Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Rita, Sue and Bob too

309 replies

BeachBlondey · 09/02/2023 13:00

As a Happy Valley fan, I was surprised to find out that the actors who played Nev and Clare in Happy Valley, were actually in two main roles of the Rita, Sue and Bob too film from the 80s.

It's made me think about that old film again, and I'm actually shocked that it was made at all.

There is some discussion online today about the film, and most comments are along the lines of "great film", "a British Classic", and so forth.

The plot (for those who haven't seen it), is centered around a fully grown married man, who seduces grooms two 15 year old school girls and engages in lots of sex with them, mainly in his car (iirc).

How the hell was this okay, to put this out as a comedy, even back then? And how can the majority of people who remember the film, still think it's a great British classic?

OP posts:
nokidshere · 09/02/2023 16:41

I mean back then we had tits on page 3 of a national newspaper - that to me is one of the most bizarre aspects of that time. That to me alone sets the bar of that era and things have moved on

And now we have love island, naked attraction, naked and afraid, and other such crap which encourages young women parading round half naked, or fully naked, in order to attract the attention of men and positively encourage them to shag on a tv programme which, given the narrative of this era, shows how little we have moved on.

slowquickstep · 09/02/2023 16:37

CTRALTDEL · 09/02/2023 15:33

‘16 was an adult then. Loads of people including myself started full time work at 16 years old’

16 wasn’t an ‘adult’ in then80s. FFS. Leaving school and having a job didn’t make you an adult.

If you can marry at 16 then you can have sex or appear on page 3 of The Sun. Times were very different then.

Iceysuperslide · 09/02/2023 16:35

I dated a guy of almost 27 when I was 16, he was a lecturer at the local college, no one including my Mother batted an eyelid. This was in 1982.

I do not want history erased I want it remembered to try and educate and stop behaviours because they are not socially acceptable.

watchfulwishes · 09/02/2023 16:31

BeachBlondey · 09/02/2023 13:29

No, I'm not saying that at all. I'm shocked that this was seen as ok, and normal in 1987 - for a married man to be having sex with 15 year old's.

It wasn't seen as morally acceptable, the film was quite shocking.

catandcoffee · 09/02/2023 16:30

I've just looked up the writer of this.
Such tragic story .

The film is very realistic of life way back for young females.

Also, in those days if your drunk husband beat the shit out of you and the children,the Police did nothing.....it was seen as 'normal'.

Another gritty film from the late 60s is Up the Junction.

PrincessHoneysuckle · 09/02/2023 16:30

The cooking money scene still cracks me up

BellePeppa · 09/02/2023 16:28

callmeblondee · 09/02/2023 15:21

I mean back then we had tits on page 3 of a national newspaper - that to me is one of the most bizarre aspects of that time. That to me alone sets the bar of that era and things have moved on, but still in today's world we are uncovering so many shady disgusting men, it feels like things have been more covered up than totally changed.

Even back in the 70s as a teenager this enraged me and don’t even get me started on the top shelves of every newsagent in the high street. Some of those front covers! An absolute disgrace! If you protested you were vilified as ‘frigid’ or ‘uptight’. It was vile.

pompomdaisy · 09/02/2023 16:25

That was life for that author. It was life for a number of poor kids growing up in the 70s and 80s. Have you heard of Jimmy Saville?

justadress · 09/02/2023 16:24

I watched it in my late teens and remember finding it quite dark and disturbing. I know people who love it though!

FancyFanny · 09/02/2023 16:23

Why all of a sudden do films, books, songs etc. have to reflect what is thought to be morally right? If this was the case then there wouldn't be any interesting media at all.

Films aren't meant to be there to promote the events they portray: they aren't often intended to be a model for society. They are intended to entertain, to make you question, to make you reflect, to reflect your life back at you, to frighten you, to inform you, to shock you, to document history, to make you laugh, etc.

Rita, Sue and Bob too is a film which has always been quite darkly comedic; the relationship between the three main characters was never promoted as being idealistic or right and I don't remember people thinking it was at the time it was released. I'm sure it is realised that the point of the film was to shine a light on how socially acceptable this kind of behaviour was at the time. It is done in very clever and subtle way, using humour to make this sensitive topic more palatable to a general audience. It is a window into the social norms of the time and as such is an iconic British film of the kind that we shouldn't allow to be hidden away by the growing tide of whitewash over our media, our society and it's history.

mattyd · 09/02/2023 16:21

Yes, that was normal then for some. Normal now for many boys is watching vile, sadistic pornography online and expecting girls to perform acts that had barely been heard of in the 80's.

Tempname123 · 09/02/2023 16:20

It wasn't normal then to have relationships with married men if you were a child. It wasn't normal to have relationships with teachers. I was the 17 in 1987 and I liked the film, but didn't find the film funny. It was shocking. Bill Wyman was still unacceptable - it's just that the men in power chose not to attack him - no one I know thought it was ok.

Sure there is more awareness now about grooming and the effects of abusive upbringings on children, but this kind of stuff still wasn't acceptable then.

and fwiw, 2 teachers at my kids school have had to resign in the last couple of years because they have had relationships with pupils. It still goes on. (and to the pp it isn't about girls dressing "provocatively" it's about men).

CaptainMyCaptain · 09/02/2023 16:17

My sex education in 1969 was that it was the girl who set the standard in any relationship and the best contraceptive was the word No. It let boys/men off the hook completely and if you didn't say No then it was entirely your fault.

54isanopendoor · 09/02/2023 16:11

GideonSmideon · 09/02/2023 13:45

But it was normal then. In a middle England ruralish school there were still men picking up 4th and 5th years down the lane from school, everyone knew who the girls were and, most of the men in a small community.

it was the girls that were looked down on and left to deal with the consequences (pregnancy/abortion) very rarely they did leave their wives - I know of one who married eventually and are still together, she's 50 ish and he's in his 80s Envy

We were all drinking in pubs from 15/16 though, fake ids that were never checked and shops would sell fags and alcohol without asking age. 6th form PE consisted of snooker or darts in the pub with teachers present.

I agree it was normal then.
It was always the young girls (who'd been groomed) who were to blame.
Men got off scot-free.
I find it a horrible film as it reminds me of that time but also because I don't think it is sufficiently clear how wrong Bob's behaviour is & the consequences for those young girls.

IWonderWhyIBother · 09/02/2023 16:09

I was surprised to find out that the actors who played Nev and Clare in Happy Valley, were actually in two main roles of the Rita, Sue and Bob too film from the 80s.

It's made me think about that old film again, and I'm actually shocked that it was made at all.

Have you seen the film? You were surprised to find out they were in it? I don’t know anyone that has watched the film that wouldn’t recognise the three main characters.

It’s a classic British film, not sure I’d call it a comedy. Although DH and I did say that if they re-enacted this scene for the end credits of Happy Valley with Sarah Lancashire as Sue that would have been a funny way to end the series!

x2boys · 09/02/2023 15:58

Ended to.happily *

GonnaGetGoingReturns · 09/02/2023 15:58

Pinkdelight3 · 09/02/2023 15:54

One thing I've always thought about horror movies, is that they almost always feature a girl or woman, being chased by a murderous man. And we watch this for entertainment!!?? That's a bit fucked up, is it not?

You're really parading your ignorance now, with the most simplistic takes on story and meaning that are barely attaining Mary Whitehouse-level insight. There's a vast array of work on women in horror, some of it conservative, some feminist, all with more nuance than this basic reading. Your take is simply not how our imaginations work and not making films that explore and address the darker sides of the psyche will not stop those sides existing nor is that their purpose. While you're down the Dunbar rabbithole, also check out the work of director Alan Clarke, who made great and provocative works like Made in Britain, Christine, Elephant and many more. They might not be your idea of 'entertainment' but they're powerful and vital contributions to the world.

The “one thing I’ve thought about horror films” well at least eg with films like The Hitchhiker and other horror films it taught us to be aware of danger and as far as I recall I never hitchhiked, partly down to that film.

Compare and contrast to early 70s where Fred West picked up girls (hitchhiking possibly) and look what happened there. It was seen as far more acceptable then.

x2boys · 09/02/2023 15:58

BeachBlondey · 09/02/2023 15:43

Thank you. This is what I meant. I'm perhaps a bit clumsy in expressing myself. It wasn't portrayed as a seriously worrying situation. If a film was made now about the Rochdale girls, it would be serious and dark. This didn't feel like that. I remember watching it in 1987, and it was definitely viewed as a light hearted comedy by many, whereas I feel like people should have been thinking WTF. Can you imagine a film about the Rochdale victims, ending with a scene depicting the abuser jumping in to bed for a funny threesome?

And Andrea Dunbar wasent happy with the final film either ,she also thought it needs too" happily"
the 80,s was a very different era though and things that were considered funny.then I wouldn't find funny now
You only have too look at the likes of St Trinnian s ect ,school.girls from.say 15 were considered fair game
I left school in 1990 and went to college but some people in my year went straight to work I'm not saying it's right or that I condone it just that it was a very different era .

UseOfWeapons · 09/02/2023 15:56

ZombieKettle · 09/02/2023 13:02

It's actually a very dark, bleak film and I believe was based on the writers own personal experience. It's not a comedy.

Absolutely correct.

GonnaGetGoingReturns · 09/02/2023 15:55

charabang · 09/02/2023 13:26

I went to an all girls school in the 80s. It really wasn't unusual for there to be men in cars collecting their underage GFs. My friend was 12 when she dated a man in his 30s. We actually thought she was so sophisticated.

Similar. It was considered cool if you had a boyfriend who was older than you, brownie points if he had a job (didn’t matter if it was building work etc) and car and took you to the local pub where of course you engaged in underage drinking!

My mum was furious when I did this but was powerless to stop me. Me and my friends almost always didn’t date boys our own age but some did.

If I’d had a teenage daughter back then I probably would’ve sent her to boarding school but my DM threatened me with this and I said I’d run away, my best friend at a private convent had been expelled from two previous boarding schools before coming to our day school.

Pinkdelight3 · 09/02/2023 15:54

One thing I've always thought about horror movies, is that they almost always feature a girl or woman, being chased by a murderous man. And we watch this for entertainment!!?? That's a bit fucked up, is it not?

You're really parading your ignorance now, with the most simplistic takes on story and meaning that are barely attaining Mary Whitehouse-level insight. There's a vast array of work on women in horror, some of it conservative, some feminist, all with more nuance than this basic reading. Your take is simply not how our imaginations work and not making films that explore and address the darker sides of the psyche will not stop those sides existing nor is that their purpose. While you're down the Dunbar rabbithole, also check out the work of director Alan Clarke, who made great and provocative works like Made in Britain, Christine, Elephant and many more. They might not be your idea of 'entertainment' but they're powerful and vital contributions to the world.

BeachBlondey · 09/02/2023 15:43

latetothefisting · 09/02/2023 15:11

No idea why people are saying "it's not a comedy"
The description is "a comedy" or comedy drama. The imdb photos and taglines show that it was clearly marketed as a comedy, specifically an adult one. All the reviews refer to it as a comedy.

Yes perhaps the original story wasn't supposed to be a comedy, yes some of it might be "dark humour", yes there are elements of realism/subversion to it but it's ridiculous of posters to have a go at the OP as if she's stupid for referring to it as a comedy when that was clearly what it was created/marketed as.

Thank you. This is what I meant. I'm perhaps a bit clumsy in expressing myself. It wasn't portrayed as a seriously worrying situation. If a film was made now about the Rochdale girls, it would be serious and dark. This didn't feel like that. I remember watching it in 1987, and it was definitely viewed as a light hearted comedy by many, whereas I feel like people should have been thinking WTF. Can you imagine a film about the Rochdale victims, ending with a scene depicting the abuser jumping in to bed for a funny threesome?

OP posts:
BethDuttonsTwin · 09/02/2023 15:39

ExistenceOptional · 09/02/2023 15:26

16 was an adult then. Loads of people including myself started full time work at 16 years old.

From age 16 onwards I never had a boyfriend younger than 23 - late 80s/early 90s At the time it was seen as expected and fine. My parents expressed no concern whatsoever. It was the same for all my friends. We were seen as adult and able to make adult decisions at a much younger age.I was actually discussing this with a friend yesterday. I was married at 19, running a home and had joined a life long career path - settled according to everyone around me. I wasn’t remotely ready for any of it, and it all ended messily in my mid twenties.
This is why I get a little impatient with people who use their own early adult achievements to criticise the current generation. You see it a lot on here “well when I was 21 I was married and had a mortgage blah blah blah”. There were very rigid expectations, very early, which many of us couldn’t live up to and we ended up crashing a few years later and then taking years to get back on track - it’s only just happening for me now.

If you think it’s wrong that 16 year olds were considered “adult” for sexual and “relationship” purposes, then that also applies to other expectations of “adulthood” surely?

NecessaryScene · 09/02/2023 15:36

I recommend The Arbor which is a drama documentary about Andrea Dunbar’s difficult life.

Bumping this. Brilliant film in its own right, and will tell you everything about the background to Andrea Dunbar's play.

Ihateboris · 09/02/2023 15:34

OldTrot · 09/02/2023 13:03

It's a fantastic film. Thought provoking, gritty and yes, funny

Should we not make / read/ watch/ consume ANYTHING at all? Just because it doesn't suit a 2023 narrative

My thoughts exactly. In fact, one of my favourite films

Swipe left for the next trending thread