Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that this book should not be sold to young girls?

519 replies

WandaWomblesaurus · 09/02/2023 09:25

twitter.com/Waterstones/status/1623584986740953091?s=20&t=WU0D0fzc6ClGJC5R-gJnuw

Waterstones tweeted celebrating a book that is about transing girls. Here is one of the illustrations from the book.

AIBU to think that this is directly promoting self harm to young vulnerable girls?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
NotBadConsidering · 10/02/2023 11:48

Article about a woman who had a mastectomy and regretted her inability to feed her child:

https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fgwh.2023.1073053/full

ClearMoth · 10/02/2023 11:48

RedAndBlueStripedGolfingUmbrella · 10/02/2023 11:37

Women are now grieving their lost ability to breastfeed
See - again, that's a personal thing.
I fucking hated breastfeeding - some love it
Some don't ever want to try it in the first place.
Should everyone never transition, not have autonomy over their own body because other people think they don't know what they want for themselves or in the future?
I think they know themselves better than randomers.

Whether you liked breastfeeding or not is irrelevant.

You had the opportunity to have children and to breastfeed, even if you then decided not to do it.

These girls do not have that opportunity. Their lives are destroyed before they've even begun. Why are you, whose autonomy wasn't taken away, whose body wasn't destroyed, so confident in saying that children should be able to make these decisions before they can possibly understand them?

The voices of detransitioners and whistle-blowers are getting louder all the time and one thing that's very clear is that no proper care is taken to 'first do no harm'

TeaKlaxon · 10/02/2023 11:45

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 10/02/2023 11:28

So to achieve happiness and be accepted for who they are, namely female people who don't like dressing in a feminine way and who are sexually attracted to women, they have to adopt a male identity, take life-shortening medication to change their appearance, and have surgery? And this is progressive?

No.

People who have gender dysphoria.

People who are lesbians, or butch, are not necessarily gender dysphoric. Hence why there are still lots of butch lesbians around, despite the desperate attempt to pretend they are all being 'transed'.

NotBadConsidering · 10/02/2023 11:44

RedAndBlueStripedGolfingUmbrella · 10/02/2023 11:37

Women are now grieving their lost ability to breastfeed
See - again, that's a personal thing.
I fucking hated breastfeeding - some love it
Some don't ever want to try it in the first place.
Should everyone never transition, not have autonomy over their own body because other people think they don't know what they want for themselves or in the future?
I think they know themselves better than randomers.

You miss the point spectacularly, as usual.

If you have mastectomy as a child you are never afforded the opportunity to refuse to do it, or try it and hate it. And none of these children think about the consequences of the surgery and its impact on this. They don’t understand it. They can’t consent.

RaininginDarling · 10/02/2023 11:42

RedAndBlueStripedGolfingUmbrella · 10/02/2023 11:37

Women are now grieving their lost ability to breastfeed
See - again, that's a personal thing.
I fucking hated breastfeeding - some love it
Some don't ever want to try it in the first place.
Should everyone never transition, not have autonomy over their own body because other people think they don't know what they want for themselves or in the future?
I think they know themselves better than randomers.

Children shouldn't, no. Which I believe is the point of this thread.

RedAndBlueStripedGolfingUmbrella · 10/02/2023 11:37

Women are now grieving their lost ability to breastfeed
See - again, that's a personal thing.
I fucking hated breastfeeding - some love it
Some don't ever want to try it in the first place.
Should everyone never transition, not have autonomy over their own body because other people think they don't know what they want for themselves or in the future?
I think they know themselves better than randomers.

ClearMoth · 10/02/2023 11:37

In the past few years it has become an explosion. Many of us feel confused by what has happened, and it’s often hard to talk about it to colleagues,” said a London-based psychiatrist working in a child and adolescent mental health unit, who has been a consultant for the past 17 years.

Like all NHS employees interviewed, she asked for anonymity due to the sensitivity of the subject.

“I might have seen one child with gender dysphoria once every two years when I started practising. It was very niche and rare.” Now, somewhere between 10% and 20% of her caseload is made up of adolescents registered as female at birth who identify as non-binary or trans, with just an occasional male-registered teenager who identifies as trans.

Also from that Guardian article.

'Trans people have been transitioning for generations' is an extremely disingenuous and misleading comment. The explosion in adolescent girls with gender dysphoria is absolutely unprecedented.

NotBadConsidering · 10/02/2023 11:37

TeaKlaxon · 10/02/2023 11:31

Trans people have been transitioning for generations.

In addition, we already know that levels of regret are extremely low among trans people who have transitioned. So are rates of detransitioning and detransitioning seems to be more commonly based on the transphobia experienced after transition than regret about the decision to transition in the first place.

So yeah, I think this author knows better than anyone on here if his decisions have had a positive or negative impact on his life.

And yes, that is disappointing for many transphobes who only want to hear from the Keira Bells of the world, because the majority of trans people who are happy with their decisions really doesn't help their claims.

In addition, we already know that levels of regret are extremely low among trans people who have transitioned

Typical TRA sentence. “We already know”. Exert something as fact when the reality is the opposite.

We DON’T know. That’s the point. A paper released this week from Australia has it at around 9%.

So are rates of detransitioning and detransitioning seems to be more commonly based on the transphobia experienced after transition than regret about the decision to transition in the first place.

Incorrect again. This is a lie.

AmuseBish · 10/02/2023 11:36

I'm now thoroughly confused.

Please can someone tell me whether or not it's transphobic to believe that one needs to have a certain type of body because of what gender they are?

ClearMoth · 10/02/2023 11:34

TeaKlaxon · 10/02/2023 11:31

Trans people have been transitioning for generations.

In addition, we already know that levels of regret are extremely low among trans people who have transitioned. So are rates of detransitioning and detransitioning seems to be more commonly based on the transphobia experienced after transition than regret about the decision to transition in the first place.

So yeah, I think this author knows better than anyone on here if his decisions have had a positive or negative impact on his life.

And yes, that is disappointing for many transphobes who only want to hear from the Keira Bells of the world, because the majority of trans people who are happy with their decisions really doesn't help their claims.

According to a study commissioned by NHS England, 10 years ago there were just under 250 referrals, most of them boys, to the Gender Identity Development Service (Gids), run by the Tavistock and Portman NHS foundation trust in London.

Last year, there were more than 5,000, which was twice the number in the previous year. And the largest group, about two-thirds, now consisted of “birth-registered females first presenting in adolescence with gender-related distress”, the report said.

The review team is looking into the causes behind “the considerable increase in the number of referrals” and the changing case mix, but is not expected to publish any findings until next year.

www.theguardian.com/society/2022/nov/24/an-explosion-what-is-behind-the-rise-in-girls-questioning-their-gender-identity

It is far, far too early to make the kind of claims you are making, given that the rates of girls applying for this treatment is utterly unprecedented.

The shit is going to hit the fan really badly over the next decade or so. Keira Bell isn't an outlier. She's just ahead of the curve

NotBadConsidering · 10/02/2023 11:33

TeaKlaxon · 10/02/2023 11:25

I'm talking about the UK.

How many under 18s have had mastectomies in the UK?

As was pointed out to you a few posts back, we know 51 teenage girls age 16 and 17 were sent from Scotland to England for mastectomies:

https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/ff0b02b0-1a5d-11ec-8d6d-67649e90fafa?shareToken=b8a372ad9402f34fa6e90c8eba962015

So if you consider all the other teenage girls across the UK managed by the Tavistock, with a huge uptick of females presenting to there over years, again, it’s likely hundreds.

And being over 18 doesn’t make it ok. Women are now grieving their lost ability to breastfeed.

RedAndBlueStripedGolfingUmbrella · 10/02/2023 11:31

So to achieve happiness and be accepted for who they are, namely female people who don't like dressing in a feminine way and who are sexually attracted to women, they have to adopt a male identity, take life-shortening medication to change their appearance, and have surgery?
Nobody has said that though, have they?
I hated dressing in a feminine way when younger, was "rough and tumble" etc - never once did I think I was male though.
You dismiss others voices by thinking it's the same for everyone.
It isn't

TeaKlaxon · 10/02/2023 11:31

RaininginDarling · 10/02/2023 11:00

Ah yes the dog whistle that is 'transphobe' - do you think anyone who disagrees with you is scared of people who identify as trans? What a simplistic worldview you have.

Choosing to make extreme body modifications to yourself, ones that will shorten your life, because of a belief system does not make you any kind of expert on medicine, the long term effects of transition, child development or the insidious impact of social contagion.

'Positive outcome'? Based on what exactly? How this person feels today? What about in ten years? Twenty? Thirty? Can you imagine thirty years' time? I ask because you sound quite young.

But of course, people who show concern are just hoping for negative outcomes. What a sad, ungenerous, defensive way to view others.

FYI: I hope I'm wrong about long-term outcomes, but I very much doubt it.

Trans people have been transitioning for generations.

In addition, we already know that levels of regret are extremely low among trans people who have transitioned. So are rates of detransitioning and detransitioning seems to be more commonly based on the transphobia experienced after transition than regret about the decision to transition in the first place.

So yeah, I think this author knows better than anyone on here if his decisions have had a positive or negative impact on his life.

And yes, that is disappointing for many transphobes who only want to hear from the Keira Bells of the world, because the majority of trans people who are happy with their decisions really doesn't help their claims.

ClearMoth · 10/02/2023 11:31

TeaKlaxon · 10/02/2023 11:26

But it is true.

Some people assigned female at birth do need to transition to achieve happiness.

We know this from the very many trans men who tell us that transitioning was the right course for them and has made them happy. Why on earth do you think you know better than them?

And how do you know if the person assigned female at birth who is having their body chopped up, being rendered infertile, given a lifetime of worsened health and being dependent on expensive drugs for the rest of their life is one of the ones who will be delighted with the outcome, or one of the increasing number of detransitioners who are beginning their adult lives full of horror and regret as the full realisation of what has been done to them begins to dawn?

Given that apparently no one can tell this in advance. Not therapists, not surgeons, not teachers, not the person themselves. How do you know?

AmuseBish · 10/02/2023 11:29

@TeaKlaxon do you think if someone is a man or a woman then they should feel pressured to have a certain type of body?

Do you think it is an acceptable belief that, for example, if you are a man, you need to have a flat chest?

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 10/02/2023 11:28

So to achieve happiness and be accepted for who they are, namely female people who don't like dressing in a feminine way and who are sexually attracted to women, they have to adopt a male identity, take life-shortening medication to change their appearance, and have surgery? And this is progressive?

TeaKlaxon · 10/02/2023 11:26

RichardBarrister · 10/02/2023 11:24

God, what a load of offensive hyperbole. This is a graphic novel about one person's experience, not Mein bloody Kampf. Its sales seem quite modest. It's hardly a number one bestseller resulting in hordes of teenage girls transitioning. Some young people will find it helpful.

Unfortunately the key message of this book is that to achieve happiness, some girls will need to take testosterone (which has similar effects on the body to anabolic steroids) and puberty blockers (a cancer drug used to chemically castrate rapists until it was decided it was against their human rights).

That is not ok.

But it is true.

Some people assigned female at birth do need to transition to achieve happiness.

We know this from the very many trans men who tell us that transitioning was the right course for them and has made them happy. Why on earth do you think you know better than them?

TeaKlaxon · 10/02/2023 11:25

NotBadConsidering · 10/02/2023 10:46

But key question - how many double mastectomies have actually been carried out on people under 18?

Hundreds worldwide at least.

This study alone documented 35 under 18, including 2 as young as 13. So multiply that by all the other hundreds of gender clinics across the USA and other countries, add in all those who weren’t including in studies, those done privately and it’s probably in the thousands.

I'm talking about the UK.

How many under 18s have had mastectomies in the UK?

RichardBarrister · 10/02/2023 11:24

God, what a load of offensive hyperbole. This is a graphic novel about one person's experience, not Mein bloody Kampf. Its sales seem quite modest. It's hardly a number one bestseller resulting in hordes of teenage girls transitioning. Some young people will find it helpful.

Unfortunately the key message of this book is that to achieve happiness, some girls will need to take testosterone (which has similar effects on the body to anabolic steroids) and puberty blockers (a cancer drug used to chemically castrate rapists until it was decided it was against their human rights).

That is not ok.

IClaudine · 10/02/2023 11:23

So do you believe that all books should be published regardless of content? This is the point the poster you quoted was making, using obviously extreme examples because people don't seem to understand actual words otherwise

Well with self publishing freely available, anyone can publish anything, to be fair.

But of course I don't think harmful, bigoted books should be published and marketed by mainstream publishing. In general they are not.

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 10/02/2023 11:22

IClaudine · 10/02/2023 11:11

God, what a load of offensive hyperbole. This is a graphic novel about one person's experience, not Mein bloody Kampf. Its sales seem quite modest. It's hardly a number one bestseller resulting in hordes of teenage girls transitioning. Some young people will find it helpful.

I've no idea what its sales have been to date, but now it's been shortlisted for a high-profile prize they're likely to increase substantially. Hence the anger on this thread that Waterstone's don't appear to have done any due diligence.

ClearMoth · 10/02/2023 11:20

RedAndBlueStripedGolfingUmbrella · 10/02/2023 11:12

Very very few girls don't have these feelings towards their bodies as they develop.
See... that is YOUR experience, you can't just say it like a fact as if that makes it true.
It certainly wasn't mine, I was comfortable in my own skin and still am.
A lot of my friends were too.
That's not to say I'm suggesting it's everyone's experience, because I'm not at all
Just that surely you can understand that we are all different, we're not all the same?

I'm very glad that you didn't experience that. I think most girls do, to a greater or lesser extent, but great for you if you didn't.

That wasn't really the point I was making, though.

the point was that other ways that girls seek to deal with feelings of hating their developing bodies (self harm, eating disorders, etc.) are discouraged, not encouraged, by those who are older and can try to guide them.

As an anorexic I sought validation from books, magazines, other girls, etc. I wasn't told by teachers, therapists, etc. that I was right to hate my breasts and hips and arse and that I should try to starve them away.

Waterstones, like a lot of people and organisations, are just doing this because it's where the money is. It is shameful.

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 10/02/2023 11:19

TeaKlaxon · 10/02/2023 10:59

I'm going to park your offensive comparison of trans people to heroin addicts...

Yes, I think the author of this book is better placed to judge whether his outcome is positive than you are.

How is it offensive? Lewis is taking medication which will permanently alter the body - drugs to suppress production of oestrogen and progesterone, plus taking a far higher amount of testosterone than a healthy female body naturally produces. Lewis is happy with the results and the book reflects that. However, Lewis is glossing over the fact that taking these drugs will lead to vaginal atrophy, loss of fertility, possible problems with incontinence, an increased risk of early-onset dementia and heart problems, and that's just the ones I can remember off the top of my head. These aren't trivial things to live with. Not every teenager who comes across this book is going to have a mum like @BlibBlabBlob who will take the time and trouble to read it too and sit down and talk about it. Most parents don't have a clue about this stuff and rely on what the medical and other professionals tell them, and unfortunately it's clear many of them have fallen down on the job in this area.

Clymene · 10/02/2023 11:15

www.thetimes.co.uk/article/ff0b02b0-1a5d-11ec-8d6d-67649e90fafa?shareToken=21bf99a7754f3a430319eb7af490245a

51 under 18s referred for double mastectomies @TeaKlaxon to remove their healthy breasts

ClearMoth · 10/02/2023 11:15

IClaudine · 10/02/2023 11:11

God, what a load of offensive hyperbole. This is a graphic novel about one person's experience, not Mein bloody Kampf. Its sales seem quite modest. It's hardly a number one bestseller resulting in hordes of teenage girls transitioning. Some young people will find it helpful.

Hordes of teenage girls are transitioning, though. The rate of young girls applying for this kind of treatment has increased by over 4000 percent. The graph is insane. That is social contagion. Young girls are extremely vulnerable to it.

There are also, consequently, ever increasing numbers of detransitioners. And their experiences are incredibly distressing to read.

These young girls are being failed, massively, by adults who should know better. It is criminal.

Swipe left for the next trending thread