Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that this book should not be sold to young girls?

519 replies

WandaWomblesaurus · 09/02/2023 09:25

twitter.com/Waterstones/status/1623584986740953091?s=20&t=WU0D0fzc6ClGJC5R-gJnuw

Waterstones tweeted celebrating a book that is about transing girls. Here is one of the illustrations from the book.

AIBU to think that this is directly promoting self harm to young vulnerable girls?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
Happylittlechicken · 09/02/2023 13:01

True. @CTRALTDEL they don’t. But then those books aren’t telling kids how to become pirates are they? Why do you think websites promoting anorexia are banned? Is it because
a) teenage girls are really impressionable and, already suffering from anxiety about their changing bodies, could be persuaded by these websites that starvation will help them feel better if told so by their peers
b ) the medical profession and other services are just prejudiced and don’t want teenage girls to achieve their true body potential.

Clymene · 09/02/2023 13:01

NowDoYouBelieveMe · 09/02/2023 12:58

So it's a graphic novel about the adolescent experiences of its author, a trans man.

I think kids are able to understand that much.

Trans boys who read it will likely relate to some or much of it and feel less alone.

It's only "despicable" if you don't believe people can be trans.

It's despicable because it is propaganda aimed at children to promote self harm and mutilation.

ScrollingLeaves · 09/02/2023 13:00

It is the same as Pro-Ana.

Waterstones is promoting self-harm by selling it.

Johnnysgirl · 09/02/2023 12:58

more an opportunity to empathise....maybe along the lines of Tracy Beaker
Ffs! Listen to yourself 🙄

LifesNotEnidBlyton · 09/02/2023 12:58

Although thinking back unsure if we're allowed to share links to their website? Oh well, MN welcome to delete if we're not....

NowDoYouBelieveMe · 09/02/2023 12:58

So it's a graphic novel about the adolescent experiences of its author, a trans man.

I think kids are able to understand that much.

Trans boys who read it will likely relate to some or much of it and feel less alone.

It's only "despicable" if you don't believe people can be trans.

LifesNotEnidBlyton · 09/02/2023 12:56

The author has a bio on Stonewalls website....

www.stonewall.org.uk/people/lewis-hancox

CTRALTDEL · 09/02/2023 12:55

'To all those saying this is a harmless book and no biggie, if a book came out at young girls promoting anorexia and bulimia would you say the same thing?'

if a book mentioned the experience of anorexia and bulimia, then yes. just as some books for older kids talk about parents in prison, drugs, bullying, sex, smoking etc.
Books showing drug use don't turn your kid into an addict, books with gay or trans people portrayed don't turn your kids gay or trans, books with criminals or pirates, don't turn your kids into criminals or pirates...

CTRALTDEL · 09/02/2023 12:53

At 11 i was reading adult books, everything from Dickens to Danielle Steele and everything in between. There's not much you an do if your kid wants to read a graphic novel about trans people. They'll find far more on the internet.

CTRALTDEL · 09/02/2023 12:51

It's not a book explaining puberty, it;s a graphic novel, semi-biographical, called'
Welcome to St hell: my trans teen misadventure'.

Seems pretty clear that it's the author's experience of being trans. You can't censor everything in the world that you don't agree with.

3peassuit · 09/02/2023 12:49

They’re pushing the lie that puberty blockers are reversible . It’s shocking.

hryllilegur · 09/02/2023 12:44

Maybe the answer is to really support the appropriate books (I assume the other books are appropriate, which may be erroneous) on the shortlist. Tell Waterstones about the really excellent literature for young people that exists out there. Repeatedly. And why it’s both good and appropriate.

They aren’t going to listen to why didactic books promoting body dysmorphia are harmful, so maybe drown them in praise for the kinds of books they should be celebrating.

TheOrigRights · 09/02/2023 12:39

Is it Welcome to St Hell?

Are there books which are recommended for trans teens?
I am dubious about this one being short-listed for a book prize, because I believe the demographic (genuine trans boys) is very, very small, but maybe it is a good book for those kids.

What age is the 'older readers' category aimed at?

SirVixofVixHall · 09/02/2023 12:36

Happylittlechicken · 09/02/2023 12:34

To all those saying this is a harmless book and no biggie, if a book came out at young girls promoting anorexia and bulimia would you say the same thing? If a book came out promoting cutting and self harm? If not, why not? Why is it ok to have literature promoting self harm if it’s in the name of gender but not for other forms of body dysmorphia?

This.

Happylittlechicken · 09/02/2023 12:34

To all those saying this is a harmless book and no biggie, if a book came out at young girls promoting anorexia and bulimia would you say the same thing? If a book came out promoting cutting and self harm? If not, why not? Why is it ok to have literature promoting self harm if it’s in the name of gender but not for other forms of body dysmorphia?

AmuseBish · 09/02/2023 12:31

Wow that's depressing.

(And transphobic to imply that men have willies and no fatty lumps! Any gender can be in any body, surely, or is there something about being a man that requires a male body, like what those terrible bigots say?)

Naunet · 09/02/2023 12:30

JudgeRudy · 09/02/2023 11:50

I'm well aware of what censoring is. It's exactly what you seem to be suggesting so lm surprised by your response.
I think you need to re-read my post. The key words are YOU and IN THIS WAY.

So you’re aware that we DO ‘censor’ books and other media in this way because it’s not suitable for children, and that’s fine, but also we shouldn’t?! Or is it just this particular book that you don’t want ‘censored’/only sold to adults?

7Worfs · 09/02/2023 12:26

Following on my previous post about more organised calls to action-

We have more and more high profile women winning important cases and getting media reporting, but surely it’s time for everyday women & mums (like me and many other readers/posters) to take action?

I don’t believe in Twitter wars, so is there a way to organise protests (Tate, Waterstones HQ, just from the last few days!), boycotts and inundating their press office/CEO/board with official complaints?

The line must be drawn here, surely. Every day something abominable normalised for our children. I just can’t take it anymore.

SirVixofVixHall · 09/02/2023 12:23

BreviloquentBastard · 09/02/2023 09:46

"Fatty lumps that need be gone" give me the proper squicks. As if little girls don't have enough shit swirling around them breeding insecurities and self loathing, let's add "cut off your disgusting fatty lumps" to the mix. Jesus.

Agree. We know a girl who had a double mastectomy at 17. Tragic.

hryllilegur · 09/02/2023 12:22

Or do some posters think that considering a book as part of the shortlist for a prize is not celebratory?

What is more celebratory than giving something a medal?

hryllilegur · 09/02/2023 12:21

There’s a big difference between censorship and alarm that Waterstones have chosen to shortlist something for a children’s literature prize.

Clymene · 09/02/2023 12:16

Sorry @7Worfs - I completely understood what you meant and didn't mean to quote you!

I absolutely agree with you. We recently had that terrible case where a teenage girl killed herself because of easy access to dangerous online materials.

Somehow we imagine that offline content is safer. But here is a book promoting mutilation, self harm, sterilisation, osteoporosis and stunted growth not just being published but actively promoted to children by the biggest chain of bookshops in the U.K.?

LizzieSiddal · 09/02/2023 12:15

Fucking hell that is a grim book. I wouldn’t want my dd anywhere near it. The vast majority of girls going through puberty dislike what’s happening to their bodies, we find it weird and uncomfortable. This book would be telling them the solution is to take drugs which, according to the Cass Review aren’t even tested on teenagers!

ResisterRex · 09/02/2023 12:14

7Worfs · 09/02/2023 11:37

I see the so open-minded their brains have fallen out brigade are starting to congregate.

To even suggest to young girls full of angst over their changing bodies that they can get rid of their breasts if they wanted to, is criminal.

The dangers of telling lies to children as shown via this US whistleblower,who managed a "transgender centre" for children.

When she spoke about needing to be thoughtful and consider the harm, she and a colleague were told: "get on board, or get out.”

www.thefp.com/p/i-thought-i-was-saving-trans-kids

And here's a UK whistleblower example:

medium.com/@kirstyentwistle/an-open-letter-to-dr-polly-carmichael-from-a-former-gids-clinician-53c541276b8d

That's just one in the UK, there are others showing where being so open-minded your brain has fallen out, leads to.

Clymene · 09/02/2023 12:13

BlibBlabBlob · 09/02/2023 12:08

Oh god my DD (12, autistic) has this book. Trans/gay literature is all the rage for her age group it seems.

Fortunately she is GC as fuck and happy to give mini lectures on how much healthier it is to learn to accept the body you have rather than taking hormones and chopping off healthy body parts! She fully believes that biology trumps gender identity and has shown no trans inclination. I'm hoping this continues throughout puberty, which is just getting going for her...

Where did she get it from?