Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it’s no more acceptable to dig up ancient graves than it would be to dig up recent ones?

158 replies

AngeloMysterioso · 09/02/2023 18:22

I follow a few historical Instagram accounts and one has just posted about a c. 1000 year old mummified body that has just been unearthed from an underground tomb in Peru.

It looks as though this poor person died in a fairly horrific way and now it’s remains are on display in a glass box with people taking pictures a few feet away.

AIBU to think these people should be left well alone to rest in peace with the same respect and dignity that we afford to people who died last week?

OP posts:
EmmaEmerald · 09/02/2023 19:36

Sparklingbrook · 09/02/2023 19:32

Let the historians have a nose and do whatever they feel they have to do if it absolutely has to be dug up but no need for the display.

Historians don't have to do anything though, in cases as old as OP mentions.

SliceOfCakeCupOfTea · 09/02/2023 19:35

But displaying them sparks interest to others which drives demand for more discoveries to be made, more research to be done and inspires generations of future archeological/anthropologists/historians etc.

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 09/02/2023 19:34

I think it's fascinating.

We can learn a lot from human remains and part of that education happens when we visually examine them so we can see that they suffered from X because of Y, or that they clearly did A because of B and C.

terrywynne · 09/02/2023 19:33

We have a lot more sensitivity around exhumation and human remains these days. The accounts of digging up the bodies of notable figures in the 18th and 19th centuries are horrific (you could try googling discovery of Katherine Parr's body but I put a huge TW on it). I think we are still catching up when it comes to cultural sensitivities around bodies that have been removed from their country and displayed in museums elsewhere but steps are being taken to address that (by some institutions at least) and it is a developing field of museum ethics.

That said, in the UK there are thousands of burials. In a town near me there are several old churchyards that are under squares/roundabouts now and most people don't even know there are bodies there. It is unfortunately inevitable that bodies will be disturbed - in most cases though they will simply be reinterred. Pp have already addressed the issues of what happens on a construction site if there isn't archaeological excavation. And the archaeological research does improve our understanding of our history. For example, the Mary Rose Museum have done some analysis of remains found on the shipwreck which has determined that the crew members were not all white English, that they included people from the Mediterranean region, and mixed race people who grew up in England. That is information we could not get from other records and it develops our understanding of 16th century English society.

The display of the remains in museums is tricky. Personally I prefer the reconstructions from the remains because I think it is easier to relate to a "human" than to the bones. I think it is difficult for museums though because people have strongly opposing views and they are unlikely to please everyone.

Sparklingbrook · 09/02/2023 19:32

Let the historians have a nose and do whatever they feel they have to do if it absolutely has to be dug up but no need for the display.

EmmaEmerald · 09/02/2023 19:27

I love history
I was thinking about this earlier today

I do think there's an acceptable time gap and I'm okay with 1000 years but I'm not sure where the lower limit is for me.

re public display, it's not something I'd want to see. But equally, I understand why it's a bit unfair to have historians able to see and no one else. It's a dilemma.

Saucery · 09/02/2023 19:26

Yes, of course, QuertyGirl! Your work is incredibly valuable and necessary, but the body should then be kept in closed storage and not viewed by everyone who fancies it.

DraconianDen · 09/02/2023 19:26

But we’ve learnt an awful lot about history by investigating human remains, for example how someone died can tell us about what weapons/tools they may have had at the time, etc. I’m not sure what the time frame is that makes it acceptable but I don’t find it distasteful in the slightest. I’d be happy to be dug up and examined in the future!

I’ve visited the catacombs in Paris and found them fascinating (they ran out of space for graveyards and wanted to build over existing ones so they relocated the bones to a series of underground tunnels where they’ve laid all the bones out in patterns). I’ve also been to the Egyptian Museum in Cairo where Tutankhamen is - imagine the history and knowledge we’d have missed out on if Howard Carter hadn’t entered his tomb!

I do wonder if religion affects people’s feelings on this; I’m a staunch atheist so to me once you’re dead your body is just a pile of atoms, there is no longer a ‘person’ there for me.

Namechangedatheist · 09/02/2023 19:26

Sparklingbrook · 09/02/2023 19:15

She kept him in a box and called him Harold.

Sad Why did they not rebury the box?

It's fair to say she was a touch eccentric.
She was my son's piano teacher, and we found out about Harold when we collected DS1 at the the end of one lesson and discovered him surrounded by Harold's remains and other archeological finds from her garden.
He thought it was brilliant 🤣.
Not sure how much piano he'd done that lesson...

TreehousePine · 09/02/2023 19:25

I agree OP 100%. Leave them to rest in peace.

QuertyGirl · 09/02/2023 19:23

Take a peasant woman who had more than a dozen pregnancies in her life time, buried half of them and worked herself to a short, agonising old age.

There are no written records of her. Her story was told because I dug her up.

It was either me, or a quarry cutting machine.

thegreenlight · 09/02/2023 19:21

Only in America is a body buried ‘in perpetuity’ otherwise you are just buried for about 100 and then your bones will either have decayed to nothing, or will be exhumed and moved to an ossuary (bone collection) as those in the catacombs or Paris or the gorgeous displays in other areas of mainland Europe. There is also only a finite amount of space and to be buried forever is an impossibility. I favour aquamation.

QuertyGirl · 09/02/2023 19:21

I don't get the problem with displaying them generally.

They're dead. We can learn from them. Staring at an Egyptian mummy in a museum every Sunday was my favourite thing as a child.

UdoU · 09/02/2023 19:19

I don’t mind old graves being re-used, but yes, displaying a body is grim.

When I die, I wanted to be buried until my bones turn into fossil fuels.

I don’t care if they build graves on top of mine.

MavisFlump · 09/02/2023 19:19

Saucery · 09/02/2023 19:14

Is that the monk who had a genetic disease that informed research into the development of the condition? I was a bit uncomfortable with that display, if so.

I think bodies should be studied if historically appropriate, then reburied or stored respectfully.

I agree @Saucery , it seems very disrespectful to display someone like that.
I feel very uneasy about excavated bones just being left in boxes on a shelf somewhere too.

QuertyGirl · 09/02/2023 19:18

They're dead. They can't consent to anything and, as another archaeologist has pointed out, they need to be dug up to preserve them.

Sometimes it's either a JCB or an archaeologist.

I've lost count of how many burials I've dug. It's just calcium etc. The person is gone.

I see it as more respectful, to study them and bring their memories alive again.

It's also important to actually understand history- skeletons from the industrial revolution onwards for example demonstrate quite graphically, why we need safety standards in the workplace and the NHS.

gamerchick · 09/02/2023 19:16

Soubriquet · 09/02/2023 18:25

I always wonder what the limit is between grave desecration/robbing and archeology

I think the same.

I'm getting those ancient fetal ejection bodies being dug up in my Facebook feed atm. Leave the poor buggers alone.

Sparklingbrook · 09/02/2023 19:15

She kept him in a box and called him Harold.

Sad Why did they not rebury the box?

Saucery · 09/02/2023 19:14

ShakespearesBlister · 09/02/2023 18:52

I live near an old Abbey ruin. In the local museum is the skeleton of a Monk which was excavated from the ruin. I really don't feel it's right having his remains on display as an exhibit to be gawped at.

Is that the monk who had a genetic disease that informed research into the development of the condition? I was a bit uncomfortable with that display, if so.

I think bodies should be studied if historically appropriate, then reburied or stored respectfully.

ThreeLittleDots · 09/02/2023 19:14

Whether or not they're dug up doesn't influence whether they're "resting in peace" or not. They're not resting, they're dead and do not have any existence at all, peaceful or not.

FourAndTwentyBlackbirdsBakedInAPie · 09/02/2023 19:13

I'm quite shocked so many people have said it's fine. Its really interesting to see different opinions.

For those who say it's OK, what would be the time period where it would become uncomfortable for you to think of bodies being on display?

How do you feel about mass graves being discovered? Do you think they should be left where they are, or be buried within the rituals of their people? (Many from the 70s-80s time period but some around 100 years on).

(Not being snarky at all, just interested).

Namechangedatheist · 09/02/2023 19:10

Someone we knew was having some work done in her garden about 20 years ago. Work stopped when a skeleton was uncovered. When the police identified that it was ancient the remains were sent off to Oxford University for analysis. 6 months later she received a parcel returning the remains.
He was a young adult male who died about 1000 years ago and his cause of death most likely the result of an abscess in his jaw.
She kept him in a box and called him Harold. 🤣.
I really can't see an issue with this.

MissHoollie · 09/02/2023 19:02

I guess I don't know enough to make a judgment.
We once were in an old graveyard as we enjoy history and there were obvious human bones scattered around . A whole hand etc
Some of the graves had sunk and ground eroded.
We phoned the council who said it was a common issue and they didn't do anything .

Soubriquet · 09/02/2023 19:00

I find it interesting that victorians used to exhume mummies just so they could eat them.

RaininSummer · 09/02/2023 18:59

I think it's pretty nasty. This is half of the reason I want to cremated.