Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think most people are concerned about climate change... but

315 replies

hopewithoutpanic · 10/02/2023 06:43

Don't know what they can personally do to make an impact?

We can see the fires, floods and impact climate change is having in both near and far places.

It has to be a concern, right? This is something that could make our planet dramatically different within our and our children's lifetimes.

Would I be correct in thinking the issue is that is individuals just don't know what (aside from recycling / trying to reduce meat etc) they can do to make a real difference?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
Allblackeverythingalways · 10/02/2023 10:48

I work in buying, there's things that you cannot source anywhere other than China now. No-one else makes them. End of. It's especially irritating because we have a "local" policy.
Where we can, our suppliers are in the same city as us, or up to 50 miles away.
So much sill has to come from China though.

lifeinthehills · 10/02/2023 10:47

MintyFreshOne · 10/02/2023 10:40

Your argument is flawed because it's the same as us paying immigrants poor wages to pick fruit etc. here in the UK. We can say, "oh they're better off than where they came from" but is missing the point. Exploitation of cheap labour is a horrible practice and we turn a blind eye and make excuses because we want cheap goods

I have lived in China for over 10 years. I have seen people that grew up using outdoor toilets planked over pig sties become millionaires (sadly I wasn’t one of them lol).

There is a strong middle class now whereas before just grinding, terrible poverty. We call those born in the 40s and 50s in China a lost generation because their potential was totally wasted, but opening up to the world has been the greatest anti-poverty program in the history of the world.

And you call this exploitation. Sure sure.

Tbh they used you just as much as you used them. Betrayed your own working class so you could get cheaper stuff. But it still seems a better way for both sides even so.

It is a good thing if poorer nations are catching up through global trade. Hopefully, in time, we will have a truly equal planet where resources are more fairly distributed.

JassyRadlett · 10/02/2023 10:46

Their point is that the UK can only control UK emissions. At best, you can onshore companies that are manufacturing abroad—but that’s not going to do much of anything anyway, since China is pretty much required to be joint venture and they’d just move on without you.

No, there's many more tools rhan that when it comes to trade.

lifeinthehills · 10/02/2023 10:43

MonicaFree · 10/02/2023 10:36

Great. You sound nice. But this is a climate change thread.

My point is no one buys wellies ‘locally made’ in the UK. We don’t grow rubber trees ffs. And the same goes for chrome plated steel and rubber plumbing supplies. A sheer fucking stupidity that stops people understanding the climate impact (and ethics) of their supply chains.

Yes, it's drifted a bit but going back to the climate change discussion, if we're looking at reducing shipping and all that entails, we would have to go back to the days when more was produced locally and find ways to do that. I know my childhood wellies were locally produced. I don't believe that will ever happen though. Maybe when fossil fuels run out, or will we find another way? Maybe a more environmentally friendly way to move things around. Solar driven ships perhaps? That would make exporting and importing less polluting and address some climate change goals.

Meanwhile, I just worry about the little things I can do to reduce suffering in the world for humans and animals. I do believe that one day we will have depleted the earth's resources and it will continue without us, at least until the sun burns out in billions of years. Climate change in the longer term doesn't really concern me.

MintyFreshOne · 10/02/2023 10:40

Your argument is flawed because it's the same as us paying immigrants poor wages to pick fruit etc. here in the UK. We can say, "oh they're better off than where they came from" but is missing the point. Exploitation of cheap labour is a horrible practice and we turn a blind eye and make excuses because we want cheap goods

I have lived in China for over 10 years. I have seen people that grew up using outdoor toilets planked over pig sties become millionaires (sadly I wasn’t one of them lol).

There is a strong middle class now whereas before just grinding, terrible poverty. We call those born in the 40s and 50s in China a lost generation because their potential was totally wasted, but opening up to the world has been the greatest anti-poverty program in the history of the world.

And you call this exploitation. Sure sure.

Tbh they used you just as much as you used them. Betrayed your own working class so you could get cheaper stuff. But it still seems a better way for both sides even so.

MonicaFree · 10/02/2023 10:36

This reply has been deleted

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

Great. You sound nice. But this is a climate change thread.

My point is no one buys wellies ‘locally made’ in the UK. We don’t grow rubber trees ffs. And the same goes for chrome plated steel and rubber plumbing supplies. A sheer fucking stupidity that stops people understanding the climate impact (and ethics) of their supply chains.

MrsSkylerWhite · 10/02/2023 10:32

ComtesseDeSpair · Today 08:47
I think a lot of people actually just don’t care, to be honest. I don’t. I’ll be dead by the time things get really bad and I truly don’t care what happens to the humans after me. Not my problem. A lot of people dress up their “I actually don’t care” with arguments about “well, whilst X, Y, Z is going on in industry and other countries it seems pointless for me to bother recycling my yoghurt pots” etc, but the baseline is lack of care“

I think you’re right. I care but only because we have children and grandchildren, so my concern is purely selfish.
If we didn’t, I may well feel the same way. The world will keep going, species will evolve as they always have. Some will die, humans may be one of them. New species will emerge.

SamanthaCaine · 10/02/2023 10:29

MintyFreshOne · 10/02/2023 10:12

The way to help China is to stop buying so much stuff and reduce our dependency on cheap labour. But then we'd manufacture more and then moan that everything is so expensive. Our CO2 would also go up so would never happen

Your way of ‘helping’ China is to impoverish them. Their quality of life has improved immensely from an export-oriented economic system.

Thankfully they do not solely rely on Western economies to buy their products.

China is one of the biggest export nations in the world. They rely on the west producing loads of our stuff, from clothes to electronics, to cars and everything else.

They may not rely solely on us but it's us that have been responsible for building a manufacturing giant. Now we're moaning about their energy production.

Your argument is flawed because it's the same as us paying immigrants poor wages to pick fruit etc. here in the UK. We can say, "oh they're better off than where they came from" but is missing the point. Exploitation of cheap labour is a horrible practice and we turn a blind eye and make excuses because we want cheap goods.

lifeinthehills · 10/02/2023 10:21

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

lifeinthehills · 10/02/2023 10:15

I admit I became much more conscious of buying local and supporting local businesses through Covid. Something I try to continue as much as possible.

If we're thinking of the environment, I hate to think how much plastic in medical waste and masks has gone into the environment from Covid alone.

lifeinthehills · 10/02/2023 10:12

MonicaFree · 10/02/2023 10:05

If you can you buy local wellies and plumbing supplies - where do you live? South Vietnam?

I don't own wellies. The closest thing I have is hiking boots and they are made more locally. I have no idea where my plumbing supplies are made. If given the option I'd go for the local product though, just to support local manufacturing. I just let the plumber do their job.

That is another issue though that, these days, we sometimes have no choice as we can't get locally produced items. Or the imported items are so much cheaper some people feel they need to buy them for the family economy. Global trade is so established now, I don't see that changing. The point is - when I CAN, I go for local.

MintyFreshOne · 10/02/2023 10:12

The way to help China is to stop buying so much stuff and reduce our dependency on cheap labour. But then we'd manufacture more and then moan that everything is so expensive. Our CO2 would also go up so would never happen

Your way of ‘helping’ China is to impoverish them. Their quality of life has improved immensely from an export-oriented economic system.

Thankfully they do not solely rely on Western economies to buy their products.

Hawkins003 · 10/02/2023 10:11

I'd guess it will be big business and big technology that will help overall

pollypokcet · 10/02/2023 10:10

@MintyFreshOne I'm taking about if the human races dies out and the idea that we don't deserve it. I'll still be around in 60 years and so will my children etc. so don't think we deserve to die out (which won't be as simple as just disappearing as you'd imagine in your head)

MarshaBradyo · 10/02/2023 10:10

We’ve made changes, beyond that we’re a tiny factor in it all but hopefully one of many.

MintyFreshOne · 10/02/2023 10:07

pollypokcet · 10/02/2023 09:57

And people won't just be disappearing into a cloud of dust either. Climate change related deaths will be drought, famine, drowning etc

All deaths from these causes have plummeted in the modern day, unironically because we use fossil fuels
to prevent them

On balance, I prefer to keep using FF to prevent further deaths from these causes

SamanthaCaine · 10/02/2023 10:06

Choconut · 10/02/2023 08:54

China has 1118 coal fired power stations on the mainland and are planning to massively expand. There is little point in individuals in the UK doing anything while that is happening IMO as the impact won't even register.

That's one way of looking at it (to put it kindly!).

You have to ask yourself why China has so many coal fired power stations in the first place.

Another way of looking at it is asking why virtually everything (during my lifetime at least) has been made in China. The west has historically abused cheap labour so that we can buy cheap goods. Almost everything we see around us is imported.

Manufacturing is hugely responsible for CO2, hence why the UK is down. But we've been exploiting cheap labour for so long that we've deluded ourselves into thinking that we're greener than everyone else. Yet it's our collective drive to be competitive and to consume that has created business models that depend 100% on exploiting cheap labour. The problem is, we don't actually care about how China generates the electricity to produce what we want. We just want cheap goods.

The way to help China is to stop buying so much stuff and reduce our dependency on cheap labour. But then we'd manufacture more and then moan that everything is so expensive. Our CO2 would also go up so would never happen.

So the solution is for us to factor the CO2 into the price of goods we buy/import via additional taxation and for the tax to go into greener power. But no-one wants that either.

MonicaFree · 10/02/2023 10:05

lifeinthehills · 10/02/2023 09:28

If I can, I do. I like to support local business. But that has nothing to do with environmental concerns. The reason I buy local produce is that it's fresher, and I think we're probably better attuned to eating things from the local climate and environment. I think people would benefit from less rat race and slower, simpler lives overall. Again, nothing to do with environmental concerns directly. If I'm honest, I don't have the energy to worry about that.

If you can you buy local wellies and plumbing supplies - where do you live? South Vietnam?

Allblackeverythingalways · 10/02/2023 10:04

BibbleandSqwauk · 10/02/2023 07:11

I completely agree that people on an individual level, especially now, are not going to make their own lives more difficult and stressful by ditching the car, seeking out individual farm shop food etc (which needs a car to get to anyway) and investing in more eco friendly things like reusable nappies when the huge industries in China etc are polluting on such a scale. Literally on a day to day level as a FT working single parent, I need things to be as easy and convenient as possible just to keep all the plates spinning. I care in a fairly non-specific general way, but no, I'm not going to make my life even more difficult.

This is my take on it
I'm not going to freeze, be stuck with inadequate public transport, buy more expensive products etc.
I'm not wasteful, but I won't make my life even harder whilst those telling us what we can and can't do are swanning around in private jets and using huge personal resources.
I do the little things, avoid fast fashion, don't waste food, drive as economically as I can, I try to buy one item that will last me a decade rather than several cheap ones etc.
When it's under £50 to get a return to Edinburgh on a plane, £160 in petrol plus parking, or £150 on a train, which do you think I'll choose? The reality is I can only afford one of them.

Daftasabroom · 10/02/2023 10:01

CoffeeMama1 · 10/02/2023 09:40

The difficulty is even with all the paper straws and reusable bags in the world it won't make a difference until the largest corporations are held accountable for thier part. I don't know the exact numbers but it's something insane like the top 10 corporation's are responsible for like 80% of the world emissions, so it doesn't really matter what us normal folk do.

The report this is based on is one of the most disingenuous and deliberately misleading pieces of research I have ever seen and has backfired spectacularly on the authors. It basically premises that all the emissions associated with burning fossil fuels for heat, power and transport can be attributed to the big energy and mining companies. Not to the power generators, not the transport providers, not to companies, organisations or households who the actually have the option to make decisions.

It really does matter what ordinary folk do.

secretllama · 10/02/2023 09:59

lifeinthehills · 10/02/2023 09:53

In terms of global warming, yes. But it is worth it for the sake of the animals that don't suffer today due to small things. I don't care about climate change but I do plant things to help the pollinators because I care about the animals around me in the immediate moment.

This is what I was trying to say in my posts too. I care about rubbish and landfill more than climate change tbh.... so the posts where people have said "why bother recycling if China is producing thousands of tonnes of emissions" make no sense to me because its 2 different impacts on the environment.

pollypokcet · 10/02/2023 09:57

And people won't just be disappearing into a cloud of dust either. Climate change related deaths will be drought, famine, drowning etc

pollypokcet · 10/02/2023 09:56

It's about preserving humans, and I'm not sure we deserve it...

'Humans' are your own children, my children and people who are alive now. Not some faraway philosophical concept.

Reluctantadult · 10/02/2023 09:56

I man stalls about environmental impact for my local friends of the earth. We get quite a lot of people round the stall when we're at things like festivals. We've got interactive stuff to do, makes it fun. But the majority of the people that visit are already well educated and taking actions themselves. It's preaching to the converted. The problem is getting this out to the masses. And systems change.

Some of the biggest things you can do as individuals are, move your money to a green Bank. Eg nationwide, monzo, tridos. Same with your pension. So your money is supporting green initiative rather than say oil. Vote green at elections (not necessarily green party, just someone better). And then, tell other people. Talk about environmental issues. Persuade people.

lifeinthehills · 10/02/2023 09:53

CoffeeMama1 · 10/02/2023 09:51

Oh absolutely, it's just not going to have a huge impact on climate change as a whole, my point was the small things we can do as individuals is a drop in the ocean of what's actually needed and no matter how hard individuals try it's a huge cultural change needed from the top.

In terms of global warming, yes. But it is worth it for the sake of the animals that don't suffer today due to small things. I don't care about climate change but I do plant things to help the pollinators because I care about the animals around me in the immediate moment.

Swipe left for the next trending thread