Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Aibu? This is not helping children’s self esteem?

78 replies

HulaHoop2012 · 08/02/2023 21:49

My DD is P6 (N.Ireland) second to last year of primary school. She’s a bright kid scored in the high 80’s and 90’s for her Numeracy and Literacy in her last round of tests . She’s in a class of 34. Explaining so I don’t drip feed.

Every month the school gives out awards for Numeracy and Literacy, you get a trophy and pictures on the school comms app etc a big well done in assembly.
Its the top scoring children or seems to be the same children, not every month but they may have got the trophy at least once though each school year, almost on rotation.

My daughter and a lot of others have never got it. My daughter has now got to the point where she can’t see that’s she’s doing really well. She’s constantly trying to ‘get’ the trophy and thinking each month she’ll get it, even though I explain she has a big class and I’m sure the teacher knows how hard she works etc etc

The same with prize giving at the end of the year. Top two kids get the prizes. In high achieving classes its very difficult for any other children to get them.

Ive now got a child who doesn’t think she’s doing well at school or is judging her success on getting these awards . How do you manage this situation and these disappointments?

OP posts:
Therellbenobutterinhell123 · 09/02/2023 11:15

When my 2 were in Primary school, my eldest one won everything under the sun. She was a perfect child to have in the classroom, intelligent, confident, friendly, helpful, volunteered for everything etc and I actually used to feel a bit embarrassed at end of term/year events as I would hear the mutterings and complaining of all the other parents.
My younger one was still a great pupil but a bit shyer, didn't grasp things quite as easily and barely won anything. They're now much older and it has not affected either of them in the slightest because we didn't let it as it's really not a big deal.The only kids that got upset were from the parents who did make a big deal about it.

5128gap · 09/02/2023 11:06

Sounds like your DD is a big fish in a big pond with some even bigger fish. Being a high achiever in an environment with other high achievers makes it more difficult to shine than if your peers are average. Such is life. Your DD is old enough to have this explained and to understand that another person's superior achievement (if this is what the trophy signifies) takes nothing away from her own, provided its her best.
The school are not likely to change the criteria for the prize, and in fairness if it is achievement based, it is a better preparation for life, as in the real world there are no prizes for effort.
Personally I'd encourage your DD to see achievement of her personal best (rather than being THE best) as the goal. And there's nothing stopping you rewarding her for her effort and achievement.

Phos · 09/02/2023 11:00

I don’t agree with prize giving at
primary school, very young ones don’t have the understanding when they don’t win anything and it’s demoralising. Yes they have to learn but at the right age. My daughter’s school have a weekly prize for the kids who have spent the most time on the online English and maths work (they get set certain tasks but can do extra) It’s the same kid every week in DD’s
class because she has the pushiest mother around. DD doesn’t bother anymore because “Maria will win it anyway she always does”

HulaHoop2012 · 09/02/2023 10:54

Wow a lot happened overnight. Thanks for getting back on track and the apologies.

@Cassie4 yep life is full of knocks and maybe I should look at this as helping her become resilient but would help if school did the same. Thank you for an opposite view x

@PlaitBilledDuckyPuss and @NImumconfused anything would be nice for a kid that had worked hard at something and improved.

@PlaitBilledDuckyPuss your right ‘the real world’ is as confusing as school, I once got a promotion without even realising I was being considered for it 🤷‍♀️

Thank you all for your responses. None of us want our children to feel shitty about themselves at 10years old, but like many of you have said I will work on trying to shift the focus from a crappy trophy.
Id almost put money on it that she’ll get it this month!

OP posts:
PlaitBilledDuckyPuss · 09/02/2023 10:16

NImumconfused · 09/02/2023 10:07

I know the "prizes for everyone" thing doesn't work, but I think there is more scope for schools to reward the kids who put a lot of effort in to improving, alongside the ones who are effortlessly bright.

We can all praise and encourage our kids ourselves of course, but like @HulaHoop2012 I found after a certain point they dismiss that as "mums always/have to say that" if they don't get at least a little bit of external validation.

I agree - why not give out awards for 'effort', or 'most progress'. That's not pretending the person has won the award for being best at x thing.

Regarding 'that's not how life works' - in my experience there's often very little logic in how promotions and awards are given out in the workplace - no method with any reason to it could prepare for that. I say that as someone who has, at different times, slogged my guts out for no reward whatsoever; received recognition for no real reason; worked hard for promotions I didn't get but was once given one after a no more than a 5 minute conversation asking if I wanted the job.

NImumconfused · 09/02/2023 10:07

Cassie4 · 08/02/2023 22:52

Sorry OP I am wholeheartedly against giving prizes to the people who didn't win.

Because that's not how life works. These top performers are heading for problems later down the road - you see it all the time.

It's good for kids to lose, it's good for them to lose again and again and again and again - as long as their family view them as winners and back them. Your job is to praise the trying. Your job is tell them how bloody fantastic and brave they are and how proud you are of them for always getting back up to give something another go.

You boost their self-esteem and you comfort the tears.

The school judges the performance objectively.

Within that mix - you'll have a well rounded child equipped to cope with life.

There's nothing wrong with saying- hey buddy I'm sorry you didn't win. I know how hard you tried. Im so proud of you for always being so determined. Come on, let's get some ice cream/watch a film/ (insert whatever your comfort thing is).

I know the "prizes for everyone" thing doesn't work, but I think there is more scope for schools to reward the kids who put a lot of effort in to improving, alongside the ones who are effortlessly bright.

We can all praise and encourage our kids ourselves of course, but like @HulaHoop2012 I found after a certain point they dismiss that as "mums always/have to say that" if they don't get at least a little bit of external validation.

CarolineMumsnet · 09/02/2023 09:59

Hello, we've removed any posts that were PAs, goady or derails. We're now unhiding the thread and hope we can get things back on track for the OP here. Anymore concerns, hit report and we'll take a look.

dustydewdrop · 08/02/2023 23:07

In my kids school it’s always the same “brainy” confident kids that get the awards with the odd one thrown in for kids with SEN that maybe need a bit of support. But what about the kids that are more middle of the road with their schoolwork - do they not need some encouragement too

Keyansier · 08/02/2023 23:03

@MNHQ please delete all the distracting posts if necessary but not the thread, because OP wants help and shouldn't have the thread deleted because I and others derailed it. Sorry.

GoldilockMom · 08/02/2023 23:02

I would go down the school council route or even a nice letter drafted to the head teacher about making clear rules for these prizes. If you don’t know the criteria how can you win?

Keyansier · 08/02/2023 22:59

Tothemoonandbackx · 08/02/2023 22:52

I think this thread has gone a little bit too far now don't you @Keyansier @dittoglass please don't compete over who was abused the worst both your stories are terrible, but I don't think the OP wanted any of this here.

100% agree. Sorry OP @HulaHoop2012

Keyansier · 08/02/2023 22:58

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Keyansier · 08/02/2023 22:57

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

BreviloquentBastard · 08/02/2023 22:55

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

dittoglass · 08/02/2023 22:54

@Tothemoonandbackx I have asked MNHQ to withdraw my posts. I have reacted to a vile poster who has been horrible to me and I shouldn't have. I apologise op.

Tothemoonandbackx · 08/02/2023 22:52

I think this thread has gone a little bit too far now don't you @Keyansier @dittoglass please don't compete over who was abused the worst both your stories are terrible, but I don't think the OP wanted any of this here.

Cassie4 · 08/02/2023 22:52

Sorry OP I am wholeheartedly against giving prizes to the people who didn't win.

Because that's not how life works. These top performers are heading for problems later down the road - you see it all the time.

It's good for kids to lose, it's good for them to lose again and again and again and again - as long as their family view them as winners and back them. Your job is to praise the trying. Your job is tell them how bloody fantastic and brave they are and how proud you are of them for always getting back up to give something another go.

You boost their self-esteem and you comfort the tears.

The school judges the performance objectively.

Within that mix - you'll have a well rounded child equipped to cope with life.

There's nothing wrong with saying- hey buddy I'm sorry you didn't win. I know how hard you tried. Im so proud of you for always being so determined. Come on, let's get some ice cream/watch a film/ (insert whatever your comfort thing is).

dittoglass · 08/02/2023 22:50

This reply has been withdrawn

Withdrawn at poster's request

dittoglass · 08/02/2023 22:47

This reply has been withdrawn

Withdrawn at poster's request

Keyansier · 08/02/2023 22:44

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

dittoglass · 08/02/2023 22:38

@Keyansier what on earth makes you think I have a nice sunflowers life?

Keyansier · 08/02/2023 22:38

Apologies to the OP and readers of this thread, I think I've somewhat conflated it with my own personal view and experiences and it's got mixed up with the OPs which is not relatable. I'm just defending myself against my own experiences and outlook on this situation.

Scienceadvisory · 08/02/2023 22:35

@dittoglass but she never said she was angry with him.

Anyway, OP, I think it would be worth speaking to the class teacher again and explaining how your daughter is feeling. Maybe if they can see this is having negative consequences for some children they will reevaluate how its done. Maybe increase the trophies and doing a split of attainment and effort.

Keyansier · 08/02/2023 22:35

dittoglass · 08/02/2023 22:28

Your attitude towards him being encourage at school is still appalling.

I was consfused as to why you were so sympathetic to this guy but I looked on my earlier post and some have it had been cut off, i don't know why. This guy was torturous and relentless with it in my school. So he absolutely deserved everything he got, and being made to feel stupid (like he was, and most likely is) was on the smaller scale of the terror he put others through. I'm sorry if that doesn't fit into your nice and sunflowers world, but it is what it was. (It's a long time ago now).

dootball · 08/02/2023 22:33

It doesn't really matter what it's for - if it's for genuine effort then it's likely to be the same kids that win it every time anyway.