Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Rita, Sue and Bob too

309 replies

BeachBlondey · 09/02/2023 13:00

As a Happy Valley fan, I was surprised to find out that the actors who played Nev and Clare in Happy Valley, were actually in two main roles of the Rita, Sue and Bob too film from the 80s.

It's made me think about that old film again, and I'm actually shocked that it was made at all.

There is some discussion online today about the film, and most comments are along the lines of "great film", "a British Classic", and so forth.

The plot (for those who haven't seen it), is centered around a fully grown married man, who seduces grooms two 15 year old school girls and engages in lots of sex with them, mainly in his car (iirc).

How the hell was this okay, to put this out as a comedy, even back then? And how can the majority of people who remember the film, still think it's a great British classic?

OP posts:
SerafinasGoose · 12/02/2023 13:23

Titsalenabumflop · 11/02/2023 19:03

I remember it and remember thinking at the time that I wouldn't have wanted to be the girl he screwed second! YUK! Pretty pervy film, and yes, especially as it was two 15 year olds.

Since this discussion thread came up I'm seeing the character of Sue in a new light. She is a really hard-done-to character but manages to keep her spirit. She has her own moral lights and her own dignity which, within the strict limits of a very confined life, speak volumes about her integrity as a character.

From that position, the liaison with the higher-status Bob would have given the girls some much-needed escapism. After Michelle leaves, how would it feel for Sue to be told he's chosen her mate over her, that she's been seeing him on the sly without her and is now pregnant, and she is the one being left behind?

Sue is understandably pissed with Rita, but reacts with admirable dignity and restraint when Bob confronts her. All he is seemingly perturbed by is the fact that Sue appears so-unbothered, only professing concern for her friend. And when he asks her to continue meeting him, she refuses to do the dirty on Rita and forcefully tells him to get lost.

The thanks she gets for her troubles is even more depressing. She tries to put Bob and Rita behind her and move on, only to be confronted by her father's ugly racism toward her new Asian boyfriend, then to face equally ugly misogyny at the hands of Aslam and his family, who in more ways than one don't speak her language. To cap it all, her continuing loyalty to Rita only results in her being accused of fucking Bob anyway. The repercussions are that she becomes the victim of domestic violence at the hands of her boyfriend and it all ends up in the undesirable ending we see.

The ending is depressing but probably inevitable. Sue is stuck. She's faced violence and abuse at home, violence and abuse at Aslam's where she'd thought she had found a sanctuary, and has absolutely nowhere else to go.

Her fighting spirit is bloody inspirational, given the awful setbacks and privations suffered by this character. I'm now a newly-formed Sue fan.

Kennykenkencat · 12/02/2023 12:34

Pemba · 11/02/2023 14:25

Yes but it was quite dishonest of the film promoters. Also awful how they changed the ending against the wishes of the author. They made money from it presumably, but it seems nobody from the entertainment, arts world befriended Andrea Dunbar and assisted her in having a better life? Her talent was exploited and she died so young, tragic.

It shouldn't have been that way, I think of the guy who wrote 'Shameless', Paul something? He grew up fairly neglected on a rough estate in a household similar to the one depicted in the show. Yet he's broken away and enjoyed his success. Why couldn't it have been like that for Andrea?

Maybe it was about realising that whilst life is bleak. The majority of film goers wouldn’t pay money to watch a bleak film.
They want to be entertained.

Films cost money to make and no producer is going to back a film which is so bleak no one would watch it.

Shameless is a comedy. It is bleak the same way as this film but it has that uplift that makes people keep watching.
If it was all bleak and tragedy it wouldn’t have got a second series.

As someone who had a career in tv script writing I think Paul Abbot realised what sold and what didn’t.

misssunshine4040 · 12/02/2023 11:22

BeachBlondey · 09/02/2023 13:00

As a Happy Valley fan, I was surprised to find out that the actors who played Nev and Clare in Happy Valley, were actually in two main roles of the Rita, Sue and Bob too film from the 80s.

It's made me think about that old film again, and I'm actually shocked that it was made at all.

There is some discussion online today about the film, and most comments are along the lines of "great film", "a British Classic", and so forth.

The plot (for those who haven't seen it), is centered around a fully grown married man, who seduces grooms two 15 year old school girls and engages in lots of sex with them, mainly in his car (iirc).

How the hell was this okay, to put this out as a comedy, even back then? And how can the majority of people who remember the film, still think it's a great British classic?

It's not a comedy.
As a dark piece of film it portrayed the characters and their situations with realistic accuracy.
Are we not to watch themes that are dark and awful?

IbizaToTheNorfolkBroads · 12/02/2023 11:13

It was controversial when it was released.

lobeliasb · 12/02/2023 11:01

Titsalenabumflop · 11/02/2023 19:03

I remember it and remember thinking at the time that I wouldn't have wanted to be the girl he screwed second! YUK! Pretty pervy film, and yes, especially as it was two 15 year olds.

Right! I just watched it the other day after seeing this thread and he used the same condom for both girls, it was vile. They also get in the car with him late at night and instead of taking them home he's like "do you want to go driving on the moors?" My first reaction was "Ummm no thanks? I don't want to be murdered"

MadMadaMim · 12/02/2023 01:34

If that's what you think the plot is, you've missed the point of the film.

battgirlatheart · 12/02/2023 00:22

At the time I thought it was ok as I was 15 seeing a 32 year old man
now our daughter is 34 and I’m 51 I think the way it was made light of is bad.
As the song says
it was acceptable in the 80s

maggiedumont · 11/02/2023 21:59

I babysat as a teenager and frequently the husbands tried it on in the car going home.
I never thought anything about it. It's fabulous that girls now know to value themselves and call these creeps out. That film merely reflected life for some girls back then, it was superb.

Whyisitsososohard · 11/02/2023 21:11

A comedy 🤣

diddl · 11/02/2023 21:08

Lesley Sharpe who plays Bob's wife in the film isn't much older than Michelle Holmes or Siobhan Finneran.

Wonder what age his wife was supposed to be?

PlaitBilledDuckyPuss · 11/02/2023 19:51

Titsalenabumflop · 11/02/2023 19:03

I remember it and remember thinking at the time that I wouldn't have wanted to be the girl he screwed second! YUK! Pretty pervy film, and yes, especially as it was two 15 year olds.

From the point of view of the characters, Rita and Sue, Bob represented an aspirational lifestyle - compare his large, detached house in a leafy culdesac to the decaying slum accommodation and bleak estate where they lived. He had his own car and, by their standards, plenty of money. In their minds, shagging Bob gave them status, as well as sexual enjoyment - sex with the experienced Bob would be better than the fumblings they might expect from their peers.

It's not so much a comment on Bob, who was an opportunist and took what was offered to him, but a comment on society - the low expectations and standards the girls had; the misery of their home lives which made shagging a randy estate agent seem an attractive way to escape normality.

Nettleweed · 11/02/2023 19:50

It’s a very well-realised film that depicts the seedier side of life for some teenagers in the 1980s, with a dark humour and iconic scenes and one-liners.

Unfortunately I don’t think as much has changed as it should have in the past 35 years, when we have the likes of Wayne Lineker not only hiding in plain sight, but actually lauded for dating much younger women.

Companyofwolves · 11/02/2023 19:18

Pemba · 11/02/2023 14:25

Yes but it was quite dishonest of the film promoters. Also awful how they changed the ending against the wishes of the author. They made money from it presumably, but it seems nobody from the entertainment, arts world befriended Andrea Dunbar and assisted her in having a better life? Her talent was exploited and she died so young, tragic.

It shouldn't have been that way, I think of the guy who wrote 'Shameless', Paul something? He grew up fairly neglected on a rough estate in a household similar to the one depicted in the show. Yet he's broken away and enjoyed his success. Why couldn't it have been like that for Andrea?

Probably because she was a working class woman.

Titsalenabumflop · 11/02/2023 19:03

I remember it and remember thinking at the time that I wouldn't have wanted to be the girl he screwed second! YUK! Pretty pervy film, and yes, especially as it was two 15 year olds.

Justbefair · 11/02/2023 18:44

First time I watched it when I was very young my reaction was ugh what a perv and 2 girls well, er, loose and and rough as hell. Defo a bit disturbing and as a young girl I couldn't imagine being in that situation. I did enjoy it, lots of funny but along with it dark threads. X

Bleachmycloths · 11/02/2023 18:39

BeachBlondey · 09/02/2023 13:29

No, I'm not saying that at all. I'm shocked that this was seen as ok, and normal in 1987 - for a married man to be having sex with 15 year old's.

FFS - No one said it was ‘ok’ It was a drama for god’s sake. Written to make people think. What do you want from drama? Andy Pandy and Rag Tag and Bob Tail?

TrixieMixie · 11/02/2023 18:38

Do you think the behaviour in Happy Valley is acceptable? Just because behaviour is depicted doesn’t mean it’s condoned.

SelinaKant · 11/02/2023 18:35

It was based on the Buttershawe Estate in Bradford which is still like that today (but far more violence, drugs and community degeneration now). 15 year olds girls having sex with much older men - it was very normal then. The film was very well acted, if a bit grim.

Bleachmycloths · 11/02/2023 18:33

I haven’t read all the posts. CBA. But drama isn’t about how the world should be but how it is.

Florenz · 11/02/2023 18:30

No way should it be legal for a grown man to have sex with 14 or 15 year old girls. I'd argue it should be raised to 18 but with an allowance where 14-17 year olds are allowed to have sex with someone within 2 years of their age.

Americano75 · 11/02/2023 18:25

I wouldn't be using social media as a source to be honest, facts are often distorted or exaggerated.

My eldest was 15 not all that long ago, I think a couple of her friends were sexually active at 15/16 but they seemed to be in the minority. That's just a small sample though.

OzBoy · 11/02/2023 18:19

I'm V aware and sensitive to the fact that many on here have Dau's and dread all this. I'm just posting an opinion based on what I hear & see on social media plus Gov't "research" etc. The past Spanish AoC is fact.

Beammeupdude · 11/02/2023 18:15

"Blimey it looks like a frozen sausage" is the one that always sticks in my mind.

Americano75 · 11/02/2023 18:14

OzBoy · 11/02/2023 18:08

16 Age of Consent is BS in the UK when most of them are at it by 15. What, one day you're illegal and a minute later you're legal. Should have been made 15 long ago in the UK, girls are maturing much younger. Until V recently the AoC in Spain was 13! Definitely don't agree with that though....

Is your assertion based on recent research or is it your own experience?

OzBoy · 11/02/2023 18:08

16 Age of Consent is BS in the UK when most of them are at it by 15. What, one day you're illegal and a minute later you're legal. Should have been made 15 long ago in the UK, girls are maturing much younger. Until V recently the AoC in Spain was 13! Definitely don't agree with that though....