Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the adoration of Zelensky in the UK feels very wrong?

713 replies

WarWhatIsItGoodFor · 08/02/2023 21:18

Exactly that. Why are UK politicians lapping it all up and hanging on to his every word? The laughter from MPs when he said he enjoyed English tea but now wants English planes… in what sense is that funny? He is wanting war planes to cause more bloodshed, death and destruction. I hope this doesn’t lead to Russian retaliation.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 12/02/2023 18:47

For me, it doesn't interest me much whether it's ideology or something else that's driving Putin to behave as he does. The parallel with Hitler is that appeasing him has demonstrably failed, and there isn't an option to make a few concessions in return for him being satisfied and not invading anyone else. For whatever reason that might be. Maybe all the bad Botox has seeped into his brain.

Johnisafckface · 12/02/2023 16:12

I always felt something was a little off about him, so I get you OP.

blueshoes · 12/02/2023 16:06

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 12/02/2023 14:21

ellyeth
I note you refer to Putin as an "actor"

In a manner having nothing whatever to do with the stage.

Have you never come across the phrase "bad actor", meaning a person or organization responsible for actions that are harmful, illegal, or morally wrong; an unruly, turbulent, or contentious individual; a mean, ill-tempered, troublemaking, or evil person; an inveterate criminal?

An irrational actor (which was the phrase actually used by Bashir) is one of those, who is also not terribly good at reasoning.

Exactly this.

@ellyeth although you have self-identified as neither a bot nor a useful idiot, is English your first language? Did you live in the UK during the Iraq war?

theadultsaretalking · 12/02/2023 15:08

CPL593H · 12/02/2023 14:27

This. Russkiy Mir is an ideology and one that makes Russia's neighbours very, very concerned.

The difference is that he was not elected on the Russkiy Mir ideology platform and this is not something that the vast majority of Russians either subscribe to or, more accurately, even think of. He will start to pushing it more now, I give you that - since his military campaign is not going brilliantly.

CPL593H · 12/02/2023 14:27

pointythings · 12/02/2023 14:24

@theadultsaretalking I wasn't saying that Putin = Hitler, I was pointing out that appeasement doesn't work when the powerful are invading the weaker.

Putin however is absolutely an ideologue - his ideology is that of a Greater Russia, a delusion of imperialism not actually that different from what the Nazis came up with. Whether he himself really believes it or whether it is a tool he is using to harness political power is pretty immaterial.

This. Russkiy Mir is an ideology and one that makes Russia's neighbours very, very concerned.

pointythings · 12/02/2023 14:24

@theadultsaretalking I wasn't saying that Putin = Hitler, I was pointing out that appeasement doesn't work when the powerful are invading the weaker.

Putin however is absolutely an ideologue - his ideology is that of a Greater Russia, a delusion of imperialism not actually that different from what the Nazis came up with. Whether he himself really believes it or whether it is a tool he is using to harness political power is pretty immaterial.

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 12/02/2023 14:21

ellyeth
I note you refer to Putin as an "actor"

In a manner having nothing whatever to do with the stage.

Have you never come across the phrase "bad actor", meaning a person or organization responsible for actions that are harmful, illegal, or morally wrong; an unruly, turbulent, or contentious individual; a mean, ill-tempered, troublemaking, or evil person; an inveterate criminal?

An irrational actor (which was the phrase actually used by Bashir) is one of those, who is also not terribly good at reasoning.

theadultsaretalking · 12/02/2023 14:19

pointythings · 12/02/2023 13:57

@ellyeth cast your mind back and find out how well appeasing Hitler worked - we're dealing with a similar level evil here.

I am connected to the region and I do hate Putin with all my heart, but he ain't no Hitler and I don't think the comparisons are useful. He is a corrupt, greedy, tin-pot dictator, who hates having his power challenged and who, sadly for us, is sitting in a country of vast resources.

He is not an ideologist, however, and this is not a battle of good vs evil and any narrative like that is actually feeding his ego and elevating him to some sort of a mythical 'baddy' status, which he clearly craves.

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 12/02/2023 14:17

ellyeth · 12/02/2023 13:51

Bashir Since you feel what I say is so obviously illogical and not useful, I don't know why you have bothered to respond, as presumably that would be apparent to everybody else too - or at least to those you would consider as right minded.

I note you refer to Putin as an "actor" - the sort of language used by military people, as in describing the "theatre" of war. War is not a play (though some people like to play with little toy soldiers or engage in battle re-enactments) War is bloody and terrifying, and the more weapons that are piled into an area, the more bloody and terrifying it will get. And since we are dealing with someone as unhinged as Putin, do we not run the risk of this escalating to the possible use of nuclear weapons and other major countries becoming involved?

For the person who asked, I am British and live here. I was part of the million+ demonstration against the Iraq invasion, for all the good it did. My friend and I were both accosted on the tube home by men accusing us of being bitches and traitors because she was wearing an anti war badge.

I've responded because your nonsense needed countering. The desperate focus on one word is pathetically obvious, incidentally.

Ultimately, if all you've got to say is Putin is unhinged so we can't apply logic, that applies to any attempt you might make to try and predict his behaviour too. We don't run the risk of other major countries becoming involved in his stupidity either, no. Look at how China have behaved in the last year.

Also, it's simply not true that war is more terrifying with more weapons. Actually it'll be much less terrifying for the Ukrainians if we arm them more. What you're advocating for is leaving them to face genocide with a weapons deficit.

CPL593H · 12/02/2023 14:15

"War is bloody and terrifying, and the more weapons that are piled into an area, the more bloody and terrifying it will get. And since we are dealing with someone as unhinged as Putin, do we not run the risk of this escalating to the possible use of nuclear weapons and other major countries becoming involved?"

OK @ellyeth what do you think we should do? Leave Ukraine to crumble for lack of supplies (including armaments)? Goodbye independent Moldova, at the very least, but I doubt he'd stop there. Finland and Sweden are not trying to join NATO for fun.

Appeasement doesn't work and it certainly doesn't work with the likes of Putin.

pointythings · 12/02/2023 13:57

@ellyeth cast your mind back and find out how well appeasing Hitler worked - we're dealing with a similar level evil here.

ellyeth · 12/02/2023 13:51

Bashir Since you feel what I say is so obviously illogical and not useful, I don't know why you have bothered to respond, as presumably that would be apparent to everybody else too - or at least to those you would consider as right minded.

I note you refer to Putin as an "actor" - the sort of language used by military people, as in describing the "theatre" of war. War is not a play (though some people like to play with little toy soldiers or engage in battle re-enactments) War is bloody and terrifying, and the more weapons that are piled into an area, the more bloody and terrifying it will get. And since we are dealing with someone as unhinged as Putin, do we not run the risk of this escalating to the possible use of nuclear weapons and other major countries becoming involved?

For the person who asked, I am British and live here. I was part of the million+ demonstration against the Iraq invasion, for all the good it did. My friend and I were both accosted on the tube home by men accusing us of being bitches and traitors because she was wearing an anti war badge.

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 12/02/2023 13:18

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar
Remember that 3 days before the invasion Russian diplomats were saying that there would be no invasion.

Remember too that in December 1994 the Russians were signatories to the Budapest Memorandum.

Ukraine, a nuclear power at that time, voluntarily gave up its nuclear weapons in exchange for security guarantees.

The US, Great Britain and Russia pledged, among other things, to respect the independence and existing borders of Ukraine.

If you were Ukrainian how much would you trust anything signed by Russia, with that as a precedent and having observed their behaviour since 2014?

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 12/02/2023 12:40

Farage, co-leader of the Brexit campaign, seems to be firmly pro-Russia

Well he would be wouldn't he! He owes Putin.

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 12/02/2023 12:37

www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2023-02-11/rishi-sunak-wants-stronger-ties-with-eu-to-limit-brexit-dangers?utm_source=google&utm_medium=bd&cmpId=google#xj4y7vzkg

PM Sunak wants to improve relations with the EU

It is, in particular, about closer cooperation between Great Britain and the European Union in the field of defense, migration, trade, energy and international standards

all you can do is roll your eyes ...

Farage, co-leader of the Brexit campaign, seems to be firmly pro-Russia, blaming Ukraine and the EU for the Russian invasion. How he explains that before 2014 Ukraine was a peaceful country and it's Russia who's aggressively invaded and killed tens of thousands of civilians, I don't know.

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 12/02/2023 12:17

Thanks @TigerQueen89

ChungusBoi · 12/02/2023 12:11

Ukraine needs the support, for reasons articulated clearly by others. The tories will try to get political capital out of the situation using the war as a distraction from their appalling corruption and lies at home.

TigerQueen89 · 12/02/2023 11:59

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 12/02/2023 10:03

I think you actually meant me there. And I wouldn't use the term useful idiot because it's so poorly done it doesn't qualify as useful.

The underlying flaw in your argument is that its based on the incorrect assumption that supplying the people who are being attacked with weapons is an obstacle to peace. When you have, as with Russia, an irrational actor who have already shown that they have no intention of behaving and will interpret concessions as a sign of weakness and encouragement, that's not how it works. We know this because what's happening now is a direct consequence of previous appeasement. It is failure to provide weapons that will escalate things further. Again, we already know this.

As for the rest, it has already been pointed out that the Ukrainians themselves are telling us very clearly what they want. It's not your naive, bullshit 'negotiations'. It's not 2003 now, we can hear directly from the people affected speaking for themselves on their own platforms, not those of traditional media.

The fact is that the papers and TV have nothing like the influence they did during Iraq. Although even then, speaking as a person who almost certainly devoted more time to anti Iraq invasion activism than you did, I recall some anti invasion coverage in the mainstream media. The Mirror and Guardian carried it. Additionally, and again this has already been pointed out, nobody would've called anyone a bot in 03 because we hadn't then been subjected to sustained and deliberate campaigns of Internet disinformation from the Russian state.

@BashirWithTheGoodBeard

Thank you for this comment. Beautifully put.

TigerQueen89 · 12/02/2023 11:56

@CPL593H

Exactly this.

CPL593H · 12/02/2023 11:54

@ellyeth 20 years ago this week there was a massive demonstration in London against the Iraq war with an estimated 1.5 million people taking part. Whatever (some) of the media were saying, very substantial numbers of people felt differently and made those feelings known.

This is not happening this time because it is a fundamentally different situation and most people can see that.

TigerQueen89 · 12/02/2023 11:52

@Casilero

I'm not into all this Putin bad, Zelensky saint shit.

Well then you clearly know nothing about the modern Russian Federation, nor Putin’s body count (do the names Anna Politkovskaya, Paul Klebnikov, Sergei Yushenkov, Alexander Litvinenko, Stanislav Markelov, Anastasia Baburova and Boris Nemtsov ring any bells?).

Because of Putin and his reactionary policies, any public expression of LGBT behaviour or lifestyle in Russia is now effectively outlawed (which is kind of a travesty given that I used to live in Moscow In 2010/2011, and the gay clubs were the only ones worth going to frankly). Further, domestic violence against woman has been decimalised ergo wife beating is now permitted in law because of him.

Now tell us about Zelensky’s record? We’re all ears…

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 12/02/2023 11:36

Natsku · 12/02/2023 11:30

Even I remember there being criticism of the Iraq war and I was a teenager barely paying attention.

Yep.

There's half a point in there in that there were certainly attempts to portray criticism of the invasion as unpatriotic etc, particularly in the early days. But the idea that there was next to no criticism simply won't wash.

Look at these Daily Mirror covers, for example.

www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/15-daily-mirror-front-pages-8364908

I presume we all know how Piers Morgan ended up losing his job as editor?

Natsku · 12/02/2023 11:30

Even I remember there being criticism of the Iraq war and I was a teenager barely paying attention.

TigerQueen89 · 12/02/2023 11:30

@ellyeth Ukraine business dealings
Biden’s involvement in Ukraine has been a major source of his legal and political issues. He served on the board of Burisma, paid as much as $50,000 a month, from 2014 to 2019, according to a Republican-led Senate report on Biden’s business activities released in 2020. That partly overlaps with a period during which his father was vice president and tapped by then-President Barack Obama to handle Ukraine issues. The overlap raised concerns about a conflict of interest among some Obama administration officials at the time..........."

Right, so this justifies Russia invading their sovereign neighbour, using terrifying hardware to destroy human life, essential infrastructure and the environment and employing rape as a key weapon of war with the youngest victims being babies? Yes that seems wholly logical and reasonable, I never thought about it that way…what insight!! Also Russia’s invasion of Ukraine began in 2014, so how can Hunter Biden getting a paid position in a Ukrainian company in the same year have any bearing in this war? Could it be because this whole debate is a red herring? I think so….

Being against sending more and more arms to Ukraine, sending fighter jets and possible military manpower does not make me a supporter of Putin.

Yeah, it does. By not providing Ukraine with everything they need to defeat a ruthless and pitiless enemy makes our government war criminals by proxy.

Or will it be another example, like in Vietnam, Afghanistan, Libya and Iraq, where the US, UK and others go in, all guns blazing, only to withdraw after many thousands have died

No, if you knew your history you would know that those conflicts were all unique and not even comparable to what is going on here. As to accusing US/UK of going in all guns blazing! Do you know the difference between an offensive and a defensive war? It’s the Russians that did that, from the results so far this is fairly evident.

I get that a lot of you don’t like Ukraine’s President, but I’m afraid he’s the only one they and we have, so we need to support him to get on with urgent task of defeating Putin - who without hyperbole truly is this century’s Hitler. And you can’t deny that - weird self-promotional Vogue shoots aside - he hasn’t been an exemplary war leader. Jesus Christ, everyone seems to love deifying Winston Churchill for what he did in WWII, and he wasn’t exactly a social worker: he had very unprogressive views about Jews and Indians, royally fucked over the Greeks and so on. Do you really think that a leader has to an absolute saint before they deserve our backing? We’d never support anyone if that were our criteria.

And I’m not coming at you @ellyeth , it’s just your arguments are utterly flawed and you’re really not helping the people of Ukraine, ordinary Russians that are against the war and who just want to get on, and also Russian victims of State repression (like Ilya Yashin - he’s in prison now due speaking out but his Instagram is still active) against a common enemy. You’re actively making life harder for them. I get that you’re scared, yes war is scary, but the world will be a damn site scarier if Putin succeeds and we in turn will be much more vulnerable and at risk as a consequence.

PerkingFaintly · 12/02/2023 11:26

As I mentioned before...

Yes, and it wasn't true the first time, and isn't true now.

I don't know what country you're in, and what media you were consuming at the time of the Iraq war, but I saw plenty of criticism and questioning of the invasion in the media, TV and print. Including televising of critical debates in Parliament.

I also don't know what you were watching that played you stirring music. Other than a normal theme tune at the beginning of the programme, the news I watch doesn't usually have incidental music.

I do remember that there were some papers cheerleading for the war. But your choice to read those papers rather than the ones next to them was yours. The coverage was there, you just didn't read it.

Put it this way, there would have been plenty of us arrested – media workers and citizens – if the UK had had the laws Russia now has, which make it a crime to criticise the war or even use the word for "war" rather than "special military operation."

Swipe left for the next trending thread