Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the adoration of Zelensky in the UK feels very wrong?

713 replies

WarWhatIsItGoodFor · 08/02/2023 21:18

Exactly that. Why are UK politicians lapping it all up and hanging on to his every word? The laughter from MPs when he said he enjoyed English tea but now wants English planes… in what sense is that funny? He is wanting war planes to cause more bloodshed, death and destruction. I hope this doesn’t lead to Russian retaliation.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
DanseAvecLesLoup · 09/02/2023 12:23

Iseered · 09/02/2023 12:14

We should not be escalating this war. It's being going on for years and no way should they get planes. Too long to write it all here but on the one hand we are told Russia always planned to take over the world/the West/3rd World War blah blah whilst simultaneously by the same people being told Russia are so crap they can't hold a few Ukraine regions. Laughable.
We are supposed to be crying for corrupt Ukrainian far right oligarchs, who made their money illegally through selling/controlling ex Russian state assets, when Russia blows up their power stations and then cheer leading them as they sue Russia. No.
All the while freezing in our homes whilst destroying our economy. No thanks not my war.
Meanwhile children starve to death and women's lives are destroyed in Afghanistan who we abandoned.

I believe this is what is called a 'word salad'.

Wiluli · 09/02/2023 12:21

Autumnnewname · 09/02/2023 12:16

We're not escalating this war

Putin can stop anytime he wants

We are and we run the risk of escalating it so much that there is no return . Are you really willing to start a potential nuclear war ( that Britain might be an easy target ) to maintain a war that should be de escalated ? Because by giving them planes that is exactly what we are at risk .
putin as much as a lunatic as he is will still crumble to pressure and there is a lot of important people in Russia unhappy with this war .
the idea that he will simply remove troops without negotiations is ludricous , he has no conscience, and he has lots of young men he can force into war to die . For everyone’s sake , we should all be pushing to peace talks

londonrach · 09/02/2023 12:20

I support the Ukraine and their president....they didn't start this war and been so brave. Just wish it was over as even the Russian boys in those tanks don't want to be in this war...it's a war no one wants. Yabu

Natsku · 09/02/2023 12:18

ExistenceOptional · 09/02/2023 12:09

I have a friend who keeps getting her posts removed on facebook because she shares Russian propaganda full of lies. I know she is not being paid, she is simply the equivalent of those QAnon people who believe the lies they are being told.

Yup. Its sad when its someone who has simply fallen for propaganda, its aggravating when its someone who has the ability to recognise propaganda but because it fits in with their beliefs e.g. the Stop The War lot don't recognise it in this instance and think its genuine. They don't stop to wonder why their talking points are the same as the Kremlin talking points because they are so convinced they are right.

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 09/02/2023 12:17

ExistenceOptional · 09/02/2023 12:09

I have a friend who keeps getting her posts removed on facebook because she shares Russian propaganda full of lies. I know she is not being paid, she is simply the equivalent of those QAnon people who believe the lies they are being told.

Yes, one thing this war has achieved is it's brought together a coalition of the most gullible people from both the far left and far right.

PerkingFaintly · 09/02/2023 12:17

More from Ukraine Explainers:

A Mini-Guide to Russian Imperialism
And Why Ukrainian Fight is an Anti-Colonial Resistance
[...]
Imperialism is usually associated with conquering and exploiting distant nations located oceans away from the empire.
But Russia's conquests were different. Russia always expanded its territory by invading neighbouring states. That way, they have gradually collected a lot: from Finland to the Caucasus, from Crimea to the islands bordering Japan.
In all these lands lived non-Russian (and non-Slavic in many cases) nationalities with their own languages, religion, culture, and history. And they were subjected to similar extermination and assimilation strategies as the colonies of Britain, France, or Spain.

But what about the USSR? It was Anti-Imperialist, right?
Not really. USSR's anti-imperialism was mostly directed against the West and its expansion. But when it came to Russian imperialism at home, it was never really recognized or challenged.
After the fall of the Russian Empire, many former colonies declared independence and proclaimed sovereign socialist republics. This was never an option for Moscow. In 1817-1921, the Soviet army violently oppressed most of these states. Finland, Poland, and the Baltic states managed to keep their independence, but most colonies were conquered back.
Ukraine fought for independence between 1917 and 1921 but fell eventually.[...]

Life under the Soviet regime was far from peaceful.
In the 1920s, Ukraine enjoyed a revival of modern art and literature. But 90% of these cultural leaders were sent to the Gulag or executed in the 1930s, becoming known as the Executed Renaissance.
In 1932-1933, the state-managed Holodomor famine hit the Ukrainian rural population. Around 4 million people died from starvation just to fulfill the mad ambitions of Moscow. Soviets kept these events secret until late 1980s.
In 1944, after taking back Crimea from Nazi Germany, USSR deported all Crimean Tatar population (200,00 people) to Central Asia, killing thousands in process. [...]

Since 1991, Russian has instigated numerous military assaults on its former colonies: Moldova in 1992, Georgia in 2008, and Ukraine in 2014. [...]

Why Russian Imperialism is so dangerous
Western imperialism is recognized, studied, and constantly challenged around the globe. Russia, on the contrary, never faced its imperialism internally or externally.
As a result, Russians don't just feel no shame about the history of Russian atrocities. They are proud of them, and they want more. That's why Russia has gone completely fascist in the last 20 years. Putin's rule is based on the idea of the rebirth of Russian imperial greatness, and Ukraine is at the centre of it.
That's why Russians feel they have an inherent right to dominate Ukraine and other post-Soviet countries. And that's why for them, the rejection of Russian dominance anywhere automatically means "Russophobia" worthy of invasion.[...]
Ukraine is fighting for existence. It is defending against centuries-long oppression, and it needs all the help to survive.
It's not just Putin who wages this war. Russians are largely running on unchecked imperialistic thinking and want to completely reboot the empire.
Russia will not agree to anything like the "neutrality of Ukraine" or independence of just Donbas. Only complete dominance over Ukraine will be enough for Russia.
The ultimate way to achieve peace in Europe is to defeat Russian and let it desintegrate as an empire once and for all. Any compromise would mean the Russian neo-imperial machine will try to fight back later.

DismantledKing · 09/02/2023 12:17

Iseered · 09/02/2023 12:14

We should not be escalating this war. It's being going on for years and no way should they get planes. Too long to write it all here but on the one hand we are told Russia always planned to take over the world/the West/3rd World War blah blah whilst simultaneously by the same people being told Russia are so crap they can't hold a few Ukraine regions. Laughable.
We are supposed to be crying for corrupt Ukrainian far right oligarchs, who made their money illegally through selling/controlling ex Russian state assets, when Russia blows up their power stations and then cheer leading them as they sue Russia. No.
All the while freezing in our homes whilst destroying our economy. No thanks not my war.
Meanwhile children starve to death and women's lives are destroyed in Afghanistan who we abandoned.

‘I don’t know the difference between Russia and the USSR. I am very intelligent.’

ExistenceOptional · 09/02/2023 12:17

@Iseered So better to allow Russia to continue taking over other countries and be dragged into a major world war? That is what will happen. Appeasement does not work.
Countries are supporting Ukraine through self interest. Our government do not care about Ukraine, they care about Britain.

Autumnnewname · 09/02/2023 12:16

Iseered · 09/02/2023 12:14

We should not be escalating this war. It's being going on for years and no way should they get planes. Too long to write it all here but on the one hand we are told Russia always planned to take over the world/the West/3rd World War blah blah whilst simultaneously by the same people being told Russia are so crap they can't hold a few Ukraine regions. Laughable.
We are supposed to be crying for corrupt Ukrainian far right oligarchs, who made their money illegally through selling/controlling ex Russian state assets, when Russia blows up their power stations and then cheer leading them as they sue Russia. No.
All the while freezing in our homes whilst destroying our economy. No thanks not my war.
Meanwhile children starve to death and women's lives are destroyed in Afghanistan who we abandoned.

We're not escalating this war

Putin can stop anytime he wants

Iseered · 09/02/2023 12:14

We should not be escalating this war. It's being going on for years and no way should they get planes. Too long to write it all here but on the one hand we are told Russia always planned to take over the world/the West/3rd World War blah blah whilst simultaneously by the same people being told Russia are so crap they can't hold a few Ukraine regions. Laughable.
We are supposed to be crying for corrupt Ukrainian far right oligarchs, who made their money illegally through selling/controlling ex Russian state assets, when Russia blows up their power stations and then cheer leading them as they sue Russia. No.
All the while freezing in our homes whilst destroying our economy. No thanks not my war.
Meanwhile children starve to death and women's lives are destroyed in Afghanistan who we abandoned.

Natsku · 09/02/2023 12:12

ExistenceOptional · 09/02/2023 11:02

Sweden and Finland have applied to join NATO because they are concerned that Putin may try to invade them next.

Yup. Prior to the invasion most Finns, myself included, were against joining NATO and now the vast majority are absolutely for it. We've learnt just how important NATO is.

ExistenceOptional · 09/02/2023 12:09

Natsku · 09/02/2023 12:05

Some people are paid to disseminate Russian propaganda, others do it for free, because they believe it.

I have a friend who keeps getting her posts removed on facebook because she shares Russian propaganda full of lies. I know she is not being paid, she is simply the equivalent of those QAnon people who believe the lies they are being told.

Spambod · 09/02/2023 12:08

I’m calling bs on you op. I recognise the language and the subsequent supporting posts. Reminds me of pro Russian posters on Facebook. Your similar style and slight overuse of English type phrasing is a bit of a giveaway for me. The slightly frantic dramatic style. I don’t feel you are a genuine poster.

Natsku · 09/02/2023 12:05

Rosscameasdoody · 09/02/2023 09:17

Care to elaborate ?

Some people are paid to disseminate Russian propaganda, others do it for free, because they believe it.

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 09/02/2023 12:04

If anyone thinks Russia would stop at the Ukraine/Poland border, they are deluded and that is why Europe are helping him as they are

Correct. Nearly all European counties recognise that helping Ukraine is in their own self interest too.

LuluBlakey1 · 09/02/2023 12:03

Johnson has said yesterday we should give Ukraine all our jets and tanks.

CrotchetyQuaver · 09/02/2023 12:02

I think the way he stepped up when the Russians invaded Ukraine was admirable, he has shown himself to have hidden depths. A very good leader.

If anyone thinks Russia would stop at the Ukraine/Poland border, they are deluded and that is why Europe are helping him as they are. The alternative is WW3, and our current economic situation is partly down to the invasion of Ukraine.

We need to carry on helping them because it's better than entering WW3

ExistenceOptional · 09/02/2023 11:57

@vera99 Ukraine want peace and keep pushing for meetings. But anything agreed with Russia in meetings has subsequently been ignored by Putin. So temporary ceasefires have not been observed.
It takes both sides to negotiate peace. Anyone who actually understands what is happening and wants peace negotiated really mean that Ukraine should give Russia what it wants.

ScrollingLeaves · 09/02/2023 11:54

PerkingFaintly · Today 11:45
Well said.

PerkingFaintly · 09/02/2023 11:46

X-posted with Logburnerperils. I think that site may answer some of your questions, Logburner.

PerkingFaintly · 09/02/2023 11:45

Eg from Ukrainian Explainers
uaexplainers.com

Why Ukrainians and Russians are not brothers
And why calling for their reconciliation right now is abusive

Since the start of the Russian full-scale invasion of Ukraine, many voices have been calling for solidarity and peace between the two "brotherly" nations." [...]
Many Ukrainians feel angered and misunderstood because of the "befriending" attempts.

Russia is waging a war of genocide and extermination against Ukraine. This is not a dispute between two nations that can't get along. This is a neo-imperialistic war that seeks to completely destroy Ukraine. [...]

Ukrainians don't buy the idea that this is Putin's war.
They have felt that Russians have treated Ukrainians as inferiors for centuries. They know how many Russians are cheering for this war.[...]

"Brotherly Nations" is an old Russian imperial narrative.
For the last 350 years, Russia and Ukraine have mostly existed as an empire and its colony. Russia has tried to destroy Ukraine's political autonomy, ban the Ukrainian language from public use, and erase Ukrainian identity.
Russia has created and exploited the "brotherly nations" narrative to justify its imperial claims over other nations: Poland, Czechoslovakia, the Balkans, and more. If you invade a "brotherly" nation, then you're there to help, right?
When Russia talks about "brotherly nations," it always pictures Russians as the older brother and other nations as the younger ones. For instance, Russians sometimes refer to Ukrainians as "Little Russians."[...]
This version of "brotherhood" completely rejects the idea of a sovereign Ukrainian state and turns everybody who supports independent Ukraine into a "Nazi" who deserves to be murdered.[...]

Unfortunately, this war is the modern culmination of Russia's unchecked imperialism (check our cards about Russian imperialism to learn more). It runs deeper than just Putin's regime, and it must be resolved in a more nuanced way. [...]

How to treat the "Brotherly Nations" narrative
First of all, start listening to Ukrainians.[...]
Stop "Westsplaining." Ukrainians and Easter Europeans know Russia far better that people in the West.
Remember, Ukrainians have the right to be outraged and angry. They have the right to distance themselves from Russians.

Igotjelly · 09/02/2023 11:44

Autumnnewname · 09/02/2023 11:38

I'm actually disgusted at the number of posts from presumably educated people who are indulging in victim blaming of the most vile type.

Honestly. Disgusting

Agree. Bots I can deal with but genuine posters with this level of either disinterest, lack of understanding and lack of empathy are another matter. The mental acrobatics needed to defend Russia at this point are mind boggling.

And on the matter of Ukraine causing this by courting NATO - why the fuck shouldn’t they? They’re a sovereign nation who can court whatever alliances they want.

PerkingFaintly · 09/02/2023 11:43

Thanks, DappledThings.

That Ukraine Explainers site – by Ukrainians – is really informative.

They're really very unhappy about Russian imperialism, and Russia's constant attempts to cast Ukraine as a mere Russian colony.

vera99 · 09/02/2023 11:43

I would recommend anyone with an interest read the RAND report in full. They are no shills or Russian bots but right at the heart of US foreign policy development and have been for more than 70 years. The fact that they seem to believe that the push for a dirty peace should begin sooner rather than later and is to the benefit of all parties should give us pause for thought. It should be noted that they will have access to much more detailed intelligence and war models than most of us will ever have. I would suspect that they have come to that conclusion because they think Ukraine cannot win and a continuance is not in the US and to a lesser extent wider western interests. Particularly so in that Joe Biden is facing an election cycle in the near future America is your friend until they're not as many countries have found out in the end.

DappledThings · 09/02/2023 11:41

Logburnerperils · 09/02/2023 11:38

I think none of you here and that includes myself know the real reason all this is happening in Ukraine but I am certain it is bigger than Putin bad Zelensky good and goes back in history before a lot of us were even born.

Of course it does. Which is why reading someone like Timothy Snyder is so important. Or listening to his lecture series on Spotify or YouTube. Answers a lot of questions.