Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to wonder about bystanders ( eg during assault on school girl in Ashford)

342 replies

whatchaos · 08/02/2023 13:24

to wonder about the ethics of being a bystander, and wonder what the bystanders were doing during the appalling assault in Ashford (Surrey) when a schoolgirl was beaten up, the awful video shows a grown woman encouraging primary aged kids to get involved...but there are any number of bystanders including a man in a car, the school principal (at the end) and any number of other school kids including much older looking boys. Wondering if anyone here would have tried to intervene to stop the fight or encouraged their children to intervene in cases like this?

www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/girl-10-among-five-arrested-29158603

OP posts:
SpinningFloppa · 09/02/2023 12:49

IhearyouClemFandango · 09/02/2023 12:45

This is a bloody awful excuse to be honest.

Don’t need an excuse I wouldn’t get involved for ANY reason other than call the police but I would like to know what started it

MangoBiscuit · 09/02/2023 12:49

OoooohMatron · 09/02/2023 12:46

Well then you're braver/more stupid than most.

Both, neither. Like I said in my previous post, it isn't a conscious decision, just instinct.

OoooohMatron · 09/02/2023 12:46

MangoBiscuit · 09/02/2023 12:42

OoooohMatron, not true. There were plenty of travellers where I grew up, some nicer than others. And I've been attacked by a group of them before. It still doesn't stop my reaction, I would see red and step in to it.

Well then you're braver/more stupid than most.

IhearyouClemFandango · 09/02/2023 12:45

SpinningFloppa · 09/02/2023 12:29

It’s not really about being a coward I don’t get involved directly in things that aren’t my business?? Not defending it but do we even know what it was over? Could be retaliation 🤷‍♀️ it obviously wasn’t a random attack and there would be a back story, not saying it was justified but obviously was an ongoing issue, maybe retaliation, revenge who knows?

This is a bloody awful excuse to be honest.

MangoBiscuit · 09/02/2023 12:42

OoooohMatron, not true. There were plenty of travellers where I grew up, some nicer than others. And I've been attacked by a group of them before. It still doesn't stop my reaction, I would see red and step in to it.

pissssedofff · 09/02/2023 12:40

Tootsey11 · 08/02/2023 13:29

Exactly what is wrong with people's attitudes in the UK today. How could anyone decent just stand back and do nothing.

Its not peoples attitudes, its that an adult physically "intervening" with a child, could well involve that adult ending up in court charged with assault... for me, that would mean i lose my job as i'd lose my SC clearance - then when the family of the child find out where you live, they come after you and the Police will do SFA.

This of course also applies getting involved with say a woman being attacked, unless you know what your doing and can physically stop the attacker & then get the hell out of there before the Police arrest you, better off walking on by, phoning 999, maybe filming the attack for evidence.

OoooohMatron · 09/02/2023 12:38

Everyone who is saying they would intervene clearly has no experience of travellers.

Zoutdroopje · 09/02/2023 12:35

This isn’t a ‘normal’ fight between kids though. It’s an organised assault on a young girl with multiple protagonists, organised by an adult.

Having been seriously assaulted as a child by a group of travellers, I wouldn’t intervene.

I have come across a group in the same area in my professional capacity and they can seemingly do what they want, involving serious criminality and fraud with everyone apparently fawning over and facilitating them.

Mabelface · 09/02/2023 12:34

Hobbesmanc · 08/02/2023 14:50

I waded into a group of lads who were pushing around a older man who obviously off his head on spice. This was Piccadilly Gardens in Manchester where sadly this isn't unusual.

The lads were drunk and laughing. I shouted and they started to give me verbals and threatened me. But to be fair another couple came over too and they backed off. Afterwards I thought i could have been hurt. But I'd do it again

You were brave! I'd not take on anyone hanging round there!

SpinningFloppa · 09/02/2023 12:33

wombat1a · 09/02/2023 12:30

I feel sorry for the police, niece is in the police but its things like this that are so depressing. Something like this happens and people won't get involved but will call the police for people like my lovely cousin to end up getting punched. Then we read things like people telling their daughters that if the police ever try to arrest them to put up the biggest fight they can because you never know it might save you from something.

Then I hear rubbish about people assaulting, punching kicking police resisting arrest and at sentencing they are sentenced far less than they would be than if they had attacked a people of the public because the for the police 'it's all part of the job'.

It's high time we changed the laws here so that attacking police gets serious jail time rather than its seen as just part of the job.

Really? I would have thought the police wouldn’t want anyone to get directly involved?

carmenitapink · 09/02/2023 12:31

I would shout that they should get off her and that I was calling the police and call them immediately, but no would not directly intervene if I'm being honest. What if the mum or the crazy daughters started attacking someone who tried to intervene?!

The fact the headteacher did not even shout telling them to get off her is mind blowing.

wombat1a · 09/02/2023 12:30

I feel sorry for the police, niece is in the police but its things like this that are so depressing. Something like this happens and people won't get involved but will call the police for people like my lovely cousin to end up getting punched. Then we read things like people telling their daughters that if the police ever try to arrest them to put up the biggest fight they can because you never know it might save you from something.

Then I hear rubbish about people assaulting, punching kicking police resisting arrest and at sentencing they are sentenced far less than they would be than if they had attacked a people of the public because the for the police 'it's all part of the job'.

It's high time we changed the laws here so that attacking police gets serious jail time rather than its seen as just part of the job.

SpinningFloppa · 09/02/2023 12:29

UdoU · 09/02/2023 12:17

I'm brown and I would have definitely intervened. And have done before.

So many cowards on this thread.

It’s not really about being a coward I don’t get involved directly in things that aren’t my business?? Not defending it but do we even know what it was over? Could be retaliation 🤷‍♀️ it obviously wasn’t a random attack and there would be a back story, not saying it was justified but obviously was an ongoing issue, maybe retaliation, revenge who knows?

RiktheButler · 09/02/2023 12:26

UdoU · 09/02/2023 12:17

I'm brown and I would have definitely intervened. And have done before.

So many cowards on this thread.

How much time have you spent in Stanwell? How well do you know the area?

MangoBiscuit · 09/02/2023 12:22

I will preface this by saying I'm ND, so I'm aware that my brain doesn't always function is a "normal" way, but I can't understand seeing awful things like that happening, and not trying to help. I was driving past on the other side of the road when I realised that 3 guys had jumped a teen on a bicycle, and were attacking him. I pulled over, and ran across. Two men, much bigger than me had also pulled over, and were watching, and doing nothing. My adrenaline kicked in, and I grabbed the nearest attacker. It wasn't a concious decision, I just can't stand by, it's like instinct takes over. I can't relate to an instinct that isn't to help. Not judging, I just relate to it at all.

Simonjt · 09/02/2023 12:21

catandcoffee · 08/02/2023 13:30

The fact adults were filming and giving instructions....no I certainly wouldn't intervene.
I would however, call the Police.

I intervened once, I ended up with broken bones, not only that but poor little rich white boy who fell over after hitting me and suffered a (minor and temporary) brain image had some lovely connections, so I ended up in court charged with ABH. The man who actually broke bones and beat three people up didn’t have a single charge brought against him, despite some very good and very clear cctv.

UdoU · 09/02/2023 12:17

I'm brown and I would have definitely intervened. And have done before.

So many cowards on this thread.

Plumbear2 · 09/02/2023 12:08

I'm not sure what you expected older boys to do. I've always told my boys to not physically get involved but ask for help, police etc. Why are you expecting children/teens to put themselves at risk?

EilonwyWithRedGoldHair · 09/02/2023 11:00

MsMarch · 08/02/2023 14:49

This is sad. My instinct is always to get involved but DH worries that one day something like what happened to this girl will happen, I'll get involved and get hurt.

But it's all the people who don't want to get involved that stood by and watched while a similar, albeit less serious, incident happened with DS. I will never look at the people who were there and did nothing in the same way ever again. This attitude of self preservation before anything else is, in my opinion, a reason why our society doesn't always function so well. The man who DID step in has my gratitude for life.

I wouldn't physically intervene, you can say it's self preservation, but it's also knowing my own physical limitations and I am never going to come off well in a fight - basically I'm not going to be stopping anything, but will get hurt. I'll go round the corner and call the police though.

Saying that, you never know. I'd never have said that my DM would intervene, but I remember as a child coming up the steps onto the platform to catch a train home, and there was a group of (probably) teenagers having a fight. My DM waded in, grabbed one of the lads by the hair and yanked him away. Everything calmed down then, and there were a lot of people around.

HedgeWitchy · 09/02/2023 10:22

When I was teaching I intervened between pupils younger than that. In the moment one just carried on and I, despite restraint training, ended up with a chipped tooth and bruised ribs. It shook me up a lot, I wouldn’t do it again. Especially not with multiple children and adults involved. I’d call the police and announce I’d done so, shout to stop… but from a safe distance

WinterAconite · 09/02/2023 09:56

Does anyone think that people seem to want to blame everyone except the family involved? I saw a TV news report where people were blaming the school. I'm sure they are doing their best and when people plan an attack they are hardly going to inform the school first. We don't know if the victims were too scared of reprisals to tell the school of any threats leading up to it. (Likely.) There's people saying that people passing are a disgrace not to wade in and fight off a family of travellers.
Is it because they know they won't get reprisals for criticising passers by and school staff but they will if they criticise the actual attackers on TV?

Oblomov23 · 08/02/2023 19:26

There's another thread about this. I sat for you to post, judging. But the place is well known for being problematic. And therefore people don't step in because they are too frightened of the repercussions, their children, parents, others targeted. So before you judge make sure you are aware of all the facts.

Florxa · 08/02/2023 19:21

I wouldn't get involved and would wait until I was a little bit away from the crowd so they couldn't hear to ring the police.
Couple of years ago I did get involved and I got threatened with a knife and punched, so not doing that again and will leave the policd to it

AutumnDaysConkers · 08/02/2023 18:58

Ponoka7 · 08/02/2023 17:45

The main girl doing the attacking is also being charged under the malicious communications act, so it hasn't just been an argument. It's being treated as a racially aggravated attack and the parents are being charged with child neglect on top of encouraging the attack.
I don't think that this is as simple as the bystander effect. It's because it's travellers and if you take one on, you take them all on. People's houses and cars would be at risk. It looks like someone did go and get the school staff members though.

This is good to hear. That poor girl.
I'm glad the police are actually taking some action. With travellers they usually take a step back as it costs too much/ need to many officers to make an arrest.

Ponoka7 · 08/02/2023 17:45

The main girl doing the attacking is also being charged under the malicious communications act, so it hasn't just been an argument. It's being treated as a racially aggravated attack and the parents are being charged with child neglect on top of encouraging the attack.
I don't think that this is as simple as the bystander effect. It's because it's travellers and if you take one on, you take them all on. People's houses and cars would be at risk. It looks like someone did go and get the school staff members though.