Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the adoration of Zelensky in the UK feels very wrong?

713 replies

WarWhatIsItGoodFor · 08/02/2023 21:18

Exactly that. Why are UK politicians lapping it all up and hanging on to his every word? The laughter from MPs when he said he enjoyed English tea but now wants English planes… in what sense is that funny? He is wanting war planes to cause more bloodshed, death and destruction. I hope this doesn’t lead to Russian retaliation.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
pointythings · 13/02/2023 13:12

@ellyeth I don't understand how you can have been so (justifiably) opposed to the Iraq war and yet feel that we should just let Putin have large chunks of the Ukraine?

@Alondra re tanks and crossing Russian borders: let's not forget who initially invaded whom, shall we?

blueshoes · 13/02/2023 13:11

ellyeth · 13/02/2023 13:05

In further response to your interrogation, I have always lived in the UK and took part in the huge demonstration against the Iraq invasion. Again, why do you ask this question?

This is not an 'interrogation' and I am not the KGB.

As for your answers, if you say so.

ellyeth · 13/02/2023 13:05

In further response to your interrogation, I have always lived in the UK and took part in the huge demonstration against the Iraq invasion. Again, why do you ask this question?

ellyeth · 13/02/2023 12:59

blueshoes You ask whether my first language is English. Yes, it is. I am in my 70s and was born in London of English parents. Why do you ask this question?

PerkingFaintly · 13/02/2023 12:58

That article matches what I know: Leopard tanks are being sent into Ukraine.

Even the Russian government spokesmen in that article are not suggesting the tanks will enter Russia.

That article also makes a comment about weaponry in general, which fits with what I said previously:

Berlin is also hesitant to supply arms that would enable Kyiv to carry out attacks on Russian soil

And also
the German government legally has the final say over how and where the tanks are used

The NATO countries are being quite fussy about where their weapons are used, and seem very keen to prevent them being used in Russia. IIRC, when the long-range weapon HIMARS was supplied, Ukraine had to sign an undertaking not to fire it into Russia.

Alondra · 13/02/2023 12:57

blueshoes · 13/02/2023 12:47

Nothing in that link mentions crossing Russian borders. The Leopard 2s are only for Ukraine.

A bit of a Freudian slip there? You do know Crimea, Donetsk and Luhansk are all illegal occupations by Russia, yes? Better adjust your filters a little higher.

It's a war. Ukrainian troops have crossed Russian borders and with the arrival of tanks, they will cross again. The tanks will not only be used to defend positions but to attack as well. It's the reason the Germans didn't want to send their tanks in the first place.

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 13/02/2023 12:52

That's true. The Assad regime supported by Russia killed hundreds and perhaps thousands by chemical attacks.

The US doesn't use chemical weopons now after the outrage. Assad and Russia still do

Since the start of uprisings across Syria in 2011,Syrian Arab Armed Forces and pro-Assad paramilitary forces have been implicated in more than 300 chemical attacks in Syria.[5][6]

But you still don't say how the Russian invasion of Ukraine is justified, nor how it's okay that Russian troops were issued viagra so they could rape more, by the UN report.

blueshoes · 13/02/2023 12:47

Nothing in that link mentions crossing Russian borders. The Leopard 2s are only for Ukraine.

A bit of a Freudian slip there? You do know Crimea, Donetsk and Luhansk are all illegal occupations by Russia, yes? Better adjust your filters a little higher.

Alondra · 13/02/2023 12:42

PerkingFaintly · 13/02/2023 12:32

Could you offer a source for the claim that Germany's Leopard tanks will be going into Russia?

You may be right, of course, but so much care has been taken about forbidding other military equipment from NATO nations from being used inside Russian borders, IIRC, that it would be a major change if the tanks were permitted to enter Russia.

Of course, Putin recently declared he'd moved Russian borders to be well inside Ukraine. So by Putin's reckoning, a tank can "cross Russian borders" without switching its engine on...

www.npr.org/2023/01/25/1150759498/germany-leopard-2-tanks-ukraine

PerkingFaintly · 13/02/2023 12:32

Could you offer a source for the claim that Germany's Leopard tanks will be going into Russia?

You may be right, of course, but so much care has been taken about forbidding other military equipment from NATO nations from being used inside Russian borders, IIRC, that it would be a major change if the tanks were permitted to enter Russia.

Of course, Putin recently declared he'd moved Russian borders to be well inside Ukraine. So by Putin's reckoning, a tank can "cross Russian borders" without switching its engine on...

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 13/02/2023 12:25

There are too many connotations with WWII about German tanks fighting again in Russia.

There are certainly some Germans who've trotted that argument out, yes. I thought this response dealt very effectively with those sentiments. Dmitry Grozoubinsky is himself Jewish and Ukrainian born.

twitter.com/DmitryOpines/status/1618521580111556608

For anyone who can't access it, this is what he said:

Also could Germans fucking spare me the "I'm historically uncomfortable with our tanks in Eastern Europe."

If your role in the 1930's and 40's consisted solely of peacefully transferring tanks to Poland to resist an invasion from Stalin you wouldn't still be apologising in 23.

Also, if you're not comfortable with German tanks being used in this incredibly clear cut example of good versus evil, maybe stop building and exporting tanks?
Did you think Rhinemetal was making exclusively school buses?!

If the Jewish President of Ukraine doesn't see a Leopard transfer as evoking Blitzkrieg and the 3rd Reich then you're probably in the clear, lads.

PerkingFaintly · 13/02/2023 12:23

By that reckoning, all governments in Ukraine are heirs of the Russian government – which has indeed put its own external money and other resources into Ukrainian elections.

Alondra · 13/02/2023 12:14

PerkingFaintly · 13/02/2023 11:53

The current Ukraine government is not the result of the "Revolution of Dignity", or indeed any revolution.

Zelenskyy was elected in 2019, in an election which fell due as normal, and even his political party was new.

The "Revolution of Dignity" mentioned was in 2014. Before that there was an "Orange Revolution" in 2004.

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Revolution_of_Dignity
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Orange_Revolution

Since independence from the Soviet Union in 1991, Ukraine has had a serious of lurches as it comes to grips, or not, with the legacy of corruption, with accusations of electoral fraud (2004), and with trying to manage the influence of its very large neighbour and former colonial power, Russia.

It is. Zelenskyy is the heir in 2019 from a government that was deposed by external money and "revolutionaries for the land" in 2014. He never disbanded the Azov regiment, he has incorporated it into a new guard in Ukraine.

Ukraine has always been the country that NATO (and NATO is controlled by the US) to get close to Russia and their unlimited natural resources. I will say it again: wars are not fought on principles like human rights or freedom. Wars are fought to control global resources.

There was a huge issue in the German press about sending Leopard tanks to Ukraine that will cross Russian borders. There are too many connotations with WWII about German tanks fighting again in Russia.

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 13/02/2023 12:02

Alondra · 13/02/2023 11:48

It has to be all about the Americans,

It is. Since WWII America has instigated or involved in the following wars, well outside their borders:

Korean war
Vietnam war
Laos (Indochina war)
Parmesian (Indonesia war)
Lebanon
Dominican Civil War
Cambodian Civil War
Invasion of Grenada
Bombing of Libya
Persian War
Invasion of Panama (to keep control of the Panama Canal)
Gulf war
Somali war
Serbian/Croatian intervention
Haiti civil war
Kosovo intervention
Niger intervention
Iraq/Syria
Ukraine..

The US is also the only Western country to drop an atomic bomb on civilians (Japan) or use awful chemical warfare against civilians in Vietnam (Napalm) with devastating consequences. They also used and tested chemical warfare in Grenada.

None of these wars ever threatened the security of the US. The US keep engaging in wars thousands of km away because they want to control world resources. Everything else is bullshit.

Hiya again racist.

This is not the best argument for a Russian apologist like you to be making, bearing in mind their imperialism, warmongering and the way they prop up the Assad regime which, whaddya know, uses chemical weapons on civilians. Interestingly you've had the brains to leave Afghanistan out, which tells me that you do actually understand what a glass houses and throwing stones this situation is.

But anyway, you also presumably understand that the above is not a comprehensive list of all the wars in the last century, and therefore that wars can exist without the US having started them. So with that in mind, there's a missing step here. You haven't explained how eg the US intervention in Somalia tells us that the Russian invasion of Ukraine is America's fault. I think we could all do with a laugh.

PerkingFaintly · 13/02/2023 11:53

The current Ukraine government is not the result of the "Revolution of Dignity", or indeed any revolution.

Zelenskyy was elected in 2019, in an election which fell due as normal, and even his political party was new.

The "Revolution of Dignity" mentioned was in 2014. Before that there was an "Orange Revolution" in 2004.

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Revolution_of_Dignity
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Orange_Revolution

Since independence from the Soviet Union in 1991, Ukraine has had a serious of lurches as it comes to grips, or not, with the legacy of corruption, with accusations of electoral fraud (2004), and with trying to manage the influence of its very large neighbour and former colonial power, Russia.

ScrollingLeaves · 13/02/2023 11:52

What America did wrong is a separate issue from Ukraine needing to repel the Russian invasion of their country with the help of foreign weapons.

Alondra · 13/02/2023 11:48

It has to be all about the Americans,

It is. Since WWII America has instigated or involved in the following wars, well outside their borders:

Korean war
Vietnam war
Laos (Indochina war)
Parmesian (Indonesia war)
Lebanon
Dominican Civil War
Cambodian Civil War
Invasion of Grenada
Bombing of Libya
Persian War
Invasion of Panama (to keep control of the Panama Canal)
Gulf war
Somali war
Serbian/Croatian intervention
Haiti civil war
Kosovo intervention
Niger intervention
Iraq/Syria
Ukraine..

The US is also the only Western country to drop an atomic bomb on civilians (Japan) or use awful chemical warfare against civilians in Vietnam (Napalm) with devastating consequences. They also used and tested chemical warfare in Grenada.

None of these wars ever threatened the security of the US. The US keep engaging in wars thousands of km away because they want to control world resources. Everything else is bullshit.

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 13/02/2023 11:41

There's really something uncomfortably close to racist about the way in which some Westerners trying to sound anti imperialist completely ignore any Ukrainian agency, discount the idea that the people might actually want self-determination and have the same right to choose a (flawed) leader as anyone else.

Yes.

The line in Russian propaganda is that Ukrainians are Russian really but have forgotten it under the influence of malign Western actors.

It completely and utterly ignores the fact that Ukrainians might want to make up their own minds - and did, in Maidan, because the Russian-aligned president was so corrupt.

The fact that so many Ukrainians have fled Russian occupation and so many picked up arms to fight should show that the Ukrainians can and do make up their own minds.

The fact that in the first days of the war desperate Ukrainian mothers were putting unaccompanied children onto the train, some of them 3 years old, should also show how Russian occupation is viewed.

DappledThings · 13/02/2023 11:38

There's really something uncomfortably close to racist about the way in which some Westerners trying to sound anti imperialist completely ignore any Ukrainian agency, discount the idea that the people might actually want self-determination and have the same right to choose a (flawed) leader as anyone else. They're not like us. Not a fully realised nation or people. It has to be all about the Americans, because nothing in this worldview is ever allowed to be about anything else.
Absolutely this. There are panel discussions at universities plenty of times in the last year on Ukraine featuring no Ukrainian voices and it doesn't seem to occur to any of the organisers how this seems perfectly normal because of the colonial mindset that is still hugely prevalent.

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 13/02/2023 11:23

Alondra · 13/02/2023 11:13

I stay away from these threads because my opinion is too different from the majority and, frankly, I don't want to be abused.

I will say what a did a couple of years ago. The actual Ukrainian government was imposed by money from the USA in a so-called Revolution of Dignity, ousting the government elected by in elections..

Also search the Azov regiment, the Nazi ideology Ukrainian arm group fighting in the Donbass against Russian-speaking people, which atrocities are well documented, and have always been a part of the Ukrainian government. The Azov regiment has been expanded and incorporated into the Ukrainian Offensive Guard Program in 2023.

What we read in news and watch on TV, has little to do with why this war is about.

Ah, right on cue, another one. It sounds like you're in the category of worst people on the far left rather than worst people on the far right, though if you're actually a fash lover rather than a tankie please let me know and I'll amend accordingly.

There's really something uncomfortably close to racist about the way in which some Westerners trying to sound anti imperialist completely ignore any Ukrainian agency, discount the idea that the people might actually want self-determination and have the same right to choose a (flawed) leader as anyone else. They're not like us. Not a fully realised nation or people. It has to be all about the Americans, because nothing in this worldview is ever allowed to be about anything else. Russia's significant Nazi problem always goes unmentioned here too, because racism isn't a problem when it threatens your worldview.

Additionally, the complete failure to acknowledge what the Russian state has done to the people of Donbass also comes from a failure to acknowledge them as truly people like you are. It's not a problem for the men to have been fed into the meat grinder, for Russia to have established torture camps there, for the cities to have been razed to the ground... Russian speakers in the Donbass are collateral.

CPL593H · 13/02/2023 11:14

Thank you, not sure at all I deserve it though, although @BashirWithTheGoodBeard @ReleaseTheDucksOfWar and several other posters certainly do.

Alondra · 13/02/2023 11:13

I stay away from these threads because my opinion is too different from the majority and, frankly, I don't want to be abused.

I will say what a did a couple of years ago. The actual Ukrainian government was imposed by money from the USA in a so-called Revolution of Dignity, ousting the government elected by in elections..

Also search the Azov regiment, the Nazi ideology Ukrainian arm group fighting in the Donbass against Russian-speaking people, which atrocities are well documented, and have always been a part of the Ukrainian government. The Azov regiment has been expanded and incorporated into the Ukrainian Offensive Guard Program in 2023.

What we read in news and watch on TV, has little to do with why this war is about.

PerkingFaintly · 13/02/2023 11:09

It did amuse me that at 08/02/2023 23:42 the Previously Banned Poster diligently explained the difference between a bot and a "paid social media poster".

Then carefully stated a few posts later that they were "certainly not a bot".

Sooo... no comment on being a shill then... Grin

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 13/02/2023 11:06

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 13/02/2023 11:02

Timely reminder again from a very influential source, the Institute for the Study of War, about how Russia is heavy on information and propaganda warfare:

"Russia has partially regained the ability to conduct successful information campaigns in support of strategic objectives and even discrete operational aims. Russian hybrid warfare theory has long called for the integration of information campaigns and military operations, with information operations sometimes taking precedence over kinetic activity... Russia skillfully conducted multiple information campaigns over the two decades preceding the re-invasion of Ukraine in February 2022"

Yes. Fascinating how some people are so keen to try and pooh pooh the idea that the Russian state might be trying to use disinformation tactics on a popular UK website, isn't it?

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 13/02/2023 11:05

also: www.understandingwar.org/backgrounder/ukraine-conflict-updates

"Russian information campaigns have supported a continuous strategic objective of deterring or slowing the West’s provision of material support to Ukraine."

This works at several levels, aimed at leaders but also very much at democratic grassroots and social media, so people put pressure on their leaders to withdraw support for Ukraine.