Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would this be seen as neglect if they weren’t wealthy?

157 replies

Thesesoundsfallintomymindwoowoo · 08/02/2023 20:09

I know a wealthy family, the Dd is 10 and hasn’t been to school since the start of October due to anxiety and feeling unwell (comes from the anxiety I believe)
They have only recently recruited a tutor for homeschooling, she’s missed months of schooling and did nothing at home.
Parents fly to another country each week for business (take it in turns, both go each time for a couple of days)
No real organisation/schedule in the house, no proper food shops, mainly expensive restaurants or takeaways. Dd hasn’t ever baked (sounds silly but surprised me) isn’t allowed to watch tv without parents etc. Dd has many issues around illness and eating and other things, highly sensitive child, she rarely goes out and has one friend she sometimes sees.
I see this as pretty unhealthy and worry about her and the situation, should I or am I just being nosey and out of order?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
LolaSmiles · 10/02/2023 20:09

Companyofwolves
Yes sadly tutoring is unregulated and any Tom, Dick and Harry can set up as one.

If the OP isn't the tutor, it's still not her role to investigate. Digging around with a view of finding out /verifying safeguarding concerns is a really bad idea. It's something that's clearly said in safeguarding training.

For example, if the OP has safeguarding concerns and she goes digging but doesn't report, and it spooks a parent who is causing or failing to prevent harm, the OP could find herself out of a job and the child goes under the radar without help. Digging around is also problematic as there's the issue of children feeling like they want to please so it could be accused of leading a child into saying something.

If the OP has safeguarding concerns then she needs to report them because it could be the part of a jigsaw that is missing (eg school might have flagged something up and other agencies might have). Just because something on its own wouldn't trigger social services involvement, so much of safeguarding children is that all the adults are vigilant and then the people with the whole picture can make the decision.

If it's coming down to OP thinking the parents should do more/making a judgement on whether the child has the right mental health support/has or hasn't done the right sort of childhood activities etc then it isn't a safeguarding issue. It's someone from outside a situation judging a family for not dealing with a complex situation the way they think they'd deal with it.

Iwantaswishyponytail · 10/02/2023 08:13

I’m not a tutor

Companyofwolves · 10/02/2023 07:48

@LolaSmiles

Ah ok do tutors as a professional body are unregulated then which definitely doesn’t help.

I just think forcing the OP into an extreme position of either report - when everyone is saying what she’s observing would not meet SS’s criteria & she’d probably lose her job as a result or put up & shut up is unhelpful, as clearly in this case it’s much more of a grey area.

It’s entirely reasonable for OP to find out more information about the family - in a natural way as part of her job of getting to know the family as being located in the family home & left with daughter for periods of time.

So as to help we put into a more informed context what she’s seeing.

As PP have said if the daughter has agoraphobia or is ND or got PTSD or anything else it may give the OP more understanding for what she’s seeing & therefore contextualise what to an outsider may seem very odd.

Nothing wrong with being a compassionate & concerned well meaning human versus a judgey, interfering person with a resentment towards people with more money than them.

Maybe daughter doesn’t watch tv alone because she has PTSD & triggers can happen & cause Panic Attacks? Maybe she has epilepsy & gets triggered.

The OP doesn’t know. She can gain a clearer understanding for herself however & then consider what options she has. Without trying to be a social worker.

And if OP is concerned is it not reasonable to ask a parent what she should do when daughter is ever under her sole care?

Are parents taking the piss & using OP as an unofficial childminder for periods of time? If so OP would have a right to know of any medical conditions & what daughter may need if has a panic, epilepsy, asthma episode for eg.

LolaSmiles · 10/02/2023 07:29

Companyofwolves

Anyone can set themselves up as a tutor. There's no requirements for anyone to do it. No need for qualifications, DBS checks, safeguarding. It's a totally unregulated industry so we can't rule the OP out from being the tutor.

Even if she isn't the tutor, it isn't the OP's job to investigate or dig around finding out and probing the child for information. That's a safeguarding no no.

If she has safeguarding concerns then they need to be reported. Safeguarding is everyone's responsibility.

If she isn't going to report them then either she doesn't have safeguarding concerns and is being nosy/judgey, or she's willing to ignore safeguarding concerns (in which case she's doing the very thing she claims society does, which is ignore safeguarding concerns if a family has money).

Companyofwolves · 10/02/2023 06:38

Disagree that OP wanted to have a judgey moan about her employer.

She’s clearly not a professional tutor, childminder or other otherwise she would know how to handle safeguarding concerns. And would be protected herself by her professional remit.

It’s possible she does domestic work for them?

And the parent goes out when she’s there leaving the daughter there.

She’s seeing that things seem off with this young person and her situation. She’s not a MH expert so she’s not an expert in anxiety, depression or ND issues.

However when she’s used the term neglect, when it does seem there are things lacking in this child’s setup - she’s been silenced into submission by people’s put downs of what is termed neglect by SServices & so she’s understandably trying to say ok I don’t know if it warrants child cruelty but something’s not right.

And she’s made the rightful observation that sometimes people with power because of wealth & status can evade scrutiny purely because of the biases & stereotyping that go on towards people of different socioeconomic backgrounds.

She is probably terrified of reporting her concerns for fear of reprisal & losing probably what is a necessary income for her that she maybe cannot afford to lose, especially at present.

So she’s caught in a catch 22. Neglect is not only defined by the social services definition of the word.

I think she’s in a difficult position. I suggest she try to build more of a relationship with the daughter & find out more about her difficulties, anxiety, panic attacks & what help she’s getting for them. Casually, naturally. Normalising & empathising with her situation. It’s not difficult to ask daughter in conversation oh are you getting help with them? My niece/friend gets them (panic attacks for eg) & they’re horrible aren’t they type thing.
Find out how they stop her from being able to do things. Does she want to do them/see friends but can’t? Find out if the tutor has any thoughts - neutrally - if OP ever sees them alone.

I don’t think it would be unreasonable to equally say to parent (If it is MH/anxiety/panic attacks related) how you know someone with them & it’s really hard for them. Sympathise & say they’ve been really helped by a therapist coming to the home (If daughter has said she gets no formal MH help) as CAMHS can’t offer them any more help & how bad it is when daughter at such critical point in her life with education /social life etc & can’t see any of her friends etc.

Worth a try - but maybe OP has very little chat with her employer & so there’s never any conversation in which case it would be difficult. Usually you get to know a family if you’re working in their home but the relationships & dynamics are difficult & clearly it’s not her role to be a social worker!

Anyway I think it’s tricky for you OP but maybe this could help you understand more about the situation & help what you do next.

If other thing come to light I think you have a safeguarding duty to anonymously report.

ChesterCheetah · 09/02/2023 14:17

AllOfThemWitches · 08/02/2023 20:54

I've got a big posh house and a similar aged daughter who barely makes it to school at the moment because it makes her self harm.

I don't have a big posh house but I went through that with my daughter. It was so shit but her mental health has improved massively since she left school. She really hated it. It's bloody awful though, isn't it?

It's horrific. FlowersFlowers

LolaSmiles · 09/02/2023 12:27

People do not care about child neglect when the children have wealthy parents. They just don't. Always all the excuses.

Not true. Even when teaching in a nice, relatively wealthy area, the main point repeated in safeguarding training is that safeguarding concerns can happen anywhere.

The problem is that the OP has started off by claiming neglect, then backtracked saying she doesn't mean neglect, then when people have said she should report any safeguarding concerns she's said that she wouldn't report her concerns.

There's two options here:

Option 1: OP has safeguarding concerns, in which case she should know to report them without starting a thread on Mumsnet. Anyone working with children should know this and if the OP doesn't then she is frankly a liability and should not be working with vulnerable children.

Option 2: OP doesn't have safeguarding concerns, which is why she won't report it. She just wanted to have a bit of a judgey moan about a family in a difficult situation that aren't doing things how she thinks they should.

ExistenceOptional · 09/02/2023 12:22

@sweeneytoddsrazor The tutor is being paid to do certain work. You can't just decide to do cooking instead as a tutor. Can you imagine the response if a parent posted here saying a tutor had been hired to teach maths and english and was instead doing baking and craft activities with the child?

sweeneytoddsrazor · 09/02/2023 12:04

If you happen to be the tutor you can do baking and craft with her. Cooking and art is still both done at school I believe.

CrazyCorgi · 09/02/2023 11:22

You probably don’t know the whole story. DS’s friend had severe agoraphobia and never left the house. DS and his mates only knew him because his brother went to their school and said that he liked playing x-box so this boy joined in. If you didn’t know the full story you might assume he was being kept in by his parents but the truth was he just refused to leave the house as he was terrified.

XelaM · 09/02/2023 11:13

ExistenceOptional · 09/02/2023 10:04

People do not care about child neglect when the children have wealthy parents. They just don't. Always all the excuses.

Seems like it. Plenty of wealthy families neglect/abuse their kids.

The Menedez brothers case is just one (high profile) case that comes to mind.

ExistenceOptional · 09/02/2023 10:04

People do not care about child neglect when the children have wealthy parents. They just don't. Always all the excuses.

XelaM · 09/02/2023 07:42

I'm shocked at all the horrible responses OP is getting. When there is a child neglect case on the news there are always people who were around that child who could have raised the alarm but didn't. But when someone raises concerns they are told to "keep their beak out of it". I think the situation OP is describing is odd and sad for the child.

Companyofwolves · 09/02/2023 07:42

In what capacity do you work with her & for her to be in your care OP?

It sounds like not a professional one otherwise you would have policies/safeguarding guidelines to follow.

It must be a difficult position to be in then hence your post.

Can you build more of a relationship with her & find out if it’s the anxiety stopping her getting out? If she starts to trust you could you suggest to a parent that she go with you to the local shop (if there is one) or the park or a walk for a short break from being at home & help her to get out?

Does she suffer panic attacks & what contact do you have with the tutor? They may be better placed to make any further recommendations to the parents - as in helping her social education /anxiety management.

Difficult.

liveforsummer · 09/02/2023 07:29

Thesesoundsfallintomymindwoowoo · 08/02/2023 20:43

@mrsbitaly It’s true and I’m really not judging, or trying not to, I just feel for her, it’s a shame she doesn’t do activities or have friends over/visits them. She doesn’t really seem to do anything

Again she likely does not want to do any of these things and found make her worse if parents attempted to push this on her

liveforsummer · 09/02/2023 07:27

Thesesoundsfallintomymindwoowoo · 08/02/2023 20:39

@mumyes This is it.

I’m sure if it was a lower class family and she hadn’t been in school for months and had no friends or activities/hobbies/classes outside the home and hadn’t ever done the more traditional things growing up at home-baking, crafts etc people may talk. Parents coming and going.
She just seems lonely I suppose and it’s sad to see someone like that at that age

All these things bar the baking and crafts could be/are likely to be a result of her severe anxiety. (and I don't bake with my dc either so can't get upset about that)

wherearetheturtles · 08/02/2023 23:05

Xol · 08/02/2023 20:54

Sadly, there are children all over the country who are too anxious to cope with school. Despite the fact that local authorities have a statutory right to provide full time education for them, you can bet the vast majority of those children will get minimal if any teaching unless their parents are resourceful and knowledgeable enough to enforce their rights.

That statutory duty applies to every child, including the children of wealthy parents. So if this child has not been educated, it's the LA which should be accused of neglect, not her parents.

I echo this 100%

My child has been out of school for a similar length of time due to anxiety and SEN. He also can't access any extra curricular clubs etc for same reason.

We have communicated with school, LA, tried all avenues but still too mentally unwell to attend.

Been seeing CAMHS for many months and no further forward.

If I had a friend that I had trusted to divulge this info to and then they started insinuating that I was neglectful, I would absolutely rip them to shreds.

AaaaaandBreathe · 08/02/2023 23:01

CowSnail · 08/02/2023 21:53

Yes. Anyone with any common sense would say to stop wasting social services’ time with ridiculous and spurious accusations even if the parents were on benefits. OP has admitted that she doesn’t even have a damn clue what’s going on.

Having high levels of anxiety is not a sign that the parents are doing something wrong. OP has no idea what support the parents are getting for her or have tried desperately to get for her. They’ve bloody hired OP so clearly they’re trying to do something.

The parents going away for work isn’t a sign of neglect either. Do you think children of military families should all be reported to social services? What about single parent families?

Feel free to tell all the parents on here who have said their child has debilitating anxiety that the reason is because they, as parents, have failed to meet their needs though. That doesn’t make you sound ignorant at all.

I have a child with high anxiety. My point was what I assume the OP was making, if they were deemed a 'lower' class, SS would already be involved. You are speaking rationally but people judge depending on where you are on the class scale, there wouldn't be the same rationale given. But either way, if you are concerned about a child I wouldn't ignore your gut feeling. Chance that you are wrong but better than being right and not doing anything.

MissMaple82 · 08/02/2023 22:36

Thesesoundsfallintomymindwoowoo · 08/02/2023 21:08

@beautifulpaintings I'm not obsessing, I know her well as she’s under my care a lot of the time. I’m at their house almost daily

So there is help in place? Make your mind up

MissMaple82 · 08/02/2023 22:33

The school will have also already highlighted any concerns or interventions needed, it's not your place to be concerned by what you THINK you know about this child

watchfulwishes · 08/02/2023 22:25

This does not constitute neglect imo.

The child is fed/clothed/provided for and parents are in attendance. The child is now getting teaching and presumably medical support if/as needed.

Is it an ideal childhood? No, clearly not due to mental health issues meaning they are not in school. But that doesn't make it neglect of the type that warrants state intervention.

MissMaple82 · 08/02/2023 22:24

Nosy. It wouldn't be classed as neglect, questionable parenting in some areas maybe. Mind your own though

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 08/02/2023 22:22

A lower income family would not be judged as being neglectful however they may have support from the local authority but I highly doubt they’d be suspected on anything close to neglect.

watchfulwishes · 08/02/2023 22:21

Thesesoundsfallintomymindwoowoo · 08/02/2023 20:41

I’m not judging at all or saying neglect really, I just know that they would be judged if it was a lower income family.
I just feel for her, but yes, it isn’t for me to do anything about

You are judging and you asked if would be classed as neglect if they were less wealthy.

SplunkPostGres · 08/02/2023 22:18

Another one who wants to point out that this is the reality for loads of children with SEN. I’ve been begging the LA, Director for Education, SS etc for a school placement for DS. Zero concern or urgency. DS has also been out of school since October, I definitely never bake, limit screen time and he’s isolated as I’m a lone parent trying to WFH. No one is going to be concerned by your scenario.