Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to be suspicious when dads of young children seem too "well"?

191 replies

UnderMilkyWood · 08/02/2023 16:36

Met up with an old (male) friend last night. He has 3 young kids now with his wife (whom I haven't met) - 4, 2 and 6 months. He just seemed... so well. Energetic, happy, and going from strength to strength at work (demanding job with lots of travelling). As well as being happy for him, I thought "hmm, I wonder how your wife is getting on".

OP posts:
UnderMilkyWood · 09/02/2023 09:25

(that was meant to be a shrug emoji!)

OP posts:
UnderMilkyWood · 09/02/2023 09:25

Yeah, maybe - hopefully - it's all fabulous. Would be great if so.
Hard to put my finger on, but it was just a niggling feeling I got from him ¯\(ツ)/¯

OP posts:
Devoutspoken · 09/02/2023 09:22

I would be wondering the same thing op

user1188 · 09/02/2023 09:17

UnderMilkyWood · 09/02/2023 08:56

Hello! Wow - thanks for all the responses to the thread, the nice/understanding ones and the ones from people who are livid with me for my evil assumptions😂

I want to reply to things, but can't do it all.

Glad to hear lots of people "get it" - thank you 😘

Some general replies:

To all the people who say they are/were bright-eyed and bushy-tailed with little kids, I say: you utter buggers. It's just rude to be that way😁. And yes, I was exhausted, emotional, on my knees and generally covered in puke, as were almost all the other parents I know (men and women), at that stage.

To the people saying I'm being a hypocrite for taking up an evening of his time: he lives in a different city now, and was visiting mine (where he used to live) for work, so we met up for dinner (with another friend, too).

To the people saying I'm being a mean friend: haha, maybe. OBVIOUSLY I'm very happy for my mate. I'm just also suspicious that someone else is doing his due suffering, and that either it's his wife or he has a Dorian Gray-like "parenting photo" in his attic, of him with bags under his eyes, sick on his shoulder, an expression of pleading/mild frustration and congealed rice cakes in all his pockets.

Urgh your update is even worse op. I can think of a fair few people I know that planned to have 3 kids close together. That's what they wanted and they've got on with it. Of course they have their bad times with the kids - who doesn't? I bet there isn't a parent on this planet that has gone every single day enjoying parenthood and all that comes with it. It's hard for everyone regardless but that doesn't mean everyone struggles in the way you imply.

You can struggle and still be blissfully happy and content with your life! You can be tired and look like you haven't slept in 6 months and still have a solid marriage and a supportive husband. It does actually happen to some people - unfortunately not often in the world of Mumsnet.

There are women out there that find motherhood just comes natural to them. There are women that don't and struggle.

While we feel for those women who find it hard, we really shouldn't take it away from those that don't.

Especially in your case when you haven't actually met this mother and your basing it all on the dad who seems in good spirits and is happy. To be honest, there's absolutely nothing to say dad isn't struggling either?

GoodChat · 09/02/2023 09:14

He was in your city for work so knew he'd have a good nights sleep ahead. I'd be super chilled too.

Dogcafedreamer · 09/02/2023 09:08

UnderMilkyWood · 09/02/2023 08:56

Hello! Wow - thanks for all the responses to the thread, the nice/understanding ones and the ones from people who are livid with me for my evil assumptions😂

I want to reply to things, but can't do it all.

Glad to hear lots of people "get it" - thank you 😘

Some general replies:

To all the people who say they are/were bright-eyed and bushy-tailed with little kids, I say: you utter buggers. It's just rude to be that way😁. And yes, I was exhausted, emotional, on my knees and generally covered in puke, as were almost all the other parents I know (men and women), at that stage.

To the people saying I'm being a hypocrite for taking up an evening of his time: he lives in a different city now, and was visiting mine (where he used to live) for work, so we met up for dinner (with another friend, too).

To the people saying I'm being a mean friend: haha, maybe. OBVIOUSLY I'm very happy for my mate. I'm just also suspicious that someone else is doing his due suffering, and that either it's his wife or he has a Dorian Gray-like "parenting photo" in his attic, of him with bags under his eyes, sick on his shoulder, an expression of pleading/mild frustration and congealed rice cakes in all his pockets.

Suffering?

Dogcafedreamer · 09/02/2023 09:08

EthicalNonMahogany · 08/02/2023 18:00

I think it's not just the wellness, I'd expect a parent of toddlers to have a fairly in depth interested conversation about the toddlers, how they were doing, the challenges of food and sleep, and along the way be saying what was tiring and what was fun. I get the impression that OP met him and he talked about work and life just like someone would who didn't have small children.

And before everyone piles on and says "oh not everyone wants to discuss boring baby stuff when they go out, you know!" - give over. If someone has 3 under 5 it is, or should be, their MAIN leisure time activity and you'd expect their head to be in the ups and downs.

Like as if someone said work was going well but didn't seem to look professional or be able to discuss anything going on at work...you'd wonder if it was going that well.

Please don't ever arrange a night out with me, I'd be bored to tears!

Itisbetter · 09/02/2023 09:04

I wasn’t “suffering” when my children were little.

Johnnysgirl · 09/02/2023 09:02

Oh, stop it, op. You must realise other people have totally different experiences to yours.

Eleganz · 09/02/2023 09:01

I think it is really rather pointless to speculate. It just sits in your mind and concretes itself into what you think is the truth. I'm sure your friend would be delighted to think that the take away from your time socialising together was that he was a lazy and useless father.

UnderMilkyWood · 09/02/2023 08:56

Hello! Wow - thanks for all the responses to the thread, the nice/understanding ones and the ones from people who are livid with me for my evil assumptions😂

I want to reply to things, but can't do it all.

Glad to hear lots of people "get it" - thank you 😘

Some general replies:

To all the people who say they are/were bright-eyed and bushy-tailed with little kids, I say: you utter buggers. It's just rude to be that way😁. And yes, I was exhausted, emotional, on my knees and generally covered in puke, as were almost all the other parents I know (men and women), at that stage.

To the people saying I'm being a hypocrite for taking up an evening of his time: he lives in a different city now, and was visiting mine (where he used to live) for work, so we met up for dinner (with another friend, too).

To the people saying I'm being a mean friend: haha, maybe. OBVIOUSLY I'm very happy for my mate. I'm just also suspicious that someone else is doing his due suffering, and that either it's his wife or he has a Dorian Gray-like "parenting photo" in his attic, of him with bags under his eyes, sick on his shoulder, an expression of pleading/mild frustration and congealed rice cakes in all his pockets.

OP posts:
Eyerollcentral · 08/02/2023 22:03

‘Men who work and travel a lot/spend a lot of time on hobbies, aren’t taking on their fair share/responsibility of child care.’ This is utter bullshit @SheldonsShoulder I know many men who do just that, including my own brother who is extremely successful, lives thousands of miles from any family support for either him or his wife and still manages to be a hands on father who shares the load with my sister in law. My sister in law has boundaries, she does her share, she doesn’t martyr herself and I SO admire her for it. There are things she doesn’t do, ‘mental load’ things that aren’t her responsibility, she doesn’t do. Often my brother does drop the ball on them - birthday cards two months late! What neither drops the ball on is their children and their work. There is a lot of martyrism wasted on unimportant things by a lot of women and a lot of sweeping statements on this thread about men that just does not ring true to my experience of modern men from all classes.

Daddydog · 08/02/2023 21:49

I bet OP would say that about me! I get asked all the time why I'm so cheerful and it's becuase of my 2 beautiful girls, 5 months and 3 years! I run a business and it's interesting sitting on zoom calls with the baby on my lap! Apart from the shopping and cooking which I do all of, we split the rest down the line. However, I'm under no illusions it will ever be 50/50. The mental and physical strain on Mums Vs Dads is grossly unbalanced. I could do everything and it still won't ever be even. Not in a million years.

For example, when I'm out alone with my girls, doing the most basic stuff like trying to turn the weekly shop into an adventure to avoid meltdowns, becuase of my gender (and partly my ethnicity), the world heralds me as some sort of superhero! "Oh what an amazing dad!" (I'm not!). Went on holiday recently and everyone at the resort kept coming up to me saying "how amazing you are with your kids"... And when my wife does the exact same stuff she's just 'a mum' - doing what mums 'should' be doing. I guess the bar is set pretty low for blokes and that's very sad.

SheldonsShoulder · 08/02/2023 21:10

This post reminds me of a guy I used to work with who had four children with his wife (who worked elsewhere in the same department).

We were talking about how tough it is raising kids while working, and him patronisingly saying women just like complaining and raising children is easy.

I remember wondering how involved he really was. Within two years his wife had dumped him because he was a total lazy bastard and left her to do everything. Men who work and travel a lot/spend a lot of time on hobbies, aren’t taking on their fair share/responsibility of child care.

PinkSyCo · 08/02/2023 21:06

I feel sorry for your enemies and/or people you don’t know very well if this is how you judge your friends OP. 🤦🏽‍♀️

Girlswithgoodbodieslikeboyswithferarris · 08/02/2023 21:05

Comedycook · 08/02/2023 20:43

So odd that you can't see beyond your own life.

I’m being deliberately awkward to prove a point. The point being that you also cannot help but have your own experiences cloud your judgement. If you read back, you will see my original point was that we can’t assume anything about the situation based on the limited information we have.

Tohaveandtohold · 08/02/2023 21:05

I think yabu op. Lots of people parent well and also look well. It may not be your experience but he does not have to be a deadbeat dad because he looks well and is progressing at work, that’s a very silly assumption.

Notsogreatexpectations · 08/02/2023 21:03

People put on a front to impress/ up-show

TrishM80 · 08/02/2023 21:00

Absolutely ridiculous thread. Is he supposed to look like he's been dragged through a hedge?!

Anyway, I see so many threads on mn complaining how men don't look after their health and appearance especially after marriage and kids, then when any of them do look good it's obviously because they're shit dads! 🙄

You couldn't fucking make it up, only on mumsnet! 😂

Johnnysgirl · 08/02/2023 20:55

PinkSyCo · 08/02/2023 20:53

Imagine a mother of 3 getting judged as being a shit mum just because they were smiley and bouncy on a night out. Confused

Precisely...

cheatingcrackers · 08/02/2023 20:53

minipie · 08/02/2023 19:47

If anyone has three children close together - especially at regulation 2 year age gaps - I tend to assume they have easy children who sleep well and are generally content. In all the families I know with 3 close together, this is the case. (Ok one had an awful sleeper first but only for 2 months then he was great. She still mentions her terrible experience 🙄).

So I wouldn’t feel too much sympathy or judgment unless she specifically mentions that she’s finding it tough. If she does then yes I would wonder why he isn’t finding it tough.

Oh gosh I don’t know about this! My two best Mum friends and I all had 3 with 2 year age gaps. We all had rubbish sleepers! I just didn’t really sleep for about 8 years.
Looking back at photos, I think I always looked happy and full of energy. Most of the time I was. Sometimes I really wasn’t!

PinkSyCo · 08/02/2023 20:53

Imagine a mother of 3 getting judged as being a shit mum just because they were smiley and bouncy on a night out. Confused

fitzwilliamdarcy · 08/02/2023 20:50

Eyerollcentral · 08/02/2023 20:09

Thing is I genuinely don’t know any good husbands who behave like you say. And all the ones who do f all were clearly going to do f all before the baby was born. I’ve occasionally been surprised when one steps up after their baby is born but I am yet to find someone does nothing who previously seemed to be a good bet tbh.

I agree but that’s MN heresy.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 08/02/2023 20:47

@TaraRhu Your husband got given a payrise by his employer just because he’d become a dad? Yikes.

Lcb123 · 08/02/2023 20:45

I know / work with plenty of mums like this. Not everyone finds it a struggle