Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Covid primary schooling and virtual lessons

185 replies

Merryoldgoat · 09/02/2023 21:29

I’ll try to be brief - I’ve been speaking to a friend from a different area who I’ve not had a proper catch up with in about 2 years.

She said during the school closures her primary aged children (Y3&Y4 at the start) had virtual lessons every school day.

Not for the full school day but about 2-3 hours depending on the lesson.

Normal state school in a mixed area.

Was this normal? We didn’t have a single online lesson.

YABU - my kid’s school had regular virtual lessons

YANBU - no virtual lessons at my kid’s school.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ethelredonagoodday · 10/02/2023 13:57

Conversely my friend's children's school, which is a very high achieving state school (has been in the top ten primaries), sent absolutely nothing home.

ethelredonagoodday · 10/02/2023 13:55

The first lockdown we had very little; workbooks that kids work through if they wanted to. 2nd lockdown we had online lessons that were available every day with probably a couple of hours work to do...

noblegiraffe · 10/02/2023 11:21

The teacher strikes, despite what some claim, do have public support, and have more support in the age group that are most likely to have school-aged children.

alsonotmyname · 10/02/2023 11:20

We had nothing much in 1st lockdown but 2nd was 9-10 lesson with an hour to continue the work, 11-12 lesson with an hour after to do work, afternoon lessons were pre recorded but work was handed in by 3pm, 3-3.30 was story time/ assembly etc
I had 2 in primary and a toddler, it was hard work and looking back I wish I hadn't done any of it as it was so stressful and even thinking about it now sends my heart rate up

cantkeepawayforever · 10/02/2023 10:40

We used to unmute all and sing Happy Birthday to anyone whose birthday was that day. A truly horrible time-lagged cacophony but very cheery!

Attictroll · 10/02/2023 10:37

@Abraxan no we saw no government Chromebook's it was doing something like this I think www.pcworld.com/article/393375/how-to-turn-a-laptop-into-a-chromebook.html
Which is a hack I need to remember
Also the school seemed to know how to get any devise whether a games console or whatever to do Teams 😂
The first day was a bit crazy with everything getting going but the school closed the first day back after Xmas when the schools were closed telling parents it was to train teachers and get kit to all.
My work actually lent my son an old office laptop as my boss was in a similar boat so dug out some and offered parents in the team. This led me to encourage other parents to ask around a bit.

To some extent it wasn't proper school but it was lovely I still remember crying on day 2 when teacher did a singing lesson online and said it was really good as when they had been back in they hadn't been able to sing. Hearing 30 8 year olds weekly sing abba songs was cheery during that awful lockdown January

MatronicO6 · 10/02/2023 10:32

In my state primary we did live lessons from 9-12. Then we provided video lessons for the afternoon for kids to watch and do in own time. We also phone called each family once a week for a catch up. We also had online assemblies, online talent show, online lunch clubs for children to just chat to friends. All kids who had EHCP's were invited to come into school.

cantkeepawayforever · 10/02/2023 10:31

I would love to see, by the way, a full study on different models of ‘remote learning’, for which lockdown schooling would provide a huge bank of data.

It’s a really unusual situation, in which both teachers and pupils started as total novices - nothing in teacher training or leadership training covered mass delivery of remote learning - and as a result there was a mass of different approaches; providers; timetables; teaching and feedback routes ; technology etc etc. Its rapid evolution, adaptation and refinement was hectic, and often involved blind alleys and inefficient approaches.

What I think is lacking is a really full evaluation- what REALLy led to best learning? Is ‘live online delivery of lessons’ really a gold standard? Does the best approach depend on age? Are the critical factors actually nothing to do with the delivery, but all about the home environment? How do differences between socio-economic groups affect this? What about provision for SEN children, particularly those who follow an adapted curriculum or who require 1:1 support to access work in the classroom?

I am not sure that the answers about genuinely effective learning online will be quite the same as we might expect, and what we are likely to find is that there is no ‘one size fits all’.

cantkeepawayforever · 10/02/2023 10:20

I don’t know, at the time we only had one primary age child and our other child was still able to attend nursery, so it wasn’t something we had to deal with.

It was really tricky for schools, because for every child in your position - a parent able to work 1:1 with a child with a suitable device - there will have been at least one (and often many) for whom that would have been utterly impractical and actively excluding.

Given all the other demands on schools at the time - as well as all the other personal considerations for school staff such as their own children; tech access; social work; vulnerable relatives - decisions around ‘best fit for the greatest number’ often meant ‘not really ideal for anyone’.

MajorCarolDanvers · 10/02/2023 10:17

2 things I will not forget

My dyslexic child receiving worksheet after worksheet she could not use - we gave up and she watched newsround.

My older child being expected to learn Spanish from scratch by PDF. - he didn't.

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 10/02/2023 09:59

MarshaBradyo · 10/02/2023 09:40

it was horrendous as it was knowing that a few weeks would be a term pretty much and seeing dc go past to school while more online and isolation from peers.

But this way of doing it was so bad. I really felt for anyone faced with this.

It was indeed! I was grateful not to live within earshot of a school at that time.

The rules functionally excluding primary aged children from socialising outside school were another highlight. We took fuck all notice and were 100% ethically justified in that, but many children had virtually no interaction at all during that period.

Nimbostratus100 · 10/02/2023 09:50

online lessons were neither desirable not possible in many schools

cantkeepawayforever · 10/02/2023 09:44

(In second lockdown, teachers delivered the same content to everyone from home, while support staff took on the role of ‘parents’ for the children in school,
viewing the same teacher content and completing the sane tasks, which teachers marked alongside the work from children doing it at home. Was as fair as we could make it)

Marmite27 · 10/02/2023 09:43

cantkeepawayforever · 10/02/2023 09:41

Marmote, how did that work fir families with eg 3 children, sharing a device, or families where parents were working all day and caught up schooling outside those hours?

We staggered ‘live’ sessions for different years, and recorded everything to be played at different times, to accommodate this - would that have been possible for you? I did a lot of weekend support for families who had to ‘catch up’ the week’s learning at weekends when adults in the family were free, as for the younger children it was very hard to complete work without any adult support.

I don’t know, at the time we only had one primary age child and our other child was still able to attend nursery, so it wasn’t something we had to deal with.

cantkeepawayforever · 10/02/2023 09:41

Marmote, how did that work fir families with eg 3 children, sharing a device, or families where parents were working all day and caught up schooling outside those hours?

We staggered ‘live’ sessions for different years, and recorded everything to be played at different times, to accommodate this - would that have been possible for you? I did a lot of weekend support for families who had to ‘catch up’ the week’s learning at weekends when adults in the family were free, as for the younger children it was very hard to complete work without any adult support.

MarshaBradyo · 10/02/2023 09:40

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 10/02/2023 08:27

Our school never did anything like that in either lockdown. One of my DC is SEN but there was no support in relation to that either.

I wasn't as bothered about the lack of education in the first lockdown because nobody else was getting any either, or nobody in state primary schools that I could see anyway. In 2021, on the other hand, about 40% of their classes were in, and the curriculum wasn't suspended that time. Those DC got the usual education with much better ratios, mine got two minutes of video a day and one phone call a week if they remembered and rang at a time I wasn't working. The legal minimum that was considered sufficient for those unworthy of schooling.

it was horrendous as it was knowing that a few weeks would be a term pretty much and seeing dc go past to school while more online and isolation from peers.

But this way of doing it was so bad. I really felt for anyone faced with this.

Marmite27 · 10/02/2023 09:37

We had 5 virtual lessons a day for reception class. Plus some scheduled time for playing out/YouTube workouts in lieu of PE.

cantkeepawayforever · 10/02/2023 09:35

It was a difficult and emotive time, because there were essentially two irreconcilable factors:

  • The right of all children to receive an education
  • The right of school employees to have a safe workplace, based on the knowledge of Covid at the time (a constantly moving goalpost)

In the first lockdown, the Government formally suspended the first factor. They suspended the curriculum, and directed schools to supply other services - principally childcare for kw parents, but also social care, food distribution etc.

In the event, most schools decided to continue their educational role in some format, insofar as that was possible within the contradictory guidance at the time (the June guidance, directing schools to take back in a number of children that it was impossible to accommodate under the struct rules laid out in the same document, was a particular highlight).

It us interesting that ‘online live teaching’ became the perceived ‘gold standard’ in the MN eye. Yes, it was better for some - like questions about homework in Ofsted parent surveys, it absolutely split parents down the middle in real life.

We delivered a mix of live, recorded, work on online platforms, and offline work uploaded (plus kw provision, in school teaching of those year groups returned to school in June, and continued social work). In our experience, impact and engagement was not a function of ‘delivery route’, but of rapid feedback, and availability to solve problems immediately. So same day, preferably same hour, response to any uploaded work; instant e-mail response to parental queries at any time of day or night; afternoon pick-ip sessions on anything causing difficulties in the day’s curriculum; personal phone or video calls - those grew engagement. Whizzy live lessons - much less so, especially in families who were device poor.

Rosie232 · 10/02/2023 09:31

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Botw1 · 10/02/2023 09:15

@Dragonsandcats

The contempt is visible on this thread. It was visible during covid on sm where some teachers were posting about their lovely long summer holiday and teaching unions campaigning to keep schools closed. Where some teachers were saying things like I hope you can explain to your kids why they've killed their teacher because you can't be arsed to look after them (genuine comment I saw on Facebook)

It's a shame relationships have broken down to such a combatative nature for some

Im not sure what the solution is.

Parents feel let down and are justifiably furious at how badly children were let down.

Teachers feel attacked and defensive.

Ultimately the govt are to blame. Just like they are to blame for the destruction of the NHS.

But if a nurse kills someone they can't stand up in court and say it was the govt fault. They are held responsible

I agree with @Futurethoughts

The damage to perception for lots of parents is done.

I still support the strikes though

cantkeepawayforever · 10/02/2023 09:07

I think that what is odd about the OP’s posting us that she feels that the period from 23rd March (start of first lockdown) to 1st June 2020 (if I read her DC’s ages correctly, they were of the age included in the partial ‘return to school’ from that date) is critical in deciding her judgement of her child’s school and in affecting their attitude to school long term.

She has already said that her child was in school for the second lockdown, so only the first, when the curriculum was suspended and there was no guidance fur schools, is relevant.

I really can’t see why this relatively short period is so critical. It is entirely possible that attitude to school is much more shaped by other things - the move from a play-based curriculum in Reception to more formal learning in Year 1; social development of others making it increasingly hard for a child with difficulties in that area; increasing needs within the class; departure of key teachers as part of the overall exodus from the profession; reducing staffing ratios with increasing age and reducing budget.

Equally, it is entirely possible that the school isn’t great - a move from Good to RI could indicate either a change in quality or a weakness in an area Ofsted us now looking deeply into or reflect the difficulties inherent in increasing need, decreasing budget and departing staff.

IME, type of lockdown learning delivered (live online; recorded; worksheet / online tools) is not necessarily tightly correlated to ‘general school quality’. A complex mixture of factors influenced it - number of kw parents; socio-economic mix; age and life stage of teachers; previous decisions on tech investment and tech confidence of heads; local broadband speed; even local Covid prevalence (those in ‘early peak’ areas were battling with the challenges and emotional aftermath of critically ill staff and parents as much as education.

Overall, it seems very ofd to focus on this short and highly abnormal single period - a matter of weeks for the OP, though much longer for others - in their child’s life rather than the much longer period when they have actually been in school.

MistressIggi · 10/02/2023 09:05

Whereas, my son's BB shut during lockdown, didn't contact us once, and never reopened.

MajorCarolDanvers · 10/02/2023 09:03

The only online experience or interactions my kids got was from Cubs and Scouts delivered by volunteers.

MistressIggi · 10/02/2023 09:03

@HufflepuffRavenclaw I can see then that was your experience, but it's not the case that all Scottish schools were closed until Easter, which is what I thought you were saying.

MajorCarolDanvers · 10/02/2023 09:02

work in Scotland. The second lockdown, in terms of schools, didn't last till Easter. I was in teaching half classes for a few weeks in March, and seniors with practical classes were in more than that. Was that not Scotland-wide then?

My primary school child got back in Natch but my high school child was halfway through April.

Practical classes didn't return for many months longer.