Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that this book should not be sold to young girls?

519 replies

WandaWomblesaurus · 09/02/2023 09:25

twitter.com/Waterstones/status/1623584986740953091?s=20&t=WU0D0fzc6ClGJC5R-gJnuw

Waterstones tweeted celebrating a book that is about transing girls. Here is one of the illustrations from the book.

AIBU to think that this is directly promoting self harm to young vulnerable girls?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
beautifulpaintings · 09/02/2023 15:30

For anyone arguing against censoring, nobody would have to censor this book. Just don't have one of the hugest book sellers in the country actively promote it with a major publisher endorse it. It looks like a bizarre book and that image is crap. It just feels like a lazy effort which could cause damage to some readers. Surely there are better choices.

Just let it wallow in self published anonymity, ignored. Nothing technically has to be censored these days if that's the option taken.

CTRALTDEL · 09/02/2023 15:29

‘Why socks?’

Good question, which would be answered if anyone actually read the book.

CTRALTDEL · 09/02/2023 15:28

‘encourage Waterstones to revise their attitude to stocking it on their bookshelves ...’

Go for it. I don’t suppose anyone at Waterstones feels that books should be banned anymore than most people do.

But before you go off on a rant you,
and anyone else planning on jumping on the outraged bandwagon, should read the book first. Rather than just read something out of context in SM and decide that’s enough to be petitioning companies to stop selling something.
personally, I’m sickened by the amount of books in the crime section that contain graphic descriptions of women being abused. So I don’t read or buy them. Much
as I would like to not have the there at all, that’s not how it works.

TeaKlaxon · 09/02/2023 15:28

ResisterRex · 09/02/2023 15:25

A 14 year old is a child. Not an "older teen" Hmm

As I said before, what's promoted is not harmless. Far from it:

"How little patients understood what they were getting into was illustrated by a call we received at the center in 2020 from a 17-year-old biological female patient who was on testosterone. She said she was bleeding from the vagina. In less than an hour she had soaked through an extra heavy pad, her jeans, and a towel she had wrapped around her waist. The nurse at the center told her to go to the emergency room right away.

We found out later this girl had had intercourse, and because testosterone thins the vaginal tissues, her vaginal canal had ripped open. She had to be sedated and given surgery to repair the damage. She wasn’t the only vaginal laceration case we heard about."

www.thefp.com/p/i-thought-i-was-saving-trans-kids

It is wrong to lie about medicating children. It is wrong to glamorise such medication.

What's the lie?

TeaKlaxon · 09/02/2023 15:26

The mask is slipping here guys.

Here is an author that those who oppose trans rights consider to be a woman.

And here we have a bunch of posters claiming that that 'woman' shouldn't be allowed to write about 'her' experiences and feelings as a teenager in a book aimed at teenagers.

And yet in the same breath, they'll claim to support women's voices. All a bit hypocritical, isn't it?

ResisterRex · 09/02/2023 15:25

A 14 year old is a child. Not an "older teen" Hmm

As I said before, what's promoted is not harmless. Far from it:

"How little patients understood what they were getting into was illustrated by a call we received at the center in 2020 from a 17-year-old biological female patient who was on testosterone. She said she was bleeding from the vagina. In less than an hour she had soaked through an extra heavy pad, her jeans, and a towel she had wrapped around her waist. The nurse at the center told her to go to the emergency room right away.

We found out later this girl had had intercourse, and because testosterone thins the vaginal tissues, her vaginal canal had ripped open. She had to be sedated and given surgery to repair the damage. She wasn’t the only vaginal laceration case we heard about."

www.thefp.com/p/i-thought-i-was-saving-trans-kids

It is wrong to lie about medicating children. It is wrong to glamorise such medication.

LubaLuca · 09/02/2023 15:23

AllOfThemWitches · 09/02/2023 09:29

Why socks?

I guess it's meant to be from the point of view of a girl who is uncomfortable in her body. Which I understand more than a man putting on a dress and declaring himself female.

Probably can't draw toes.

It's grim beyond belief. Imagine if this was a book about 'the old/disabled/black body' presented in a similar way. Would that make it into a book prize shortlist?! Disgusting.

Onnabugeisha · 09/02/2023 15:20

Ah, having looked further it’s a teen book for 14+ readers:

www.amazon.co.uk/Welcome-St-Hell-misadventure-remarkable/dp/0702313904

And is essentially a graphic novel style autobiography written by a transman.

I don’t really have a problem with it in that context as being for older teens. Most girls will be done or almost done with puberty by age 14 anyway so it’s not going to convert anyone imho,

Thats the author’s lived experience…including being told false facts about puberty blockers. So I have no issue with him publishing what his younger self was sold.

It will be as important for history to have a record of how people determined their trans-identity belief, just like we have books that record how people determine their gender critical beliefs.

fUNNYfACE36 · 09/02/2023 15:19

UWhatNow · 09/02/2023 14:08

How is homophobia even remotely comparable to concern for the mental health and bodily safeguarding of girls?

Your analogy is, as usual when TRAs trot it out, unhinged from reality.

What is TRA?

BlibBlabBlob · 09/02/2023 15:19

Clymene · 09/02/2023 12:13

Where did she get it from?

Bought from the 'gay book section' (as DD calls it) in our local branch of Waterstones. It's very prominent. I'm totally happy for her to read the gay stuff but this particular book made me wobble a lot. At least it's been another discussion point for us though and I don't think she's likely to be taken in by the trans agenda any time soon. It's been a particular concern of mine, as mother to an autistic female child, because a worryingly high percentage of trans boys/men i.e. females with a male gender identity are also neurodiverse. So she's potentially more at risk than neurotypical girls of being sucked in by it all in the search for her own sense of identity.

Heartsandbirds · 09/02/2023 15:14

Whoooooaaaaa…. That’s… shocking.

Onnabugeisha · 09/02/2023 15:07

The illustration appears to be about puberty and reflecting the thoughts of a girl in puberty. Without knowing what the rest of the book says, I can’t really say if it’s age appropriate for the ages 10+ readers.

I can imagine misjudging some classic books I read at that age similarly based on illustrations alone. Tale of Two Cities had a guillotine graphic for example.

nopuppiesallowed · 09/02/2023 15:06

Perhaps we should express our opinions on this book to Waterstones. Keeping our thoughts about it solely to Mumsnet readers won't encourage Waterstones to revise their attitude to stocking it on their bookshelves ...
Memo to self - do this tonight

Catspyjamas17 · 09/02/2023 15:04

ClearMoth · 09/02/2023 14:45

Ok then. Explain why that isn't true. But why it is true of young girls who feel that way about their sex, rather than their race. Go on.

Explain why it's wrong.

You are the one saying it's wrong, why don't you explain?

JusteanBiscuits · 09/02/2023 15:02

ClearMoth · 09/02/2023 14:29

You have two children but you don't understand the difference between fact and fiction?

I am making a presumption that you have kids, yet can't understand quoted threads and responses to them.

JusteanBiscuits · 09/02/2023 15:00

7Worfs · 09/02/2023 14:28

How did I know you will reply with your “credentials”? 🤔
Tell me more about the superheroes who acquired their powers (achieved their true potential) after being groomed into self-loathing and persuaded to mutilate their bodies?

Did you even bother to read the quote I replied to??? I was commenting on the ridiculous nature of them comparing this book to "what if someone wrote a book about someone who jumped off a building and could fly". You then told me to go read some comic books. So I'm now allowed to point out I have, actually, read a lot of them??? Stop being so faux outraged you can't read posts anymore.

7Worfs · 09/02/2023 14:51

Oh enough with the faux concern about free speech.

Funny how the same open-minded types demand “curating” of content when it suits, but children must have access to anything and everything, and have the agency to make decisions (I wonder what’s the end game there - surely not eroding age of consent?)

Adults can read whatever they want; children cannot.

ClearMoth · 09/02/2023 14:45

Catspyjamas17 · 09/02/2023 14:40

Yeah, just carry on enjoying yourself putting words into my mouth. What a croc.

Ok then. Explain why that isn't true. But why it is true of young girls who feel that way about their sex, rather than their race. Go on.

Explain why it's wrong.

CTRALTDEL · 09/02/2023 14:43

'Shall we also include books about torturing & killing small animals?'

Include them in what? Are there books on this? Maybe in biographies of serial killers it gets a mention.
Should we ban all books about true crime? I wouldn't miss them.

Catspyjamas17 · 09/02/2023 14:40

ClearMoth · 09/02/2023 14:38

And based on your post, you also think that the reason young Black people might hate their bodies is that they're really White people who have somehow been 'born in the wrong body' and should therefore have surgery and take drugs to make their outer appearance look 'White'?

Wow again.

Yeah, just carry on enjoying yourself putting words into my mouth. What a croc.

Always4Brenner · 09/02/2023 14:39

Dreadful book I give up now fatty hips I grew up in a family being told I was fat from 13 today I still hate mirrors.

Unsure33 · 09/02/2023 14:39

7Worfs · 09/02/2023 12:07

I think many have woken up, but no decisive action by the majority.

There need to be more organised calls to action and boycotting/protests etc

I think need more men as well as women to stand up for their daughters. I am following James Esses on Twitter who has a court case coming up . He is doing his best to spread the word . Expelled from unversity for GC views

ClearMoth · 09/02/2023 14:38

ClearMoth · 09/02/2023 14:30

What you seem to be (deliberately?) missing is that this book tells girls they are RIGHT to feel this way about their bodies, and that they should listen to the voices that tell them they are disgusting and hideous and revolting and ugly and sweaty etc.

You would approve a book telling young Black people that they were all of those things, and that the answer is for them to bleach their skin, straighten their hair, get nose jobs, etc.

Wow.

And based on your post, you also think that the reason young Black people might hate their bodies is that they're really White people who have somehow been 'born in the wrong body' and should therefore have surgery and take drugs to make their outer appearance look 'White'?

Wow again.

Oblomov23 · 09/02/2023 14:35

Jesus Christ that is horrific. This is so not ok.

ResisterRex · 09/02/2023 14:31

What's promoted is not harmless. From the link I posted upthread:

"How little patients understood what they were getting into was illustrated by a call we received at the center in 2020 from a 17-year-old biological female patient who was on testosterone. She said she was bleeding from the vagina. In less than an hour she had soaked through an extra heavy pad, her jeans, and a towel she had wrapped around her waist. The nurse at the center told her to go to the emergency room right away.

We found out later this girl had had intercourse, and because testosterone thins the vaginal tissues, her vaginal canal had ripped open. She had to be sedated and given surgery to repair the damage. She wasn’t the only vaginal laceration case we heard about."
www.thefp.com/p/i-thought-i-was-saving-trans-kids

It is wrong to lie about medicating children. It is wrong to glamorise such medication.

Swipe left for the next trending thread