Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have said she didn't have to go...

166 replies

Shouldigo90 · 08/02/2023 20:08

So DD (8) was hysterical tonight saying she didn't want to go to football training. She has played for around a year and has been committed always wanted to go. We have recently had a couple of occasions where she hasn't wanted to go. I have tried to talk to her tonight and she has basically said she isn't are she wants to play anymore. Absolutely fine, it's always been her choice what clubs she does.
I said ti her she should give it a miss tonight as she was hysterical.
Husband wanted nothing to do with talking to her and seeing how she was feeling. He said oh I will be waiting in the car when she has her clothes on. He must have waited 10 mins and she didn't come out so he drove to the shop. He came home half an hour later and he hasn't spoken to DD at all. She has told me at bedtime 'oh daddy is ignoring me'.
He has made no effort to see if she is OK, bear in mind he walked put while she was hysterical.
Was I unreasonable to say to her she didn't have to go today and she should take a few days to think about if she is still enjoying it.
BTW I have always said she needs to be committed if she is in a team and that it is unfair to others if she simply doesn't turn up.

OP posts:
Ladybug14 · 11/02/2023 07:39

This is so hard to read as I had a parent who used to withdraw their love and ignore me, as punishment

Sending you love, OP. I know you'll do the right thing for your children Flowers

IAmWomanHearMeRoar1 · 11/02/2023 07:35

ElizaGumpyLeg · 11/02/2023 07:33

@IAmWomanHearMeRoar1

Plenty of adults do things when they don’t fully feel like them. If you’ve committed to a team sport most adults will actually try to show up for that rather than just flake off if they don’t feel like it - otherwise they shouldn’t be doing it.

Of course adults whose childhood tantrums are catered to and are allowed to skip out on things they’ve made commitments to may continue that pattern into adulthood

Absolute bullshit. Not one of us adults would continue playing a sport or doing a hobby if we no longer enjoy it. And forcing a child to do what we wouldn't do is classified as abuse, and anyone who encourages that has no business being anywhere near a child.

ElizaGumpyLeg · 11/02/2023 07:33

IAmWomanHearMeRoar1 · 11/02/2023 07:00

@ElizaGumpyLeg What you're telling us is you don't understand safeguarding and abuse. This wasn't just a 'tantrum', this girl is clearly very stressed and traumatised. I sincerely hope you don't have children because not only are you teaching a child they have no agency they will be forced to do something (which lets be honest, no adult does something they don't want to do, so why force an innocent child?) they don't want just so you can teach her a 'lesson' and live vicariously through her, and that you can't tell the difference between a 'tantrum' and a child that is VERY CLEARLY in deep distress/abused.

@IAmWomanHearMeRoar1

Plenty of adults do things when they don’t fully feel like them. If you’ve committed to a team sport most adults will actually try to show up for that rather than just flake off if they don’t feel like it - otherwise they shouldn’t be doing it.

Of course adults whose childhood tantrums are catered to and are allowed to skip out on things they’ve made commitments to may continue that pattern into adulthood

IAmWomanHearMeRoar1 · 11/02/2023 07:33

Yes, I'd definitely go to your mums. Even if your husband isn't abusing physically, he is certainly abusing her emotionally and psychologically. He is cruel, cold and selfish and harming your daughter. He is a harmful influence on her. I feel frightened for you and your daughter. I hope you get away from him asap and ask for only supervised visitation at this stage.

Gwdihooooo · 11/02/2023 07:13

Shouldigo90 · 09/02/2023 18:01

How do I plan to leave - do I just tell him I want a divorce? What happens about the kids do we just agree custody?
I can go to my Mums she has enough room for us.
Would custody agreements just start from when I left?
I honestly don't know how it works, but I know I want out of this.

I’d move to your mums asap. Then sort out the rest later

IAmWomanHearMeRoar1 · 11/02/2023 07:07

Tbh if my daughter made a commitment to do something

She is fucking 8 years old!! She's a CHILD. What is with these adults on here expecting a solemn commitment to kicking a ball around an oval, from an 8 year old little kid?! What the fuck is wrong with you people? Ease up! It shouldn't be that serious! And your OBSESSION with teaching 'commitment' will end up crushing your child's spirit.

then hysterically decided not to

If they hysterically decided not to, that is a CLUE that something very serious is going on! DUH!!

The amount of abusive and punitive parents on this thread that will be shocked, shocked I tell you, at their kids feeling they cannot confide abuse to their parents and won't be believed, is astounding. No child hysterically acts like that unless something VERY SERIOUS is happening!

LISTEN TO THAT INNOCENT CHILD CRYING OUT FOR HELP!!!! Don't put your need as a selfish parent to look good and live through your child, before your own child's NEEDS and wants. Put them first, your selfish need for parental validation last!

And even if it wasn't serious, a child should be taught body autonomy, basic freedom, and the ABILITY TO CHANGE THEIR MIND.

watchfulwishes · 11/02/2023 07:00

anya21 · 10/02/2023 10:29

lots of kids can turn on tears ,hysteria and even vomiting at will, to get their way.Not always the case of course but it is incredibly naive of you not to know this,

Goodness, this is just so wrong.

This attitude belongs in the 70s/80s when kids were not listened to.

IAmWomanHearMeRoar1 · 11/02/2023 07:00

ElizaGumpyLeg · 11/02/2023 06:36

@Shouldigo90

Idk, you’re getting support on here but why did she actually want to miss training? And why was she “hysterical” about it?

Tbh if my daughter made a commitment to do something then hysterically decided not to aid probably not be so accepting as though that was normal. All your teaching her is that it’s alright to throw a tantrum like a little miss and cancel on other people.

Unless there was a specific reason (bullying or something) I’d have made her go up till the point she had committed to or until I talked to her coach or whoever and explained.

@ElizaGumpyLeg What you're telling us is you don't understand safeguarding and abuse. This wasn't just a 'tantrum', this girl is clearly very stressed and traumatised. I sincerely hope you don't have children because not only are you teaching a child they have no agency they will be forced to do something (which lets be honest, no adult does something they don't want to do, so why force an innocent child?) they don't want just so you can teach her a 'lesson' and live vicariously through her, and that you can't tell the difference between a 'tantrum' and a child that is VERY CLEARLY in deep distress/abused.

windyarse · 11/02/2023 06:48

All your teaching her is that it’s alright to throw a tantrum like a little miss and cancel on other people.

No, what she taught her DD is that she is listened to. There is no value in forcing children to take part in activities they don't want to do. There is massive value in teaching them that you will listen, support and advocate for them.

ElizaGumpyLeg · 11/02/2023 06:36

Shouldigo90 · 09/02/2023 17:29

I am done! He didn't speak to her on school run this morning and only said bye to her outside her classroom.
I have told him how out of order it is to give your child the silent treatment for 24 hours. His response was 'oh you need to stop trying to make me look bad'
He said she would never have got away with missing training when we were due to leave that hour if it was up to him.
She is very upset that Dad hasn't spoken to her and has said she would rather carry on playing football and have her dad speak to her again!

@Shouldigo90

Idk, you’re getting support on here but why did she actually want to miss training? And why was she “hysterical” about it?

Tbh if my daughter made a commitment to do something then hysterically decided not to aid probably not be so accepting as though that was normal. All your teaching her is that it’s alright to throw a tantrum like a little miss and cancel on other people.

Unless there was a specific reason (bullying or something) I’d have made her go up till the point she had committed to or until I talked to her coach or whoever and explained.

IAmWomanHearMeRoar1 · 11/02/2023 05:28

anya21 · 10/02/2023 10:29

lots of kids can turn on tears ,hysteria and even vomiting at will, to get their way.Not always the case of course but it is incredibly naive of you not to know this,

Not like this, over something they loved doing! You've never been around children, clearly, have no idea of abuse, trauma etc.

IAmWomanHearMeRoar1 · 11/02/2023 05:23

4thonthe4th · 10/02/2023 03:42

Your DH is a twat but why on earth was your 8yo hysterical about not going to football? Seems very dramatic.

@4thonthe4th Please tell us you're not a parent. You clearly can't see this child is hysterical BECAUSE something is going on at these 'practices' and at 8 she doesn't have the tools to express what. Duh.

IAmWomanHearMeRoar1 · 11/02/2023 05:17

@anya21 I sincerely hope you're not a parent if you thinking punishing a child for being traumatised/abused is good parenting. This girl is clearly crying out for help, something is happening to her at these practices, and she can't say what. She is only 8 and doesn't have the tools to. But, she is hysterical and clearly deeply scared and traumatised. You don't turn your back on a child that is scared and traumatised. She didn't just suddenly get bored with it, she is truly terrified of going. SOMETHING is going on and no decent parent would subject their child to ongoing abuse.

And NO! Children need to learn that they have body autonomy and their needs and wants are important, they should not be forced to continue with an activity, physical or otherwise, to suit the needs of selfish parents who choose to force their will and their personality on their child and crush them. Parents who FORCE their child to go to something they truly don't want to do are truly evil, selfish, cruel and unfit parents.

Forgooodnesssakenow · 11/02/2023 03:17

agentleandeffectivecleaneverytime · 10/02/2023 19:06

Yes, I can see this too. I couldn't personally have left my DC alone with my ex husband even for five minutes (that was part of the problem), but when you are in that situation, there is unfortunately no right answer. I'd have said there was, until I was in that situation.

I was the child in that situation, having the parent you trust not protect you and never leave and all the justification you hear for why they never left. It stays with you and you're never 'safe'

That said as an adult I understand my mum's decisions, I'd still not make the same decisions she did BUT I have more autonomy, more choices and significantly fewer children not to mention living in a different culture altogether to 80s Ireland.

MrsTerryPratchett · 10/02/2023 20:38

LetsdothisL6 · 10/02/2023 20:28

I rang a solicitor today and have an appointment on Monday. I'm really worried about it all!
I don't even know at what point I would tell him. Feeling very anxious about it all!

You don't have to decide now. Talking to a solicitor is just information. One thing at a time.

LetsdothisL6 · 10/02/2023 20:28

I rang a solicitor today and have an appointment on Monday. I'm really worried about it all!
I don't even know at what point I would tell him. Feeling very anxious about it all!

agentleandeffectivecleaneverytime · 10/02/2023 19:10

I do think it's good, though, that there is much more understanding of what constitutes abuse now, though. I did go down the legal route before I left (my children are now adults) to see whether I could prevent my ex husband from having unsupervised contact, and the verdict was that his behaviour was bad, but not quite bad enough. Now, though, I think it would be seen as "bad enough".

agentleandeffectivecleaneverytime · 10/02/2023 19:06

Forgooodnesssakenow · 10/02/2023 15:52

If they're there 100% of the time and the other parent complicit you are 100% never safe (never feel safe)

50% of the time there alone BUT 50% of the time you are safe, your other parent is not complicit, you have 1 safe parent versus no safe parent.

Yes, I can see this too. I couldn't personally have left my DC alone with my ex husband even for five minutes (that was part of the problem), but when you are in that situation, there is unfortunately no right answer. I'd have said there was, until I was in that situation.

windyarse · 10/02/2023 16:38

Posted too soon,

It's clear to most reasonable people that when a child is unhappy/acting up the to is an explanation. It doesn't take a genius to match abusive husband to frightened child, does it?

windyarse · 10/02/2023 16:37

IWineAndDontDine · 10/02/2023 16:31

Your child is acting like a child, obviously. But your husband is also acting like a child....

No he isn't. Children are not abusive cunts, and that is what he is.

IWineAndDontDine · 10/02/2023 16:31

Your child is acting like a child, obviously. But your husband is also acting like a child....

Caplin · 10/02/2023 16:25

This all sounds awful. I know someone who left in a similar situation.

First, take some advice, ideally get a lawyer and check your options. Don't leave the house, ask him to leave. You can either try to get an agreement between you on custody, but if he is an arse you will need to get something agreed by the court.

You can speak to a domestic abuse charity as this is abusive behaviour, an he is inflicting it on your daughter.

You probably won't be able to block him from seeing her, but you can try your best to minimise it. Then track every awful thing he does and report it.

Sadly, my friend still has to hand her kids to her husband within the custody agreement. But they are fast coming up to the age where they can make their own decisions and at least one wants to cut contact. It still needs to go to court, but he can state his wishes.

neslop · 10/02/2023 16:17

DaveyJonesLocker · 10/02/2023 16:07

You get out first. Then deal with the rest. You don't need a full plan. You just need the first step.

If you agree to 50% contact this will undermine your assertion that DH is emotionally abusive. Why would you agree to an abuser spending any unsupervised time with your child? I wouldn't be agreeing to any contact, deal with it through solicitors, it may be that limited supervised contact is more appropriate. And as others have said, try to support your claim, eg by going to GP and reporting the stress/anxiety his behaviour is causing to both you and DD, and by speaking to a domestic violence charity for advice, before you leave. As well as taking legal advice before leaving - you may be able to get a court order to get him to leave instead, if there is abuse. Or you leave temporarily and then get a court order getting him out and allowing you and DD back into family home.
Wish you the best of luck.

GoldenFarfalle · 10/02/2023 16:15

samqueens · 08/02/2023 20:55

Does your DH always take her to football? Have there been any incidents recently when they’ve been at club or to/from that either have mentioned?

If it’s a sudden change of heart about club then I would wonder that. And she seems to have been quite focused on his reaction, more than I’d imagine she would have been if in midst of meltdown. Is this common for him? Has she noted it before?

Maybe he unwittingly embarrassed her at a session? Or told her off about something? From a first read it seems as if the meltdown and her dad’s reaction are somehow linked to her. But I could be way off. Just a thought

my thoughts exactly.

1FootInTheRave · 10/02/2023 16:13

My god, your husband is so cruel.

Please put your daughter first.