Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the adoration of Zelensky in the UK feels very wrong?

713 replies

WarWhatIsItGoodFor · 08/02/2023 21:18

Exactly that. Why are UK politicians lapping it all up and hanging on to his every word? The laughter from MPs when he said he enjoyed English tea but now wants English planes… in what sense is that funny? He is wanting war planes to cause more bloodshed, death and destruction. I hope this doesn’t lead to Russian retaliation.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Jonnywishbone · 09/02/2023 14:47

I think there is a vast difference between saying Russia is not guilty of war crimes and that saying that we created this situation. They are completely separate things. It's pretty obvious that Russias conduct and behaviour is inhumane and illegal but that is a different point to saying that the we eg NATO/EU created a situation which led to Russian invasion. I don't think that nuance is particularly difficult to grasp. That doesn't excuse russian behaviour. Russia were very clear about what would happen, we ignored them and they invaded. We followed a course of action which led them to do exactly what they said they would do.

Whilst it would be nice to have ideological foreign policy its not realistic is it? We don't cut off relations with Saudi Arabia over human rights issues, we didn't intervene in multiple African civil wars to stop atrocities, we don't sanction India over its treatment of women, we didn't intervened in Syria when they gased their own population. What in particular made Ukraine so special that we decided that it was worth getting involved?

The other absolutely galling thing about this, is that having dangled the carrot of NATO membership to the Ukrainians which led to this situation, when the Ukraine did get invaded we didn't provide military support and pretty much left them to it with a few weapons and some training. We basically caused a fight and then walked away leaving them to beat each other up.

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 09/02/2023 14:43

for all the people quoting the Rand piece (and there are other pieces that disagree with the sometimes rather odd Rand Foundation), the military people who have analyzed what's going on have said that the best way to stop Putin carrying out another war is to drive him back to the pre-2014 borders of Russia.

It's also been pointed out many times that since Russia fears the US and wants to weaken it, this war has been excellent for the US since Russia is weakening itself. Just need to make sure it doesn't succeed in this war, unlike the others, because it'll just be encouraged to start yet another one if it succeeds here.

There was a rather amusing post by a Chinese person that in fact, Russia's helping China a lot by removing itself as a credible threat and reducing its GPD to the size of Guangdong's, one single province of China. How far it's true I don't know.

Autumnnewname · 09/02/2023 14:22

Thanks to the pp that explained the difference between a bot and a shill

I've learned something from this thread. Maybe not what the OP intended, but at least it something

SleeplessInEngland · 09/02/2023 14:20

Russian bots are making threads now, I see.

vera99 · 09/02/2023 14:20

www.washingtonpost.com/world/2023/02/01/ukraine-avoid-long-war-rand-talks-argument/

The argument for why the West should change course on Ukraine
Analysis by Ishaan Tharoor

The war in Ukraine, at least for some policymakers in Western capitals, can be measured in deliveries of weapons. Their response to the brutal onslaught unleashed by Russia last February has been a parade of armor and steel: Javelins, howitzers, drones, strike vehicles, antiaircraft systems, HIMARS and, most recently, battle tanks. At every stage, Kyiv has clamored for more to throw out the invading Russians, and at almost every stage, the West has acceded to Ukrainian demands, though perhaps not at the speed Ukraine would like.

The next round of wrangling may center on Ukraine’s desire for scores of multipurpose fighter jets, which Kyiv wants as it prepares to repulse a rumored forthcoming Russian offensive and reclaim Russian-held territory in the country’s southeast, as well as the Crimean peninsula that Russia annexed in 2014. “Give us your weapons, and we will get back what’s ours,” Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky told the global elites in Davos last month.

When asked this week if he would send F-16 jets, President Biden flatly said “no,” while British officials said it was “not practical” to send such strike craft. But French President Emmanuel Macron told reporters that, “by definition, nothing is excluded” in terms of delivery of aid to Ukrainians. Such is the Western rhetorical commitment to the Ukrainian war effort. The West seems to fully embrace Ukraine’s fight for its sovereignty, as well as Kyiv’s maximalist vision for victory.

Western officials recognize that the war should (and probably can only) end diplomatically. But every time a reporter asks a Western politician or diplomat on the record what the endgame looks like, they almost always offer the same set of responses: It’s up to Ukraine to determine the conditions of the peace (even though without foreign help, they would likely not be able to hold their own); Russia is not interested in good faith negotiations; and the important task now is to arm Ukraine sufficiently so that its hand at a theoretical future negotiating table is as strong as it can be.

A new report takes issue with this position, warning that it puts the United States on the path toward open-ended conflict that could escalate even more dangerously. “Avoiding a long war: U.S. policy and the trajectory of the Russia-Ukraine conflict,” published recently by the influential Rand Corp., a Washington-based think tank, argued that the longer the war dragged on, the more likely the risk of an escalation that could pit Russia in direct conflict with NATO and possibly see the Kremlin deploy nuclear weapons on the battlefield. Instead of enabling the war to sprawl onward, Western powers should do more to push the warring parties toward talks, it advised.

This is an argument that has been made before — including by Henry Kissinger, a venerable fixture of the U.S. foreign policy establishment. But the Rand report marks perhaps the most systematic case for a shift in policy put forward by a Washington think tank, the vast majority of which have hailed the war in Ukraine as a good and necessary fight, as well as a moment to reassert U.S. leadership on the world stage. In a departure from the Beltway script, the report does not reference “democracy,” “rule of law,” or Western “values” once.

In sober terms, the report’s authors, political scientists Samuel Charap and Miranda Priebe, spell out the troubling structural factors of the war: Neither Russia nor Ukraine has a chance to secure “absolute victory” in the way they see it, yet both countries feel optimistic about their ability to win out in the longer run and are pessimistic about what may follow a cease-fire or uneasy peace.

Whatever the political rhetoric, uncertainty looms over how long the West can sustain its flows of aid and weapons to Ukraine. A new Pew poll shows that more Americans already believe the United States is giving too much to Ukraine, while the Rand report’s authors point to the obvious reality that an extended war would see more Ukrainian suffering and more economic havoc in Europe.

Then there’s the question of nuclear weapons. For months, Ukraine and its allies have urged their supporters to ignore Russian President Vladimir Putin’s sporadic attempts at nuclear brinkmanship.

“It’s a scare tactic,” Maj. Gen. Kyrylo Budanov, Ukraine’s military intelligence chief, recently told my colleagues in Kyiv. “Russia is a country that you can expect a lot from but not outright idiocy. Sorry, but it’s not going to happen. Carrying out a nuclear strike will result in not just a military defeat for Russia but the collapse of Russia. And they know this very well.”

Even then, Charap and Priebe point to the reality of the risk of “a hot war with a country that has the world’s largest nuclear arsenal.” An escalation in hostilities, perhaps even triggered by targeting errors or other tactical miscalculations in the fog of war, could quickly pull NATO countries into an open clash with Russia.

“Keeping a Russia-NATO war below the nuclear threshold would be extremely difficult, particularly given the weakened state of Russia’s conventional military,” they wrote. “Some analysts are doubtful that Russia would attack a NATO country since it is already losing ground to Ukrainian forces and would find itself in a war with the world’s most powerful alliance. However, if the Kremlin concluded that the country’s national security was severely imperiled, it might well deliberately escalate for lack of better alternatives.”

Why court such a scenario, they argue, when even settling along the current lines of the conflict would mark a significant Russian defeat? “The war has already been so devastating to Russian power that further incremental weakening is arguably no longer as significant a benefit for U.S. interests as in the earlier phases of the conflict,” Charap and Priebe wrote. “It will take years, perhaps even decades, for the Russian military and economy to recover from the damage already incurred.”

In a separate essay for the Economist, Christopher Chivvis, director of the American Statecraft Program at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, made a similar claim: “If the negotiations froze the battlelines where they are now, Putin would have paid a very high price for very limited gains,” he wrote. “His armed forces have displayed their incompetence to the whole world. Russia is now a pariah state and its relationship with Europe — for centuries its most important — is destroyed. Sanctions will slow Russia’s economic growth for years to come, even if they are eventually moderated in return for concessions from the Kremlin.”

The Rand authors advise, among other things, that the United States should offer a road map to Russia for what the conditions for eventual sanctions relief would look like. Chivvis contended that embarking even on an imperfect, fitful process of negotiations or talks about talks would be preferable to buying into the idea that Russia can be wholly dislodged from Ukrainian territory.

“Yes, it would be nice if Ukraine clawed back some more territory,” he wrote. “But at what cost and for what strategic gain? Even in the unlikely event that the West were to back Ukraine to the hilt for many years and were eventually to force Russia out of all Ukrainian territory, Russia would probably restart the war at some point to salvage its lost gains and its reputation.”

Charap and Priebe acknowledged in their introduction “that Ukrainians have been the ones fighting and dying to protect their country against an unprovoked, illegal, and morally repugnant Russian invasion.” But that still, in their view, does not mean that Ukraine’s interests are “synonymous” with those of the United States.

sunshinenroses · 09/02/2023 13:48

ACynicalDad · 08/02/2023 21:30

The world must make sure Russia loses or they will try again. It will probably take tanks and planes to win, let’s do it quickly before Russia strengthens and keep the war as short as possible. Russia must not win. He’s an incredible leader, history will show his flaws, but he’s getting a lot right, let’s go with it.

Agree!

Rosscameasdoody · 09/02/2023 13:41

Natsku · 09/02/2023 12:05

Some people are paid to disseminate Russian propaganda, others do it for free, because they believe it.

Thank you for clarifying.

KarmaStar · 09/02/2023 13:28

What on earth are you on about?
if Mr Zelensky was not such a determined,strategic ,brave and incredibly empathic leader Ukraine would possibly have fallen by now.If Ukraine falls Europe will be next,there is no doubt about that.
Putin needs stopping and now.
we need to supply as much as we can in the way of arms,welfare and friendship to these simply amazing people who have fought heroically for almost a year now.
slava ukraini 🇺🇦

daytriptovulcan · 09/02/2023 13:28

Iseered · 09/02/2023 12:43

If you read the UN reports (before Russia invaded) you would see that Ukrainian soldiers were murderers, criminals, rapists and torturers if you were the wrong kind of Ukrainian.

Your narrative aligns perfectly with Kremlin propaganda.
Under international law Ukraine is entitled to defend itself.
It's pragmatic too, if Russia invades Estonia the crisis will increase exponentially. Let Ukraine defeat them in Ukraine.

orangegato · 09/02/2023 13:28

YABU, he’s not invaded anywhere. I suppose you’d just roll over ey?

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 09/02/2023 13:26

Iseered · 09/02/2023 12:43

If you read the UN reports (before Russia invaded) you would see that Ukrainian soldiers were murderers, criminals, rapists and torturers if you were the wrong kind of Ukrainian.

Uh huh, link to reports?

Will you also link the reports that show just how far Ukraine has gone to clean up its act?

Will you link the reports over the Russian occupation of Bucha, Mariupol, Izyum, and the other freed settlements?

Because I'm sure that some Ukrainians aren't perfect (and who governed Ukraine until very very recently and forced its culture on the people, the ones that it didn't kill in Holodomor? Oh yes ... It's Russia!)

But what's coming out of Ukraine now are reports by, oh yes the UN, that far far eclipse whatever sins the Ukrainians committed by magnitudes.

Daftasabroom · 09/02/2023 13:24

Boshi · 09/02/2023 10:44

Have a look at this image and think about why Russia would have been triggered by Ukraine trying to join NATO. To think Ukraine invited this war on themselves is a valid opinion, that they would have been better trying to negotiate with Russia than trying to join NATO.

Russia does not want NATO on its borders and it has warned Ukraine about the consequences. Fair enough Ukraine is a sovereign nation and decided to press ahead but equally Russia decided they did not want NATO on their borders. Hence, war. I’m not coming down on either side, both are corrupt countries but I do find Zelensky essentially guilt tripping the west to be a bit disingenuous when you look at how and why the war began.

Have a look at your image. If Putin is successful in his invasion of Ukraine he goes from having little border with NATO to, guess what? A big border with NATO. It's daft for either Putin or yourself to justify the invasion of Ukraine on the basis of NATO borders.

The USSR had borders with NATO for decades.

If Ukraine falls so will Moldova. Belarus will apply to join the Russian Federation. Then Estonia will be invaded. Latvia and Lithuania would be obvious candidates but they are members of NATO.

NATO only poses a threat to Putin if he attacks a NATO member. He knows this.

MasterBeth · 09/02/2023 13:22

Iseered · 09/02/2023 12:14

We should not be escalating this war. It's being going on for years and no way should they get planes. Too long to write it all here but on the one hand we are told Russia always planned to take over the world/the West/3rd World War blah blah whilst simultaneously by the same people being told Russia are so crap they can't hold a few Ukraine regions. Laughable.
We are supposed to be crying for corrupt Ukrainian far right oligarchs, who made their money illegally through selling/controlling ex Russian state assets, when Russia blows up their power stations and then cheer leading them as they sue Russia. No.
All the while freezing in our homes whilst destroying our economy. No thanks not my war.
Meanwhile children starve to death and women's lives are destroyed in Afghanistan who we abandoned.

No, I am crying for innocent Ukraine citizens being bombed from their homes by the invading Russian army.

DanseAvecLesLoup · 09/02/2023 13:19

Iseered · 09/02/2023 12:35

I don't believe that will happen. And I do blame Ukraine, the EU, the US and the West for not doing more before Russia invaded. Maybe it would not have made a difference but we will never know.
Russia raised concerns for example about having an EU land border Their concerns were pretty much identical to the concerns the EU had about a land border in Ireland. Yet Russia were unreasonable twats to have concerns whilst the EU were totally justified with theirs. Hypocrisy.

So in order to mitigate the risk of having an EU/NATO country on its border the solution is for Russia to deny the right of Ukraine to exist, invade and absorb it into Greater Russia, thus ensuring that it now shares a border with four existing NATO and EU countries?

EerieSilence · 09/02/2023 13:09

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 09/02/2023 13:05

And at least in 1938, they didn't have the failure of 1938 to look back and learn from. In 2023 there isn't even that excuse.

Well, those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it. Those, who are doing it despite being fully aware of the past are just sociopaths without any character and excuse.

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 09/02/2023 13:05

EerieSilence · 09/02/2023 13:02

It's nice to see that Munich 1938 mentality still lives and thrives in the UK of 2023. Why should the UK care about the world, just sell them.

And at least in 1938, they didn't have the failure of 1938 to look back and learn from. In 2023 there isn't even that excuse.

EerieSilence · 09/02/2023 13:02

It's nice to see that Munich 1938 mentality still lives and thrives in the UK of 2023. Why should the UK care about the world, just sell them.

LadyJ2023 · 09/02/2023 13:00

Tbh I like him he is ordinary says what he wants and means and actually has proven he acts for his people. You seem to forget Ukraine never started a war to.

Daftasabroom · 09/02/2023 12:56

@Genevieva However, history shows that all modern wars end around a table and not on the battlefield.

Try telling that to the Syrians, the Chechens, and the Georgians. You probably ought to add if Afghans while you're at it.

ScrollingLeaves · 09/02/2023 12:54

Iseered · Today 12:43
If you read the UN reports (before Russia invaded) you would see that Ukrainian soldiers were murderers, criminals, rapists and torturers if you were the wrong kind of Ukrainian.

if you were the wrong kind of Ukrainian.

In other words, shipped in Russians, shipped in Russian soldiers, and pro-Russian people collaborating with them, just after Russia had invaded and annexed Crimea.

CalistoNoSolo · 09/02/2023 12:53

Iseered · 09/02/2023 12:35

I don't believe that will happen. And I do blame Ukraine, the EU, the US and the West for not doing more before Russia invaded. Maybe it would not have made a difference but we will never know.
Russia raised concerns for example about having an EU land border Their concerns were pretty much identical to the concerns the EU had about a land border in Ireland. Yet Russia were unreasonable twats to have concerns whilst the EU were totally justified with theirs. Hypocrisy.

The more of your posts I read, the more utterly batshit they become. You're seriously comparing Russian expansionist aggression and sabre rattling to EU maintaining a trade border on the island of Ireland??

DismantledKing · 09/02/2023 12:53

Iseered · 09/02/2023 12:43

If you read the UN reports (before Russia invaded) you would see that Ukrainian soldiers were murderers, criminals, rapists and torturers if you were the wrong kind of Ukrainian.

Yeah, you’re a bot. Nobody is quite this stupid.

Autumnnewname · 09/02/2023 12:50

@Iseered Before russia invaded?

So before 2014

Can you point me to these IN reports prior to the little green men having a jolly holiday in Donbas in 2014

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 09/02/2023 12:47

Yes, I wouldn't try and get any logic out of it @PerkingFaintly. That's not going to happen.

user1471449196 · 09/02/2023 12:46

This