Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think most people are concerned about climate change... but

315 replies

hopewithoutpanic · 10/02/2023 06:43

Don't know what they can personally do to make an impact?

We can see the fires, floods and impact climate change is having in both near and far places.

It has to be a concern, right? This is something that could make our planet dramatically different within our and our children's lifetimes.

Would I be correct in thinking the issue is that is individuals just don't know what (aside from recycling / trying to reduce meat etc) they can do to make a real difference?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
CurrentHun · 29/07/2023 17:50

Great work thank you Daftasabroom

CurrentHun · 29/07/2023 17:46

Grow up containsnuts of course it makes a difference. Everyone has to do what they can to protect the planet. If everyone was that selfish we’d be even more screwed than we are now. People don’t seem to understand that it can always get worse. I don’t want that for my kids, thanks.

samsam123 · 29/07/2023 12:28

containsnuts · 10/02/2023 06:55

If you feel climate change is inevitable then there's less motivation to try and stop it. The planet has changed dramatically over time and there's been floods, droughts, valcanic eruptions and ice ages before. Perhaps this planet was only ever going to be habitable for humans for a short period of time? How does paying for a plastic bag change any of that?

it might not stop climate change but it stops people expecting a plastic bag every time they go shopping then chucking it away after 5 mins. cant see whats wrong with that

Isitjustmeoriseverythingshit7970 · 29/07/2023 00:17

hopewithoutpanic · 10/02/2023 07:01

Yes I think this is the nail on the head.

It's beyond our control using it. We're in the hands of our government.

But collectively we can make a difference by doing these very things, and if the majority are much less meat, went electric for their cars where possible and re-used where possible there would be a huge impact. I'm all for lobbying parliament but unfortunately lobbyists who are paid huge amounts by powerful industry players hold much more sway over the politicians to ensure laws aren't passed that would protect the climate but erode profit. Plus governments don't want to be sued by big companies in corporate courts - check these out if you thought the law applied equally to all. And we've allowed our right to protest to be criminalised through the police crime and sentencing act and now a new public order act. So really these changes you think would be ineffective would be the only effective way forward but we need to work together on this! Take away the dand for meat and oil and things will get better. We can all do something, just as everyone did something to stop the fur trade - we stopped buying fur. Don't think we can't make a difference because we can and the planet needs us, as do our children.

Dibbydoos · 28/07/2023 04:52

bellamountain · 10/02/2023 07:07

Very true. You can't lecture ordinary folk who only fly abroad once a year (or can't even afford a holiday anyhow). Penalising people for having an older car (Sadiq Can't). The media, the celebrities and the MPs lecture the wrong people. Speak to anyone who grew up in 1960s cities across the UK, they'll tell you the air is much cleaner now. They couldn't even see their way home back then due to the smog and pollution (and that wasn't cars).

In any event, the human race might die out but the planet will eventually renew.

Yes smog was burning coal. A lot less motorised vehicles in use in the 60's. Even in 1970 we were living withing one planet, now we need 1 and 3/4 planets!
But we can each do what we can. It is unlikely to affect the outcome because since we knew about our affect on climate change, we're increased emissions by 30% globally.

Globally, a full switch to renewables would be brilliant. But not everyone can afford the investment - I'm off grid except for when I have to heat my house in winter. I drive an ICE vehicle, would have liked a switch to hybrid, but none available when my car went kaput 2 weeks ago 😞 but I 'offsett' my impacts through mangrove planting.

Carry on doing what you can, but you're right when you say it's bigger than us.

We need stronger governmental leadership globally, better to feel a financial impact now than live in a dangerous climate from 2030 onwards....

Daftasabroom · 21/03/2023 10:22

sixthreesix · 20/02/2023 08:12

I think that most people just think what they do is a drop in the ocean and therefore not worthwhile or impactful.

The intense irony of this comment really struck me. If most people actually took worthwhile steps the impact would be immense.

sixthreesix · 20/02/2023 08:12

I think that most people just think what they do is a drop in the ocean and therefore not worthwhile or impactful.

Daftasabroom · 19/02/2023 10:34

Hi @Elvis1956 there's a really good primer on ice-cores here. This is an extract:

The oldest ice cores, from East Antarctica, provide an 800,000-year-old record of Earth’s climate. How do we know they’re that old? Each season’s snowfall has slightly different properties than the last. These differences create annual layers in the ice that can be used to count the age of the ice, just like rings inside a tree.

Additionally, as the ice compacts over time, tiny bubbles of the atmosphere—including greenhouse gases like carbon dioxide and methane—press inside the ice. These air pocket “fossils” provide samples of what the atmosphere was like when that layer of ice formed, LeGrande said. “Scientists can directly measure the amount of greenhouse gases that were in the atmosphere at that time by sampling these bubbles,” she added.

Personally I think it's pretty cool we measure climate and temperature over an 800,000 year time span. I'd like to know who had the job of counting the layers?

There's a good graphic here of temperature since the last glaciation.

Kalasbyxor · 19/02/2023 00:30

Daftasabroom, I'm so pleased you're taking the time to post on this thread; really interesting links!

Daftasabroom · 15/02/2023 18:07

@Elvis1956 My reasons for doubting climate change man made are:

We have only been measuring climate for 300 years and in that time we have industrialised so do we know if that had an impact or would the climate change naturally...we've had several ice ages including the little ice age of about 1200.

But we can and do measure temperature change and climate over the course of thousands years of years. Whether this is tree ring data, ice cores, bog samples (seeds and pollen), geological formations, silts etc etc. We really can measure temperature and climate change to a high level of confidence over exceptionally long periods of time.

These multiple sources of data can let us identify individual influences on climate change - e.g. solar activity, the Earths orbit round the sun etc. What is beyond doubt is that the sun is currently in an inactive phase (this has been measured by counting sunspots) so if the sun was behind all this we'd be in another mini-ice-age. Except we're not.

We removed both the passenger pigeon and the American bison in less than 50 years which seems to have no impact on the climate despite scientist claims that animal dung contributes to climate change...That was approximately 1 billion animals removed from the earth.

I have no idea how much impact the extinction of passenger pigeons might have had, I'd expect very little. I've also not seen any study comparing bison impact with current beef, dairy and associated modern agricultural techniques that replaced them.

Scientists don't claim that animal dung, aerobically digested or composted, contributes significantly to climate change, this would apply to previous wild bison herds. It is actually the methane emissions from flatulence (both ends), and much more significantly the anaerobic digestion of effluent in large clamps that releases significant amounts of CH4, combined with intensive monocrop agriculture to feed these animals.

scientists have agendas...climate change leads to grants and academic career progress.

That's pretty naive to be honest. Head here if you want some insight into research funding in the UK. If you really really want to get into the nitty gritty of academic funding you'll need to get into the various select committee minutes (which I wouldn't wish on anyone TBH).

Didn't easy Anglia university fake data

Oh gosh this has been debunked so many times. A huge number of scientific studies give a range of data outputs. This link gives a good overview of the spikiness of what is measured versus how that data might be smoothed to make it easily digestible. I've recently been asked asked to reduce over two hundred pages of text and data into three ppt slides for people with a two minute attention span.

scientists can be wrong.

Of course, but in a world of peer reviewed papers and continual progress they might be out be a few percentage points (see above) buts it's almost unheard of that the fundamental science is wrong.

Please, if you have any questions I'll try to answer them as best I can.

MintyFreshOne · 15/02/2023 17:12

By promoting the burning of fossil fuels you are personally proposing that we condemn the global poor, the very people you purport to support, to hardship, ever increasing poverty and early death

We have decades of positive correlation between life expectancy and fossil fuel consumption—East Asian countries that have industrialised all have made huge gains in life expectancy and reductions in deaths from natural disasters.

Why not extend this to the rest of the developing world? Do they not deserve to be protected from hot and cold weather? Do they not deserve to have access to reliable electricity? Modern kitchens instead of indoor (god forbid dung) fires?

You have no proof that climate change will harm more than poverty. Poverty demonstrably kills—and cheap fossil fuels are a way out of that. Follow the East Asian model into wealth and prosperity.

You have nothing to offer developing countries, to be frank.

Bangladesh is one of the world's countries most vulnerable to sea level rises induced by climate change

And yet this:

Bangladesh, however, has also drastically reduced its cyclone-related deaths, by more than 100 fold since 1970 – an accomplishment noted in disaster risk reduction circles and backed up by a data-driven investigation by The New Humanitarian

www.thenewhumanitarian.org/investigation/2021/12/2/how-Bangladesh-is-beating-the-odds-on-climate-disaster-deaths

That’s while the population has gone up, by the way.

Elvis1956 · 15/02/2023 17:12

Daftasabroom · 15/02/2023 08:08

It's both, taking positive steps will save you money and the planet.

I'm genuinely interested why you don't "believe" in climate change, could you explain why?

My reasons for doubting climate change man made are:
We have only been measuring climate for 300 years and in that time we have industrialised so do we know if that had an impact or would the climate change naturally...we've had several ice ages including the little ice age of about 1200.
We removed both the passenger pigeon and the American bison in less than 50 years which seems to have no impact on the climate despite scientist claims that animal dung contributes to climate change...That was approximately 1 billion animals removed from the earth.
scientists have agendas...climate change leads to grants and academic career progress. Didn't easy Anglia university fake data
scientists can be wrong. Look at the views on cholesterol in eggs, diesel.

Daftasabroom · 15/02/2023 15:46

@HandyLady the link you provided doesn't support any of your claims whatsoever. Actually it supports the generally hypothesis that the steps we need to take to mitigate climate change and drive all aspects of sustainability will improve the lives of all of us, especially the poor.

Daftasabroom · 15/02/2023 15:36

@MintyFreshOne

By promoting the burning of fossil fuels you are personally proposing that we condemn the global poor, the very people you purport to support, to hardship, ever increasing poverty and early death.

Bangladesh is one of the world's countries most vulnerable to sea level rises induced by climate change. It has land borders with India and Burma among others. It's sea border is a maze of rivers and estuaries. It needs those rivers to release the monsoon rains. You are actually proposing an environmental intervention that would have the potential to cause more damage than the unmitigated disasters posted by @Mysticguru up thread.

You clearly have no idea of the science of climate change.

MintyFreshOne · 15/02/2023 15:09

if we continue business as usual indefinitely we will make much of the planet we rely on uninhabitable

No, that is not certain.

Look at the recent floods in NZ the wild fires in Aus, the heat dome in the USA, the drought in CA, put these together and it's starting to look more and more apocalyptic

There have always been wildfires,
please read this about CA with an open mind: www.forbes.com/sites/michaelshellenberger/2020/08/24/stop-blaming-climate-change-for-californias-fires-many-forests-including-the-redwoods-need-them

Sadly it will be the global poor (esp. South) who are least equipped to mitigate the inevitable changes we have already caused

They are not equipped because of poverty. You’ll note that Singaporeans can handle cyclones better than, say, Bangladesh, because they have good infrastructure that protects them. The developing world needs more and better infrastructure. Not more handwringing and whingeing by Western countries.

Climate change will make poverty worse, ignoring climate change, or underplaying it, will condemn the poor to ever increasing hardship

No, the denial of literally lifesaving fossil
fuels will condemn them to hardship. Wherever industrialisation has occurred, death by climate has gone down. This is indisputable.

Daftasabroom · 15/02/2023 12:32

MintyFreshOne · 15/02/2023 10:06

That’s not the apocalypse that was promised.

There will be localized challenges (as there always is) but there’s not going to be anything planet-wide that will doom the human species. Not from climate change anyway.

I’m tired of people acting like there is. Imho living in poverty is far worse than anything related to climate change.

I'm not sure anyone has promised an apocalypse any time in the near future, but there is no doubt if we continue business as usual indefinitely we will make much of the planet we rely on uninhabitable. Look at the recent floods in NZ the wild fires in Aus, the heat dome in the USA, the drought in CA, put these together and it's starting to look more and more apocalyptic.

Sadly it will be the global poor (esp. South) who are least equipped to mitigate the inevitable changes we have already caused. Climate change will make poverty worse, ignoring climate change, or underplaying it, will condemn the poor to ever increasing hardship.

Alexandra2001 · 15/02/2023 12:02

MintyFreshOne · 15/02/2023 10:06

That’s not the apocalypse that was promised.

There will be localized challenges (as there always is) but there’s not going to be anything planet-wide that will doom the human species. Not from climate change anyway.

I’m tired of people acting like there is. Imho living in poverty is far worse than anything related to climate change.

So we wait until there is an apocalypse and its far too late to mitigate/limit any changes?
Seems a sensible policy but not one that any climate scientist suggests.

What we are seeing now and over time (avg temps, glacial melt, concentrations of gasses in atmosphere) is or should be, very concerning but no one cares enough to alter behaviors and this can only be done by Governments, we can't chose to use renewables or change transport policies or buy stuff that isn't for sale.... what the individual can do is very limited.

Mysticguru · 15/02/2023 11:52

Maybe arrogance is also part of the problem!!

DdraigGoch · 15/02/2023 10:38

Mysticguru · 14/02/2023 17:58

@Daftasabroom

Wildflowers are natural.

The seeds land wherever they fall.....

The packet you buy from Tesco might not be locally appropriate.

MintyFreshOne · 15/02/2023 10:06

Daftasabroom · 15/02/2023 08:19

AR5 was from 2014, you need AR6 from 2022. Granted I don't know anyone who has actually read all 2900+ pages.

Many Pacific Islands at high risk from rises in sea level, some have already been abandoned.

That’s not the apocalypse that was promised.

There will be localized challenges (as there always is) but there’s not going to be anything planet-wide that will doom the human species. Not from climate change anyway.

I’m tired of people acting like there is. Imho living in poverty is far worse than anything related to climate change.

Tumbleweed101 · 15/02/2023 08:25

I think the global response to Covid showed that we can work together as a globe so why aren't government doing so for climate change?

The current ways of doing things just seem to make life more expensive or impractical for poorer people to implement. Like cutting down electric or power or oil. Making these things expensive doesn't make things better unless the whole world is doing the same, it just makes people poor and uncomfortable, this gives little incentive on an individual level to take it seriously as just feel big cooperations are taking advantage.

Proper infastructure needs to be put into place. Proper bus and rail services to rural areas, nobody can give up their car if they literally can't get anywhere by other means. And it has to be financially viable for the poorest in our communities.

Until things like this are tackled then people haven't got the options and choices needed to make a difference in their daily lives. Things like reducing meat- make other food options cheaper. Eco friendly options are always the more expensive options and beyond the budgets of poorer people in the community.

I don't do as much as I should. I don't have time to cycle day to day, I don't have time to find locally grown produce as things are shut when I finish work. What I do as my bit to help is make sure my garden is as friendly to native plant species as possible and make areas for insects and animals to live and hide. Its the one thing I can do easily on a day to day basis.

Daftasabroom · 15/02/2023 08:19

MintyFreshOne · 14/02/2023 19:06

The planet being uninhabitable to human life doesn't seem preferable to me. Being poor isn't great but it's better than being dead

The planet won’t become uninhabitable, nothing in the IPCC AR5 has suggested it, so don’t know why you believe it

AR5 was from 2014, you need AR6 from 2022. Granted I don't know anyone who has actually read all 2900+ pages.

Many Pacific Islands at high risk from rises in sea level, some have already been abandoned.

To think most people are concerned about climate change... but
Daftasabroom · 15/02/2023 08:08

Elvis1956 · 14/02/2023 20:53

It's being presented wrongly. Rather than telling people that the earth is going to be destroyed...which most minds can't believe or deal with, the famine in China situation. Tell them taking steps to save themselves money also helps climate change.

personally I don't believe climate change is man made. HOWEVER, I
1 only boil the exact amount of water I need for tea/coffee/ect
2 have solar panels
3 batch cook
4 fitted low energy then led bulbs
5 buy economic card
6 cycled to work twice a week(when I had an office job)
Etc, ECT

it saves me money. As a by product I may be helping with climate change....As I could well be wrong in my views😁

It's both, taking positive steps will save you money and the planet.

I'm genuinely interested why you don't "believe" in climate change, could you explain why?

Daftasabroom · 14/02/2023 22:11

Mysticguru · 14/02/2023 17:58

@Daftasabroom

Wildflowers are natural.

The seeds land wherever they fall.....

Wild flowers are natural? That'll include the likes of Himalayan Balsam etc?

Please, just volunteer for your local wildlife trust. They would be so happy to someone as motivated as you are.

Swipe left for the next trending thread