Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that this book should not be sold to young girls?

519 replies

WandaWomblesaurus · 09/02/2023 09:25

twitter.com/Waterstones/status/1623584986740953091?s=20&t=WU0D0fzc6ClGJC5R-gJnuw

Waterstones tweeted celebrating a book that is about transing girls. Here is one of the illustrations from the book.

AIBU to think that this is directly promoting self harm to young vulnerable girls?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
RichardBarrister · 10/02/2023 11:15

Yes, I think the author of this book is better placed to judge whether his outcome is positive than you are.

Except that is not a full and balanced representation of the facts.

This book has no discussion of the health status of the author. This is written by someone deeply invested in the ideology and as such the account should be taken with extreme caution. This is not flagged in the book however.

The ‘lived experiences’ of the growing number of girls who show pictures of terribly mutilated breasts, reports of severe haemorrhage due to ripping of the vagina as testosterone has thinned the skin so badly, the growing numbers we see on walking sticks due to bone density issues caused by being out into menopause as a teenager.

There are the detransitioners accounts of severe liver damage due to the body trying to metabolise the huge overdoses of testosterone and the phantom nipple/breast pain due to amputation.

It is utterly irresponsible of Waterstones to suggest all the ways girls should hate their changing bodies and then present the solution to that not as something healthy like getting into sport, but as taking testosterone.

They even mock Keira Bell who is a victim of this and has been permanently harmed.

NotBadConsidering · 10/02/2023 11:14

IClaudine · 10/02/2023 11:11

God, what a load of offensive hyperbole. This is a graphic novel about one person's experience, not Mein bloody Kampf. Its sales seem quite modest. It's hardly a number one bestseller resulting in hordes of teenage girls transitioning. Some young people will find it helpful.

Anything that contributes to the social contagion teenage girls are experiencing is a concern, and a major company like Waterstone’s shouldn’t be promoting it as a result.

AmuseBish · 10/02/2023 11:13

God, what a load of offensive hyperbole. This is a graphic novel about one person's experience, not Mein bloody Kampf. Its sales seem quite modest. It's hardly a number one bestseller resulting in hordes of teenage girls transitioning. Some young people will find it helpful.

So do you believe that all books should be published regardless of content? This is the point the poster you quoted was making, using obviously extreme examples because people don't seem to understand actual words otherwise.

NotBadConsidering · 10/02/2023 11:12

They do not become unreasonable just because some transphobes desperately want all trans people to have awful outcomes to justify their campaign against trans healthcare.

Medical treatments result in worse outcomes. Including children. There is no evidence medical treatment improves outcomes.

The “campaign” if you want to call it that, is for children to receive evidence-based healthcare, not consumer-driven ideological healthcare.

RedAndBlueStripedGolfingUmbrella · 10/02/2023 11:12

Very very few girls don't have these feelings towards their bodies as they develop.
See... that is YOUR experience, you can't just say it like a fact as if that makes it true.
It certainly wasn't mine, I was comfortable in my own skin and still am.
A lot of my friends were too.
That's not to say I'm suggesting it's everyone's experience, because I'm not at all
Just that surely you can understand that we are all different, we're not all the same?

IClaudine · 10/02/2023 11:11

ClearMoth · 10/02/2023 11:01

No, but a bit of extra thought and care would be welcome from

Publishers when choosing what to publish
Bookshops when choosing what to promote
Teachers and librarians when choosing what to stock
Parents when choosing what to buy

I wouldn't want my kids having unfettered access to rabidly racist books, for example, without some guidance and context.

I wouldn't want or expect Waterstones to promote Mein Kampf or David Irving or Little Black Sambo as a book of the week.

I wouldn't want the school library packed full of antisemitic, anti-Black literature with the students encouraged to borrow and read them without any critique.

God, what a load of offensive hyperbole. This is a graphic novel about one person's experience, not Mein bloody Kampf. Its sales seem quite modest. It's hardly a number one bestseller resulting in hordes of teenage girls transitioning. Some young people will find it helpful.

AmuseBish · 10/02/2023 11:11

They do not become unreasonable just because some transphobes desperately want all trans people to have awful outcomes to justify their campaign against trans healthcare.

@TeaKlaxon do you think if someone is a man or a woman then they should feel pressured to have a certain type of body? Do you think it is an acceptable belief that, for example, if you are a man, you need to have a flat chest?

NotBadConsidering · 10/02/2023 11:08

TeaKlaxon · 10/02/2023 10:59

I'm going to park your offensive comparison of trans people to heroin addicts...

Yes, I think the author of this book is better placed to judge whether his outcome is positive than you are.

Not trans people. The effects of “gender affirming care”.

I’ve seen with my own eyes, and heard first hand, trans people list all the physical problems they have as a result of puberty blockers, wrong sex hormones, surgery, and how they’ve impacted their lives and still claim life is wonderful and it was all worth it.

It’s sunk cost fallacy. They’ve invested so much it’s hard to acknowledge the error of their ways. Those who come to that realisation end up on r/detrans.

ClearMoth · 10/02/2023 11:06

TeaKlaxon · 10/02/2023 10:59

I'm going to park your offensive comparison of trans people to heroin addicts...

Yes, I think the author of this book is better placed to judge whether his outcome is positive than you are.

It's not about the outcome for this one individual. Even if they were magically able to predict their health in the future or to know that they've increased their risk of cancer, osteoporosis, etc.

Even if that individual were absolutely fine, which 'Lived experience' doesn't tell you, that doesn't mean it's OK to tell adolescent girls that the answer to their very normal and painful experience of growing into a woman Is to surgically destroy their body.

Very very few girls don't have these feelings towards their bodies as they develop. That's why self harm and eating disorders are so prevalent. And socially contagious.

The difference is that on the whole, parents, teachers, doctors and other authority figures generally try to reduce and stop those behaviours, not to encourage them and share in the belief that their bodies are disgusting and wrong and the answer is to hack them to pieces.

When i was anorexic, no one gave me appetite suppressants.

When i was self harming, they gave me stitches, not a knife.

RaininginDarling · 10/02/2023 11:04

"Frothing"

Ever get the feeling that somebody is a bit angry at their mum? 🤣

ClearMoth · 10/02/2023 11:01

MrsSkylerWhite · 10/02/2023 10:52

Don’t think book banning is the answer to anything.

No, but a bit of extra thought and care would be welcome from

Publishers when choosing what to publish
Bookshops when choosing what to promote
Teachers and librarians when choosing what to stock
Parents when choosing what to buy

I wouldn't want my kids having unfettered access to rabidly racist books, for example, without some guidance and context.

I wouldn't want or expect Waterstones to promote Mein Kampf or David Irving or Little Black Sambo as a book of the week.

I wouldn't want the school library packed full of antisemitic, anti-Black literature with the students encouraged to borrow and read them without any critique.

RaininginDarling · 10/02/2023 11:00

TeaKlaxon · 10/02/2023 10:12

No.

But it probably would make you fairly well qualified to tell your friend who is scared of flying that the experience is actually fine or even pleasant.

Someone saying 'here is my story and here is its (positive) outcome' is entirely reasonable.

They do not become unreasonable just because some transphobes desperately want all trans people to have awful outcomes to justify their campaign against trans healthcare.

Ah yes the dog whistle that is 'transphobe' - do you think anyone who disagrees with you is scared of people who identify as trans? What a simplistic worldview you have.

Choosing to make extreme body modifications to yourself, ones that will shorten your life, because of a belief system does not make you any kind of expert on medicine, the long term effects of transition, child development or the insidious impact of social contagion.

'Positive outcome'? Based on what exactly? How this person feels today? What about in ten years? Twenty? Thirty? Can you imagine thirty years' time? I ask because you sound quite young.

But of course, people who show concern are just hoping for negative outcomes. What a sad, ungenerous, defensive way to view others.

FYI: I hope I'm wrong about long-term outcomes, but I very much doubt it.

TeaKlaxon · 10/02/2023 10:59

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 10/02/2023 10:36

Someone saying 'here is my story and here is its (positive) outcome' is entirely reasonable.

But is true? Is it backed up by fact? If a heroin addict wrote a memoir saying the dangers of heroin were exaggerated, would that be reasonable? It would be an opinion, it would be lived experience, and it would also be dangerous and potentially harmful to present to impressionable people as fact.

I'm going to park your offensive comparison of trans people to heroin addicts...

Yes, I think the author of this book is better placed to judge whether his outcome is positive than you are.

MrsSkylerWhite · 10/02/2023 10:52

Don’t think book banning is the answer to anything.

CecilyP · 10/02/2023 10:51

It's bizarre that the law literally allows a 17 year old to choose to refuse life saving treatment and die, but folks obsess about a tiny number of 16 or 17 year olds choosing to have mastectomies.

I don't think it's bizarre at all. For a teenager to need life saving treatment, they must be seriously ill, the treatment may be unpleasant and dangerous and not always successful, so they may prefer to let nature take it's course.

In terms of a 16 or 17 year old having a double mastectomy, it is radical surgery but also cosmetic/unnecessary surgery to remove healthy body parts. I can't see any problem in asking them wait for what amounts to one or 2 years.

NotBadConsidering · 10/02/2023 10:50

If we don’t know completely because gender clinics don’t publish their figures and there’s a huge private market.

Shrouding the realities of the iatrogenic harm they carry out is very much the MO of gender clinics and surgeons.

NotBadConsidering · 10/02/2023 10:46

But key question - how many double mastectomies have actually been carried out on people under 18?

Hundreds worldwide at least.

This study alone documented 35 under 18, including 2 as young as 13. So multiply that by all the other hundreds of gender clinics across the USA and other countries, add in all those who weren’t including in studies, those done privately and it’s probably in the thousands.

nolongersurprised · 10/02/2023 10:43

having healthy body parts removed*

nolongersurprised · 10/02/2023 10:42

It's bizarre that the law literally allows a 17 year old to choose to refuse life saving treatment and die, but folks obsess about a tiny number of 16 or 17 year olds choosing to have mastectomies

Stop with the frothing. Being concerned about teens having healthy body parts isn’t “obsessing”

AmuseBish · 10/02/2023 10:37

If an equivalent book was talking about how unhappy a girl was to have a flat chest, fat tummy, and masculine jaw and athletic figure - because everything everywhere says women have to have big boobs and flat stomachs and long legs and be feminine please! - it wouldn't necessarily be a bad thing - unless they then got cosmetic surgery and called that the beginning of really being themselves.

I don't see how enforcing the idea that someone's body is "wrong" is ever helpful. Women have to look like THIS and men have to look like THAT is just a shitty message.

If anyone feels that their body is the "wrong" amount of feminine (too much or too little) then that's a problem with our society, not with their body.

TeaKlaxon · 10/02/2023 10:37

Clymene · 10/02/2023 09:42

No, but they're having them under -8 @TeaKlaxon

They can't vote or get a tattoo but can have a double mastectomy

Assume you meant under 18, not under 8.

Yes, the law on this is generally that anyone over 16 is presumed competent to consent to healthcare (or to refuse healthcare). This has been the case for forty years.

It's bizarre that the law literally allows a 17 year old to choose to refuse life saving treatment and die, but folks obsess about a tiny number of 16 or 17 year olds choosing to have mastectomies.

But key question - how many double mastectomies have actually been carried out on people under 18?

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 10/02/2023 10:36

TeaKlaxon · 10/02/2023 10:12

No.

But it probably would make you fairly well qualified to tell your friend who is scared of flying that the experience is actually fine or even pleasant.

Someone saying 'here is my story and here is its (positive) outcome' is entirely reasonable.

They do not become unreasonable just because some transphobes desperately want all trans people to have awful outcomes to justify their campaign against trans healthcare.

Someone saying 'here is my story and here is its (positive) outcome' is entirely reasonable.

But is true? Is it backed up by fact? If a heroin addict wrote a memoir saying the dangers of heroin were exaggerated, would that be reasonable? It would be an opinion, it would be lived experience, and it would also be dangerous and potentially harmful to present to impressionable people as fact.

BlibBlabBlob · 10/02/2023 10:28

So... as this book is in my house already, owned by my DD (age 12, bought I think when she was still 11 from our local Waterstones where it was part of a 'gay book section', as she calls it, display), I sat down last night and read it from cover to cover. My thoughts:

  1. This is a rather clumsily-done autobiography.
  2. I feel very sorry for the author, who clearly had an awful time as a teenager and has now - as an adult - essentially produced this graphic novel for his own therapeutic reasons. The art work is not particularly good, the way in which the story is told isn't particularly great. 15 years ago it would have remained self-published with a very narrow readership at best. Most likely it'd have been sitting on a shelf at the author's house, never to see the light of day again.
  3. The author was what most of us would call a tomboy who, during puberty, became what most of us would call a butch lesbian.
  4. The author recognised, aged 11, that being a girl who looks like a boy would mean social death at high school. So he deliberately tried to adjust his personal appearance to look more feminine, although he didn't/couldn't go as far as shaving his legs or armpits. This appears to have made him even more miserable.
  5. Outside of school, he dressed in a goth-like and fairly masculine way and this was fine except that, when he realised he was attracted to girls, he also felt this was socially unacceptable.
  6. He developed a serious eating disorder and had serious body dysmorphia and gender dysphoria. The author feels that the eating disorder was an attempt to have a more masculine, less curvaceous body. He was anorexic to the point of it threatening his life.
  7. I am not in a position to judge, but it seems to me that the author MAY have developed gender dysphoria as a result of feeling completely unable to be their true self i.e. a masculine-presenting lesbian. I think it's also possible that the author, as an adult, STILL believes that being a butch lesbian would not be OK. Being a trans ('straight') man is his happy ending.
  8. The author appears to feel that medical transition is the only solution to gender dysphoria and feels that he would have had an easier time of it and better outcome if he'd been able to obtain and take puberty blockers as a young teenager. He makes only passing reference to any negative effects of medical transition.
  9. The bit referencing Keira Bell (not by name) is presenting in a really worrying way. Like her experience and court case has ruined everything for 'true' trans teens.
  10. The book ends with him starting his 'real' life with the first injection of testosterone.
  11. Overall, this is a really sad tale of a young woman who felt such crippling social pressure to be someone other than her true self that she set herself on a path of self-mutilation (deliberate starvation and over-exercising, then medical transition) in order to become somebody that she/they/he felt was socially acceptable. If being a tomboy/butch lesbian was something they felt accepted as then they could have had a very different teenage experience and would now have more options open to them as an adult e.g. pregnancy/breastfeeding.

I told DD about this thread and we had another life-affirming hour-long discussion about the whole thing! I don't think anything, including this book, is likely to suck her into identifying as trans any time soon. 🤞 This is really important to me as I believe that medical transition is not a panacea and should only be embarked upon when the patient feels there is really no other option after years of therapy etc. This book, which presents medical transition as the only way forward and to be started on ASAP if you don't feel like a 'proper' boy/girl, could be very dangerous in the wrong (young) hands.

NotBadConsidering · 10/02/2023 10:22

The only “lived experience” with regards to the long term effects of puberty blockers and wrong sex hormones that is acceptable to hear is the “positive” ones. The experiences of those harmed, like detransitioners, are widely ignored.

Children who are puberty blocked at Tanner stage 2 who progress onto wrong sex hormones are sterile. They’ve been rendered sterile by doctors. On purpose.

Children who are puberty blocked at Tanner stage 2 who progress onto wrong sex hormone are anorgasmic. They’ve been rendered anorgasmic by doctors. On purpose.

The evidence this helps children is very poor.

These are indisputable facts.

Many of these people are only realising the implications of what has been done to them as they reach their 20s.

They will require a lifetime of medical supervision.

We are in the midst of one of the greatest medical scandals ever known.

AlisonDonut · 10/02/2023 10:17

TeaKlaxon · 10/02/2023 10:10

No, there isn't.

And anyone should be entitled to share their lived experience. I know those who want trans people to have fewer rights and less access to healthcare desperately think we should only hear from the small minority of trans people who detransition or regret their transition - but that would not be reasonable, fair or representative.

Young trans people deserve to hear the stories of people like them, just as any minority group deserve to hear from people like them.

What do you mean when you say 'healthcare'?

Nobody thinks trans people should have less access to 'healthcare'.

But the gruesome activity of blocking puberty, injecting cross sex hormones, removing reproductive organs, removing breasts of kids/teens/young adults is not 'care'. It is the very opposite of 'care'.