Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to wonder about bystanders ( eg during assault on school girl in Ashford)

342 replies

whatchaos · 08/02/2023 13:24

to wonder about the ethics of being a bystander, and wonder what the bystanders were doing during the appalling assault in Ashford (Surrey) when a schoolgirl was beaten up, the awful video shows a grown woman encouraging primary aged kids to get involved...but there are any number of bystanders including a man in a car, the school principal (at the end) and any number of other school kids including much older looking boys. Wondering if anyone here would have tried to intervene to stop the fight or encouraged their children to intervene in cases like this?

www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/girl-10-among-five-arrested-29158603

OP posts:
Cocobutt · 09/02/2023 20:29

The worst person was the adult woman encouraging it.

Cocobutt · 09/02/2023 20:27

I would have got involved, even if it was just shouting at them and ringing the police.

I would have tried to protect the girl in whatever way I could and I would hope anyone with a young daughter would do the same, as that could have been your daughter being attacked so brutally.

Fights like this do sometimes happen in school or on the way home and it would be horrible to think that people allow it to happen because they’re scared of the repercussions - stopping a fight isn’t going to cause the traveller community to attack or kill you.

There was enough adults around to have stopped it much sooner.

NotTerfNorCis · 09/02/2023 20:23

The teachers aren't to blame at all. It's disgusting they're being criticised for this.

Glad to hear the attackers got arrested. That woman deserves jail time.

Naumann · 09/02/2023 20:22

no surprise bystanders weren’t getting involved given who the attackers were (a fact that doesn’t seem to be being properly reported in the media).

if I was a teacher id think very carefully about getting involved too. Unfortunately

Weallgottachangesometime · 09/02/2023 20:21

This is really good thanks. I like the tips like addressing other by standers directly. Seems to give a guide for intervening without running over and getting involved in the fight.

AutumnDaysConkers · 09/02/2023 20:16

MinceandMash · 09/02/2023 20:09

Travellers don’t live or operate by the same rules as the rest of us. They do not fear the law and to the police are shit scared of them. I’m not from the area where this incident took place but do live near a large traveller community and the stories I could tell about the things I’ve seen over the years would shock you. They are also very quick to cry racism despite being horrifically racist themselves (witnessed with my own eyes on numerous occasions).

Exactly. From young ages Travellers are taught to resolve their differences by fighting. That is their culture.

I am worried how this situation is going to play out. The black community are quite rightly disgusted at this racist attack and want justice. At the moment their anger is aimed at the teachers but this will eventually be aimed at the travelling community which could turn very nasty.

RumNotRun · 09/02/2023 20:11

I have got involved and broken up fights in my home town, usually in the centre on a night out, although once was on my way to work one morning when two homeless guys were beating up another one. Loads of people were watching, no one phoned the police or backed me up. I did think as I walked over yelling that someone would support me as often it takes one person to get other people to move.

I don't know if I'd get involved in this case though. Looking at what people have said about the area, I guess if you live there then you know the history and likelihood of repercussions etc. It's a sad thing that some people know they can get away with being violent thugs just cause everyone is scared of them and their gang - this goes for gangs of kids, as well as gangs of travellers or any other packs of feral twats.

AutumnDaysConkers · 09/02/2023 20:10

Greenshake · 09/02/2023 17:45

I would absolutely have stepped in to help that poor girl. I couldn’t live with the guilt of not doing so.

If you did you very well likely would be dead now. Travellers do not like people getting involved in their 'issues'. They would turn on you as well as your family.
The problem is the police find it very hard to press charges or get cases against them to court. There is a lot of witness intimidation.
Even arresting them police are hesitant. They can't just go to the campsites with 3 or 4 officers. My police friend has told me it's like a military operation as they know if they arrest one traveller on the site they will be attacked.

MinceandMash · 09/02/2023 20:09

Travellers don’t live or operate by the same rules as the rest of us. They do not fear the law and to the police are shit scared of them. I’m not from the area where this incident took place but do live near a large traveller community and the stories I could tell about the things I’ve seen over the years would shock you. They are also very quick to cry racism despite being horrifically racist themselves (witnessed with my own eyes on numerous occasions).

Chippy1234 · 09/02/2023 20:01

A certain community should not be allowed to behave however they like because everyone is scared of reprisals. Who the hell do they think they are?

It was a disgusting attack and that women egging the fight on should be hanging her head in shame but because they are allowed to get away with it or people are too frightened they will get more and more powerful..

Greenshake · 09/02/2023 19:53

@pissssedofff as I said, you make your decisions and I will make mine. It doesn’t make me foolish, it makes me think that I am doing the right thing. I am sure if it was your child getting their head kicked in you would be grateful if someone intervened. I doubt you would label them “foolish” then.

pissssedofff · 09/02/2023 19:47

Greenshake · 09/02/2023 18:32

In truth, I don’t know. Having said that, I have stepped in before in several situations like this, plus I used to work on rather doors so I am probably more confident than most.

Well, i'd suggest that unless you have relevant self defence skills, then you re being foolish.

You also have a responsibility to your partner/children/loved ones and if you re lying on the ground being stamped on, you re no good to anyone, least of all the original victim.

@WhatTrophy The point is, as i ve found out and Martin did too, get involved and the law will not be on your side, what was TM meant to do? ask them politely to stop robbing him?

Martin was driven to act the way he did because the Police could not or would not protect his property, he eventually got a manslaughter charge because it was recognised he was driven to what he did.

SomeCommonThing · 09/02/2023 19:47

I was born in a rough area and know many of the crime families thru infamy. I never got involved. And never would.
One of the young men, at the grand age of 23, was trying to steal a bike from someone and beat them in the town centre in front of everyone, a guy intervened and was stabbed.

Now I live in an area with a large Traveller population. My friend intervened after a group of them started on one guy, she ended up in a&e.

Take yourself some place safe, video if needs be, and call the police. Don't ever endanger yourself.

And fwiw, I have been there being assaulted in the street and no one intervened. Fact was had someone intervened, I'd have got it alot worse later on.

NoseyNellie · 09/02/2023 19:35

NoseyNellie · 09/02/2023 19:34

You train your ‘civil courage’ - I’ve put a link below to a training leaflet about this very thing. It is geared specifically towards hate attacks but can be used in many situations.

its really about practicing scenarios in your head - if you think about it, people who do jobs like air stewards, nurses, even police don’t naturally know what to do - yes, they may be more confidant personality-wise but they have been trained and repeatedly made to go through the motions. Not all situations are safe to intervene in, I agree, but knowing ahead of time what level of intervention you are willing to action is useful.

I currently have no dependents. I have intervened, I have been lucky not to have been hurt but I also know I would again - my choice, my risk assessment.

Whoops - link
s3.eu-central-1.amazonaws.com/unitedfia.org/wp-media-folder-united-for-intercultural-action/wp-content/uploads/2014/05/LeafletCourageA4.pdf

Iwantabloodypizza · 09/02/2023 19:35

RoseFl0wers · 09/02/2023 19:31

I’m pregnant and an older woman verbally abused me at a bus station the other day. She was angry that her bus was late (probably mentally ill). I’m very small and felt intimidated as she kept getting closer to me, pointing at me and shouting. She pushed me. The bus station was fairly busy and no one (staff or the public) stepped in to help me. I was really shaken and no one asked if I was ok.

I know what it’s like.

When I was 16, I was sitting at a bus stop and a man put his penis in my face for a few seconds and was laughing. He wasn’t discreet.

Bus stop was packed. People saw and afterwards buried their heads in newspapers or looked away.

Not one person stopped him, said anything or asked if I was okay afterwards.

NoseyNellie · 09/02/2023 19:34

Weallgottachangesometime · 09/02/2023 16:54

I think we need to understand that people have their own experiences, personalities, difficulties etc. Those by standers aren’t necessarily bad people. Though obviously it’s better if people feel able to intervene and help when others are at risk not everyone is able to. I’m absolutely useless in an emergency because I have a freeze response and genuinely don’t know what to do. I’d feel comfortable shouting or calling for help, I’m not sure where I’d start with a physical altercation, because I’ve never had one. I’ve literally never been hit or hit someone else.

I personally would like guidance on what to do if you come across someone being attacked by a group. Is there a way to approach it that makes it more likely to deescalate rather than escalate?

I obviously hope if I ever get attacked someone would help me. However im
not sure how we foster the skills that people need to feel able to intervene.

You train your ‘civil courage’ - I’ve put a link below to a training leaflet about this very thing. It is geared specifically towards hate attacks but can be used in many situations.

its really about practicing scenarios in your head - if you think about it, people who do jobs like air stewards, nurses, even police don’t naturally know what to do - yes, they may be more confidant personality-wise but they have been trained and repeatedly made to go through the motions. Not all situations are safe to intervene in, I agree, but knowing ahead of time what level of intervention you are willing to action is useful.

I currently have no dependents. I have intervened, I have been lucky not to have been hurt but I also know I would again - my choice, my risk assessment.

RoseFl0wers · 09/02/2023 19:31

I’m pregnant and an older woman verbally abused me at a bus station the other day. She was angry that her bus was late (probably mentally ill). I’m very small and felt intimidated as she kept getting closer to me, pointing at me and shouting. She pushed me. The bus station was fairly busy and no one (staff or the public) stepped in to help me. I was really shaken and no one asked if I was ok.

DashboardConfessional · 09/02/2023 19:20

My mind just goes to the man who was attacked with a Samurai sword in my hometown by 2 teenagers. His colleague tried to intervene and has lose the use of his hand. You never know what kids have got on them.

Iwantabloodypizza · 09/02/2023 19:18

Dh tried to stop a man beating up his girlfriend on the street once.

A week in hospital and rebuilt jaw for doing so.

LozzaChops101 · 09/02/2023 19:13

I’ve always been too scared to directly get involved in violent altercations, but I have made sure people know there’s a witness and that I’m calling the police. An ex partner of mine once intervened as we were walking home late at night in Manchester once - a HUGE steroidy looking man was being physically and verbally abusive to his partner in an alleyway. My ex (a really petite woman) was so brave, I think about it frequently now almost 10 years later and try to work out what I could do to be like her in that kind of situation. There’s always a balancing act with circumstances though.

ShakespearesBlister · 09/02/2023 19:04

I find it really questionable that a person would actually stand there filming this sort of stuff for entertainment. My partner was sent it on a Wattsapp group and wanted to show it to me. When I told him to fuck away from me with his depraved videos his sick mates at work send each other because they are all sick in the fucking head he seemed oddly offended. Pillock.

Greenshake · 09/02/2023 19:00

@RiktheButler I too know and work in that area with various different user groups. You wouldn’t have intervened, I would have done. There’s really no more to say on it. We all have different levels of what we deem acceptable personal risk and I would have assessed my decision as the right one. You may well disagree- and that’s fine too.

WhatTrophy · 09/02/2023 18:59

pissssedofff · 09/02/2023 16:48

Its got nothing to do with travellers, they are no more likely to attack you then any other gang.

People who fight in gangs in the street are scum and behave like it, look at Gary Newlove? kicked like a football according to the judge who sentenced the youths who turned on him after he asked them not to vandalise vehicles, they weren't travellers and there has been many more since.

Then you have that Norfolk farmer, Tony Martin, repeatedly burgled, in the end, used a gun because the Police wouldn't defend his property, he got a life sentence.

Tony Martin served 3 years, for shooting someone with an unlicensed firearm, having previously shot at someone for scrumping (which is why his licence was revoked), but let's not let the facts get in the way.

But that aside, the fear in this situation isn't "just" of being harmed during the attack it's of sustained reprisals afterwards too.

RiktheButler · 09/02/2023 18:57

Greenshake · 09/02/2023 18:51

@RiktheButler Yes of course I have. That doesn’t mean that we should all do nothing.

  1. Philip Lawrence was my teacher when I was 11/12
  2. I have stopped to intervene in fights before, including when the assailant was a bodybuilder
  3. I used to work in social housing covering this exact area. More red flags for properties in Stanwell/Ashford than the whole of the rest of my patch (37,000 properties)

No way I would have intervened. Not a fucking chance

Greenshake · 09/02/2023 18:57

And I am pleased to say I put myself in the first category.