Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think most people are concerned about climate change... but

315 replies

hopewithoutpanic · 10/02/2023 06:43

Don't know what they can personally do to make an impact?

We can see the fires, floods and impact climate change is having in both near and far places.

It has to be a concern, right? This is something that could make our planet dramatically different within our and our children's lifetimes.

Would I be correct in thinking the issue is that is individuals just don't know what (aside from recycling / trying to reduce meat etc) they can do to make a real difference?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
MintyFreshOne · 10/02/2023 09:14

Our balance of trade is vastly different to eg China's. A lot of their domestic emissions are tied up in the goods they produce for export

If they didn’t have UK as a market, you think they’d stop manufacturing?

Life has become so much better in China since they’ve developed their export-oriented economy (like Japan, Taiwan and South Korea before them), and they have markets outside of the UK to sell their products to as well. They don’t need the UK specifically.

Im not in the West these days and I have seen cheap Chinese goods flood our markets in the last few years, which has been only a good thing, as the local alternatives were too expensive and not that much better in quality tbh.

JassyRadlett · 10/02/2023 09:13

This could be the great Brexit benefit - trade deals that give preferential tariffs access for lower emission imports eg non-deforestation palm oil and soya.

Somehow I'm sceptical that this government would do it....

JizzlordTheCat · 10/02/2023 09:10

I think most people don’t care about climate change.

When the narrative becomes “I’m so worried about the future for my three children”, you know it’s already pointless.

lifeinthehills · 10/02/2023 09:09

MintyFreshOne · 10/02/2023 09:07

False choice. We don’t have to accept it at all, why do you think we do?

We have enough fossil fuels to last for centuries (although naturally I’d prefer a nuclear program like in France)

Centuries or not, there's going to be a time when it all runs out. I haven't put a time frame on it.

JassyRadlett · 10/02/2023 09:09

MintyFreshOne · 10/02/2023 08:55

Rich Western countries didn’t offshore so politicians can brag about emission reductions so why frame it this way?

By now, China can sell to countries outside the West anyway, and are doing just that to diversify their markets. They don’t need Western investments like they did thirty years ago. Things have moved on.

No one suggested that it was done for PR. Just that pointing to domestic production emissions as a 'we don't make a difference anyway!' get out is a bit misleading when a significant proportion of our emissions (Uni of Leeds seems to suggest 40-50%) are on someone else's books.

And as a PP points out, the per capita emissions aren't that rosy for the UK either...

Don't get me wrong, I think it's the systems that need to change and there are severe limits to individual action. But the 'tiny island, low emissions!' argument doesn't really stack up as much when you look at our per capita emissions, or our consumption, or what our money eg pension funds is actually paying for in other countries.

thebellagio · 10/02/2023 09:08

Another point that I've been trying to make at school is that the teachers are always teaching the kids about what's making the planet unhealthy. If my 7yo sees some litter, she literally says "mummy, someone naughty is making the earth sick" and she's absolutely right. It's great that schools are pushing this to the children.

BUT.

As an example, World Book Day is coming up. I (and several other parents) have emailed the HT asking to know sooner rather than later if it's a dress up day, so people have time to save up rather than being lumbered with the cost of several costumes a day or two in advance. I've asked that we don't do dress up, because of the sustainability issue. How can we tell children that we need to protect the environment one week and then tell them that they should go to Sainsbury's and spend £15 on a polyester costume that was probably made in China in a sweatshop and will only be worn once (at most)? Even if you freecycle it and pass it on, you're only getting 4-5 wears out of it before someone chucks it in landfill.

ForTheLoveOfSleep · 10/02/2023 09:07

Daftasabroom · 10/02/2023 08:58

I understand per capita however that means not a lot in terms of the whole picture. All that really matters is total emmissions. The UK makes no impact on overall numbers as a nation as if we suddenly didn't exist no difference would be made to the current climate change models.

The only way to stop climate change is to research and develop renewable energies that are cheaper for the world.

Daftasabroom · 10/02/2023 09:07

@Sunnytomorrow great post but you left off:

  1. Get involved. Learn about sustainable strategies, become an advocate or champion at work, at your sports and social clubs, in your local community, stand for your local council.

Every little counts it really does.

MintyFreshOne · 10/02/2023 09:07

lifeinthehills · 10/02/2023 09:01

Yes, and either we accept shorter and shitter, or we accept we'll eventually use up the earth's resources.

False choice. We don’t have to accept it at all, why do you think we do?

We have enough fossil fuels to last for centuries (although naturally I’d prefer a nuclear program like in France)

Sunnytomorrow · 10/02/2023 09:06

@Daftasabroom , this book sounds fascinating! I am definitely going to read it, thank you for sharing it (and for summarising).

follyfoot37 · 10/02/2023 09:05

ForTheLoveOfSleep · 10/02/2023 08:47

The reality is as a nation the is absolutely nothing the UK can do. The UK is responsible for 1.03% if Co2 emissions. If the UK disappeared tomorrow its would have zero impact on climate change.

China - 29%
US - 14%
India - 7%

The only way to slove climate change is more investment and research in cheaper renewable energy. Because the above countries only care about economic growth.

We pretty much have renewable energy, but guess wgich countries do not want us to stop using their fossil fuels?
No doubt governments are being paid handsome backhanders to make a noise about climate but do nothing

lifeinthehills · 10/02/2023 09:03

Its no wonder that people turn and think "fuck it, what's the point"

This is pretty much where I'm at.

JassyRadlett · 10/02/2023 09:02

ForTheLoveOfSleep · 10/02/2023 08:51

Therefore we can assume the same for at least a portion of the highest countries' emissions too.

Oh what basis would you make that assumption?

Basic maths, as well as common sense, would indicate that 'that must be the same for everyone' must be nonsense (and 'for at least a portion' makes no sense when you're looking at countries' overall emissions) - someone is manufacturing that stuff for us, and that manufacturing is showing up in their domestic emissions.

Our balance of trade is vastly different to eg China's. A lot of their domestic emissions are tied up in the goods they produce for export.

We export a lot less, particularly manufacturing exports. We import a lot more. Demonising China while simultaneously outsourcing our emissions to them, India, Brazil et al is just a teeny bit hypocritical.

thebellagio · 10/02/2023 09:02

It does feel futile doesn't it?

For the last few elections, I've voted Green party (mainly as a protest vote). Ive used the same shopping bags for about 10 years. I've upgraded my boiler and windows to improve the efficiency of my home. I've added solar panels. I do less than 4,000 miles a year in my car. I've had one short haul flight in the last 5 years. I have a compost heap where I put as much as possible. I recycle as much as I can. I have a water butt for the garden in the summer to save water. My hobby is sewing, so I try to make as much of my own clothes as possible (although admittedly the fabric is not UK made).

For most of this, I do it without even thinking about it. I wouldn't even think of myself as a "particularly green" person - its all just positive habits. I would argue that most people in the UK are probably fairly similar - we know to use our own shopping bags, we know to recycle etc, but no matter what I do, my efforts will amount to absolutely fuck all when the industries aren't even TRYING to make an effort.

i drove through my town centre at night recently. So many offices (including my former employer) had all the lights on (cos safety innit) all the time. And at the exact same time, we were all being told to preserve energy to prevent blackouts. Its a joke. Its no wonder that people turn and think "fuck it, what's the point"

Daftasabroom · 10/02/2023 09:01

Hungrycaterpillarsmummy · 10/02/2023 08:59

Oh yes, I agree. I do recycle. But I know there is very little impact!

It has a huge impact when 28 million households do it!

lifeinthehills · 10/02/2023 09:01

MintyFreshOne · 10/02/2023 08:57

They should try to live locally like their great-grandparents did. Life was short, shit and usually one or more of your kids died along the way.

Yes, and either we accept shorter and shitter, or we accept we'll eventually use up the earth's resources.

lifeinthehills · 10/02/2023 09:00

MonicaFree · 10/02/2023 08:55

Sorry but this is soooo naive. ‘Live locally’?!

Ha! No one local to you makes smart phones or the components. No-one local to you manufactures the screens for your television. Or mines the component elements and metals. No one local to you grows rice. No one local to you manufacturers sieves or driveway materials or fluorescent tubing.

You get the picture. Well meaning but stupid people like to imagine we need farmers markets. Whatever makes you feel better. The actual problem is getting raw ingredients for modern life out of the ground and then shipping these and other commodities from A to B.

Yes, and that's along the lines of what I said in another post. We don't need those phones really. We might want them, but we don't need them. It is possible to live locally, plenty of people do, some live off grid quite self-sufficiently. I source all my fruit and vegetables from local sources. We might not be able to get every food item we want all the time, or even ever, if we eat within a certain radius (it's a whole movement), but we'd have to accept that. And less medical advances. In short, we need to accept shorter, less comfortable lives. But we don't want that.

Hungrycaterpillarsmummy · 10/02/2023 08:59

lifeinthehills · 10/02/2023 08:51

It makes people feel better that they are 'doing their bit', whether it makes much difference or not.

Oh yes, I agree. I do recycle. But I know there is very little impact!

Daftasabroom · 10/02/2023 08:58

ForTheLoveOfSleep · 10/02/2023 08:47

The reality is as a nation the is absolutely nothing the UK can do. The UK is responsible for 1.03% if Co2 emissions. If the UK disappeared tomorrow its would have zero impact on climate change.

China - 29%
US - 14%
India - 7%

The only way to slove climate change is more investment and research in cheaper renewable energy. Because the above countries only care about economic growth.

Consumption based GHG Emissions per capita:

China - 7.04
USA - 15.47
India - 1.63

UK - 6.93

investment and research in cheaper renewable energy

MintyFreshOne · 10/02/2023 08:57

MonicaFree · 10/02/2023 08:55

Sorry but this is soooo naive. ‘Live locally’?!

Ha! No one local to you makes smart phones or the components. No-one local to you manufactures the screens for your television. Or mines the component elements and metals. No one local to you grows rice. No one local to you manufacturers sieves or driveway materials or fluorescent tubing.

You get the picture. Well meaning but stupid people like to imagine we need farmers markets. Whatever makes you feel better. The actual problem is getting raw ingredients for modern life out of the ground and then shipping these and other commodities from A to B.

They should try to live locally like their great-grandparents did. Life was short, shit and usually one or more of your kids died along the way.

Sunnytomorrow · 10/02/2023 08:56

You’re right that it seems futile to make individual changes when a lot of the climate damage is happening at the national level or by huge multi-national companies. However, it is not, as there are two sides to the climate ‘coin’ (demand and supply). If we (customers) change what we demand, then the main polluters (big companies and our government) will be forced to change what they deliver/supply.

In other words, our actions do matter: as they drive the actions of the big polluters.

Another issue is that the ‘true’ cost of the polluting activities (burning fossil fuels) isn’t reflected in the economic cost borne by the polluter. They don’t pay for the damage that we, as society, suffer via pollution and climate change. This means that the price point for polluting activities is kept artificially low. This can usually only be fixed by using taxes and government action to make polluters pay the full cost. But we aren’t powerless here either - as we can tell those who represent us democratically that this is an important issue.

Here are the main things you can do:

  1. If possible, change your electricity provider to one who uses renewable energy. If even 10% more people did this, it would send a clear signal to both electricity and traditional fossil fuel energy companies (Shell etc) that it would be worth their while financially to do more to invest in these areas.
  2. Email your MP and ask them what they are doing to support measures to counter climate change. Tell them that you care. Tell them you will be voting for MPs who also care.
  3. Email your favourite large companies and ask them the same question. If you receive an unsatisfactory answer or no answer at all, ask the same question again but this time publicly (using social media). Companies will have to factor in the cost of negative publicity if they continue to make poor climate choices.
  4. Don’t worry that it’s not perfect. Sure, there will be some greenwashing, but it’s all part of a process to re-educate the worse culprits and society as a whole (and mitigate and relieve some of the worst aspects of climate change in the meantime).
  5. Continue to do the little things: recycle your yoghurt pots, use renewable shopping bags, etc. If nothing else, it sets a good example to our children. Who knows, perhaps a child of someone here on Mumsnet will be the future prime minister or someone who invents an amazing technical solution? We need to make sure that our kids care about this issue too.

Finally, let’s continue to talk about it on forums such as this! It helps us to know we aren’t alone.

MintyFreshOne · 10/02/2023 08:55

ForTheLoveOfSleep · 10/02/2023 08:51

Therefore we can assume the same for at least a portion of the highest countries' emissions too.

Rich Western countries didn’t offshore so politicians can brag about emission reductions so why frame it this way?

By now, China can sell to countries outside the West anyway, and are doing just that to diversify their markets. They don’t need Western investments like they did thirty years ago. Things have moved on.

MonicaFree · 10/02/2023 08:55

lifeinthehills · 10/02/2023 08:05

We need to quit the shipping and live locally for starters. Most people aren't willing to give up the convenience shipping items around the world gives them though.

Sorry but this is soooo naive. ‘Live locally’?!

Ha! No one local to you makes smart phones or the components. No-one local to you manufactures the screens for your television. Or mines the component elements and metals. No one local to you grows rice. No one local to you manufacturers sieves or driveway materials or fluorescent tubing.

You get the picture. Well meaning but stupid people like to imagine we need farmers markets. Whatever makes you feel better. The actual problem is getting raw ingredients for modern life out of the ground and then shipping these and other commodities from A to B.

Whydoitry · 10/02/2023 08:55

A lot of people make excuses to avoid having to change. "X takes 100 flights a year, but I only take 10 so it's ok" kind of thing.

Or have a mental aversion / socially derived aversion eg using family cloth or showering every other day to save water.

People want quick and effortless. I was depressed last summer with attitudes to water during the heatwave.

NerdyBird1 · 10/02/2023 08:54

ComtesseDeSpair · 10/02/2023 08:47

I think a lot of people actually just don’t care, to be honest. I don’t. I’ll be dead by the time things get really bad and I truly don’t care what happens to the humans after me. Not my problem. A lot of people dress up their “I actually don’t care” with arguments about “well, whilst X, Y, Z is going on in industry and other countries it seems pointless for me to bother recycling my yoghurt pots” etc, but the baseline is lack of care.

Presuming you don't have children, it's not so bad and I say this as someone who cares very much

Swipe left for the next trending thread