Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that this book should not be sold to young girls?

519 replies

WandaWomblesaurus · 09/02/2023 09:25

twitter.com/Waterstones/status/1623584986740953091?s=20&t=WU0D0fzc6ClGJC5R-gJnuw

Waterstones tweeted celebrating a book that is about transing girls. Here is one of the illustrations from the book.

AIBU to think that this is directly promoting self harm to young vulnerable girls?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
Johnnysgirl · 10/02/2023 10:16

TeaKlaxon · 10/02/2023 10:12

No.

But it probably would make you fairly well qualified to tell your friend who is scared of flying that the experience is actually fine or even pleasant.

Someone saying 'here is my story and here is its (positive) outcome' is entirely reasonable.

They do not become unreasonable just because some transphobes desperately want all trans people to have awful outcomes to justify their campaign against trans healthcare.

That post screams your agenda from the rooftops 🙄
You're all transphobes, You want trans people not to have medical care, Want to see awful outcomes rather than positive...
It's all there.

Sep200024 · 10/02/2023 10:13

Fucking hell. I’ve had an absolute shedful of this.

As if puberty is not hard enough, and has already been made 100x harder by the internet and social media, now we have this absolute bullshit to deal with as well.

I used to be completely tolerant of genuine body dysmorphia, but not anymore. The way it’s being pushed and normalised so heavily is impacting non-dysmorphic young people, which is totally unacceptable. We don’t improve the life experience of a small number of people by making the life experience of a larger number of people worse.

Had enough, and the trans community have entirely lost my support.

TeaKlaxon · 10/02/2023 10:12

RaininginDarling · 10/02/2023 09:43

I have the lived experience of being on a plane - many, many times over - does that make me a pilot?

Lived experience does not equal professional (and neutral) expert. What a ridiculous argument.

No.

But it probably would make you fairly well qualified to tell your friend who is scared of flying that the experience is actually fine or even pleasant.

Someone saying 'here is my story and here is its (positive) outcome' is entirely reasonable.

They do not become unreasonable just because some transphobes desperately want all trans people to have awful outcomes to justify their campaign against trans healthcare.

TeaKlaxon · 10/02/2023 10:10

ClearMoth · 10/02/2023 09:31

'Lived experience' is not (only) how we measure the effects of medical treatment.

Sure, anyone can share their experiences.

There is actual medical science that disagrees.

No, there isn't.

And anyone should be entitled to share their lived experience. I know those who want trans people to have fewer rights and less access to healthcare desperately think we should only hear from the small minority of trans people who detransition or regret their transition - but that would not be reasonable, fair or representative.

Young trans people deserve to hear the stories of people like them, just as any minority group deserve to hear from people like them.

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 10/02/2023 10:02

Returning to the enormous difference between the fast-growing number of teenage girls and very young women identifying as male vs the tiny number of older women doing it - here we are on Mumsnet, largely used by women who came through puberty some years ago. I wonder how many of us here look back on our teenage years and think 'If only I'd been allowed to have a double mastectomy and a hysterectomy as soon as I turned 18?' I wouldn't. I had a horrendous time with endometriosis, but that pales into comparison besides the fact that I was able to have children. I could never have understood fully when I was in my teens what that would mean to me.

RaininginDarling · 10/02/2023 09:59

ResisterRex · 10/02/2023 09:53

"Lived experience" only ever seems to count in the current fashionable areas of identity politics. It never counts for women (adult human females) nor does it count in disability. It used to in the latter - "nothing about us without us" - and occasionally we were allowed a view in the former. But not now.

See also: words of disagreement = violence unless its actual violent threats made against women.

They always know who the women are really, and our lived experience doesn't count.

PurpleButterflyWings · 10/02/2023 09:53

MY EYES!!! 😵

ResisterRex · 10/02/2023 09:53

"Lived experience" only ever seems to count in the current fashionable areas of identity politics. It never counts for women (adult human females) nor does it count in disability. It used to in the latter - "nothing about us without us" - and occasionally we were allowed a view in the former. But not now.

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 10/02/2023 09:52

TeaKlaxon · 10/02/2023 09:28

The author who has considerably more lived experience on this issue clearly disagrees.

Why do you think he should not be allowed to share his lived experience?

We can all spout our opinions on all sorts of things. What I expect from a reputable publisher like Scholastic, and what I would hope would be carefully considered before shortlisting a controversial book for a high-profile award, is whether those opinions are backed up by fact.

This is a book aimed at a particularly impressionable age group. Lewis has opinions which are at odds with those of many health care professionals and others with professional training and experience in working with young people and children. Fine for Lewis to write a one-sided book aimed at adults. Not fine for this to be published and pushed towards teenagers without any attempt to point out that Lewis is just plain wrong in saying that puberty blockers are harmless, just represent pressing a pause button, etc etc.

YouSetTheTone · 10/02/2023 09:50

*The author who has considerably more lived experience on this issue clearly disagrees.

Why do you think he should not be allowed to share his lived experience?*

The author may have experience of puberty blockers (surely lived experience is tautology? You can’t have dead experience). But that doesn’t mean it’s appropriate or responsible to represent them casually in a cartoon as something that’s no big deal to take, and is reversible.
This is misrepresentation that will have serious consequences. These drugs are actively harmful to growing children.
The human body is designed to go through puberty. It is important to go through it for a number of physical, endocrine, and neurological reasons. Pausing puberty on an otherwise healthy child, using drugs, will impair them.

RaininginDarling · 10/02/2023 09:43

TeaKlaxon · 10/02/2023 09:28

The author who has considerably more lived experience on this issue clearly disagrees.

Why do you think he should not be allowed to share his lived experience?

I have the lived experience of being on a plane - many, many times over - does that make me a pilot?

Lived experience does not equal professional (and neutral) expert. What a ridiculous argument.

Clymene · 10/02/2023 09:42

No, but they're having them under -8 @TeaKlaxon

They can't vote or get a tattoo but can have a double mastectomy

ClearMoth · 10/02/2023 09:31

TeaKlaxon · 10/02/2023 09:28

The author who has considerably more lived experience on this issue clearly disagrees.

Why do you think he should not be allowed to share his lived experience?

'Lived experience' is not (only) how we measure the effects of medical treatment.

Sure, anyone can share their experiences.

There is actual medical science that disagrees.

nolongersurprised · 10/02/2023 09:31

For crying out loud, you don't get your cock cut open and turned inside out for fun do you?

Adult men, who have reached sexual maturity and had an orgasm and have preserved fertility can do what they like with their bodies.

Did you know that a male child, who has been on puberty blockers since early puberty will never have sexual function, never have an orgasm, never father a child and have a micro penis.

do you think an 11 year old boy can consent to that?

TeaKlaxon · 10/02/2023 09:29

PriOn1 · 09/02/2023 22:54

I refuse to believe gender dysphoria is 'made-up'.

I don’t think anyone is suggesting that the feelings of distress don’t exist. My personal feeling is that physical transition is snake oil and that in the longer term, and on average, it causes more physical and mental damage than it alleviates. It is far from being fixed science and is based on poor evidence, having been set in motion by a pervert (John Money - feel free to look him up.)

For crying out loud, you don't get your cock cut open and turned inside out for fun do you?

95% of men who claim they are women have no intention of having their penis and testicles removed. The majority claiming they are trans now, and particularly those driving much of the extremist lobbying, would previously have been called transvestites.

And where is anyone saying these young women are having mastectomies for shit and giggles? These are children as young as twelve and presumably feel strongly it’s the right thing for them. Do you think they understand the consequences well enough at fourteen years old to take that decision?

No one is getting mastectomies at 14 in the UK.

TeaKlaxon · 10/02/2023 09:28

ClearMoth · 09/02/2023 22:50

Puberty blockers are not harmless.

The author who has considerably more lived experience on this issue clearly disagrees.

Why do you think he should not be allowed to share his lived experience?

nolongersurprised · 10/02/2023 09:02

Catspyjamas17 · 09/02/2023 09:40

I don't think it's encouraging self-loathing. Why shouldn't it be represented in fiction if some kids do feel that way about their bodies?

I read a load of Judy Blume books aged 11+ which I remember were quite explicit about all sorts of things from puberty, body image, sexual feeling, sex itself. I didn't automatically starting thinking in the same way as the characters in the book but it was good to have different perspectives on life.

This book may help kids to understand how their friends may be feeling.

I’m reading the Judy Blume books to my youngest now. The books discuss normal puberty, body changes, anxiety around whether or not normal changes are actually normal. No where do any of them normalise wanting healthy body parts/organs removed.

ClearMoth · 10/02/2023 08:48

Onnabugeisha · 09/02/2023 23:56

@ClearMoth
Your data is very old compared to mine.

There is a huge difference between ability to access gender affirming surgery (and pay for it in the US) vs intent or desire to have it. You cannot say that the vast majority of men (or the pp 95%) have “no intention” of ever getting genital surgery on the basis of a decade old data that only shows those who could access surgery, pay privately for surgery and have already done it.

In addition, the 1% of the population being transgender includes nonbinary people who both vastly outnumber transmen or transwomen and don’t need surgery so you cannot use 1% to extrapolate an expected need for gender affirming surgery of 3m people.

Whatever. I'm actually not that bothered about men and their dicks. Cba to argue about that.

This thread is about young girls. I posted several times, long posts about my experiences and about girls of different ethnicities being taught to hate their bodies in different ways.

That's what we are meant to be talking about.

RaininginDarling · 10/02/2023 08:46

YANBU

www.thefp.com/p/i-thought-i-was-saving-trans-kids

Johnnysgirl · 10/02/2023 08:38

Onnabugeisha · 10/02/2023 08:34

@PriOn1

While I agree social contagion/gender confusion is a thing, I don’t think the difference in #s of older women not transitioning compared to young teen girls identifying at transmen can solely be put down to the above.

The waitlist from first referral to first consultation at the NHS gender clinic is around 4.5yrs! The latest figures they show are that they offered 1st appointments in May 22 to those referred in Jan 18. Obviously some of this is the knock on effect from covid, but it also doesn’t include the waitlists to get two consultants to agree to refer to the gender clinic..those are probably another year or so if NHS usual waitlists are anything to go by. It doesn’t include the process time and waitlist for the surgery itself either.

But the point is that a teen can identify as a transman in an instant, but it takes more than 5yrs to even be seen at the gender clinic, never mind get the surgery.

There is also the fact that the older you are, the more you would be put off by such long waitlists for surgery. Plus you are at higher risk of surgical complications. So the things you might have desperately wished for when young, the ship could have quite literally sailed for your generation.

Finally, as is typical with medicine, surgery techniques and technology for natal men was/is prioritised over surgery for natal women/transmen.

Nah, your first line had it all. Social contagion is a real thing.

Onnabugeisha · 10/02/2023 08:34

@PriOn1

While I agree social contagion/gender confusion is a thing, I don’t think the difference in #s of older women not transitioning compared to young teen girls identifying at transmen can solely be put down to the above.

The waitlist from first referral to first consultation at the NHS gender clinic is around 4.5yrs! The latest figures they show are that they offered 1st appointments in May 22 to those referred in Jan 18. Obviously some of this is the knock on effect from covid, but it also doesn’t include the waitlists to get two consultants to agree to refer to the gender clinic..those are probably another year or so if NHS usual waitlists are anything to go by. It doesn’t include the process time and waitlist for the surgery itself either.

But the point is that a teen can identify as a transman in an instant, but it takes more than 5yrs to even be seen at the gender clinic, never mind get the surgery.

There is also the fact that the older you are, the more you would be put off by such long waitlists for surgery. Plus you are at higher risk of surgical complications. So the things you might have desperately wished for when young, the ship could have quite literally sailed for your generation.

Finally, as is typical with medicine, surgery techniques and technology for natal men was/is prioritised over surgery for natal women/transmen.

PriOn1 · 10/02/2023 05:50

RobertaFirmino · 09/02/2023 23:16

@PriOn1 Regardless of how small the percentage is, there are still biological males having this procedure. They were once boys and I'm willing to bet their adolescence was a living hell. Todays boys (and girls) in this situation need to be listened to and understood, regardless of number. And who on earth is allowing girls as young as 12 to have a mastectomy? That's abysmal and you will recall that I spoke about a much longer period of time living as the opposite sex before interventions start. In the meantime, how is their wellbeing ensured? How can they feel less alone? Part of this surely includes hearing the experiences of others.

Being listened to is fine. Being told it’s all going to be fine and being given appropriate treatment, whatever that might be, is also fine.

We are discussing a book that is being pushed into the mainstream, into a febrile situation where there has been a 4000% increase in patients in the demographic the book represents.

There are clusters of cases in teenagers in certain schools and areas, and older women are not transitioning in similar numbers, which strongly suggests social contagion.

To throw a book like this, which is basically normalizing an experimental treatment with devastating side effects, into this febrile situation is, at best, negligent.

Onnabugeisha · 10/02/2023 00:18

RobertaFirmino · 10/02/2023 00:00

I've just been reading about top surgery on 13 year olds. In the USA. Unscrupulous surgeons with dollar signs in their eyes. That's where blame lies. Not with Waterstones and not with someone writing about their own experiences. I also found out that nobody would be having this surgery in the UK until the age of 17-18 which is still far too young, granted, but my outrage is directed firmly over the Atlantic. If these surgeons said no, this wouldn't be happening.

Agree. It’s batshit you can’t drink alcohol, or have sex but you can undergo major irreversible body modification surgery.

Onnabugeisha · 10/02/2023 00:00

ClearMoth · 09/02/2023 23:39

@Onnabugeisha

In 2016, a meta-analysis of 27 studies estimated a rate of approx 10 per 100,000 of the population (0.01%) have a transgender diagnosis and/or surgical or hormonal treatment. In contrast 355 per 100,000 of the population(0.35%) self-identity as transgender. This means only 2.8% of the transgender community is undergoing any gender-affirming treatment with the vast majority 97.2% simply self-identity with no modifications to their sexed body whatsoever.

No one knows for sure how many transwomen keep their penis, but there are fewer than 10 surgeons in the UK who can undertake the relevant operation. Even if they each performed one operation every single day this would still only represent an absolute maximum of 3,500 surgeries each year. The actual number performed is likely to be very much smaller than this. An estimate of just a few hundred operations each year would not be unreasonable.

There is also data available from the US HERE showing that genital surgery is very rare. In this study (sampling 20% of all outpatient hospital discharges in the US) there were only a few hundred genital surgeries performed each year. (205 in 2012, 250 in 2013, 345 in 2014). This suggests that between 1000-2000 genital surgeries were performed across the whole of the US each. If the trans community in the US represents 1% of the US population this means we’d expect there to be in the region of 3 million people identifying as trans in the US. This means less than 0.1% of the trans community undergoes genital surgery each year supporting our conclusion that the vast majority of males who identify as women retain their penis.

fairplayforwomen.com/penis/

@ClearMoth
“FairPlay” also misrepresented the study that the HERE links to
There is also data available from the US HERE showing that genital surgery is very rare

The HERE links to this 2018 study which states that genital surgery isn’t that rare for those undergoing gender affirming surgery at all:

p3 “The incidence of genital surgery increased over time: in 2000-2005, 72.0% of patients who underwent gender-affirming procedures had genital surgery; in 2006-2011, 83.9% of patients who underwent gender-affirming procedures had genital surgery. Most patients (2319 of 4118 [56.3%]) undergoing these procedures were not covered by any health insurance plan.”
www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5875299/

RobertaFirmino · 10/02/2023 00:00

I've just been reading about top surgery on 13 year olds. In the USA. Unscrupulous surgeons with dollar signs in their eyes. That's where blame lies. Not with Waterstones and not with someone writing about their own experiences. I also found out that nobody would be having this surgery in the UK until the age of 17-18 which is still far too young, granted, but my outrage is directed firmly over the Atlantic. If these surgeons said no, this wouldn't be happening.

Swipe left for the next trending thread