Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it’s no more acceptable to dig up ancient graves than it would be to dig up recent ones?

158 replies

AngeloMysterioso · 09/02/2023 18:22

I follow a few historical Instagram accounts and one has just posted about a c. 1000 year old mummified body that has just been unearthed from an underground tomb in Peru.

It looks as though this poor person died in a fairly horrific way and now it’s remains are on display in a glass box with people taking pictures a few feet away.

AIBU to think these people should be left well alone to rest in peace with the same respect and dignity that we afford to people who died last week?

OP posts:
Untitledsquatboulder · 10/02/2023 06:46

I think if we paid more attention to how we treat the living and our environment and made less fuss over a load if old bones the world would still turn and would probably be a better place.

webuiltthiscityonrockandwheat · 10/02/2023 05:57

From a religious perspective and obviously this is me speaking about my opinion but I'm a practicing Christian and believe in heaven and hell etc. I still wouldn't care what happens to my remains. I believe I'll be restored In heaven when I die and so I have no use for my body. Once I die my remains are just bones. I don't know if this is what Christians way back when believed but I thought I would offer my perspective

MissingNightshades · 10/02/2023 05:47

I've always found it disrespectful and stinks of entitlement "I have a right to know" Where has it got us? Are we now an amazing species that because of regularly digging up dead bodies has learnt lessons from the past ? etc etc because that's the excuse always used and it bloody doesn't look like does it?
No I can't stand it and watching Tony Robinson ewwww a few decades ago being snotty and superior over people questioning a dig just confirmed my suspicions of entitlement.

Nimbostratus100 · 10/02/2023 00:54

And given that mummification was an attempt to be remembered for ever, I strongly suspect that those who chose this would be delighted to still be seen and remembered in the modern age

I know I would love to think I was in a display case and of interest in 5 thousand years time,

EmmaEmerald · 10/02/2023 00:54

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 10/02/2023 00:51

There's lots of things in life people are not OK with but just have to accept, why would it be any different in death?

Personally, I find the amount of time, effort, money, physical and head space people give to the dead bizarre. I'm sure there's something far more productive we could be doing with the millions upon millions of meat suits left behind each year.

Are you the lady who suggested the whole “using brain dead women as surrogates”’thing?

Nimbostratus100 · 10/02/2023 00:53

A lot of ignorance on this thread on how archeologists treat human remains.

MyOtherCarIsAHearse · 10/02/2023 00:52

I agree with a pp who said we are weird about death in the west. The more acquainted we are with it the better we will cope when we encounter our own dying.

Anyway, I think it’s all perfectly respectful. I have several skulls. They’re well looked after.

Nimbostratus100 · 10/02/2023 00:52

redglobox · 09/02/2023 18:32

Completely agree. I never understand why this is viewed as okay. It feels particularly wrong when it is, for example, a mother and child who suffered a tragic death and were buried together. Leave them to rest in peace, as intended. I think they have a right to that. Who are we to dig them up and put them in a museum/photograph their bones for everyone to gawp at.

its not "viewed as ok" - who do you think is viewing it as ok.

It takes clearance from a coroner to move someone who died one thousand or ten thousand years ago, just as much as someone who died yesterday. You cant as much move a skull from one museum shelf to another without clearance, even in storage

EmmaEmerald · 10/02/2023 00:51

And so Charles, having been gawped at in life, is now gawped at in death? Having particularly planned to avoid it?

I can’t find any justification for that.

did anyone think what Burke and Hare did was okay?

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 10/02/2023 00:51

EmmaEmerald · 10/02/2023 00:36

But when someone has specifically said they’re not okay with it, it’s different.

There's lots of things in life people are not OK with but just have to accept, why would it be any different in death?

Personally, I find the amount of time, effort, money, physical and head space people give to the dead bizarre. I'm sure there's something far more productive we could be doing with the millions upon millions of meat suits left behind each year.

AndNowIKnowWhatHappened · 10/02/2023 00:47

@EmmaEmerald
But when someone has specifically said they’re not okay with it, it’s different

But they are dead? They don't exist anymore. If there are relatives around then I think it's right to do what they want but unless you believe in the afterlife I don't understand why it matters what happens to the physical remains.

When my father died he was cremated and we said we didn't want the ashes and that they could dispose of them however they want.

The ashes are 'just' ashes and have no meaning to our family. Our memories of when he was alive are what are important to us. Those are all that matter.

As an atheist I struggle to understand who people are sopposed to be disrespecting if they are digging up ancient remains.

JudgeRinderonTinder · 10/02/2023 00:41

EmmaEmerald · 10/02/2023 00:36

But when someone has specifically said they’re not okay with it, it’s different.

Well…ok then, but I’m talking in general.

anyway, this might seem disrespectful to some but when a person died 200 odd years ago, has no living relatives to object, and they themselves certainly won’t know because they no longer exist, who is being hurt or harmed?

StrawHatOnTheParcelShelf · 10/02/2023 00:40

QuertyGirl · 09/02/2023 20:37

@WiddlinDiddlin

Agreed!

Honestly, we should spend more time worrying about and looking after the living. The dead are gone.

We're just projecting our own sensibility onto these remains.

They're not going to be left in peace.

Think of the billions of people who have died on earth. Where do people think they all went? Most of those bodies have been totally destroyed.

I agree.

But I don't see remains as 'people', the people have gone. I fancy the idea of being an interesting artefact in 1000 years over the idea of 'resting' when I'm nothing but bones.

Having a protected space on Earth solely for your remains, forever, is a rare privilege and not sustainable.

I support the idea of remains being left for a reasonable period while any mourners are still alive, and an enduring mark of their place on Earth e.g. a plaque. But burial and crypts need a re-think on the whole.

EmmaEmerald · 10/02/2023 00:36

JudgeRinderonTinder · 10/02/2023 00:35

Who needs to rest in peace? There is no person anymore, it’s just bones. I don’t understand this logic.

They can do what they damn well like with me when I’m dead 😂

But when someone has specifically said they’re not okay with it, it’s different.

JudgeRinderonTinder · 10/02/2023 00:35

Who needs to rest in peace? There is no person anymore, it’s just bones. I don’t understand this logic.

They can do what they damn well like with me when I’m dead 😂

EmmaEmerald · 10/02/2023 00:28

yummyscummymummy01 · 09/02/2023 23:53

I think this poor fella is an excellent example of this dilemma. He specifically stated that he did not want this to happen to him. The fact he remains in his glass vase propped up for all to see really haunts me.

londonist.com/2011/12/should-the-hunterian-museums-giant-skeleton-be-buried-at-sea

Oh that’s awful. Maybe when they reopen, that poor soul won’t be there? I’ve never been there.

yummyscummymummy01 · 09/02/2023 23:53

I think this poor fella is an excellent example of this dilemma. He specifically stated that he did not want this to happen to him. The fact he remains in his glass vase propped up for all to see really haunts me.

londonist.com/2011/12/should-the-hunterian-museums-giant-skeleton-be-buried-at-sea

PumpkinPie2016 · 09/02/2023 21:19

I agree, OP. It seems very disrespectful to dig up someone's resting place intentionally.

Not the same at all, but we recently had a family grave opened to intern my Nana's ashes and I was very particular about having the vicar present and him doing a final blessing. I do keep faith and I appreciate some people don't but it wouldn't have felt right to me to just open the grave where people are at rest.

Cinnamonandcoal · 09/02/2023 21:14

A bit torn on this.

I studied archaeology including a lot on ancient bones, how to interpret them forensically. It was fascinating but I always connected the bones to the people they once were. In hindsight some of them were from native American populations and should probably have been returned, I don't know how they got to my UK university.

I don't really have an issue with displays of bones in museums if suitably ancient. In spite of my academic background I absolutely cannot cope with mummies and will avoid looking at them at all costs. Extremely creepy.

As others have said, it's better for remans to be reinterred or even respectfully destroyed rather than churned up by piling equipment and bulldozers.

Interesting debate.

SnottyLottie · 09/02/2023 21:05

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 09/02/2023 20:10

Ah, OK, maybe that particular story was indeed invented, then; but there's no doubting that monarchs and other powerful people through history have treated innocent people appallingly, just on whim.

I always think of Anne Boleyn and how she must actually have felt, when she knew she was about to be brutally murdered as a young woman as 'punishment' for her husband wanting to be married to somebody else instead. I know she put on a brave, dignified face (according to the history books, anyway); but what must have been going through her head in the run up to it?

I think towards the end she resigned herself to her situation. When the swordsman was delayed from Calais she got very upset because she wanted it all over and done with. She did seem scared about the pain of dying such a violent death but tried to hide it behind dark humour.

She was a very religious woman with a strong belief in a Christian afterlife. Back then, people were more sure in their belief in the afterlife and she seemed convinced that she was going to a better place (as she managed to receive her last confession and the sacrament of the Eucharist, which means that she would ‘die a good death’). In that sense, she would have seen it as the end of one journey and the start of the next, which would have given her great comfort.

I personally feel that’s how she managed to keep her shit together so well at the end. Resigned to her fate, weary of life and strong faith in a better afterlife.

EmmaEmerald · 09/02/2023 20:56

terry thank you so much!

terrywynne · 09/02/2023 20:49

EmmaEmerald · 09/02/2023 20:42

Not suggesting she knew she'd be executed. And yes, the frenzy really ramps up.

I just think that court was incredibly harsh and I imagine her father would need her to be keen to some extent - the extent to which a woman had agency over on her own life. Being Queen was a hell of a task.

wasn't Anne keen to show Henry reasons to break with the Catholic Church? I don't pretend to "know" - none of us can. So I don't know that she was merely a pawn in the game either.

didn't know about that docudrama. I am a bit of a dusty old book 😂, I like a dusty old book or a straight documentary but as I seem to have a lurgy and cba getting off the couch, I might have a lok.

If you are laid up and more of a book person than docudrama, try this podcast episode on Tudor women and their families The interviewee Nicola Clarke has also written a dusty old book on Gender, Family and Politics that looks at what power women did have in the Tudor world - it is an academic book though rather than general history.

WhoWants2Know · 09/02/2023 20:42

I think it's fine for people to decide what they want to happen to their physical remains, and that their wishes should be respected to whatever degree is possible.

If people are buried in sanctified ground, then I wouldn't feel right about disturbing that. Even if it's not sacred to me, it was to them.

EmmaEmerald · 09/02/2023 20:42

terrywynne · 09/02/2023 20:34

There was a netflix docudrama about her recently - a bit modern in style for my taste but the historian talk heads were interesting and gave the impression that she did have some agency (within the context of the time) so not just a pawn.

In terms of knowing what to expect in terms of executions, the treason executions really ramp up after her death. Henry VIII executed a lot of nobility but if you look at the dates most of them are in 1536-1547 so I don't think it is far to say she should went in knowing what to expect.

Not suggesting she knew she'd be executed. And yes, the frenzy really ramps up.

I just think that court was incredibly harsh and I imagine her father would need her to be keen to some extent - the extent to which a woman had agency over on her own life. Being Queen was a hell of a task.

wasn't Anne keen to show Henry reasons to break with the Catholic Church? I don't pretend to "know" - none of us can. So I don't know that she was merely a pawn in the game either.

didn't know about that docudrama. I am a bit of a dusty old book 😂, I like a dusty old book or a straight documentary but as I seem to have a lurgy and cba getting off the couch, I might have a lok.

QuertyGirl · 09/02/2023 20:37

@WiddlinDiddlin

Agreed!

Honestly, we should spend more time worrying about and looking after the living. The dead are gone.

We're just projecting our own sensibility onto these remains.

They're not going to be left in peace.

Think of the billions of people who have died on earth. Where do people think they all went? Most of those bodies have been totally destroyed.

Swipe left for the next trending thread