one area where we can make better choices. This should be cheaper but it currently isn’t. The government’s role here should be ensuring renewable energy is cheaper and incentivising its use. And allowing onshore wind - those turbines won’t be around for ever but we need them while more futuristic energy sources are developed. Let’s accept them for a few generations to help their kids survive.

Reducing or quitting meat & dairy is another huge area we as consumers can influence. Farmers should be able to adapt and provide the plant based proteins we need to replace them. Again the government can help here with grants and subsidies to convert.

And cycling / public transport must be made safe, comfortable and affordable. Taking a bus or train should be the obvious choice, and that means we need to demonstrate demand for those services. If we don’t use them and travel solo in cars, we’re causing them to shut down not become more available and frequent. Let’s shut down all the whining about cyclists and this weird UK cyclist / motorist confrontational culture. In other countries they build really good segregated infrastructure, and voila - it gets used. Netherlands, Denmark, Switzerland - just fantastic.

Where I live there is a need for a cycle route from the village into the city. Farmers oppose it because they anticipate “anti social behaviour” and are very much “not on my land” about it. This “default negative” attitude in the UK stinks, what happened to “can do” and “let’s try it” - so much moaning and very little excitement to progress !

Consumers have demand in their control, and working together we can engineer that demand to force the market to move faster into a more sustainable space.

MonicaFree · 10/02/2023 09:20

lifeinthehills · 10/02/2023 09:00

Yes, and that's along the lines of what I said in another post. We don't need those phones really. We might want them, but we don't need them. It is possible to live locally, plenty of people do, some live off grid quite self-sufficiently. I source all my fruit and vegetables from local sources. We might not be able to get every food item we want all the time, or even ever, if we eat within a certain radius (it's a whole movement), but we'd have to accept that. And less medical advances. In short, we need to accept shorter, less comfortable lives. But we don't want that.

It’s great that you buy local fruit and veg.

However, you don’t buy local welly boots and plumbing supplies.

JamSandle · 10/02/2023 09:20

I think it's challenging for all the reasons people have said but also because a lot of people don't even believe in climate change.

We've also all been conditioned now to an aspirational way of life - that children do better than their parents. Noone wants to reduce their quality of life. Understandably so!

When it's cheaper for most people to go on holiday rather than buy a house, they will do.

When a vegan chocolate bar is 100% more than the dairy bar people will buy the dairy.

Noln · 10/02/2023 09:18

Britain is responsible for less than 2% of global carbon emissions. Data here. We also have quite a low per capita carbon footprint -
if you scroll down this link you can see we are close to global averages, not high like Australia, the US, China.

All this means that even if the UK sunk into the sea next week, it would have very little impact overall. Bring that down further to individual changes and the difference we can make is minimal. Most of us aren't leaving a huge carbon footprint - a little driving, using energy at home but turning things off when not using, recycling and using food waste, buying clothes only as needed etc... there's not much more you can strip down without exiting modern life, and even then the data shows, it would make very little difference.
The difference will be made with new technologies for cleaner energies and more pressure on the most carbon heavy countries to clean up. China put more new coal energy plants into use last year than the rest of the world combined. It's not demonising China to note this is pretty crazy when much of the world is trying to lose them. Criticising the Chinese government's choices surely is no different to criticising the Tories. But no one ever says they're being demonised 😂

Daftasabroom · 10/02/2023 09:18

megletthesecond · 10/02/2023 09:16

Our council climate change team asked for people to get involved so I emailed them a list of suggestions to help the local environment, supporting local litter pickers, food waste collection, ensuring footpaths and cycle paths are well lit and safe, local food markets, banning balloon releases.... and they came back with a reason they couldn't do any of them.
I will reply but my current mood will be so arsey it won't end well.

So why not set up an independent forum or lobby group?

FunnyItWorkedLastTime · 10/02/2023 09:17

We can vote and we can talk. We need to make it politically possible for governments to make the right choices.

Educate yourself on the facts, and the common justifications given for inaction. Be ready to challenge them politely whenever you hear a normally reasonable friend/family member/mumsnetter repeat a superficially clever thing they read on Facebook.

Decarbonising the UK's heating and transport systems will involve short term expense and inconvenience for a lot of people, although should give us longer term benefits in energy security etc. Those of us who can withstand that with manageable sacrifices of time and money should do so without moaning. Those of us who can manage it without thinking twice should be prepared to subsidise the people who will really struggle.

Personally: fly less, eat less meat and dairy.

Daftasabroom · 10/02/2023 09:16

@thebellagio my efforts will amount to absolutely fuck all when the industries aren't even TRYING to make an effort.

You are very mistaken in this, the major sectors are making massive investments in renewable and sustainable technologies. The Climate Disclosure Project has an A List of companies making serious efforts in becoming more sustainable, and publishing independently audited data on line.

megletthesecond · 10/02/2023 09:16

Our council climate change team asked for people to get involved so I emailed them a list of suggestions to help the local environment, supporting local litter pickers, food waste collection, ensuring footpaths and cycle paths are well lit and safe, local food markets, banning balloon releases.... and they came back with a reason they couldn't do any of them.
I will reply but my current mood will be so arsey it won't end well.

CurrentHun · 10/02/2023 09:14

I see every little or big green thing I can do as buying a tiny little bit of time for the environment and climate because we really urgently need it. I have kids and want them to have a life and also be able to have kids, so I am desperate that this gets sorted for them.