Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it’s no more acceptable to dig up ancient graves than it would be to dig up recent ones?

158 replies

AngeloMysterioso · 09/02/2023 18:22

I follow a few historical Instagram accounts and one has just posted about a c. 1000 year old mummified body that has just been unearthed from an underground tomb in Peru.

It looks as though this poor person died in a fairly horrific way and now it’s remains are on display in a glass box with people taking pictures a few feet away.

AIBU to think these people should be left well alone to rest in peace with the same respect and dignity that we afford to people who died last week?

OP posts:
purpledalmation · 09/02/2023 20:36

Timesawastin · 09/02/2023 18:26

Hard disagree. They are only remains, the person has long long gone and their relatives ditto. Fwiw archaeologists do give extra care to human remains.

I'll be giving my body to medical science once I'm dead. My mother, like most, was cremated. How is burning better?

agree with this. The person is no longer there and the remains are of historic significance.

terrywynne · 09/02/2023 20:34

SliceOfCakeCupOfTea · 09/02/2023 20:30

If I remember correctly, Henry aggressively pursued her and her dad ordered her to marry him.
I'm not sure she had much choice...

There was a netflix docudrama about her recently - a bit modern in style for my taste but the historian talk heads were interesting and gave the impression that she did have some agency (within the context of the time) so not just a pawn.

In terms of knowing what to expect in terms of executions, the treason executions really ramp up after her death. Henry VIII executed a lot of nobility but if you look at the dates most of them are in 1536-1547 so I don't think it is far to say she should went in knowing what to expect.

SliceOfCakeCupOfTea · 09/02/2023 20:30

EmmaEmerald · 09/02/2023 20:24

I hope Anne will forgive me for saying it...but she wasn't young, and she grew up mostly in court. My memory is awful but he must have executed a dozen or more for "treason" in her day. If she chose him, she knew he was about. But I haven't read enough to know how free she felt to make that decision.

She must have been a very strong, even egotistical, person, in order to think England would back her as the new Queen.

hopefully this is a sensible thread and not the Monty Python argument sketch, so I don't need to say that I don't approve of beheading her! I just don't see as a young girl being beheaded in the same way as, perhaps, Lady Jane Grey.

If I remember correctly, Henry aggressively pursued her and her dad ordered her to marry him.
I'm not sure she had much choice...

SliceOfCakeCupOfTea · 09/02/2023 20:27

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 09/02/2023 20:19

Maybe it's just me, but I don't really get the fascination at looking at human bones as a tourist attraction. They all look pretty much the same (to the layperson), anyway, don't they?

Unless somebody told you and/or you knew the context, would most of us really be able to tell the difference between the bones of Henry VII and those of Derek Perkins who lived in a village 300 miles away at the same time?

But that's why they're displayed, usually with information and context surrounding them. Tour guides and school telling the stories

EmmaEmerald · 09/02/2023 20:24

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 09/02/2023 20:10

Ah, OK, maybe that particular story was indeed invented, then; but there's no doubting that monarchs and other powerful people through history have treated innocent people appallingly, just on whim.

I always think of Anne Boleyn and how she must actually have felt, when she knew she was about to be brutally murdered as a young woman as 'punishment' for her husband wanting to be married to somebody else instead. I know she put on a brave, dignified face (according to the history books, anyway); but what must have been going through her head in the run up to it?

I hope Anne will forgive me for saying it...but she wasn't young, and she grew up mostly in court. My memory is awful but he must have executed a dozen or more for "treason" in her day. If she chose him, she knew he was about. But I haven't read enough to know how free she felt to make that decision.

She must have been a very strong, even egotistical, person, in order to think England would back her as the new Queen.

hopefully this is a sensible thread and not the Monty Python argument sketch, so I don't need to say that I don't approve of beheading her! I just don't see as a young girl being beheaded in the same way as, perhaps, Lady Jane Grey.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 09/02/2023 20:19

Maybe it's just me, but I don't really get the fascination at looking at human bones as a tourist attraction. They all look pretty much the same (to the layperson), anyway, don't they?

Unless somebody told you and/or you knew the context, would most of us really be able to tell the difference between the bones of Henry VII and those of Derek Perkins who lived in a village 300 miles away at the same time?

WiddlinDiddlin · 09/02/2023 20:14

Would we be thinking about these people and their lives and experiences, if we didn't dig them up, examine, exhibit some etc etc.

Exhibits need to attract visitors. An exhibit of boring stuff, just rubbish thrown out, no personal effects, grave goods or remains would not attract visitors. Without human interest and effectively, archaeology tourism, funding drops even lower...

Take that to its logical conclusion, the stuff you lot are all aware of and fighting over, would be relegated to dusty passages and low res images in an archive somewhere you wouldn't even know to look in, let alone have access to.

We'd know far less, we'd have far less chance of finding things before they're destroyed by modern construction, we'd have less of a connection to our, human, past, than we do now...

I cannot agree that that is ever a good thing.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 09/02/2023 20:10

Ah, OK, maybe that particular story was indeed invented, then; but there's no doubting that monarchs and other powerful people through history have treated innocent people appallingly, just on whim.

I always think of Anne Boleyn and how she must actually have felt, when she knew she was about to be brutally murdered as a young woman as 'punishment' for her husband wanting to be married to somebody else instead. I know she put on a brave, dignified face (according to the history books, anyway); but what must have been going through her head in the run up to it?

thecatsthecats · 09/02/2023 20:00

Erm, maybe don't visit the Sedlec Ossuary, OP.

I'd quite like to donate my skeleton to an ossuary personally, but I'm not sure anyone's making a new one. I quite like the idea of staring down future generations.

But if it helps, I am always awed when I visit such places that each and every skull belonged to a real person with hopes, dreams, friends, annoying habits, favourite songs... I like that more than the idea of being buried under the soil.

EmmaEmerald · 09/02/2023 19:59

Saucery well put.

LibrariansGiveUsPower · 09/02/2023 19:57

I agree. Let them rest in peace in the way they wanted.

I think plundering graves is disrespectful.

Sparklingbrook · 09/02/2023 19:56

If you don't want too see it, don't go and look

I got taken to loads of museums as a child. I had no choice, I couldn't exactly walk around with my eyes closed in case there was something I didn't want to see as it was upsetting. There was a foetus in jar in one museum and I would much rather have not seen that.

Saucery · 09/02/2023 19:55

It’s about respect, QuertyGirl. I’m not squeamish, obsessed with youth or think we’re immortal. Hmm

That person believed they were entitled to whatever eternal rest the god/s they believed in would provide. It’s modern, casual hubris to think we have a right to stick those remains under glass and gawp at them on a wet weekend afternoon when the only building open is the museum.

I get why you are defensive, but I think you’re misunderstanding a little. I agree with Professor Dame Sue Black - never forget this was a living person and accord the remains the respect that deserves.

SliceOfCakeCupOfTea · 09/02/2023 19:52

ErrolTheDragon · 09/02/2023 19:47

Yes - and in that case the poor dog too. But those casts bring home the tragedy of the event, which can otherwise rather get lost among the wonderful buildings

Totally agree. I just found it shocking as I had thought they were just models to demonstrate what it might have looked like.

SliceOfCakeCupOfTea · 09/02/2023 19:50

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 09/02/2023 19:39

Running out of room in graveyards is another.

I may be wrong, but I think in Germany, you only get to 'use' a grave for 30 years, before the remains are moved to a mass site out of town and then the grave is 'recycled' for another body. That seems really wrong to me.

What I really hate is when people get jocular and laugh about deaths of people from a few centuries ago. I'm not talking about massive tyrants from history; they're fair game.

We have one of those 'bathroom trivia' books, designed to dip into whilst you're, erm, 'busy' in the bathroom, and I was horrified to see a very lighthearted bit about some important historical figure (a queen, maybe?) who bathed in the blood of virgins every day. Imagine: how wacky when she sent out for virgins for her daily blood supplies!!!!

No, no, no. Imagine the absolute terror of the young girls and their parents when murderers (let's call a spade a spade) appeared at their door to take her away by force to slaughter her - just for the perverse proclivities of some disgusting self-aggrandising rich person. How would you feel if somebody came for your own daughter now for the same reason? I really just don't get how actual people are considered to have been any less human - with all that involves - just because they lived decades or centuries before we happen to.

I think it's because the victims are completely anonymised. They say the blood of virgins and it's so easy for people to not follow that thought through. This is why it's important to give voices and stories to those who've passed.

I agree that the victims need to be respected and not have their death mocked.

QuertyGirl · 09/02/2023 19:49

Saucery · 09/02/2023 19:26

Yes, of course, QuertyGirl! Your work is incredibly valuable and necessary, but the body should then be kept in closed storage and not viewed by everyone who fancies it.

Why?

If you don't want too see it, don't go and look.

We're so squeamish about death. This is about the modern obsession with youth and wanting to feel immortal.

Appreciating and witnessing death makes you appreciate they sheer fucking miracle that you're alive right now.

ErrolTheDragon · 09/02/2023 19:47

SliceOfCakeCupOfTea · 09/02/2023 19:44

I will admit that I felt really uncomfortable in Pompeii because I hadn't realised that the 'people' we saw were casts of real bodies that were found.
It's fascinating to visit and really, really interesting but that specifically I found upsetting because I wasn't prepared for it.

I fully accept how important it is to have a snapshot into the past but yikes.

Yes - and in that case the poor dog too. But those casts bring home the tragedy of the event, which can otherwise rather get lost among the wonderful buildings

EmmaEmerald · 09/02/2023 19:45

WeBuilt I thought there was no evidence for that, just a crazy political story?

I wish the history board was active here, I've got a lurgy and was thinking earlier today, I need a history chat board! (Then I fell asleep, woke up and came back here).

ErrolTheDragon · 09/02/2023 19:45

It seems to me it would be disrespectful to just rebury these bodies without investigating to try to understand what happened and why. Not display them for people to gawp at though.

www.livescience.com/child-sacrifices-chimu-people-peru

SliceOfCakeCupOfTea · 09/02/2023 19:44

I will admit that I felt really uncomfortable in Pompeii because I hadn't realised that the 'people' we saw were casts of real bodies that were found.
It's fascinating to visit and really, really interesting but that specifically I found upsetting because I wasn't prepared for it.

I fully accept how important it is to have a snapshot into the past but yikes.

Saucery · 09/02/2023 19:43

put about

Saucery · 09/02/2023 19:43

Countess Elizabeth Bathory, @WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll . It was likely a story out about to discredit her family due to their political influence. Bit like Catherine The Great and bestiality.
History as written by males reserves its most repugnant accusations for females with influence.

EmmaEmerald · 09/02/2023 19:42

I still can't get past Jeremy Bentham being on permanent public display when he didn't specify that. I remember it putting me off history as a 17 year old and our teacher trying to explain why he thought it was okay.

Personal artefacts - I'm going to come up against this myself, but I do feel an item is different than a body part.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 09/02/2023 19:39

Running out of room in graveyards is another.

I may be wrong, but I think in Germany, you only get to 'use' a grave for 30 years, before the remains are moved to a mass site out of town and then the grave is 'recycled' for another body. That seems really wrong to me.

What I really hate is when people get jocular and laugh about deaths of people from a few centuries ago. I'm not talking about massive tyrants from history; they're fair game.

We have one of those 'bathroom trivia' books, designed to dip into whilst you're, erm, 'busy' in the bathroom, and I was horrified to see a very lighthearted bit about some important historical figure (a queen, maybe?) who bathed in the blood of virgins every day. Imagine: how wacky when she sent out for virgins for her daily blood supplies!!!!

No, no, no. Imagine the absolute terror of the young girls and their parents when murderers (let's call a spade a spade) appeared at their door to take her away by force to slaughter her - just for the perverse proclivities of some disgusting self-aggrandising rich person. How would you feel if somebody came for your own daughter now for the same reason? I really just don't get how actual people are considered to have been any less human - with all that involves - just because they lived decades or centuries before we happen to.

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 09/02/2023 19:37

SliceOfCakeCupOfTea · 09/02/2023 19:35

But displaying them sparks interest to others which drives demand for more discoveries to be made, more research to be done and inspires generations of future archeological/anthropologists/historians etc.

Exactly.

Museums are full of personal artefacts from people who never consented for them to be there. It's what gets people interested.