Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would this be seen as neglect if they weren’t wealthy?

157 replies

Thesesoundsfallintomymindwoowoo · 08/02/2023 20:09

I know a wealthy family, the Dd is 10 and hasn’t been to school since the start of October due to anxiety and feeling unwell (comes from the anxiety I believe)
They have only recently recruited a tutor for homeschooling, she’s missed months of schooling and did nothing at home.
Parents fly to another country each week for business (take it in turns, both go each time for a couple of days)
No real organisation/schedule in the house, no proper food shops, mainly expensive restaurants or takeaways. Dd hasn’t ever baked (sounds silly but surprised me) isn’t allowed to watch tv without parents etc. Dd has many issues around illness and eating and other things, highly sensitive child, she rarely goes out and has one friend she sometimes sees.
I see this as pretty unhealthy and worry about her and the situation, should I or am I just being nosey and out of order?

OP posts:
BigotSpigot · 08/02/2023 21:03

You really can't assume that professional treatment will 'work wonders' when you really have no idea what is going on for this girl. The family may be on a journey with an ASD/PDA diagnosis for instance which they haven't shared with you. If you really believe she is neglected then report it to the SS. That said, I do believe there is a great deal more abuse and neglect in middle class families than ever gets acknowledged.

MissyB1 · 08/02/2023 21:03

Hongkongsuey · 08/02/2023 20:46

Maybe if people were a bit more nosey and judgmental , we wouldn’t have the horrific levels of child abuse in this country.

This! 👆
You can’t win on here, everyone rants that people should notice when something isn’t right with a child. But when someone does notice they are “nosey and judgmental” 🤷‍♀️

MissHoollie · 08/02/2023 21:02

I'd be concerned too
But like you not sure what to do

JeanBodel · 08/02/2023 21:02

As a PP said, there is a very high threshold for neglect. This is the case law:

Hedley J in Re L (Care: Threshold Criteria) [2007] 1 FLR 2050, para 50, :

"society must be willing to tolerate very diverse standards of parenting, including the eccentric, the barely adequate and the inconsistent. It follows too that children will inevitably have both very different experiences of parenting and very unequal consequences flowing from it. It means that some children will experience disadvantage and harm, while others flourish in atmospheres of loving security and emotional stability. These are the consequences of our fallible humanity and it is not the provenance of the state to spare children all the consequences of defective parenting. In any event, it simply could not be done."

WindscreenWipe · 08/02/2023 21:02

Thesesoundsfallintomymindwoowoo · 08/02/2023 20:59

@WindscreenWipe I don’t know, I only know what she says obviously, it just seems a quiet, lonely house

That doesn’t actually make sense as a response. Are you saying that you asked her what she does and she told you she doesn’t do anything? As opposed to that you’ve actually witnessed her not doing anything all day? Have you considered that she just doesn’t like you or want to talk to you or want to tell you things? Have you considered, for just a second, that she has anxiety?

MotherOfPuffling · 08/02/2023 21:02

Thesesoundsfallintomymindwoowoo · 08/02/2023 20:58

@ChiefWiggumsBoy Is that strange she can’t watch tv alone? It seemed it to me but again maybe it’s just because my upbringing/house were/are different

In fairness, whilst my DD is only 9, she’s not allowed to watch TV alone either. I don’t think it’s appropriate. There’s too much I don’t approve of, plus screen time is not good in excess. Also DD’s behaviour and self-regulation go to pot if she has more than a little screen time, and if I wasn’t watching with her I wouldn’t trust her to be mature enough yet to switch it off after the agreed cut off point.

FailingAtStrife · 08/02/2023 21:00

@Thesesoundsfallintomymindwoowoo My DS also rarely socialises and has no hobbies. He wants to, but he finds it impossible. I’m not berating you or saying you’re wrong to be concerned, but there is always more to what we see on the surface.

Thesesoundsfallintomymindwoowoo · 08/02/2023 20:59

@WindscreenWipe I don’t know, I only know what she says obviously, it just seems a quiet, lonely house

OP posts:
johsq20 · 08/02/2023 20:58

From your title my initial thought was that maybe your issue is that the parents are capable of offering these things and choose not to and have an unstable home life, rather than it to do with them being unable to afford it/being due to certain circumstances?

Thesesoundsfallintomymindwoowoo · 08/02/2023 20:58

@ChiefWiggumsBoy Is that strange she can’t watch tv alone? It seemed it to me but again maybe it’s just because my upbringing/house were/are different

OP posts:
WindscreenWipe · 08/02/2023 20:57

Thesesoundsfallintomymindwoowoo · 08/02/2023 20:54

@LovelyIssues That’s what I found strange/sad, she doesn’t really do anything or see any friends or anyone. She doesn’t go to any clubs, have hobbies etc

She must do something. She’s not comatose. When I was 10 I would make up dances or play imaginary games in my room. I’d be a spy or a princess or a French high school student - but if an adult walked in or came past then I’d stop being it’s a bit weird/embarrassing/childish. I suppose, from the outside, it might look like I spent the whole time just standing/sitting around.

FailingAtStrife · 08/02/2023 20:56

@Redbushteaforme you would assume a child would be flagged up but sadly , it is not always the case. Some schools are utterly useless and lots of DC do not get the education they are entitled to. I am utterly broken by my experience of the education system since my DS has been unable to attend school.

Thesesoundsfallintomymindwoowoo · 08/02/2023 20:56

@FailingAtStrife I’m so sorry.
This situation is different though, this girl seems to want to do certain things but it doesn’t seem to be facilitated by her parents etc

OP posts:
ChiefWiggumsBoy · 08/02/2023 20:56

I’d be concerned. And if people think I’m nosy for being concerned about an anxious child who seemingly has no outside activities and isn’t even allowed to watch tv alone, then quite frankly I don’t care. My feelings and their feelings are not important when a child is being isolated and possible neglected.

AllOfThemWitches · 08/02/2023 20:54

I've got a big posh house and a similar aged daughter who barely makes it to school at the moment because it makes her self harm.

I don't have a big posh house but I went through that with my daughter. It was so shit but her mental health has improved massively since she left school. She really hated it. It's bloody awful though, isn't it?

Thesesoundsfallintomymindwoowoo · 08/02/2023 20:54

@LovelyIssues That’s what I found strange/sad, she doesn’t really do anything or see any friends or anyone. She doesn’t go to any clubs, have hobbies etc

OP posts:
Xol · 08/02/2023 20:54

Sadly, there are children all over the country who are too anxious to cope with school. Despite the fact that local authorities have a statutory right to provide full time education for them, you can bet the vast majority of those children will get minimal if any teaching unless their parents are resourceful and knowledgeable enough to enforce their rights.

That statutory duty applies to every child, including the children of wealthy parents. So if this child has not been educated, it's the LA which should be accused of neglect, not her parents.

Thesesoundsfallintomymindwoowoo · 08/02/2023 20:53

@DinnerThyme Not my intention at all. I think I’ll remove this

OP posts:
FailingAtStrife · 08/02/2023 20:52

@Thesesoundsfallintomymindwoowoo I don’t think you can ever know the full extent of the situation even if you work with the family.

I am from a working class background and my DS has been out of school for a year due to severe anxiety co morbid with autism. You would not be aware of the fight I have to put up to get him any education at all. It’s exhausting and humiliating to have to beg for what your child is legally entitled to.

My DS spends most of his time at home or running errands with me; his anxiety became so bad, he could not learn at home either. We are taking a break from formal education whilst we await a nurture school placement for him. His anxiety triggers have reduced so much since.

Please don’t judge the family. They are likely trying their best in an extremely difficult situation. You can never truly understand the hell having to deal with a situation where a child is unable to attend school, until you are in the thick of it yourself.

LovelyIssues · 08/02/2023 20:52

Yanbu OP. This would flag as a concern in my mind. Who is this child actually socialising with? May well sound silly to others but to never baked at that age is a bit strange, what kind of interactions are the parents having with the child?

Thesesoundsfallintomymindwoowoo · 08/02/2023 20:51

@Redbushteaforme Just that she’s a very sensitive child, no outside help given

OP posts:
DinnerThyme · 08/02/2023 20:51

Do you really not think you’ve done anything wrong here?

“I work for a family and their child has an illness. I accept that she’s not being neglected but I think that their family set-up isn’t ideal for vague or arbitrary reasons that I haven’t actually outlined. Please join me in slagging them off on a public forum. By the way, just in case anyone feels bad about insulting them, they’re rich so they’re fair game”.

Thesesoundsfallintomymindwoowoo · 08/02/2023 20:50

@SwordToFlamethrower Yes, probably, do you not think the anxiety etc should be addressed and some moves towards integration back into life with friends etc?

OP posts:
LindorDoubleChoc · 08/02/2023 20:50

The threshold for "neglect" is extremely high. I have a very close friend who is a senior social worker and part of his job is making the ultimate decision about taking children into care.

I agree with you OP that this child seems neglected in some aspects of her life. But she is warm, safe from harm and has food. That's how low the bar goes generally.

Redbushteaforme · 08/02/2023 20:50

I think I would be a bit concerned too, OP. Does the mum say anything about what is causing the anxiety and/or if they are arranging any specialist support (other than tutor)? Perhaps the girl is autistic? You don't know the full story, obviously, but I think that any child missing school for anxiety in the state system for more than four months would probably be flagged up as a concern.

Swipe left for the next trending thread