Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to wonder about bystanders ( eg during assault on school girl in Ashford)

342 replies

whatchaos · 08/02/2023 13:24

to wonder about the ethics of being a bystander, and wonder what the bystanders were doing during the appalling assault in Ashford (Surrey) when a schoolgirl was beaten up, the awful video shows a grown woman encouraging primary aged kids to get involved...but there are any number of bystanders including a man in a car, the school principal (at the end) and any number of other school kids including much older looking boys. Wondering if anyone here would have tried to intervene to stop the fight or encouraged their children to intervene in cases like this?

www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/girl-10-among-five-arrested-29158603

OP posts:
MargaretThursday · 08/02/2023 17:06

In that case there's fear that they'll be next. I'd probably get away asap and call the police where I didn't think I would be heard.

However there's also the bystander effect where no one intervenes until one person does, then everyone else does.
I remember one time a tree had come down over a main exit road to our estate. I came up as lots of people stood around looking at the tree, when it had been down a short time. I knew one of the men did a lot of DIY so I asked him if he had a saw so we could try and cut some of the smaller branches off, in the hope that would make it easier to move.
As soon as he came out with it, several other bystanders went off and came back with tools themselves and within half an hour, the tree was cut up and off the road.
They'd all been at the tree looking at it without doing anything until one person started doing something, then they all joined in.

TiredBefuddledRose · 08/02/2023 17:06

I have intervened a couple of times in my area - which has zero traveller population - once a group of teenage boys were beating another so I went over, stopped it and accompanied the victim back to his school (this was about 8.30 in the morning).
The other time I was walking a friend's dog and upon entering the park saw a group of school age kids surrounding a smaller group of teenage girls who were beating on 1 smaller girl, went on over and it quickly became apparent that 2 Mums had organised it and became very aggressive towards me, if I hadn't have had a large rottweiler with me barking her head off (soft as a marshmallow but sounds like cujo when she's nervous) I probably would have got beaten up.
There were also a couple nearby who told me to 'leave it'.
It seems like the girl being beaten had been arguing with one of the other girls in school and the parents thought this was the most appropriate way to deal with it.

Knowing the particulars of this situation though I'd be calling the police from the sidelines.
It's very saddening to think that in reality there will be no real consequences for the adults or kids involved.
Really the kids of those parents should be removed and raised by someone who doesn't behave like feral scum but it won't happen.

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 08/02/2023 16:31

Knowing the area there's no way I would have intervened. Horrible place

NoBiscuitsLeftInMyTin · 08/02/2023 16:22

Apparently ‘racially aggrevated’

apple.news/AqGKwWPR5RhWi_vhZZJYnwA

caramac04 · 08/02/2023 15:56

LunaMay · 08/02/2023 15:26

Please be careful doing this. I'm not in the UK but only a few weeks ago in my town someone went out to intervene/break up a fight in front of his neighbours.
They left, he and another neighbour got the man help needed.
A few hours later they came back but this time to the neighbours house broke in and beat the shit out of him, all because he 'helped'. Not worth it if you have kids or others in the house

That is horrifying! Yes there is certain a risk and it’s greater now than it was. Too many adults not taking responsibility for their actions and not teaching their dc to be responsible. They’re not afraid of the police or the justice system.

MsMarch · 08/02/2023 15:47

Not worth it if you have kids or others in the house

I understand this mindset but instinctively I disagree. That's someone else's child being attacked. If adults routinely stepped in to help other children, your children would b benefit too.

LunaMay · 08/02/2023 15:26

caramac04 · 08/02/2023 14:17

I’ve intervened when 2 teenage lads were assaulting another one. The victim turned out to be vulnerable with SEN and that’s why he was picked on. It was just outside the school gates. The school took it seriously and the aggressors were punished. They also had had to listen to me bollocking them.
I also intervened one night when 8 males attacked a group of 2 males and a female. 1 male was on the floor and 2 were kicking him in the head. He lost a tooth but was mostly ok. The girl was punched really hard on the jaw, the sound was sickening.
By going out and shouting, threatening calling the police made them disperse. This was close to my house and a neighbour called the police.
I would intervene again but I recognise that could put me in danger and as I get older perhaps I won’t. I would call the police.
That poor girl to be battered like that, it will impact her education going forward and could take a long time to get over.
The adults encouraging it are despicable.

Please be careful doing this. I'm not in the UK but only a few weeks ago in my town someone went out to intervene/break up a fight in front of his neighbours.
They left, he and another neighbour got the man help needed.
A few hours later they came back but this time to the neighbours house broke in and beat the shit out of him, all because he 'helped'. Not worth it if you have kids or others in the house

Comefromaway · 08/02/2023 15:13

verdantverdure · 08/02/2023 14:52

Filming is evidence gathering so I don't judge people who only did that.

It goes without saying that I would hand over all footage to the police and it would NOT go on the internet.

Beezknees · 08/02/2023 15:01

Just read all the comments, I appreciate I don't know the area and families though so who knows.

FrostyFifi · 08/02/2023 14:56

Exactly what is wrong with people's attitudes in the UK today. How could anyone decent just stand back and do nothing

Stabbed. Arrested for allegedly assaulting a minor. Comeback from the families.

Beezknees · 08/02/2023 14:55

I would have intervened, and have done before when I witnessed a lone man being beaten by a group (football related violence).

I'd want someone to intervene if it was my child so I'd be a hypocrite if I wouldn't do the same.

verdantverdure · 08/02/2023 14:52

Filming is evidence gathering so I don't judge people who only did that.

Hobbesmanc · 08/02/2023 14:50

I waded into a group of lads who were pushing around a older man who obviously off his head on spice. This was Piccadilly Gardens in Manchester where sadly this isn't unusual.

The lads were drunk and laughing. I shouted and they started to give me verbals and threatened me. But to be fair another couple came over too and they backed off. Afterwards I thought i could have been hurt. But I'd do it again

Thekormachameleon · 08/02/2023 14:49

I was in this situation a few years ago. Driving along and saw a huge crowd. When I got closer I could see a group of teenage girls beating one girl - there were adults there too.

I did get out my car and break them up and the mother of one of the girls did try and attack me for doing so. Luckily I'm pretty handy with my fists and a gobby cow too so I told her if she wants to fight she should pick on someone her own size - ie me. Strangely enough she didn't want to do that. The police were called and I drove the girl who had been beaten up home and called her mum for her.
I also followed the other woman and her kid home so I had an address to give to the police. She was later charged

MsMarch · 08/02/2023 14:49

This is sad. My instinct is always to get involved but DH worries that one day something like what happened to this girl will happen, I'll get involved and get hurt.

But it's all the people who don't want to get involved that stood by and watched while a similar, albeit less serious, incident happened with DS. I will never look at the people who were there and did nothing in the same way ever again. This attitude of self preservation before anything else is, in my opinion, a reason why our society doesn't always function so well. The man who DID step in has my gratitude for life.

WinterAconite · 08/02/2023 14:46

Tootsey11 · 08/02/2023 13:29

Exactly what is wrong with people's attitudes in the UK today. How could anyone decent just stand back and do nothing.

I'm not convinced there is a specific UK problem of not getting involved. If you Google there are lots of examples of people in the UK getting involved and being injured or even killed themselves.

Weallgottachangesometime · 08/02/2023 14:45

*we not hurting anyone

Weallgottachangesometime · 08/02/2023 14:44

I hopeI would have intervened, but I have never been in the situation so can’t truly say how I would act.

I might not intervene if I was the only person with my two small children because I’d be worried about them getting hurt.

I suppose people were scared. Or maybe didn’t know what to do. Not everyone is good at sticking their neck out or dealing with a scary situation.

One thing I would say is that I think I would find it easier intervening in an adult being aggressive than a child. In fact I saw a group of 4 11/12 ish year old boys at the weekend being a nuisance. They were hurting anyone but I was watching ad they were approaching people and trying to intimidate. I realised that I felt like their age is really hard to deal with. Older and I’d be happy to try and intervene and possibly get physical, smaller and I would have felt able to manage them with child gloves. That middle age though I’d not be sure what to do….I wouldn’t want to hit them if it got aggressive but im sure no child friendly methods wouod have worked:

Irishfarmer · 08/02/2023 14:44

I've intervened with 2 approx 12 yr olds harassing another 12 yr old at the park and they looked me like 'old bag' but left him alone. He smiled and walked off.
I also intervened between a couple I met on a night out and found myself in A&E the man started hitting the woman and I said hey stop that so he punched me in the face!

In the 1st incidence I would do it again, not sure about the 2nd. Judging by the fact everyone is saying they are travellers not a hope, sorry, unless it was my own child or family member. I have seen how vicious they can get. Even with the Garda for breaking them up, a Garda friend has had all of the windows in his house smashed and the tyres on his car slashed. Where I grew up they mostly won't even intervene if travellers are fighting.

WinterAconite · 08/02/2023 14:43

If I saw an entire family attacking someone then no I wouldn't wade in and fight them off. For a start I'm at least 10 years older than the man who was arrested and the rest are even younger. I'm a widowed mum and have a responsibility to my kids to not put myself in dangerous situations. What I would do is call emergency services.

ClareBlue · 08/02/2023 14:42

We have fights between traveller families in our community. Often organised and filmed for social media and often between children, including young girls. You absolutely would not get involved. The repercussions would be far ranging and dangerous for you and your family. This is not an example of bystander apathy, it is an example of people knowing how their community works.

Merlo · 08/02/2023 14:38

That video honestly made my feel physically sick, it’s absolutely horrendous. I do agree though, whilst I like to think I’d always step in, I think the reality is very different.

lovesunshine247 · 08/02/2023 14:37

The poor girl. I could not have stood back and watched such an appalling assault and have intervened in a fight in the past.

Some teenagers don't fear anyone. I saw a video clip of two girls fighting on the school premises of a secondary school and a female teacher came to break it up. One of the girls looked directly at the teacher and punched her in the head.

I feel deeply worried about the future of this country, if our young people have such little respect for people around them

Tessasanderson · 08/02/2023 14:29

Yes, i have stepped in before.

I was walking my two dogs and came upon 3 girls shouting at one girl. A fight broke out between two of the girls and i stormed over and shouted at them to stop which they did. The 3 girls rode off on their bikes and the other girl went inside the house.......here is the amazing part.

The 3 girls turned around after 100yards and rode back. The other girl came back out of her house and the fight started again between the 2 girls. ONLY THIS TIME MOTHER AND FATHER CAME OUT AND ENCOURAGED IT.

I couldnt believe my eyes and i again shouted for them to stop. Father shouted back at me that these girls were bullying his daughter and if they were going to fight, he was going to make sure it was fair.

I again told them to stop and shouted at the mother & father that they were disgusting trying to parent in such a way (I have full sympathy for anyone being bullied but this isnt the way). At this point the husband gave me some swearing abuse until he realised my partner was on his way over to have a word with him in person. He dragged his daughter indoors and slammed the door.

I was stunned at the feral behaviour of all concerned.

Oblomov23 · 08/02/2023 14:29

You need to understand the context. Everyone seems very opinionated but unless you know the area, you can't understand. I know it. I wouldn't intervene, it's more than my life is worth.