Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My Unpopular Child

283 replies

LunchBoxTeeth · 09/02/2023 16:33

My 7 year old DS isn't exactly disliked by his peers, but he isn't particularly liked either. If ever the kids are asked to choose someone to be with, he is one of the last to be chosen. Even when we have friends round our house, when there is more than one child, the other children are constantly calling "hey x, look at this" or whatever, but they never call out to my DS to look at things or join in. It's not that they purposefully leave him out, they just always choose a different child as a first choice, when one is available.

He gets invited to whole class parties, but very rarely gets invited to other parties. Now that whole class parties are becoming less common because the kids are older, he simply doesn't get invited at all. I asked him who he wanted to invite to his party this year, and it was heartbreaking to hear him talk about the people he really liked, because I know that they have already had a party and DS wasn't invited.

I spoke to the class teacher about it and she said that I could try having more play dates, or doing more clubs. But we already do that. Every week he invites someone over, but increasingly they turn down the invitation. He does some clubs, but hasn't made any friendships through them. I watch him play and if I see him doing something that I think might not be helpful, I talk about it to him afterwards, but nothing that he does seems such a big deal that people don't really want to be around him.

OP posts:
Dalekjastninerels · 10/02/2023 19:06

Parents used to worry a lot about me being friendless as a child; I also did but only because I knew it meant something was wrong with me. I actually liked being alone and was never lonely by myself.

As a teenager I used to try and fit it; because I started to care about it.

As an adult I am liked as far as I know at work and have 2 close friends.

I am as far as I know neurotypical; but suspect NVLD as i fit the criteria for it- but obviously am not a Doctor of any sort so cannot say for certain.

CountessWindyBottom · 10/02/2023 19:05

First of all massive hugs to you, this must be a painful experience.

From a developmental psychology perspective, involving yourself in your child's life and all the little ecosystems that go with that is important. Play dates are, in my humble opinion, absolutely vital for children, particularly children in this age cohort who missed out on a lot of play time with their peers during Covid lock-downs etc. Keep these up! And have a few kids over at a time (perhaps 3) so that they can have a proper play together. I also would, within reason, leave them to their own devices and you'll be able to observe from afar what the dynamics are etc. I wouldn't mind so much about reciprocation - it's all about immersion! Expose him to the children he likes as much as possible.

I'd limit time on the Switch or Games Console during these visits as he is actually missing out on honing his communication skills. Have it as a treat for half an hour after you feed them but I wouldn't let it be the sole activity. Have you a garden? If so, hats and gloves on and let them run around and make their own fun. Boys love games with 'rules' while girls tend to forge friendships based on sharing confidences and lots of conversation. So don't worry if you see that they're not having deep and meaningful conversations - they will bond through play and role play. Nerf Guns and Goggles for the garden are always a good option.

I also think that ball sports for little boys is a gift for life really. He doesn't have to be really good either but being able to kick a ball around and having confidence to do so is like a universal language of friendship and means he will always have peers who are interested in a kick-around.

I also wouldn't underestimate how irritating bossiness is for children. I have little sons and if I ask why they don't want to play with a particular child (although I host whole class parties) the retort is invariably that the child is bossy. A couple of sessions with a play therapist may be very useful in modelling how to make requests or suggestions nicely. I think it may also boost his confidence in making friends.

You sound like you are doing a great job and I really sympathise with your concerns but he will find his own little crew. He is still young. Keep up those playdates, get to know some of the other Mums and introduce him to team sports which will be of huge benefit to him xx

LunchBoxTeeth · 10/02/2023 19:00

Iceysuperslide · 10/02/2023 13:23

Many parents can’t see the wood for the trees at least you have insight in to the personality trait that’s causing the issue. Plus some children do not grow out of being bossy so do not assume anything. My friends DS was like yours a know it all and bossy. She always excused it said he was lovely and never pulled him up on his ways, ever. My DS really started to complain about spending time with him, he was a year younger so I let the friendship slide.

You do need to find an appropriate way to address his behaviour.
Sometimes parents have no clue or do not want to see, love really is blind. I think you are emotionally astute to recognise and acknowledge the issue.

Thank you

OP posts:
LunchBoxTeeth · 10/02/2023 18:55

Dixiechickonhols · 10/02/2023 12:37

Do school do anything eg dd’s school used to have a scheme where older played with younger - they had equipment like bean bags or a buddy bench where you can sit and someone will come over knowing you want to play.

No buddy system except for reception aged children. The school offered him Lego therapy, but either they have forgotten or there's a long waiting list. I'll bring it up again at the next parents evening.

OP posts:
MarvellousMonsters · 10/02/2023 18:55

stackofchairs · 09/02/2023 17:35

I was like your DS and I'm autistic. I'm not saying yours could be but I just didn't know how to make friendship work. I had people I really liked but didn't know how to approach them, the way others do it.

Has the teacher mentioned any sen? When did the problem start? 7 is roughly the age when kids start to find their own tribe but for some it can take a little longer.

Don't invite more than one child per playdate to minimise issues you mentioned. Is he happy at school?

I was going to suggest these things too.

harrassedmumto3 · 10/02/2023 18:51

Is he happy though? I mean, if he's fairly oblivious, then I would be careful not to project your anxiety onto him.
It's so hard though, I know Flowers

Thepeopleversuswork · 10/02/2023 18:48

This may not be much comfort if your son is struggling but I actually think being popular is overrated.

A lot of “popularity” is pretty ephemeral and based on status markers and things which reflect on others. It rarely leads to durable friendships.

And also usually among the popular children there are one or two “ringleaders”: charismatic and extrovert types who boss the others around. Many of the other kids in these big groups are hangers on who have aligned themselves with the group for status or protection.

This can be painful if you are outside the group but often the children who are not in the cool set end up making deeper and more lasting friendships.

Wanderingowl · 10/02/2023 18:45

LunchBoxTeeth · 10/02/2023 18:19

Yes, he loves Minecraft. He's not amazing at it but good enough to engage in conversation about it with friends. When friends visit, they spend time on the Switch, it usually goes well until he starts getting a bit bossy about what the other child is 'allowed' to do. He's not any better at it than his friends but still feels the need to educate them on it when they are playing. It's a difficult balance between pointing out the things he does that are annoying the other kids and not doing it so much that I'm destroying his confidence.

Maybe see if there is a Pokemon club anywhere near you. My DS's favourite activity is Pokemon. It's in our local Games Workshop type shop. (It used to be a GW but is independent now.) He loves it because he says it's where he gets to meet other kids who are like him. Because while most kids like Roblox/Minecraft/etc. They aren't as into it as he is, whereas the Pokemon kids are proper nerds like he is.

The kids there usually move on to being into D&D, Warhammer/etc when they get a bit older. It's good for him to have that kind of connection with people with similar interests. I am pretty strict about him keeping up some physical activities too. I was a nerdy kid/teen myself and the young men I hung out with tender to be more awkward if the games where their only outlet. And more confident (and attractive) when they also had a sport/gym habit.

LunchBoxTeeth · 10/02/2023 18:44

TheTurn0fTheScrew · 10/02/2023 11:44

I read a great book when my socially awkward kid started school: The Unwritten Rules of Friendship. It considers how kids may need different kinds of support socialising depending on their personalities, strengths and interpersonal styles. It's a bit cheesy/American in the way it labels behaviours eg "the mini adult", "the different drummer", "the shy child", but once you get past there are lots of helpful suggestions.

I would also add that her starting secondary school was brilliant. She attends a very average comp with a broad and diverse intake. But in a year group of 240 you have a far greater chance of finding your people than in a single form entry school with 30 in a class. She has her gang of lovely, quirky kids who are frequently found in my house when not hanging out at Games Workshop.

Thank you, I'll look into that book.

OP posts:
LunchBoxTeeth · 10/02/2023 18:43

DailyEnergyCrisis · 10/02/2023 12:04

It’s so hard. Do you know why he does the showing off stuff? Is it linked to insecurity or just his personality? I guess I’m asking if you think his behaviour can be modified as I think it’ll be a big part of his problem.
My DD is the opposite- quite self deprecating and happy for others to take the lead but if I’ve had a child over to play who’s constantly showing off and taking over I do make a mental note to discourage the friendship and support friendships where it feels more balanced and fun for my DD.

My DD is very popular and I do think easy going kids have an easier time of it with friendships. Maybe talk to him about what he values in a friend, how he feels when others show off and take over to help him understand that these behaviours aren’t very conducive to friendships/inclusivity as they’re all about just one person. It’s a fine balance though as you don’t want to totally trash his personality and always make a point of highlighting his lovely attributes (of which I’m sure there are loads).

As others have said, having cool/sought after gear is helpful too. 7 year olds can be very shallow 🤣

I think he shows off because he wants to demonstrate how great he is and how worthy of their friendship, as in if they are impressed by him they'll want to be his friend. Ironically, he hates other children bragging and knows it's a bad trait, but doesn't seem to make the link that that's what he's doing.

It doesn't help that he's quite academic and sometimes the teachers ask him to help the kids who are struggling (he's not the only one who does this), so sometimes it's 'good' to demonstrate his knowledge and other times it's 'bad' and boasting. I don't want to ask the teachers to stop this because it's a big confidence boost for him and he'd be really sad if he couldn't do it any more, especially as the other kids would continue.

OP posts:
PeachyPeachTrees · 10/02/2023 18:41

It was like this for my youngest DS at same age. Not disliked but not popular enough to be picked over others and no best friend or special friends. Teacher said it's partly to do with being youngest in the year and he was a bit bossy. He is not sporty. He is 10 now and although he doesn't have many friends they are good solid friends and he has a best friend.
Hopefully in time your DS will gain a few great friends. Keep up with the playdates, clubs and praise.

33JM · 10/02/2023 18:38

Does he seem to be aware and or upset about the situation? We put our own social anxieties on to our kids and actually they are sometimes perfectly happy with everything. I know from personal experience having kids with asd - they don’t actually notice or care x

MyNDfamily · 10/02/2023 18:32

OP I've read all of your posts and I really think you need to look into autism.

Kids with autism like things of their terms and to control the play. My son is the same.

Autism is so varied, he is probably high functioning being bright and wanting to take the lead. Coming across as loud. If you want you can PM me I have 3 neurodiverse children and I'm ND myself.

The social problems are a huge red flag IMO

LunchBoxTeeth · 10/02/2023 18:32

Wonderpoo · 10/02/2023 12:02

Do you let him experience popular culture type stuff that allows him to join in with peers. The kids I see left out are the ones who’ve never seen Harry Potter or watched Enola Holmes or aren’t into what everyone else is in to, be that Pokémon or whatever. I think kids need social currency like adults otherwise others find them a bit meh…..

Yes, we have TV subscriptions that he can watch and a switch with all the big popular games (that I know it), he gets pretty much whatever he asks for for Christmas/birthdays. Also he can join any clubs he wants to, although he only really wants to do Beavers and play on the switch.

OP posts:
Beenmum · 10/02/2023 18:28

Being popular isn’t really that important - I stressed being kind to people … which helped . My boy was very bright , old for his year and doesn’t suffer fools gladly . He also wasn’t a classic lunchtime football player and was in a small school so not too many potential friends to chose from .

I would recommend a bigger primary ( if your son is in a small school) - more chance for him to find his people , and maybe a selective environment for secondary if that’s an option .

Out of school try some different clubs - near us are coding clubs , Lego holiday clubs and science clubs . The scouting network is also something to stick with .

My son has thrived at Secondary , he still doesn’t have really close friends but he manages to get on with everyone which is a skill in itself .

emjam67 · 10/02/2023 18:28

Sorry you're going through this - my son was the same. He is on the spectrum but high functioning. He is an only child and to be honest I was always there for him and I was his play mate!!! He would always gravitate to adults at that age - he would even spend breaks with the teachers at school rather than other children. He was never invited to any parties and never wanted a "birthday party" of his own. In Year 6 he had a couple of close friends that he would go to play dates with but at secondary school they drifted away and he has got his own tribe now, of which I am very thankful. But during school holidays, he doesn't hang out with them even if I suggest that maybe he contacts them and arranges something. We live in a rural area so it is hard. I'm still worried about what will happen next year when he goes to college!
I was sad to read your comment "Maybe it’s me they don’t like and that’s why he doesn’t get the invites" because that's what I thought as well! Hang in there - things will get better.

fuzzwuss · 10/02/2023 18:26

Swimming is quite an individual sport. Could you try something like football or rugby, even tennis can be more of a "team" thing....

MyNDfamily · 10/02/2023 18:24

MangshorJhol · 09/02/2023 17:30

Can I offer a different perspective? This was my DH. Never had friends. Didn’t really get invited to parties (he grew up in the Midwest in the US but he’s Asian). Was never part of a group. He was also shy and geeky. Even as an adult he has a small select group of friends. We met at Uni and we have been together since day dot. He is quite socially awkward. Quite a bit in fact. But that’s who he is. He’s kind, genuinely an equal parent and the loveliest person I know. We have been together for 20 + years. He’s also ridiculously smart (as in he’s won presidential awards for his work as a scientist/physician). He’s very popular with his patients and colleagues because he’s humble and kind. He’s never going to be the heart and soul of a party. MIL talks about how she spent years worrying about him endlessly and trying to find friends for him. She was almost in tears one day telling me about it. She had a chronic disease and was in hospital and she said her worry about him consumed her. He’s still a loner but he’s happy in himself, we have a good life with our kids and so as long as your son is good and kind, I hope life will be kind to him too.

Do you think he could be autistic? Autism is different for everyone and his main symptom could be a lack of social skills? Autism can come with above average intelligence. My eldest son is autistic but is kind and extremely bright for our family. He doesn't get his maths skills from me or DH who are both average intelligence. It's as if a gene has be altered in him that makes his brain far more mathematical than normal but at a cost of h having very bad social skills.

Toomuchtrouble4me · 10/02/2023 18:23

ExistenceOptional · 09/02/2023 16:55

Is he trying to be best friends with the popular kids and ignoring the less popular kids?

It could be this.

my DS is a bit nerdy, likes space and Lego and is rubbish at sport. He is really attracted to the cool footballing skateboarding kids and although they weren’t horrible to him, he was always on the outside of the group. Sort of there, but pretty much ignored. He sort of by accident got thrown together with one of the quiet nerdy boys in the holidays, got to know his friends and ‘found his people’.
At 7 you are still the centre of his world and it’s early days so try to play it down and keep doing what you’re doing, three is always a crowd, try to keep it one friend over at a time. Good luck.

Onehappymam · 10/02/2023 18:21

My daughter was in the same boat all through primary. It continued for the first couple of years of secondary too. It was heartbreaking. By her 13th birthday she literally had no friends. Not even one. I have a photo of her on her own next to her cake and balloons - she didn’t have anyone to invite.

By her 14th she had a party with a dozen people and now she has lots of friends, to the point I’m now complaining about how much her socialising costs me!

It is so hard to watch, but I honestly don’t think there’s anything you can do to encourage friendships. They will happen in their own time.

LunchBoxTeeth · 10/02/2023 18:19

Bunce1 · 10/02/2023 11:32

Bossy/know it all is a hard one to navigate and children will recoil from it. My nephew is also super comparative but also very immature so everything is a competition and he has to win, will cry/strop if he doesn’t. Horrid

My godson is like this and really struggles with friendships. The saving grace has been Pokémon cards. He is Mensa level Pokémon knowledge about them and he loves to chat and swap with a couple of other kids who like them too.

Does he have an interest like that?

Yes, he loves Minecraft. He's not amazing at it but good enough to engage in conversation about it with friends. When friends visit, they spend time on the Switch, it usually goes well until he starts getting a bit bossy about what the other child is 'allowed' to do. He's not any better at it than his friends but still feels the need to educate them on it when they are playing. It's a difficult balance between pointing out the things he does that are annoying the other kids and not doing it so much that I'm destroying his confidence.

OP posts:
Dalekjastninerels · 10/02/2023 18:16

I was this child; when young I didn't care about it- but when I got to the teenage years I felt I should be popular and tried and failed.

But as an adult I accept myself and realise being popular is not everything 😎

Fergie51 · 10/02/2023 18:14

I found my Grandson went through a similar time and I agree it’s heartbreaking to watch. I do agree with others who have recommended joining a group such as Beavers or Cubs. The leaders are so understanding and enthusiastic in dealing with a variety of children and knowing when and where to encourage the less outgoing to lead activities. A great leveller in my experience.

DSDorangex · 10/02/2023 18:12

My elder son is now 19 and is very content with a large social network and some really good friends who he has been close to since he was around 9 years old… But when he was the age of your child, I was so worried about how he didn’t get invited to the homes of the other boys in his class. I arranged play dates and basically tried grooming and befriending other mothers just to find him friends. He was happy at home and eventually made best friends with a similarly quiet girl in his class. They are good friends to this day, and bolstering each other they slowly met others through their own interests and connections, rather than mine. My son and his friends tend to be what many might consider ‘alternative’ very arty and creative, mostly now studying fine art and music degrees….but living their best lives together, clubbing and partying like all students. I mention his interests only because as I tried to force friendships, I had him join junior rugby and football which was never going to be him and left him feeling ‘different’. I now have a second son, 16 years younger, and a completely different personality, who makes friends easily with his peers, all very stereotypical rough and tumble, very different to my elder son, which came as a bit of a shock to me tbh. My advice would be to stand back, let him be happy in his home environment and take his time to develop the relationships he’ll choose as he grows. It’s so hard for us as parents, but he will find ‘his’ people in time.

Mgi4243765 · 10/02/2023 18:09

@LunchBoxTeeth have him tested for aspergers I had no idea until my son was 12 and he had these issues.. it helps to know if they do have it the early you know the better you can support them

Swipe left for the next trending thread