Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would this be seen as neglect if they weren’t wealthy?

157 replies

Thesesoundsfallintomymindwoowoo · 08/02/2023 20:09

I know a wealthy family, the Dd is 10 and hasn’t been to school since the start of October due to anxiety and feeling unwell (comes from the anxiety I believe)
They have only recently recruited a tutor for homeschooling, she’s missed months of schooling and did nothing at home.
Parents fly to another country each week for business (take it in turns, both go each time for a couple of days)
No real organisation/schedule in the house, no proper food shops, mainly expensive restaurants or takeaways. Dd hasn’t ever baked (sounds silly but surprised me) isn’t allowed to watch tv without parents etc. Dd has many issues around illness and eating and other things, highly sensitive child, she rarely goes out and has one friend she sometimes sees.
I see this as pretty unhealthy and worry about her and the situation, should I or am I just being nosey and out of order?

OP posts:
LolaSmiles · 08/02/2023 21:25

Look, either she’s being actually neglected/there’s a safeguarding issue, in which case you should report it to the relevant authorities. I’m all in favour of taking an interest in child’s welfare and following safeguarding processes. Phone the LA or NSPCC and talk it through with them.

Or she’s not, in which case you’re being judgemental about what are just very different parenting standards. Whether you personally think x, y or z would be good for her is completely irrelevant because she’s not your child - ultimately it’s up to the parents to bring up their child how they see fit unless actually causing harm or neglect
This 100%

If OP has genuine concerns then she needs to raise them, and it's a little concerning that a tutor working with vulnerable children doesn't know this.

If the OP doesn't have any safeguarding concerns then it's irrelevant what she thinks about someone else's parenting choices.

Pinkypurplecloud · 08/02/2023 21:23

Thesesoundsfallintomymindwoowoo · 08/02/2023 21:10

@Lozzybear I suppose it’s with a lot of things together, as an isolated thing, I wouldn’t think anything of it
There’s barely any contact with the outside world, I personally think it could be good for her

Look, either she’s being actually neglected/there’s a safeguarding issue, in which case you should report it to the relevant authorities. I’m all in favour of taking an interest in child’s welfare and following safeguarding processes. Phone the LA or NSPCC and talk it through with them.

Or she’s not, in which case you’re being judgemental about what are just very different parenting standards. Whether you personally think x, y or z would be good for her is completely irrelevant because she’s not your child - ultimately it’s up to the parents to bring up their child how they see fit unless actually causing harm or neglect. There’s kids brought up in relative isolation all over the world, for lots of reasons. Wouldn’t be my choice, but they have the right to make that choice for their own child. Just like there’s people who choose never to discipline their child or choose to bring them up off grid in a yurt or who have 20+ kids they can’t possibly pay enough attention to or who schedule their child with three activities a day and “tiger mother” them. There’s many ways to raise children, many reasons for those choices (often related to circumstances or parenting the actual child you have rather than the standard model child you expected) and many costs and benefits to those choices. But they are the parents choices.

StrawberryAnnie · 08/02/2023 21:22

Not every family bakes- just because it’s your ‘normal’ doesn’t mean it’s everyone else’s.

Watching TV as a family or only under parental supervision is quite likely allowing the child to explore other interests instead of being stuck in front of a screen.

The family have a different very different routine to yours, and it appears you believe it is incorrect.

It’s sounds like there was disruption to her education, but they have now accessed a tutor for her as she can’t attend school. Could be many reasons for this.

Does the child’s mother speak with warmth and concern about her or does she sound indifferent? Is she accessing support for her child’s anxiety?

If something feels off, it would be worth getting advice from from the NSPCC

Sqqueeeeeeee · 08/02/2023 21:19

Thesesoundsfallintomymindwoowoo · 08/02/2023 21:17

@Sqqueeeeeeee For goodness sake, it’s not that *Nothing adds up. I don’t want to go into too many details and have contacted mumsnet to remove it as I feel it’s too outing now.
It’s true I haven’t been working with her fir a long period but have been able to get a sense of her life. I work with her only a few hours per day, it isn’t my job to organise activities etc, although I have talked with her and gently tried to encourage getting together with her friends etc, but again, it’s not my place
This host was written from a place of concern, no other reason. I’m trying not to be judgemental, but I admit I don’t understand some of the way she’s raised, sorry, I’m human

So you’re the tutor 🙄I hope the family see this and act accordingly.

Everyonehasavoice · 08/02/2023 21:18

If she suffers from anxiety then all of her behaviour is not surprising

Did you really say she’s never baked?!! Stuff about when and how she’s allowed to watch tv!?!?!
This sort of thing is obv how her family like to live…and not your concern

Tbh think none of this is your business

Indecisivebynature · 08/02/2023 21:18

I have a highly sensitive child. It’s hard to imagine the things that make them anxious. My DD has been crying every evening for 3 weeks because it will soon be my birthday and it means I’m a little bit older and a little bit closer to dying. That feels her with fear. I doubt you have the full picture and I suspect their home life is a lot more complicated than you realise.

Thesesoundsfallintomymindwoowoo · 08/02/2023 21:17

*Post

OP posts:
Thesesoundsfallintomymindwoowoo · 08/02/2023 21:17

@Sqqueeeeeeee For goodness sake, it’s not that *Nothing adds up. I don’t want to go into too many details and have contacted mumsnet to remove it as I feel it’s too outing now.
It’s true I haven’t been working with her fir a long period but have been able to get a sense of her life. I work with her only a few hours per day, it isn’t my job to organise activities etc, although I have talked with her and gently tried to encourage getting together with her friends etc, but again, it’s not my place
This host was written from a place of concern, no other reason. I’m trying not to be judgemental, but I admit I don’t understand some of the way she’s raised, sorry, I’m human

OP posts:
Sqqueeeeeeee · 08/02/2023 21:12

Thesesoundsfallintomymindwoowoo · 08/02/2023 21:08

@beautifulpaintings I'm not obsessing, I know her well as she’s under my care a lot of the time. I’m at their house almost daily

How long has she been under your care daily?

Like PP said, this doesn’t add up. You’ve previously said you don’t know what she does all day and are relying solely on what she tells you. If you saw her daily then you’d know, surely?

If she’s under your care so much then why aren’t you doing any activities with her?

Lavenderflower · 08/02/2023 21:12

I would say it unusual for a child not to attend school even if there are mental and/or physical health issue. Absence from school trigger concerns, however there isn't enough information here to say this a case of neglect.

allthegearandnoideaatall · 08/02/2023 21:11

@Thesesoundsfallintomymindwoowoo i don’t think you are nosey or overly judgemental. I think you are concerned, and I don’t think that comes from ill-intention. You seem to be accepting that other families do things differently.

Able you able to offer friendship at all particularly play dates for this girl?

If not friendship, then perhaps raise your concern with the safeguarding lead at her old school?

At least that way you have flagged your concern. If it turns to be unfounded, you will have done the right thing. I believe we all have a responsibility to each other. Sometimes that means looking out for others.

FriedasCarLoad · 08/02/2023 21:10

Your concern shows you in a positive light, in spite of what some others have said.

It doesn't sound like a great childhood to me, but on the other hand I wouldn't be considering an SS referral.

The months off from education wouldn't actually worry me (even though I was a teacher). When I had very bad MH I needed a few months off work to recover, and I see this as equivalent.

The parents coming and going wouldn't worry me either - she has two parents who are still together in one home, and who time their business travel so one is always home. No problem.

The lack of other activities and social time isn't good. The former definitely isn't a neglect issue though and wouldn't meet SS thresholds. The latter...not ideal, but maybe it'll change.

Thesesoundsfallintomymindwoowoo · 08/02/2023 21:10

@Lozzybear I suppose it’s with a lot of things together, as an isolated thing, I wouldn’t think anything of it
There’s barely any contact with the outside world, I personally think it could be good for her

OP posts:
LolaSmiles · 08/02/2023 21:09

I wouldn’t ever report them for anything but I do feel she should be getting some help of some sort
So you're concerned about neglect and think the family are getting away with all sorts because they're rich, but you're not willing to do anything about it?

Either you're not actually concerned about the child's welfare or you don't have meaningful safeguarding concerns.

CowSnail · 08/02/2023 21:09

BeatieBourke · 08/02/2023 21:04

@Thesesoundsfallintomymindwoowoo there's a rule on mumsnet (and in life):

If the kids seem unhappy, the family set up questionable or home life sub par and the family is working class / skint / on benefits it is the first port of call to assume the parents are at fault, in some way ignorant or deficient.

If on the other hand everything else is described as above but the family are loaded, criticise at your peril. You are then judgemental, nosey, jealous, shitstiring, or all of the above.

This is how money buys you safety from scrutiny. I detest it.

Would you really judge a working class family for what OP has outlined? I certainly wouldn’t.

beautifulpaintings · 08/02/2023 21:09

Thesesoundsfallintomymindwoowoo · 08/02/2023 21:08

@beautifulpaintings I'm not obsessing, I know her well as she’s under my care a lot of the time. I’m at their house almost daily

I don't believe that for a moment, if she was under your care every day then your original post doesn't make any sense.

Lozzybear · 08/02/2023 21:08

Why would you even feel that the TV point is an issue. A school friend of mine didn’t have a TV growing up. A conscious choice by her parents. She appears to be a perfectly well adjusted adult.

Thesesoundsfallintomymindwoowoo · 08/02/2023 21:08

@beautifulpaintings I'm not obsessing, I know her well as she’s under my care a lot of the time. I’m at their house almost daily

OP posts:
CowSnail · 08/02/2023 21:07

MissyB1 · 08/02/2023 21:03

This! 👆
You can’t win on here, everyone rants that people should notice when something isn’t right with a child. But when someone does notice they are “nosey and judgmental” 🤷‍♀️

Except that OP has flat-out admitted that she doesn’t think the child is being neglected or abused at all. She just thinks she’s sad and lonely but she hasn’t actually articulated why beyond ridiculous reasons like “she doesn’t bake” and, it appears from her updates, she doesn’t actually know what’s going on and has just got an impression from talking to a child with anxiety where she seemed, to be honest, just bloody anxious.

Be as nosey and judgemental as you like if a child is actually being abused or neglected but being nosey and judgmental just because the child has anxiety isn’t the same thing. OP’s over-invested and ill-informed criticism is likely to do more harm than good.

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 08/02/2023 21:07

In terms of child protection, that’s not what ‘neglect’ means.

beautifulpaintings · 08/02/2023 21:06

Don't include me in that conclusion @BeatieBourke I would have posted exactly the same whatever the situation of the family income wise! The OP needs to stop obsessing over a girl she knows nothing about as it's unwise and fan cause a lot of distress.

Thesesoundsfallintomymindwoowoo · 08/02/2023 21:06

I wouldn’t ever report them for anything but I do feel she should be getting some help of some sort

OP posts:
LolaSmiles · 08/02/2023 21:05

You're muddying the waters with silly dogs about the child not having done baking and having the right childhood activities, which makes you seem more invested in looking to have a dig than raise real concerns.

If a child has been missing from school then school will have reported it and will be following the relevant procedures.

If a child is unable to attend school for medical reasons the local authority has a duty of care to provide EOTAS for the child. The wait lists for this are often long so some parents decide that they will arrange their own private tutoring to fill the gaps in EOTAS services.

If you have any safeguarding concerns then you need to report them to social services, who will look at the rest of the jigsaw and decide what needs to happen.

If you're just looking in and deciding that you think the house just be lonely/you're speculating that the child wants to do things and creating your own narrative about the parents preventing them then take a step back and consider that you're only seeing part of a picture and you're filling your own gaps in.

BeatieBourke · 08/02/2023 21:04

@Thesesoundsfallintomymindwoowoo there's a rule on mumsnet (and in life):

If the kids seem unhappy, the family set up questionable or home life sub par and the family is working class / skint / on benefits it is the first port of call to assume the parents are at fault, in some way ignorant or deficient.

If on the other hand everything else is described as above but the family are loaded, criticise at your peril. You are then judgemental, nosey, jealous, shitstiring, or all of the above.

This is how money buys you safety from scrutiny. I detest it.

beautifulpaintings · 08/02/2023 21:04

OP honestly you have a really unhealthy interest in this child!

You really have zero knowledge about what is going on in that house, no idea of any special needs or learning differences she might have, yet you're judging, throwing around the word neglect, speaking as if you have intimate knowledge of the family (which you don't), making statements like 'she doesn't bake' (which is a strange comment in itself), & judging the poor quality of their parenting, judging their travel schedule, judging the poor quality of her home schooling, judging how they eat, and even managing to judge the fact they're wealthy. Stop judging. You have no right to and you're overstepping boundaries all ove the place here. Plus saying that you know their travel schedule and daily eating habits sounds like you are spying on them. You should just leave them alone.