Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the adoration of Zelensky in the UK feels very wrong?

713 replies

WarWhatIsItGoodFor · 08/02/2023 21:18

Exactly that. Why are UK politicians lapping it all up and hanging on to his every word? The laughter from MPs when he said he enjoyed English tea but now wants English planes… in what sense is that funny? He is wanting war planes to cause more bloodshed, death and destruction. I hope this doesn’t lead to Russian retaliation.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
PitYerTapOan · 12/02/2023 20:41

Putin doesn't want to drag it out. He has other things to concentrate on, specifically building up this new banking system with China. And China has its own international issues, plus is already making restive statements towards Russia over this prolonged war.

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 12/02/2023 20:37

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 12/02/2023 20:32

PitYerTapOan
Well he'll pull out of all out war with Ukraine.

For a few months, or even as much as a year.... Maybe. If he really reckons that he can't rearm while his army goes on killing and torturing civilians.

"Naive you are if you believe life favours those who are naive."

Yes, if there were an option that involved Russia genuinely pulling out of all war in Ukraine, as opposed to taking a temporary hiatus to rearm then coming back doing more of same, the situation would be quite different. There isn't. Nobody who fails to understand this has any chance of coming up with a sensible analysis.

PitYerTapOan · 12/02/2023 20:36

I'm just a twat on a talkboard, not a UN negotiator. Going back from the Greater Russia thing (even though it was never going to happen) looks like a climbdown, axing komoloisky (but keeping the money) and taking Azov off the payroll (but somehow funnelling to them, doubtless) also looks like a climbdown, so job done.

Putin and Russia both have other fish to fry.

It's just disgusting that people are actually dying for this bloated, grotesque power play . Also ridiculous that so many people in economically connected countries like the UK see it as a good vs evil matter.

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 12/02/2023 20:32

PitYerTapOan
Well he'll pull out of all out war with Ukraine.

For a few months, or even as much as a year.... Maybe. If he really reckons that he can't rearm while his army goes on killing and torturing civilians.

"Naive you are if you believe life favours those who are naive."

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 12/02/2023 20:31

No.

So what was your point, then?

Agreed. Which is why we need to stop pissing our pants like he's some great satan or even Hitler. It's rhetoric. That the USA handed to him on a plate when they killed all those kiddies in Hiroshima.

Well, he's like Hitler in that they're both an example of appeasement not working. But yes, the pants pissing is stupid and the nuclear stuff is rhetoric only. Hitler was dead well before Hiroshima, though.

PerkingFaintly · 12/02/2023 20:28

It's just it looks like you're expecting all the compromising to be done by Ukraine.

So Russia loses nothing (well, except all the people it's killed), and has gained something it wants. Waits two years and goes at it again.

Which is precisely the strategy it's been using for years. Why do you think Russia's other neighbours are so scared?

PitYerTapOan · 12/02/2023 20:27

Well he'll pull out of all out war with Ukraine. That's quite a big deal isn't it? One that everyone wants? The rest of the world was happy enough with fighting and atrocities being confined to the donbas prior to twelve months ago. Sure they'd be grand for that again.

PerkingFaintly · 12/02/2023 20:23

I wouldn't expect putin to, he's never said he was a nice guy.

Which brings us back to, what's the compromise you'd like Putin to make?

Your expectations of him seem pretty low, so do you expect him to compromise at all? Or to stick to his promises if he appeared to compromise?

PitYerTapOan · 12/02/2023 20:08

Is there a limit, a formula?

No.

As for the second, the Russian state and her representatives can talk about nukes all they want. Whevs. The important point is that they've demonstrated that it's no more than hot air.

Agreed. Which is why we need to stop pissing our pants like he's some great satan or even Hitler. It's rhetoric. That the USA handed to him on a plate when they killed all those kiddies in Hiroshima.

PitYerTapOan · 12/02/2023 20:05

PerkingFaintly · 12/02/2023 19:58

But what's the "it" that would be the disputed border?

The Ukrainian provinces which Putin declared to be part of Russia just a few months ago? (Which Russian troops don't even fully control.)

The territory Russian troops control today?

Where the border was before the Feb 2022 Russian invasion?

Where the border was before the 2014 Russian invasion (annexation of Crimea)?

That's for the negotiable detail. There's room enough to discuss, which is pretty crucial - it means it's possible.

Fucking awful for anyone directly affected.

Maybe zelensky should have thought about that. (I wouldn't expect putin to, he's never said he was a nice guy.)

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 12/02/2023 20:04

PitYerTapOan · 12/02/2023 20:02

Ukraine already sells its children to western Europe and the usa.

Russia talks about nuclear weapons because through the cold war and beyond it's had thousands of nuclear weapons systems aimed at it by the only country in the world that has used nuclear weapons on a civilian population. Twice. It reflects the bogeyman we hold over it back to us.

Nor quite sure of the relevance to what I presume is the frequency of surrogacy in prewar Ukraine: do you think that justifies the forced deportations, then? Is there a limit, a formula? Tell us more.

As for the second, the Russian state and her representatives can talk about nukes all they want. Whevs. The important point is that they've demonstrated that it's no more than hot air.

PitYerTapOan · 12/02/2023 20:02

Ukraine already sells its children to western Europe and the usa.

Russia talks about nuclear weapons because through the cold war and beyond it's had thousands of nuclear weapons systems aimed at it by the only country in the world that has used nuclear weapons on a civilian population. Twice. It reflects the bogeyman we hold over it back to us.

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 12/02/2023 20:01

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 12/02/2023 19:49

I think Putin probably knows that if he used a nuke, he could say goodbye to the Kremlin and his life; and so do his immediate circle, who would prefer not to be vaporised with him. I strongly suspect that if it looked to them too much as if he would do so, he would fall out of a fourth or fifth floor window.

Yep.

I think people have this idea that it'd just be him pressing a button and kaboom. But the term Mutually Assured Destruction arose for a reason. It's not like conventional warfare where Putin and the elites can just shove other people's kids in the meat grinder while their own loved ones are kept safely out of the way. Nuclear weapons involve elites putting their own heads and those of their loved ones on the block too. They tend not to like that.

PerkingFaintly · 12/02/2023 19:58

But what's the "it" that would be the disputed border?

The Ukrainian provinces which Putin declared to be part of Russia just a few months ago? (Which Russian troops don't even fully control.)

The territory Russian troops control today?

Where the border was before the Feb 2022 Russian invasion?

Where the border was before the 2014 Russian invasion (annexation of Crimea)?

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 12/02/2023 19:56

DotAndCarryOne2 · 12/02/2023 19:48

But is the fact that he hasn’t resorted to the nuclear option for a year, any guarantee that he won’t ? He’s not out of conventional options yet. When he is, that will be a different matter. Your argument is a logical one and I agree that the concept of an off ramp is a difficult one, for reasons you’ve laid out pretty well, but is that a reason not to look for one ?

There is never any guarantee that a nuclear weapon won't be used, by any state that has them. There is no option we can take that completely precludes that possibility. I understand wanting that, but you can't have it.

All we can do is base our decisions on the things we actually know. We know that the West can give Ukraine all manner of weapons without Russia using a nuke, and we know that when Putin was given an inch he took a mile.

The reason we shouldn't be looking for an off ramp at this point isn't because it would be difficult, but because none can exist until Russia have been sufficiently well beaten to actually observe it. Until that point, all that would happen even if the Ukrainians would accept one, which they won't, is that Russia would use the time to regroup and rearm, then continue at their leisure.

The Ukrainians, like most countries who border Russia (see the excellent Kaja Kallis explanation above) understand this, and it's why they aren't willing to negotiate a solution that will ultimately involve Russia continuing their aggression. Off ramps, negotiations, those are all nice words for what in reality means you want the Ukrainians to accept a certain amount of torture chambers and forced deportations of children.

PitYerTapOan · 12/02/2023 19:51

I don't think there's much he can do that I'd personally "like" as such, because everything is pretty fucked russia included.

But hopefully now zelensky has publicly at least distanced himself from komoloisky, once he takes the Azovs off the payroll Putin can do the whole 'this is not the right time to fight for a Greater Russia but I will protect Russians in the donbas' schtick, it will go back to being a disputed border (that's unavoidable imo, sadly) and Russia can carry on being a key player in the new international banking system, fucking us all up the arse energy wise and eventually BRICS and then wider Africa and couple of generations hence the global south will by dint of manpower if nothing else have completed their ascendency over pension aged Europe, the USA having since collapsed inwards, and we'll all be fucked.

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 12/02/2023 19:49

DotAndCarryOne2 · 12/02/2023 19:18

The problem is that that parallel doesn’t factor in that Hitler didn’t have nuclear weapons at his disposal, and if he had, I doubt that WWII would have played out the way it did. Putin does have nukes, and the fact that he has even referred to them, to my mind leaves no doubt that he would use them if backed into a corner. So the question in the end, is how far the west goes in support of Ukraine, without inviting WWIII. The rat is never more dangerous than when cornered, so it’s not a question of appeasement, it’s a question of finding an off ramp acceptable to all, to stop the war. The alternative is unthinkable.

I think Putin probably knows that if he used a nuke, he could say goodbye to the Kremlin and his life; and so do his immediate circle, who would prefer not to be vaporised with him. I strongly suspect that if it looked to them too much as if he would do so, he would fall out of a fourth or fifth floor window.

DotAndCarryOne2 · 12/02/2023 19:48

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 12/02/2023 19:42

We now have a full year of evidence that Russia will not respond to the West arming Ukraine by using nuclear weapons. They know full well we, amongst other countries, have been providing Ukrainians with the equipment that allows them to kill Russian soldiers in vast numbers and attack what they see as sovereign Russian territory, and they've not done it. There's a reason for that.

Russia responded to the West letting them have their own way by becoming more dangerous. They responded to the West indirectly standing up to them by sabre rattling and by not nuking anything. There's a lesson to be learned in there, and it's absolutely and unequivocally about how appeasement doesn't work on Putin. The people telling us that there's going to come a point when we invite WW3 completely ignore this, whereas those of us who understand that the best form of defence here is attack are basing our arguments on what has actually happened.

This off ramp nonsense is wishful thinking. Lots of you would like there to be an option where we could give Putin something and de-escalate the crisis, but none of you can ever tell us what that is or how to deal with the small matter of the Ukrainians not having it. Your appeasement has already failed.

But is the fact that he hasn’t resorted to the nuclear option for a year, any guarantee that he won’t ? He’s not out of conventional options yet. When he is, that will be a different matter. Your argument is a logical one and I agree that the concept of an off ramp is a difficult one, for reasons you’ve laid out pretty well, but is that a reason not to look for one ?

PerkingFaintly · 12/02/2023 19:45

It's just I'm very aware of what the Estonian Prime Minister, Kaja Kallas, said at the Munich Security Conference before the invasion. She said this about Kremlin aggression over the years, not just Ukraine:

Russia is making the demands. Russia is threatening. And now if we think: “Oh let’s offer them something, then they actually get something that they didn’t have before.”

And I’ve quoted this foreign minister, Alexei [should be Andrei] Gromyko, a Soviet-time foreign minister, several times, who said about the negotiation tactics of the Soviet Union, three things:

First, demand the maximum. Do not ask, but demand something that has never been yours.

Second, present ultimatums. You know, threaten.

And third, do not give one inch in negotiations, because there will always be people in the West who offer you something.

And then in the end, you will have one-third or even one half of something you didn’t have before. So we have to keep that in mind all the time.

twitter.com/munsecconf/status/1512451999622643714

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 12/02/2023 19:42

DotAndCarryOne2 · 12/02/2023 19:18

The problem is that that parallel doesn’t factor in that Hitler didn’t have nuclear weapons at his disposal, and if he had, I doubt that WWII would have played out the way it did. Putin does have nukes, and the fact that he has even referred to them, to my mind leaves no doubt that he would use them if backed into a corner. So the question in the end, is how far the west goes in support of Ukraine, without inviting WWIII. The rat is never more dangerous than when cornered, so it’s not a question of appeasement, it’s a question of finding an off ramp acceptable to all, to stop the war. The alternative is unthinkable.

We now have a full year of evidence that Russia will not respond to the West arming Ukraine by using nuclear weapons. They know full well we, amongst other countries, have been providing Ukrainians with the equipment that allows them to kill Russian soldiers in vast numbers and attack what they see as sovereign Russian territory, and they've not done it. There's a reason for that.

Russia responded to the West letting them have their own way by becoming more dangerous. They responded to the West indirectly standing up to them by sabre rattling and by not nuking anything. There's a lesson to be learned in there, and it's absolutely and unequivocally about how appeasement doesn't work on Putin. The people telling us that there's going to come a point when we invite WW3 completely ignore this, whereas those of us who understand that the best form of defence here is attack are basing our arguments on what has actually happened.

This off ramp nonsense is wishful thinking. Lots of you would like there to be an option where we could give Putin something and de-escalate the crisis, but none of you can ever tell us what that is or how to deal with the small matter of the Ukrainians not having it. Your appeasement has already failed.

PerkingFaintly · 12/02/2023 19:40

What's the compromise that you'd like Putin to make?

PitYerTapOan · 12/02/2023 19:38

*compromises

PitYerTapOan · 12/02/2023 19:33

Agree they both have to find a way out of it. Both have comprises they can make - zelensky will probably be glad to get rid of his neo Nazis, he's already thrown his backer overboard, so looks like he's moving. Putin can do the climbdown from the greater Russia position (who knows whether he really believes it? I suspect not, he's more concerned with BRICS and China won't wait for him pissing around forever, but it's a useful bargaining chip nonetheless.)

Re nuclear weapons, maybe Hitler would have used them, maybe not. We'll never know. We do know though that the USA did use them and is the only country in the history of the world to do so. So yeah, maybe see how that looks if you live in Russia.

DotAndCarryOne2 · 12/02/2023 19:18

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 12/02/2023 18:47

For me, it doesn't interest me much whether it's ideology or something else that's driving Putin to behave as he does. The parallel with Hitler is that appeasing him has demonstrably failed, and there isn't an option to make a few concessions in return for him being satisfied and not invading anyone else. For whatever reason that might be. Maybe all the bad Botox has seeped into his brain.

The problem is that that parallel doesn’t factor in that Hitler didn’t have nuclear weapons at his disposal, and if he had, I doubt that WWII would have played out the way it did. Putin does have nukes, and the fact that he has even referred to them, to my mind leaves no doubt that he would use them if backed into a corner. So the question in the end, is how far the west goes in support of Ukraine, without inviting WWIII. The rat is never more dangerous than when cornered, so it’s not a question of appeasement, it’s a question of finding an off ramp acceptable to all, to stop the war. The alternative is unthinkable.

BigMC93 · 12/02/2023 19:05

headstone · 09/02/2023 10:17

No chance that Russia would ever attack Poland or a NATO country. Imo it would have been better all round if Ukraine had had a pro Russia president instead of Zellinsky, so many lives would have been saved by now. Escalation will just lead to a destroyed Ukraine and more deaths.

Should we all just nazi sympathisers too? 🙄

You win the record for the most ridiculous comment I’ve ever read on MN