Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Teacher dialect

237 replies

MaverickGooseGoose · 08/02/2023 18:22

No doubt I'll make a mistake on this, Sod's Law and all that...

All the SLT and from what I've heard a lot of the teachers speak is sard east London dialect.

Free / three / roof / ruth / we was etc.

It's grating on me, if Roof was on the roof and needed free pounds to get off but her mum was coming to get her where was she going?

I understand dialect / colloquialisms but some of what they say/write doesn't make sense.

Anyone else as irritated as me? It's the same
on the radio now, the guy on capital is giving away free fousand pounds for free. Argh.

OP posts:
Glitterblue · 09/02/2023 08:26

The teaching assistants at DD's primary school all said "I seen" and "I done" and "what was you doing?" Thankfully DD already knew not to say any of those but the vast majority of the kids did, and still do in year 8. DD said her English teacher is still trying to drum into them that it's not "I seen/I done"!

HufflepuffRavenclaw · 09/02/2023 08:26

BadNomad · 09/02/2023 08:12

children's books which rhyme "scarf" with "giraffe"

Whaaaat? How?? Scaraff? Jarf?

Southern English people say

scaaaaaaaaf and giraaaaaaafe.

I know. Weird, right? Like those endless threads where they think farm and palm sound the same too. And let;s not get started on them whacking a "r" sound where there's not one, like rhyming Hannah and spanner.

Woahtherehoney · 09/02/2023 08:20

Ooooh so much of all your privilege of growing up somewhere that doesn’t have a ‘common’ accent is showing.

BadNomad · 09/02/2023 08:19

HedgeWitchy · 09/02/2023 08:16

Sc-arf
gi-rarf

Oh that extra "r" thing. I never understand that. (Never understarnd thart?)

Spendonsend · 09/02/2023 08:17

Girlswithgoodbodieslikeboyswithferarris · 09/02/2023 08:11

That would be wrong where I am. Aunt rhymes with can’t.

The way you are pronouncing it isn’t phonetic either - it would be pronounced like “au” in “fault” - so more like ont.

Its not just me, its millions of southerners. Im not saying its better. You asked how else could it be pronounced and thats the way many pronounce it so thats how else it is pronounced. No one says it with the 'au' sound like in taunt anywhere ive been. If i was doing a spelling test I would put words in a sentence if they sounded the identical otherwise its entirely reasonable to spell the wrong one. Like tail or tale.

HedgeWitchy · 09/02/2023 08:16

BadNomad · 09/02/2023 08:12

children's books which rhyme "scarf" with "giraffe"

Whaaaat? How?? Scaraff? Jarf?

Sc-arf
gi-rarf

HedgeWitchy · 09/02/2023 08:15

It’s interesting, as someone not form the UK originally, how some accents here are seen as ‘common’ or lesser. Cockney/ Essex are the worst. If your accent is ‘posh’ it seems it doesn’t matter how interchangeable the vowels are in your accent, but if you use the glottal stop you must be stupid and held up for ridicule!

I know when teaching I was far to hard on my attempts at ‘h’ at the beginning of words, and I had a habit of ‘z’ instead of ‘th’ if I was lazy. I also forgot to use the definite article at times. I never had a complaint though, unlike the cockney sounding staff.

Girlswithgoodbodieslikeboyswithferarris · 09/02/2023 08:14

And don’t get me started on the internal panic I have if I see the name Karl/Carl on a register!

BadNomad · 09/02/2023 08:12

children's books which rhyme "scarf" with "giraffe"

Whaaaat? How?? Scaraff? Jarf?

Girlswithgoodbodieslikeboyswithferarris · 09/02/2023 08:11

Spendonsend · 09/02/2023 07:55

Long a at the front. Like aaahnt.

That would be wrong where I am. Aunt rhymes with can’t.

The way you are pronouncing it isn’t phonetic either - it would be pronounced like “au” in “fault” - so more like ont.

EnidSpyton · 09/02/2023 08:06

Accent is not the same as dialect.

Free for three, roof for Ruth, etc is an accent. It’s very common in Estuary English, which is the accent of much of the South East of London and down into Kent and Essex. It is snobbery to take issue with the accent of a teacher.

Dialect is a different issue. ‘We was’ may be a common feature of a local dialect, but it is not our place as teachers to teach local dialect. Our job (former English teacher) is to teach formal standard English. So even if you naturally use a dialect form of English in your everyday speech, you should be making it clear to your students that the dialect you use doesn’t follow the forms of standard English grammar.

There doesn’t need to be a judgement attached - there’s nothing wrong with speaking using a regional dialect - but it’s important that students know and understand the difference between regional language constructions and standard formal ones.

I would say the grammatical error that I see most frequently employed by teachers is the use of the reflexive ‘myself’ when ‘me’ is meant. I have no idea why people do it except for perhaps thinking it makes them sound more formal. It doesn’t. It makes them sound like an idiot. ‘Myself and Mr Smith will be organising this trip’ or ‘Contact myself for any more information’. It’s a reflexive ffs. It can only be used when you’re describing something you have done/are doing to your own body. ‘I washed myself’, ‘I stopped myself before I said something I’d regret.’ Every time I see it used incorrectly it sets my teeth on edge!

user1494050295 · 09/02/2023 08:04

DrMarciaFieldstone · 08/02/2023 18:24

Yes, it’s grim.

Really grim

Spendonsend · 09/02/2023 07:55

Girlswithgoodbodieslikeboyswithferarris · 09/02/2023 07:17

… I pronounce aunt as ant, how else can you possibly pronounce it?

Long a at the front. Like aaahnt.

HufflepuffRavenclaw · 09/02/2023 07:50

I think people are confusing accent and dialect. Everyone has an accent. Even you people who live within the M25 and think you don't. Some accents pronounce things differently - think of the endless threads with Scottish people like me complaining about children's books which rhyme "scarf" with "giraffe". I would argue that although intensely irritating, "free" instead of three falls into that category.

However common the use of "we was in the park" is, it it grammatically incorrect and unacceptable. The Scottish equivalent is "I seen it" or "I done it" which is similarly wrong.

FancyFanny · 09/02/2023 07:44

RobertaFirmino · 09/02/2023 01:42

It's perfectly possible to have a strong regional accent and use English correctly. I know I do. Knowing that you say 'I was' and 'We were' is much more important than the way you pronounce words.

I would say 'We have seen' something like 'Wiv seen' but what I know not to say is 'We seen'.

When you are saying 'wiv seen' you are simply using a regional pronunciation of we've seen, which is not incorrect.

It's like saying 't' shop'- a contraction of 'to the shop' and a perfectly acceptable way to speak in Yorkshire so not incorrect.

BrightSaturn · 09/02/2023 07:37

Good to see another teacher bashing thread. It had been a few hours.

echt · 09/02/2023 07:34

I have a Northern accent and speak Standard English, though can speak and write the dialect of my home town.

I was often called in to do the dictation part of EFL exams at the college where I taught, so plainly my short "a" for bath and laugh caused no problems. What seemed to matter was my diction and projection. I did not teach on those courses. Now I think of it most of the EFL teachers had quasi-RP accents. One was Scottish. Not a problem .

As an aside, apparently Byron ripped the piss out of Keats for his common accent, saying grass with a long a: grarse, when any fule knos it rhymes with ass.

Just goes to show how accents change.

DilemmaDelilah · 09/02/2023 07:32

@Whyisitsososohard It's not about whether it is possible to understand, it is about teaching children what the correct words and grammar are. If you don't give them that basic understanding how are they ever going to know? How they (and their teachers) choose to speak outside the school is completely up to them, but within the educational environment the children should hear how things are meant to be said. And it is quite possible to say things correctly while still using a regional accent! (Possibly excluding the Irish dropping of the 'h' in th, which is basically the same as the dropping of the k in knock or knob)

Goingforasong · 09/02/2023 07:28

YANBU I think it is very important for teachers to speak correctly, especially in primary years when children are learning language.

I still believe that I failed to master spoken French because I had a Scottish French teacher who's accent was very confusing.

watchfulwishes · 09/02/2023 07:23

MeanderingGently · 09/02/2023 07:10

In my student days I remember going to a sit in on a class where the teacher had a very broad accent but didn't seem to realise the impact it had on the children in her class. They were doing a simple spelling test and one of the words was "aunt" which she read out for them to write down. She pronounced it as "ant", and sure enough, all the class spelled it as A-N-T, and afterwards she told them all off for getting it wrong.

It's not snobbish to say I was appalled.

I can't tell if this is real or satire! Very funny either way.

If it is real, this lack of awareness is mindboggling.

English has non-phonetic spellings all over the place. Including Aunt in huge swathes of the country.

JennyDarlingRIP · 09/02/2023 07:20

The th f thing is an issue because it does affect spelling/reading

JennyDarlingRIP · 09/02/2023 07:20

This happens at DS' nursery, we live in Essex. He comes out sounding like a TOWIE extra , all we can do is model and correct at home

WhatTrophy · 09/02/2023 07:17

MeanderingGently · 09/02/2023 07:10

In my student days I remember going to a sit in on a class where the teacher had a very broad accent but didn't seem to realise the impact it had on the children in her class. They were doing a simple spelling test and one of the words was "aunt" which she read out for them to write down. She pronounced it as "ant", and sure enough, all the class spelled it as A-N-T, and afterwards she told them all off for getting it wrong.

It's not snobbish to say I was appalled.

Rubbish. She'd have also pronounced grass "grass" instead of "grarse" so does that mean teachers with an RP accent can't teach spelling either?

My mum has a northern accent and used to read with my DC. If she told them a word was booooook, they were quite capable of knowing she meant book from about 2yo.

Girlswithgoodbodieslikeboyswithferarris · 09/02/2023 07:17

MeanderingGently · 09/02/2023 07:10

In my student days I remember going to a sit in on a class where the teacher had a very broad accent but didn't seem to realise the impact it had on the children in her class. They were doing a simple spelling test and one of the words was "aunt" which she read out for them to write down. She pronounced it as "ant", and sure enough, all the class spelled it as A-N-T, and afterwards she told them all off for getting it wrong.

It's not snobbish to say I was appalled.

… I pronounce aunt as ant, how else can you possibly pronounce it?

MeanderingGently · 09/02/2023 07:10

In my student days I remember going to a sit in on a class where the teacher had a very broad accent but didn't seem to realise the impact it had on the children in her class. They were doing a simple spelling test and one of the words was "aunt" which she read out for them to write down. She pronounced it as "ant", and sure enough, all the class spelled it as A-N-T, and afterwards she told them all off for getting it wrong.

It's not snobbish to say I was appalled.

Swipe left for the next trending thread